| Death of Ayrton Senna | |
| Venue: | Autodromo Enzo e Dino Ferrari |
| Location: | Imola, Emilia-Romagna, Italy |
| Cause: | High speed crash |
| Time: | 2:17 p.m. |
| Timezone: | CEST |
| Deaths: | Ayrton Senna |
On 1 May 1994, Brazilian Formula One driver Ayrton Senna was killed after his car crashed into a concrete barrier while he was leading the 1994 San Marino Grand Prix at the Imola Circuit in Italy. The Supreme Court of Cassation of Italy ruled that mechanical failure was the cause of the crash, as post-crash analysis found that Senna's steering column had snapped around the time that his car was about to round the Tamburello corner.
Senna's death was the capstone to one of the darkest weekends in Formula One history. The previous day, Austrian driver Roland Ratzenberger had died when his car crashed during qualifying. Several other collisions took place that weekend, including a serious one involving Rubens Barrichello. Ratzenberger and Senna's crashes were the first fatal accidents to occur during a Formula One race meeting since Riccardo Paletti died at the 1982 Canadian Grand Prix.
Senna's death, as well as the other events of the race weekend, helped trigger significant reforms prioritizing driver safety in Formula One. The Formula One drivers' union, the Grand Prix Drivers' Association, was re-established in the wake of Senna's death. Formula One did not suffer a fatal accident for another twenty years, until Jules Bianchi sustained fatal injuries at the 2014 Japanese Grand Prix.
See also: Williams FW16 and 1994 Formula One World Championship. Ayrton Senna joined McLaren-Honda in 1988 and won three World Drivers' Championships with the team from 1988 to 1993.[1] However, he had spent the last two years of his career in uncompetitive machinery, as the combination of Williams-Renault began dominating the sport.[2]
Although Senna's fellow drivers considered him the best driver in the sport,[3] Williams outpowered him with the help of its technological advantages. Renault boasted the best engine on the grid.[4] Williams also employed a talented group of chassis designers, including veteran engineer Patrick Head and upcoming aerodynamicist Adrian Newey. However, the most controversial aspect of Williams' package was its set of innovative electronic driver aids, including active suspension, traction control, and anti-lock brakes. In 1992 and 1993, Williams' Nigel Mansell and Alain Prost stormed to the Drivers' Championship, each winning eight of the first ten races.
Although most teams in Formula One scrambled to copy Williams' electronic advantage following its 1992 successes,[5] including Senna's McLaren, Williams maintained its advantage in 1993. To equalise competition, the sport's top regulator, Max Mosley, attempted to ban active suspension midway through the 1993 season. However, he was unable to force through such an abrupt change. Williams was the only team that specifically optimised its chassis for active suspension, and it was pointed out that without active suspension, Williams would have to sit out at least three races while Head and Newey redesigned the car. Mosley had to settle for banning the electronics at the end of the season.[6]
Senna joined Williams in 1994, driver aids or no driver aids.[7] Although the Williams FW16 was still very fast (Williams won the Constructors' Championship in 1994), Senna was disappointed with its poor handling. He frequently called his old rival Prost, now in retirement, to complain about the car.[8] The car was touchy because its design philosophy was still oriented towards active suspension.[9] In addition, its set-up window was very narrow, leaving minimal room for error. Newey later said that the car was "aerodynamically unstable,"[10] explaining that "having had active suspension for two years, when we then lost it we had more trouble re-adapting to passive suspension than other people who hadn't been on it for very long."[11] In addition, Senna was unhappy that the cockpit was not a good fit for his body.
Williams did not have enough testing time to perfect the car before the start of the season. In fact, the car was not even ready in time for the traditional pre-season test at the Estoril Circuit, where Senna actually drove a modified version of the previous year's Williams FW15C (the FW15D). Senna expressed deep misgivings about the FW15D following the test:
I have a very negative feeling about driving the car and driving it on the limit and so on. Therefore I didn't have a single run or a single lap that I felt comfortable or reasonably confident. I am uncomfortable in the car. It all feels wrong. We changed the seat and the wheel, but even so I was already asking for more room. Going back to when we raced at Estoril last September, it feels much more difficult. Some of that is down to the lack of electronic change. Also, the car has its own characteristics which I'm not fully confident in yet. It makes you a lot more tense and that stresses you.[12]
Williams rolled out the FW16 at the Jerez test on 25 February 1994, but it was not an improvement.
