Devi Bhagavata Purana Explained

Author:Vyasa
Religion:Hinduism
Language:Sanskrit
Verses:18, 000
Chapters:318
Volumes:12
Background:yellow

The Devi Bhagavata Purana (Sanskrit: देवी भागवतपुराणम्, ), also known as the Srimad Devi Bhagavatam or simply Devi Bhagavatam, is one of the eighteen Mahapuranas of Hinduism.[1] Composed in Sanskrit by Veda Vyasa, the text is considered a major purana for Devi worshippers (Shaktas). It promotes bhakti (devotion) towards Mahadevi, integrating themes from the Shaktadvaitavada tradition (a syncretism of Samkhya and Advaita Vedanta). While this is generally regarded as a Shakta Purana, some scholars such as Dowson have also interpreted this Purana as a Shaiva Purana.[2]

The Purana consists of twelve cantos with 318 chapters. Along with the Devi Mahatmya, it is one of the most important works in Shaktism, a tradition within Hinduism that reveres Devi or Shakti (Goddess) as the primordial creator of the universe, and as Brahman (ultimate truth and reality). It celebrates the divine feminine as the origin of all existence: as the creator, the preserver and the destroyer of everything, as well as the one who empowers spiritual liberation. While all major Puranas of Hinduism mention and revere the Goddess, this text centers around her as the primary divinity. The underlying philosophy of the text is Advaita Vedanta-style monism combined with the devotional worship of Shakti. It is believed that the text was spoken by Vyasa to King Janamejaya, the son of Parikshit.[3]

Nomenclature

The title of the text, 'Srimad Devi Bhagavata', is composed of two words, which together mean "devotees of the blessed Devi". Johnson states the meaning as the "ancient annals of the luminous goddess".[4]

History

The Srimad Devi Bhagavata Mahapurana has been variously dated. A few scholars suggest an early date, such as Ramachandran, who suggested that the text was composed before the 6th-century CE. However, this early date has not found wide support, and most scholars date it between the 9th and the 14th century.[7] Rajendra Hazra suggests 11th or 12th century, while Lalye states that the text began taking form in the late centuries of the 1st millennium, was expanded over time, and its first complete version existed in the 11th century.[8] Tracy Pintchman dates the text to between 1000 and 1200 CE.

The last ten chapters (31 to 40) of the seventh canto consist of 507 verses, a part which has often circulated as an independent volume, just like the Bhagavad Gita of the Mahabharata circulates independently. This text, from Book 7 of this Purana, is called Devi Gita. This text may have been composed with the original text, or it might be a later interpolation, according to C Mackenzie Brown. He suggests that this portion of the text was probably composed by the 13th century; it may be later, but was set down before the 16th century.

The ninth canto contains many verses that reference Mlecchas (barbarians) and Yavanas (foreigners). These words may just refer to hill tribes, but the details contained in the description of Mlecchas within these verses, according to some scholars like Hazra, suggest that the writer of these parts knew about Islam and its spread in India, leading scholars to date these parts of the ninth book to the 12th to 15th centuries, compared to the older core of the ninth book.

The Devi Bhagavata Purana is not the earliest Indian text that celebrates the divine feminine. The 6th century CE Devi Mahatmya, embedded in the Markandeya Purana, asserts the divine superiority of the Goddess. Archaeological evidence in Mathura and Bengal suggests that the concept of the divine feminine was in existence by about the 2nd century CE. Both the Devi Mahatmya and Devi Bhagavata Purana have been very influential texts within the Shakta tradition, asserting the supremacy of the female and have made the Goddess a figure of devotional (bhakti) appeal.

This text, along with all the Puranas, Vedas and the Mahabharata has traditionally been attributed by Hindus to the sage Veda Vyasa.

Characters

Avatars of Devi

This table shows the notable incarnations of Devi mentioned in the Purana.

