Differential stress explained

Differential stress is the difference between the greatest and the least compressive stress experienced by an object. For both the geological and civil engineering convention

\sigma _{1} is the greatest compressive stress and \sigma _{3} is the weakest,\sigma _{D} = \sigma _{1} - \sigma _{3} .

In other engineering fields and in physics,

\sigma _{3} is the greatest compressive stress and \sigma _{1} is the weakest, so\sigma _{D} = \sigma _{3} - \sigma _{1} .

These conventions originated because geologists and civil engineers (especially soil mechanicians) are often concerned with failure in compression, while many other engineers are concerned with failure in tension. A further reason for the second convention is that it allows a positive stress to cause a compressible object to increase in size, making the sign convention self-consistent.

In structural geology, differential stress is used to assess whether tensile or shear failure will occur when a Mohr circle (plotted using

\sigma _{1} and \sigma _{3} ) touches the failure envelope of the rocks. If the differential stress is less than four times the tensile strength of the rock, then extensional failure will occur. If the differential stress is more than four times the tensile strength of the rock, then shear failure will occur.^[1]

Differential stress at any point in the Earth is limited by the strength of the rock itself - any attempt to increase the differential stress above the ultimate rock strength will lead to deformation. Tectonic stress adds to the total differential stress in a rock - when a rock deforms by brittle fracturing, its strength will change and differential stress is reduced. Therefore, both rock strength and overburden of crust are able to alter the differential stress. ^[2]

References

1. Cosgrove. J. W. (1998) The role of structural geology in reservoir characterization. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, v. 127; p. 1-13
2. Fossen. H. (2010) Structural Geology (2nd edition). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. p. 93. ISBN 978-0-521-51664-8