Senna got off to one of the worst starts of his career, retiring from the first two races. In the season opener at Interlagos, Senna took pole and initially got out to a large lead, but fell behind Benetton's Michael Schumacher after a poor pit stop. Senna pushed the car hard to catch up, but on lap 55 he lost control and spun off at the Subida dos Boxes corner. At the Pacific Grand Prix, Senna took pole again, but the car continued to perform poorly in slow-speed corners. Senna spun off track after being hit from behind by Mika Hakkinen's McLaren. Senna's teammate Damon Hill also spun off several laps later, but was fortunate to recover and made his way back to second place before retiring with a transmission failure.[13]
Entering round 3 at Imola, Senna trailed Schumacher by 20 points.[14] Williams readied upgrades to hopefully correct the car's handling issues.
See main article: 1994 San Marino Grand Prix. The weekend of the San Marino Grand Prix was marred by a variety of dangerous racing incidents and two deaths, including Senna's. It is widely considered one of the darkest weekends in Formula One history.
On the Friday before the race, Senna's protégé, Jordan's Rubens Barrichello, clipped a curb and crashed heavily at 225kph at the Variante Bassa chicane. Senna got out of his Williams car and went to the scene of the collision. Barrichello's tongue blocked his airway and emergency work performed by FIA doctor Sid Watkins saved his life. Barrichello regained consciousness and found Senna looking over him. After learning Barrichello had survived, Senna returned to his car.[15] He set the fastest time in qualifying, picking up provisional pole with a time half a second faster than Schumacher's.[16]
After the session concluded, Senna left his car and went to the Williams motor home to review the car with race engineer David Brown. He was so absorbed in checking for problems that he kept his pre-arranged press interviewers waiting for an hour. Following the interviews, Senna continued his work with Brown for another two hours.
Once he arrived back at his hotel in Castel San Pietro, Senna reportedly telephoned his girlfriend Adriane Galisteu and broke down into tears while recounting Barrichello's crash earlier that day.
On Saturday morning, Senna tried out the car again and agreed with teammate Damon Hill that the car had improved. Barrichello was released from the hospital and told Senna that he would fly back to England and watch the race on television.In the afternoon, the second qualifying session began. 18 minutes into the session, Simtek's Roland Ratzenberger struck the concrete wall on the outside of the Villeneuve curve at 314kph.[17] He had previously damaged his front wing when he went off track, and at the Villeneuve corner, part of the wing broke off completely, sending the car off course.[18] [19] He suffered a basilar skull fracture and a ruptured aorta,[20] and was pronounced dead on arrival at the hospital.
Qualifying was red-flagged following Ratzenberger's accident. Williams and Benetton agreed to sit out when qualifying resumed out of respect for Ratzenberger. In any event Senna's Friday time was fast enough to secure the pole position.
Senna saw the replays of the collision and rushed into the pitlane to get inside a course car. When he arrived, with Ratzenberger taken into an ambulance, Senna inspected the damaged Simtek. He then attended the circuit's Medical Centre where he learnt from neurosurgeon Sid Watkins that Ratzenberger had died from injuries sustained in the accident. When the two left the centre together, Watkins told Senna that he did not have to race ever again and suggested that he withdraw from the race and go fishing with him. Senna responded by telling Watkins he could not stop racing and then went back to the Williams garage, where he summoned Patrick Head and Frank Williams, telling them of the situation and deciding to withdraw for the remainder of the qualifying session.
Reportedly, Senna retired to his motor home where he broke down in tears and collapsed onto the floor. This had concerned Williams, who asked Betise Assumpção, Senna's PR chief to arrange a meeting to discuss Senna's emotional state. Senna decided not to attend the post-qualifying press conference, leading the FIA to discuss but decide not to take disciplinary action against him. On the following day, however, race stewards called Senna out of his motor home to discuss his having commandeered a course car to visit Ratzenberger's crash site. A row ensued and Senna stormed off in disgust. The stewards decided to take no action.