!Avatar (Incarnation)!Description!Canto
BhuvaneshvariThird Mahavidya form of Devi, queen of Manidvipa3
DurgaGoddess of protection, strength, motherhood, destruction and wars5, 7, 9
ParvatiConsort of Shiva, Goddess of love and fertility, who resides upon Kailasa. -- 5,7,9
KaliGoddess of time and destruction5, 9
LakshmiConsort of Vishnu, Goddess of wealth and purity1, 3, 9
SaraswatiConsort of Brahma, Goddess of knowledge, music, art, speech, wisdom, and learning3, 5, 9
RadhaConsort of Krishna, Goddess of love, compassion and devotion, Queen of Goloka9
SavitriPersonified form of Gayatri Mantra and mother of Vedas9
ShakambhariThe one who nourished mankind with fruits and vegetables.7
BhramariThe Goddess of bees10
TulasiPersonification of the Tulasi plant9
ManasaGoddess of Serpents9
Mangala ChandikaA form of goddess Chandika9

Notable devotees

This table shows the devotees of the Goddess according to the Purana.

!Name!Description!Canto
Ila / Sadyumana1
AnuhaThe son of Vibhraja; He married the daughter of Shuka named Kirti.1
PratipaFather of Shantanu and grandfather of Bhishma2
ShringiThe young sage who cursed Parikshit2
KuntiMother of Pandavas and wife of king Pandu2
SutaSon of Lomaharshana and a disciple of Vyasa--
VasudevaFather of Krishna, Balarama, and Subhadra; The king of the Vrishnis and a Yadava prince. 2
subahuThe king of Kashi3
SudarshanaThe son of king Dhruvasandhi3
IndraThe king of devas, God of weather--
PrahladaSon of Hiranyakashipu4
NimiThe son of Ikshvaku6
SachiConsort of Indra, Queen of devas6
HimavanPersonification of the Himalayas, He is the guardian deity of the Himalayas, The Goddess preached the Devi Gita to him.7
SukanyaDaughter of King Sharyati7
SatyavrataA prince cursed by sage Vasishtha7
JanamejayaKing of Kuru kingdom, Son of Parikshit, Vyasa preached the Devi Bhagavata Purana to him.--
SavarniThe eighth Manu of Hinduism10

Notable demons and villains

Many demons (villains) are mentioned throughout the Srimad Devi Bhagavatam

!Avatar (Incarnation)!Description!Canto
Madhu-KaitabhaTwo demons who originated from the earwax within the god Vishnu's ears.1
Asura HayagrivaSon of Kashyapa and Danu who Slain by Lord Hayagriva1
TakshakaOne of the sons of Kadru, Murderer of Parikshit2
RavanaMulti-headed rakshasa king of the island of Lanka,3
MahishasuraThe son of Mahisi (Buffalo) and the great-grandson of Brahmarshi Kashyapa, He was ultimately killed by goddess Durga5
TamraOne of minister's of Mahishasura5
Durmukha One of minister's of Mahishasura, killed by goddess Durga5
CiksuraGeneral of Mahishasura, killed by goddess Durga5
Shumbha and NishumbhaTwo Asura brothers, sons of Kashyapa and Danu, Goddess Kaushiki killed them both5
DhumralochanaThe asura who was the general of the demon king Shumbha5
One of minister's of the demon king Shumbha5
VritrasuraA great demon (asura) killed by Indra6
NahushaA king of the Chandravamsha (Lunar dynasty), Nahusha was made the ruler of Svarga during Indra's absence6
HiranyakshaHe is slain by the Varaha (wild boar) avatar of Vishnu8
HiranyakashipuYounger brother of Hiranyaksha, Slain by Narasimha5,10
DurgamasuraA powerful demon who was killed by Goddess Durga9
ShankachudaSudama who was lord Krishna's friend in his previous life9
ArunasuraA powerful demon who was killed by the goddess Bhramari10

Content and structure

The theosophy in the text, state Foulston and Abbott, is an encyclopedic mix of ancient history, metaphysics and bhakti. This history, states C Mackenzie Brown, is of the same type found in other Puranas, about the perpetual cycle of conflict between the good and the evil, the gods and the demons. These legends build upon and extend the ancient Hindu history, such as those found in the Mahabharata. However, this Purana's legends refocus the legends around the divine feminine, integrate a devotional theme to goddesses, and the Devi is asserted in this text to be the eternal truth, the eternal source of all of universe, the eternal end of everything, the nirguna (without form) and the saguna (with form), the supreme unchanging reality (Purusha), the phenomenal changing reality (Prakriti), as well as the soul within each living being.

