Death of Clare Nowland explained

Death of Clare Nowland should not be confused with Raymond Clare Nowland.

Death of Clare Nowland
Location:Cooma, New South Wales
Type:Tasering
Reported Deaths:1
Accused:Sen Con Kristian White
Charges:Manslaughter (Initially charged with recklessly causing grievous bodily harm, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, and common assault)

On 17 May 2023, Clare Nowland, a 95-year-old resident with dementia, was tasered by New South Wales police at an aged care home in Cooma, Australia. She was hospitalized after she fell and fractured her skull when she received the Taser electric current.[1] She died a week later, on 24 May. The officer who fired the Taser has been suspended and charged with a number of offences.[2]

Participants

Clare Nowland

Nowland was a 95-year-old resident at an aged care home in Cooma. She had dementia and used a walker.[3] Nowland was known for skydiving to celebrate her 80th birthday.

Kristian White

White was a 33-year-old senior constable with 12 years' experience at the time of the incident.[4]

Incident

In the early hours of 17 May 2023, Nowland obtained a steak knife from the kitchen of the aged care home where she had lived for the previous five years.[5] Staff were unable to retrieve the knife from her, and called the local police. Two officers, White and a female officer, arrived at the home about 4am, and found Nowland in her room. They called on her to drop the knife, but she walked slowly towards them with her walker, carrying and raising the knife.[5] According to The Daily Telegraph, the female police officer allegedly said she could take the knife from Nowland. White allegedly said "no, bugger it" before firing his Taser.[6] White fired his Taser twice, hitting Nowland in the back and the chest. Nowland fell, fracturing her skull.[7] [8] [9] She was taken to Cooma District Hospital where she was given end-of-life care.[10] She died on 24 May.[1]

Aftermath

On 23 May, White was suspended from duty.[11] On 24 May, hours before Nowland's death, he was charged with recklessly causing grievous bodily harm, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, and common assault.[12] On 29 November, White's charges were upgraded to manslaughter.[13]

On 27 May, a small group of protestors marched on NSW Police headquarters in Parramatta.[14]

Nowland's funeral was held in Cooma on 13 June 2023.[15]

In June 2023, following a freedom of information request by The Sydney Morning Herald, it was discovered that NSW Police media had deliberately withheld advice to the public that a Taser had been used on Nowland.[16]

Legal proceedings

White was due to appear in Cooma Local Court on 5 July 2023, with the court committing to considerable expense in arranging security for the appearance. Unbeknown to the magistrate hearing the matter, the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions had allowed White to appear via video link, which angered the magistrate. On 7 February 2024, White's lawyer indicated that White would plead not guilty to manslaughter. The other three charges were withdrawn by the prosecution.[17]

Nowland's family has lodged a civil lawsuit against the state of New South Wales seeking undisclosed damages for trespass to the person (assault and battery) and negligence.[18] The matter has been adjourned until late August.[19]

Notes and References

  1. News: Goodwin . Sean Tarek . Taouk . Maryanne . 18 May 2023 . 'Not above the law': Police commissioner pledges robust review into elderly taser incident . en-AU . ABC News . 25 May 2023.
  2. News: 24 May 2023 . 95-year-old woman Tasered by police in Australia dies . en-GB . BBC News . 25 May 2023.
  3. Web site: Thompson . Angus . 19 May 2023 . Volunteer, thrill-seeker and very 'good golf player': Clare Nowland is revered . 25 May 2023 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  4. Web site: Ireland . Perry Duffin, Olivia . 22 May 2023 . NSW Police officer who Tasered 95-year-old once detained and recorded a man illegally: court . 25 May 2023 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  5. Web site: McPhee . Perry Duffin, Sarah . 25 May 2023 . Officer who Tasered Nowland 'very distressed', will fight case: lawyer . 25 May 2023 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  6. Web site: 26 May 2023 . Lawyer says NSW cop who tasered great-grandmother 'must be charged with murder' . 26 May 2023 . 7NEWS . en.
  7. Web site: Duffin . Olivia Ireland, Jenny Noyes, Perry . 19 May 2023 . Body-cam footage captured 'confronting' moment grandmother, 95, was Tasered . 25 May 2023 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  8. Web site: Ward . Laura Chung, Mary . 20 May 2023 . 'We all want to know why': Critical days to come for grandmother after being Tasered by police . 25 May 2023 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  9. Web site: View . The Herald's . 19 May 2023 . Taser tragedy cause for disbelief and disquiet . 25 May 2023 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  10. News: Knaus . Christopher . 22 May 2023 . Clare Nowland: aged care resident Tasered by police remains in 'heavy sleep' amid end-of-life care . en-GB . The Guardian . 25 May 2023 . 0261-3077.
  11. Web site: Ireland . Olivia . 23 May 2023 . Senior constable who Tasered Clare Nowland suspended . 25 May 2023 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  12. Web site: Keoghan . Perry Duffin, Sarah . 24 May 2023 . Clare Nowland dies in hospital after police officer charged with Tasering her . 25 May 2023 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  13. Web site: NSW police officer Kristian White charged with manslaughter over taser death of Clare Nowland at nursing home. ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation).
  14. News: 27 May 2023 . Protesters call for commissioner's resignation over great-grandmother's death . news.com.au . 27 May 2023.
  15. Web site: Thompson . Angus . 2023-06-13 . Taser victim Clare Nowland farewelled by hundreds in Cooma . 2023-06-13 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  16. Web site: McGowan . Olivia Ireland, Michael . 2023-06-21 . Top NSW cops covered up Tasering of Clare Nowland . 2023-06-21 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  17. News: 2024-02-06 . Court hears police officer will plead not guilty to tasering manslaughter of 95yo with dementia . 2024-02-07 . ABC News . en-AU.
  18. Web site: Mitchell . Georgina . 2023-07-18 . New bail conditions imposed on police officer accused of Tasering grandmother . 2023-07-18 . The Sydney Morning Herald . en.
  19. Web site: Family of great-grandmother who died after allegedly being tasered by police sues NSW. 11 July 2023. www.abc.net.au.