On Sunday morning, Senna was the fastest in the warm-up session by nine-tenths of a second.
Senna was scheduled to film an in-car lap of the Imola Circuit for French television channel TF1, where his now-retired rival Alain Prost was working as a pundit. They ate breakfast together, and Senna encouraged Prost to help out with a proposed revival of the Grand Prix Drivers' Association (GPDA), the old Formula One drivers' trade union. They agreed to meet before the Monaco Grand Prix with further details, but this was not to be. Senna confided to Prost that "I'm not optimistic at all about this race."[21] After the breakfast, Senna filmed the lap for television and personally greeted "our dear friend Alain" on camera, to Prost's surprise.[22]
At the drivers' briefing, Senna attended along with Gerhard Berger. Since he was unwilling to speak out due to the earlier row with race officials that had left him still fraught with emotions, Senna asked Berger to raise his concerns about the pace car's presence during the formation lap, which had no role other than to promote the then latest Porsche 911. At the San Marino Grand Prix, this pace car was thus made to leave the grid in advance of the Formula One cars, instead of together.
Senna then met with fellow drivers to discuss the re-establishment of the GPDA in an attempt to increase safety in Formula One. As the most senior driver, Senna offered to take the role of leader, starting with the next race event in Monaco. Niki Lauda suggested that Senna lead the group because of his strong personality and standing in the sport, relative to the other drivers.[23]
In preparation for the race, Senna placed a furled Austrian flag in the cockpit of his car. It was later inferred that Senna intended to raise the flag in memory of Ratzenberger (who was Austrian), if Senna won the race.[24]
At the start of the race, Pedro Lamy and JJ Lehto were involved in a serious collision, spraying debris into the crowd and injuring bystanders. Track officials deployed the safety car, an Opel Vectra driven by Formula Three driver Max Angelelli,[25] to slow down the field and allow the removal of debris. The competitors proceeded behind the safety car for five laps.
The Vectra was based on a family sedan so not particularly fast; Senna pulled alongside the Vectra to gesture to its driver to speed up because his tyres were getting cold and were losing grip. A subsequent investigation showed that the Vectra was inadequate for the role of safety car, because its brakes overheated and it therefore had to be driven slowly, lest it cause another crash itself. One of the theories explaining the accident suggests that this slow running caused the cars to suffer a drop in tyre temperature and pressure.[26] [27] Before the start of the sixth lap, David Brown told Senna via pit-to-car radio that the safety car was pulling off, and Senna acknowledged the message.
On lap 6, the race resumed and Senna immediately set a quick pace with the third-quickest lap of the race, followed by Schumacher. At the flat-out left-hander Tamburello corner, Schumacher noticed that Senna took a tight line through the curve and his car jiggled on the bumps.
On lap 7, the second lap at racing speed, Senna's car left the racing line at Tamburello, ran in a straight line off the track and struck an unprotected concrete barrier. Telemetry data recovered from the wreckage shows he entered the corner at 309km/h and then braked hard, downshifting twice to slow down before impacting the wall at 211km/h.[28] The car hit the wall at a shallow angle, tearing off the right front wheel and nose cone before spinning to a halt.
After Senna's car stopped, he was initially motionless in the cockpit. After about ten seconds, as recorded by the close-up aerial footage, his head was seen to lift to the left before returning to its original position. Thereafter he did not move again. The right front wheel had shot up upon impact and entered the cockpit, striking the right frontal area of his helmet. The violence of the wheel's impact shoved his head back against the headrest (which was already far forward from the car's impact with the wall) causing fatal skull fractures. In addition, a piece of suspension attached to the wheel had also partially penetrated his Bell M3 helmet and caused trauma to his head. Also, it appeared that a jagged piece of the upright assembly had penetrated the helmet visor just above his right eye. Senna was using a medium-sized (58 cm) M3 helmet with a new "thin" Bell visor. Any one of the three injuries would probably have killed him.[29]
After the crash, it was immediately evident that Senna had suffered some form of injury, because his helmet was seen to be motionless and leaning slightly to the right. The subtle movement of his head in the seconds that followed raised false hopes. Moments after the crash, Angelo Orsi, a photographer and a friend of Senna, took photographs of Senna in the car after his helmet was removed and Senna being treated before marshals blocked his view. Despite receiving numerous offers, the photographs have only been seen by Orsi and the Senna family, who insisted that Orsi not publish the photographs.