Stated authorship and purpose

From Swami Vijnanananda translation:

Puranic characteristics

As a Mahapurana

There are two Bhagavatas in Hindu puranic literature, the Vishnu Bhagavata and Devi Bhagavata. There are some doubts between genuine of these two puranas, as an example in Uma Samhita of Shiva Purana Mentioned Srimad Devi Bhagavatam as fifth Mahapurana called Srimad Bhagavatam.[9] Devi Bhagavata as it is called in itself, Bhagavata or Srimad Bhagavata confirms to the definitions of Bhagavata contained in other Puranas including Matsya Purana.[10]

From J. L. Shastri's translation:[11]

As mentioned in the Matsya Purana, the Bhagavata Purana is contain 18,000 slokas and begins with the Gayatri and glorifies the Sarasvata Kalpa.[12] Vyasa mentions in Devi Bhagavatam that it was composed in Sarasvata Kalpa.

Farquhar mentions that devotees of Devi accept this Purana as the original Bhagavata Purana, the fifth among all the Puranas, and the Vishnu Bhagavata Purana is believed to have been composed by Vopadeva around A.D. 1300. He points out that Sridhara remarks on this claim in his (Vishnu) Bhagavata Purana commentary, a claim apparently common during his day, thus making it clear that Devi Bhagavata is posterior to the Bhagavata Purana and prior to Sridhara, who lived about A.D. 1400.[13]

Winternitz mentions that there are three polemic treatises discussing whether Devi Bhagavata should instead be considered a Mahapurana.[14]

Hazra mentions that there is a band of scholars, both European and Indian, who hold that the Devi Bhagavata is the real Bhagavata and that the Vaishnava Bhagavata is a spurious work, which he views their opinion as untenable and elaborates on eleven reasons why in his book.[15]

Vishnulok Bihari Srivastava states that in Sanskrit literature, both Srimad Bhagavatam and Devi Bhagavatam are accepted as Mahapuranas, while the Vayu Purana, Matsya Purana and Aditya Upa Purana accept Devi Bhagavatam as a Mahapurana.[16] Vanamali, in her book "Shakti", states that Devi Bhagavatam is classified as a Mahapurana.[17] Puri states that in the Devi Bhagavata Purana it is entitled as the Bhagavata Mahapurana and the Vaishnava Bhagavata as an upapurana.[18] Sanyal states that in the Saura Purana and the revakhanda of Skanda Purana, the Bhagavata Purana is mentioned as being divided into two parts. He further points out that the Vaishnava Bhagavata Purana is not so divided and that the Devi Bhagavata Purana is divided into two parts of six chapters each, so it may be the Devi Bhagavata Purana.[19]

Wilson states that It is acceptable to include the Bhagavata among the eighteen Puranas, but it is said that it can only be the Devi Bhagavata as the circumstances apply more precisely than the Vaishnava Bhagavata.[20]

Five characteristics

As a Sattvic Shakta Purana the Srimad Devi Bhagavatam has five characteristics.

From Swami Vijnanananda translation:

Shlokas / Verses

Srimad Devi Bhagavatam consists of 12 cantos with 318 chapters. Although the number of original Sanskrit shlokas ('verses') is stated to be 18,000 by the Devi Bhagavata itself. The actual text, in different versions, is close.

Srimad Devi Bhagavatam Chapters and Verses
Swami Vijnanananda Translation
CantoChaptersVerses
1201,185
212723
3301,746
4251,426
5352,086
6311,885
7402,251
824793
9503,563
1013508
11241,239
1214964
Total31818,369
Difference (Sanskrit)+369

Cantos

For ease of reference, Swami Vijnanananda's complete 18-volume translation of the Srimad Devi Bhagavatam in wisdomlib is cited. It also provides original Sanskrit verses, transliterations, synonyms, and purports.