Fire marshals arrived at the car and were unable to touch Senna before qualified medical personnel arrived. Senna was pulled out of the car within minutes. Television coverage from an overhead helicopter was seen around the world, as rescue workers gave Senna medical attention. Close inspection of the area in which the medical staff treated Senna revealed a considerable amount of blood on the ground, probably from the pieces of suspension and upright assembly penetrating his helmet, which had ruptured his superficial temporal artery. From visible injuries to Senna's head, it was evident to attending medical professionals that he had sustained a grave head trauma. An emergency tracheotomy was conducted alongside the track to establish a secure airway through which the medical personnel could artificially maintain his breathing. The race was stopped one minute and nine seconds after Senna's crash. Williams team manager Ian Harrison went up to race control, finding a scene where many race officials were sensing that Senna's crash had been serious. Bernie Ecclestone later arrived in race control to calm the situation.[30]
Neurosurgeon Sid Watkins, the head of Formula One's on-track medical team, performed the on-site tracheotomy on Senna.[31] Watkins later reported:
Watkins cleared the respiratory passages, stemmed the blood flow, replaced lost blood and immobilised the cervical area. Watkins radioed for a medical helicopter and asked the intensive care anaesthetist, Giovanni Gordini, to escort Senna to Maggiore Hospital.
During the safety car period, Érik Comas brought his Larrousse-Ford to the pit lane to correct a vibration issue caused by contact under a yellow flag on the first lap. Shortly after the helicopter landed on the racing surface, Comas left the pit area and attempted to rejoin the now red-flagged Grand Prix due to a miscommunication with his crew. The race marshals waved frantically at Comas as he approached Tamburello, since he was apparently unaware of what was taking place, and he slammed on his brakes in time to stop the Larrousse and avoid a collision with the medical helicopter. When he spotted Comas approaching the accident scene, John Watson - covering the events as an analyst for EuroSport - said it was the "most ridiculous thing I've ever seen at any time in my life".[32]
Senna's car was eventually lifted onto a truck and returned to the pit lane where officials impounded it. However, an unidentified person insisted that the black-box data carried on the car be removed. It was suspected to be a member of the Williams racing team who took the black box. At 15:00, around 43 minutes after the crash, the helicopter landed in front of the Maggiore Hospital. Doctors rushed Senna into intensive care; a brain scan confirmed the diagnosis made on the track. At 15:10, Senna's heart stopped beating, doctors restarted his heart, and he was placed on a life-support machine. Senna's brother Leonardo arranged for a priest to perform the last rites which occurred at 18:15. Senna's heart stopped beating again at 18:37, and it was decided not to restart it. Doctor Maria Teresa Fiandri, the emergency department head physician at the hospital who was off-duty and had been watching the race live from home with her sons, immediately left for the hospital and arrived at the same time as Senna's helicopter landed. In her interview after 20 years, she confirmed that the blood loss suffered by Senna was due to a damaged superficial temporal artery and that, apart from his head injuries, Senna appeared serene and the rest of the body was intact. Fiandri became responsible for providing medical updates to the media and public that had amassed at the hospital and, at 18:40, she announced that Senna had died.[33]
Some time after the race, Williams team manager Ian Harrison was called by an Italian lawyer informing Harrison of Senna's death and that it was being treated as a "road traffic accident". Early in the morning of 2 May, Harrison was called by another lawyer, who took him to a mortuary. Harrison declined to see Senna's body upon being asked.