First Canto

Consisting of 20 chapters, the first book (skandha) like other major Puranas, states Rocher, presents the outline, the structure of contents, and describes how in the mythical Naimisha forest, the Devi-Bhagavata Purana was first recited among the sages. It also asserts that all of Reality was initially nirguna (without form, shape or attributes; in other words, there was nothingness except Truth). However, asserts the text, this nirguna Reality was a Bhagavati (woman), and she manifested herself as three Shaktis - Sattviki (truth, creative action), Rajasi (passion, aimless action) and Tamasi (delusion, destructive action). It also includes:

In chapter fifteen chapter of the 1st canto, Devi reveals her true identity to Vishnu who is lying on a banyan leaf.

Second Canto

Consisting of 12 chapters, this canto is short and historical. It weaves in the characters well known in the Hindu epic Mahabharata, states Rocher, and introduces in the key characters that appear in remaining books of the Devi-Bhagavata Purana. It also includes:

Third Canto

Consisting of 30 chapters, this canto mentions the glory of Devi Bhuvaneshvari and her worship, at the beginning of the universe Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva see the Goddess reside in Manidvipa and praise her. It also weaves in legends from the Ramayana.

Fourth Canto

Consisting of 25 chapters, this fourth canto presents more legends, including interactions between avatars of Hari, Krishna and Shiva and Kashyapa's birth as Vasudeva. It also introduces tantric themes and presents yoga meditation.

Fifth Canto

Consisting of 35 chapters, the canto mentions the glory of Devi (Devi Mahatmya), fight between Durga and Mahishasura, killing of Sumbha and Nisumbha and other demons.

Sixth Canto

Consisting of 31 chapters, The sixth book continue these legends, states Rocher, with half of the chapters focussed on the greatness of Goddess, how male gods are befuddled by problems, how they run to her for help, and how she solves them because she is enlightened knowledge. The text presents the feminine to whom all masculine deities are subordinate and dependent on. Its also include Indra killing of Vritra.

Seventh Canto

Consisting of 40 chapters, The seventh canto of the Srimad Devi-Bhagavatam shifts towards more philosophy, asserting its version of the essence of the Vedas. This book contains the philosophical text called Devi Gita, or the "Song of the Goddess". The Goddess explains she is the Brahman that created the world, asserting the Advaita premise that spiritual liberation occurs when one fully comprehends the identity of one's soul and the Brahman. This knowledge, asserts the Goddess, comes from detaching self from the world and meditating on one's own soul.Chapter 28 of the seventh book contain the story of Durgamasur and his annihilation by goddess Sivaa (Parvati) in her form of Shakambhari.

This canto, states Rocher, also includes sections on festivals related to Devi, pilgrimage information and ways to remember her. Her relationship with Shiva and the birth of Skanda is also briefly mentioned in the 7th book. The last ten chapters (31 to 40) of the canto 7 is the famous and philosophical Devi Gita, which often circulates in the Hindu tradition as a separate text.

Eighth Canto

Consisting of 24 chapters, The eighth book of the Devi-Bhagavata Purana incorporates one of the five requirements of Puranic-genre of Hindu texts, that is a theory of the geography of the earth, planets and stars, the motion of sun and moon, as well as explanation of time and the Hindu calendar. Its include:

Ninth Canto

The largest canto is the 9th skandha Consisting of 50 chapters, which is very similar in structure and content of the Prakriti-kanda of the Brahmavaivarta Purana. Both are goddesses-focused, and discuss her theology, but have one difference. The Prakriti-kanda of the Brahmavaivarta Purana also includes many verses which praise Vishnu using various names (incarnations), which re-appear in the 9th book of the Devi Bhagavata Purana with Vishnu names substituted with Devi names (incarnations). Its also Mentioned Krishna as the male form of goddess.

SDB 09.38.29:31 original Sanskrit:

Tenth Canto

Consisting of 13 chapters, This Canto of the Devi-Bhagavata Purana is one of the shortest, and integrates manavantaras, another structural requirement for this text to be a major Purana, but wherein the Devi is worshiped in every cosmic time cycle, because she is the greatest, she kills the evil and she nurtures the good.Chapter 13 of the tenth book describes the glory of goddess Bhramri that how in the past she killed the demon Arunasura.

Eleventh Canto

Consisting of 24 chapters, This canto of the text discusses Sadachara (virtues) and Dharma to self as an individual, as belonging to a Grama (village, community) and to a Desha (country). The text praises Sruti and asserts it to be the authoritative source, adding that Smriti and Puranas are also sources for guidance. This section is notable for adding that Tantra is also a source of guidance, but only if it does not conflict with the Vedas. Verses in the 11th books also describe sources for Rudraksha as Japa beads, the value of Tripundra mark on the forehead, five styles of Sandhyas (reflection, meditation) and five types of Yajnas.

Twelfth Canto

The last and 12th canto of the Devi-Bhagavatam Consisting of 14 chapters, Its describes the Goddess as the mother of the Vedas, she as the Adya Shakti (primal, primordial power), and the essence of the Gayatri mantra. The verses map every syllable of the Gayatri mantra to 1008 names of reverence in the Hindu tradition. These names span a spectrum of historic sages, deities, musical meters, mudras and the glories of the goddesses. Also in Chapter 10 to Chapter 12 Describe the supreme abode of Devi called Manidvipa which is above Vaikuntha and Goloka.

SDB 12.10.03:04 original Sanskrit:

SDB 12.13.27:28 original Sanskrit

Devi Gita

Main articles: Devi Gita

The Devi Gita, like the Bhagavad Gita, is a condensed philosophical treatise. It presents the divine female as a powerful and compassionate creator, pervader and protector of the universe. She is, states Brown, presented in the opening chapter of the Devi Gita as the benign and beautiful world-mother, called Bhuvaneshvari (literally, ruler of the universe, and the word is feminine). Thereafter, theological and philosophical teachings become the focus of the text, covering chapters 2 to 10 of the Devi Gita (or, chapters 32 to 40 of this Purana's Book 7). Some of the verses of Devi Gita are almost identical to the Devi Upanishad.

The Devi Gita frequently explains Shakta ideas by quoting from the Bhagavad Gita. The Devi is described by the text as a "universal, cosmic energy" resident within each individual, weaving in the terminology of Samkhya school of Hindu philosophy. It is suffused with Advaita Vedanta ideas, wherein nonduality is emphasized, all dualities are declared as incorrect, and interconnected oneness of all living being's soul with Brahman is held as the liberating knowledge. However, adds Tracy Pintchman, Devi Gita incorporates Tantric ideas giving the Devi a form and motherly character rather than the gender-neutral concept of Adi Shankara's Advaita Vedanta.

Supreme Goddess describes her gross form in the Devi Gita as follows:

The Bhakti theology of the Devi Gita part of this Purana may have been influenced by the Bhagavad Gita, and with Vaishnava concepts of loving devotion to Krishna found in the Bhagavata Purana. All these texts highlight different types of devotion in a Samkhya philosophy framework. Tamasic Bhakti is one, asserts the text, where the devotee prays because he is full of anger, seeks to harm others, induce pain or jealousy to others. Rajasic Bhakti is one where the devotee prays not to harm others, but to gain personal advantage, fame or wealth. Sattvic Bhakti is the type where the devotee seeks neither advantage nor harm to others but prays to purify himself, renounce any sins and surrender to the ideas embodied as Goddess to liberate himself.

Philosophy

Vedic literature

Devi Bhagavatam mentioned number of Vedic mantras connected with observance. In eleventh canto describes certain rites, also Devi is identified with Yajurveda and Rudra. In the ninth canto mentioned various phase powers of Devi. Dhyana stotras of Lakshmi and Svaha are adopted from Samaveda. Use of Rudrakshas mentioned in ninth canto is supported by the Sruti.[21]

Upanishad

Devi Bhagavatam adopted some of the passages in the Upanishad. In the seventh canto of the purana, Devi describes her own form. These verses are identical with some verses of the Devi Upanishad. Also, in the fourth canto some famous expressions of Taittiriya Upanishad are used to describe the nature of Devi.

Samkhya

See main article: Samkhya.

Devi Bhagavatam belongs to the Shaktadvaitavada tradition (syncretism of Samkhya and Advaita Vedanta; literally, the path of nondualistic Shakti). The duality of Prakriti and Purusha in Samkhya is not accepted by Devi Bhagavatam. In the text prakriti is identified with Parashakti. She is also called Mulaprakriti.

Bhakti

Main articles: Bhakti and Bhakti yoga

The Devi Bhagavata Purana adds Para Bhakti (Sanskrit: दवी) in Devi Gita as the highest level of devotion, states McDaniel, where the devotee seeks neither boon nor liberation but weeps when he remembers her because he loves the Goddess, when he feels her presence everywhere and sees the Goddess in all living beings, he is intoxicated by her ideas and presence.

From Swami Vijnanananda translation:

Advaita

Advaita Vedanta concepts can be seen throughout the Devi Bhagavata Purana. One of the main Advaita concepts found in the Purana is the concept that the individual self and the Supreme Self are one. As P. G. Lalye states that the Advaita Vedanta concept most prominent in the Devi Bhagavata Purana is the non-dual unity of the Goddess.[22]

Karma

Lalye state that Devi Bhagavatam has described many events that directly affect karma. In purana Vyasa, Narada and Narayana are exponents of Karma theory. He further states that one's actions must be forgiven. As the action is, so is the result. In this narrative the theory of karma and the theory of destiny are mixed together in the Purana.[23]

Significance

The Devi Bhagavata Purana promotes devotion to the Goddess.[24] As Lynn Foulston states, the text was written to satisfy Shakti devotees. He further mentions that the Devi Gita in the seventh Canto is the Shakta alternative to the Bhagavad Gita.[25]

Hindu Festivals

Devi Bhagavatam also mentions the Navaratri festival which is a special festival of Goddess and the rituals to be performed on that festival and about the Navaratri Puja performed by Rama on Ashtami night.[26]

In the thirteenth chapter of the Ninth canto mentions, the Hindu festival of Dola Purnima, celebrated during Holi.[27]

shaktism

Divya Jyoti Jagrati Sansthan, a non-profit organization, performs the rituals of the Devi Bhagavatam and preaches its stories.[28]

When Swami Vivekananda talks about Para bhakti, the highest form of devotion to Brahman, he gives examples and definitions from the Devi Bhagavata Purana.[29]

Sanyal states that Devi Bhagavata Parayana is still popular in Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Maharashtra etc.[30]

Reception

The verses and ideas in the Devi-Bhagavata Purana, state Foulston and Abbott, are built on the foundation of the Upanishads wherein the nonduality and oneness of Brahman and Atman (soul) are synthesized. The text makes references to the philosophy and metaphors used in the Advaita Vedanta tradition of Adi Shankara. However, those ideas are reformulated and centered around the Goddess in the Devi Bhagavata Purana, states C Mackenzie Brown, as well as other scholars. In Devi Bhagavata text, states Tracy Pintchman, the Devi is not only Brahman-Atman (soul, interconnected oneness), she is also the always-changing empirical reality (Maya).

SDB 01.18.41 original Sanskrit:

The Goddess, in Devi Bhagavata Purana, is both the source of self-bondage through Avidya (ignorance) and the source of self-liberation through Vidya (knowledge), state Foulston and Abbott. She is identical to the Vedic metaphysical reality concept of Brahman, the supreme power, the ruler of the universe, the hero, the hidden energy, the power, the bliss innate in everything, according to the text. The Devi, states Kinsley, is identified by this Purana to be all matter, mother earth, the cosmos, all of nature including the primordial. The Goddess is presented, states Brown, as "the womb of the universe", who observes the actions of her children, nurtures them to discover and realize their true nature, forgive when they make mistakes, be fearsomely terrible to the wicked that threaten her children, and be friend of all souls.

Cynthia Humes compares the depiction of Goddess in the 6th-century Hindu text Devi Mahatmya, with that in this later Devi-Bhagavata Purana text. Both revere the feminine, states Humes, but there are some important differences. Nowhere does the Devi Mahatmya state anything negative about women, and it is explicit in asserting that "all women are portions of the Goddess". By contrast, states Humes, the portrayal of women in Devi-Bhagavata Purana is more complex. It includes verses critical of the feminine, with the text stating that behavior of woman can be "reckless, foolish, cruel, deceitful" and the like. The Devi Bhagavata also praises women and describes their behavior can be "heroic, gentle, tenacious, strong" and the like.

As Hazra points out, in some parts of the Devi Bhagavata Purana, Vishnu is shown as the supreme deity, and in some parts Shiva is shown superior to Vishnu and Krishna. In the ninth canto, Krishna is shown as Para-Brahman. He further shows that the author of this Purana has composed it in such a way as to be consistent with all the Hindu sects, without contradicting the views of any sect.[31]

The Devi-Bhagavata Purana is an important and historic Shakta Bhakti text, states June McDaniel.

Commentaries and translations

Commentaries

Translations

The Devi Bhagavata Purana has been translated into different languages.

Telugu

Kannada

Malayalam

Hindi

Gujarati

Bengali

Nepali

Tamil

English

German

Russian

See also

References

Works cited

External link

Notes and References

  1. Web site: The Devi Bhagavatam: The First Book: Chapter 1. 2021-03-22. www.sacred-texts.com.
  2. Book: Dowson, John . A Classical Dictionary of Hindu Mythology and Religion, Geography, History, and Literature . Trübner & Company . 2008 . 83.
  3. Book: Doniger, Wendy . Purāṇa Perennis . State University of New York Press . 1993 . 9780791413814 . 37.
  4. Book: Johnsen, Linda . The Living Goddess . Yes International Publishers . 1999 . 9780936663289 . 11.
  5. Web site: Sanskrit Dictionary for Spoken Sanskrit: 'purana'. spokensanskrit.org. 2020-01-14.
  6. Book: Parmeshwaranand, Swami. Encyclopaedic Dictionary of Puranas. purana word completes.. 2001. Sarup & Sons. 978-81-7625-226-3. 222. en.
  7. "portrayals of the Goddess in the later Devi Bhagavata (c. ninth century CE) bear crucial differences from those of the Goddess in the Devi Mahatmya."

  8. Book: P. G. Lalye. Studies in Devī Bhāgavata. 1973. Popular Prakashan. 101–105.
  9. Book: Winternitz, M. . A History of Indian Literature Vol- I Part - II . University of Calcutta . 1978 . 486–487.
  10. Book: Wilson, H. H. . The Vishnu Purana - A System Hindu Mythology and Tradition; Vol. 1 . 11 March 2022 . 9783752583281 . 49. BoD – Books on Demand .
  11. Book: Shastri, J.L. . The Siva Purana . 1950 . . 1626.
  12. Book: Basu, B. D. Ed. . The Matsya Puranam . The Panini office, Bhuvaneswari ashrama . 1916 . English.
  13. Book: Farquhar, J. N. . An outline of the religious literature of India . London, New York : H. Milford, Oxford university press . 1920 . 269.
  14. Book: Winternitz, Moriz . A History of Indian Literature . 1 . Motilal Banarsidass Publ. . 1996 . 1927 . 9788120802643 . 555 . en.
  15. Book: Hazra, R. C. . Studies in the Upapuranas . 2 . 1963 . 337–341.
  16. Book: Bihari Srivastava, Vishnulok . Dictionary of Indology . Hindoology Books . 2009 . 9788122310849 . 55.
  17. Book: Vanamali . Shakti: Realm of the Divine Mother . Inner Traditions/Bear . 2008 . 9781594777851.
  18. Book: Puri, Vishnu . Bhakti Ratnavali : An Anthology from Srimad Bhagavata . Sri Ramakrishna Math . 2020.
  19. Book: Purana Bulletin 1969 January & July . All India Kashiraj Trust, Varanasi . 135–136.
  20. Book: Wilson, Horace Hayman . Puranas, Or an Account of Their Contents and Nature . Society for the Resuscitation of Indian Literature . 1987 . 49.
  21. Book: Layle, P.G. Studies in Devi Bhagavata. Popular Prakashan. 1973. 978-8171540693. 38–39.
  22. Book: Lalye, P. G . Studies In Devi Bhagavata . 1973 . 80.
  23. Book: Lalye, P. G . Studies In Devi Bhagavata . 1973 . 133–134.
  24. Book: J. N., Farquhar . Outline of the Religious Literature of India . Motilal Banarsidass Publishers Pvt. Limited . 1984 . 9788120820869 . 359.
  25. Book: Foulston, Lynn . Hindu Goddesses - Beliefs & Practices . Liverpool University Press . 2009 . 9781782847205 . 73–74.
  26. Web site: www.wisdomlib.org . 2013-05-15 . On the narration of the Navarātra ceremony by Nārada and the performance of that by Rāma Chandra [Chapter 30] ]. 2023-11-11 . www.wisdomlib.org . en.
  27. Web site: The Devi Bhagavatam: The Ninth Book: Chapter 30 . 2023-11-11 . sacred-texts.com.
  28. Web site: Shrimad Devi Bhagwat Katha DJJS Divya Jyoti Jagrati Sansthan . 2023-11-12 . www.djjs.org.
  29. Book: Swami, Vivekananda . The Complete Works Of Swami Vivekananda Vol. 3 . Advaita Ashrama . 1958 . 85.
  30. 1969 . Purana Bulletin 1969 January & July . Purana Bulletin 1969 January & July . 150.
  31. Book: Hazra, R. C. . Studies in the Upapuranas . 1963 . 2 . 333.
  32. Book: Brown, C. Mackenzie. The Triumph of the Goddess. SUNY Press. 1990. 9780791403648. 327.
  33. Book: Purāṇam. 1962. All-India Kasiraja Trust.. 401. en.
  34. Book: Tirupati Venkata Kavulu . Devi Bhagavatamu . 1920 . 21 October 2020 . te.
  35. News: Krishnamoorthy . Dasu . 6 May 1996 . A multi-faceted genius . The Andhra Pradesh Times.
  36. Book: ramabrahmam, Bethavolu. Sri Devi Bhagavatam. VGS Publishers. 2005.
  37. Book: Rukminamma. Sri Devi Bhagavatam. Victory Publishers. 2008.
  38. Book: Prakashan, Laxmi. Shri Mad Devi Bhagwat Mahapuran. Laxmi Prakashan. 2018. 488.
  39. Book: Shamu Menon, Varavoor. Srimad Devi Bhagavatam. PRASANTHI PUBLISHERS. 2015. 978-8189823443.
  40. Book: Shukla, Harendra. શરીમદ દવી ભાગવત. Shree Harihar Pustakalay Surat. 9789385955785. 984.
  41. Book: Singh, Shivjeet. Srimad Devi Bhagawat Mahapurana. SHREE THAKUR PRASAD PUSTAK BHANDAR. 2012. 576.
  42. Book: Menon, Ramesh. Devi: The Devi Bhagavatam Retold. Rupa & Co. 2010. 9788129115546. 514.
  43. Web site: Srimad Devi Bhagavatam (2 Volumes): English Version Prose . 2023-11-04 . Motilal Banarsidass . en.
  44. Book: Stibane, Michael. Shrīmad Devī Bhāgavatam: Mutter Natur in Aktion. Alfa-Veda Verlag. 2020. 978-3945004456.