Senna's body was flown back to Brazil on 4 May 1994. He lay in state at the Legislative Assembly building in São Paulo. His funeral took place the following day, 5 May. With over half a million visitors, it was the largest funeral procession in city history.[34] Senna was buried in the Morumbi Cemetery in São Paulo.[35]
Ratzenberger's funeral took place on 7 May 1994, in Salzburg, Austria.[36] Max Mosley, the FISA president, opted to attend Ratzenberger's funeral instead of Senna's. He later explained that "I went to his funeral because everyone went to Senna's. I thought it was important that somebody went to his."[37]
For the next race at Monaco, the FIA decided to leave the first two grid positions empty and painted them with the colours of the Brazilian and the Austrian flags, to honour Senna and Ratzenberger.[38]
Five-time World Champion Juan Manuel Fangio was watching the race from his home in Balcarce, Argentina. He turned the television off almost immediately after the accident, remembering later; "I knew he was dead".
ESPN, which broadcast the San Marino Grand Prix in the United States, also carried the Alabama 500 NASCAR Cup Series race at Talladega Superspeedway in Talladega, Alabama, later the same day. On lap 103, a seven-car incident at the tri-oval led to the second yellow flag of the race. As the fieldwas getting set to resume the event on lap 112, ESPN lead race announcer Bob Jenkins informed the audience of the tragedy at Imola; as a tribute, the ESPN booth of Jenkins, Ned Jarrett, and Benny Parsons went silent for the lap 112 restart. During his postrace interview in victory lane with Jerry Punch, race winner Dale Earnhardt, who would later lose his own life in a crash at the 2001 Daytona 500, offered his condolences to Senna's family and friends.
In Brazil, the country's television networks spent the rest of the day interrupting their normal programming schedules to announce Senna's death and replay his last interview, given to the media on the day before the crash.[39] Many motor racing fans gathered outside of Maggiore Hospital to pay their respects to Senna, causing major traffic jams.[40] [41] Fans also gathered in the Williams F1 factory in Didcot where around 200 people attended with flowers laid on the front gates of the factory.
The Italian and Brazilian press were critical of the FIA for the rule changes that were enacted for 1994. Benetton driver Schumacher called for improvements in safety.[42] BBC Sport commentator Murray Walker called Senna's death the "blackest day for Grand Prix racing that I can remember".[43]
Two and a half months later, following Brazil's victory over Italy in the 1994 FIFA World Cup, the Brazilian squad dedicated their World Cup victory to Senna.[44]
On 3 May, the FIA called a meeting at the request of the Italian Automobile Club to review the events of the weekend.[45] Later on, the governing body announced new safety measures for the next round in Monaco which included the following three changes:[46]
On 8 May, it was reported that Federico Bendinelli, an official who worked at Imola, said Senna had inspected the Tamburello corner and declared it was "O.K."[47] Williams ran tests on one of their rigs attempting to replicate Senna's accident from the data retrieved. They attempted to simulate a mechanical failure which had not proven conclusive.
At the next race in Monaco, retired world champion Niki Lauda announced the reformation of the Grand Prix Drivers' Association (GPDA). The representatives elected were Lauda and active drivers Michael Schumacher, Gerhard Berger and Martin Brundle. At the end of the season, the GPDA demanded the FIA improve the safety of Formula One. The FIA responded quickly and introduced changes to the regulations as follows:[48]
For the Spanish Grand Prix:
All together this would reduce the amount of downforce by about 15%.
For the Canadian Grand Prix:
Other changes included improved crash barriers, redesigned tracks and tyre barriers, higher crash safety standards, higher sills on the driver cockpit and a limit on 3-litre engines.[49] The FIA immediately investigated the Autodromo Enzo e Dino Ferrari in Imola, and the track's signature Tamburello turn was changed into a left–right chicane as a result.
In February 1995, a 500-page report by a team of judicial investigators was handed over to Italian prosecutors which attributed Senna's crash to steering column failure caused by a pre-race adjustment.[50]
During legal proceedings before the Italian courts on 3 March 1997, based on the expert testimony and evidence of the pathologist, Dr Cipolla, Senna's official time of death was recorded as 2:17 pm on 1 May 1994,[51] coinciding with cerebral death under Italian law, upon Senna hitting the Tamburello wall. The FIA and Italian motorsport authorities still maintain that Senna was not killed instantly, but rather died in the hospital, where he had been rushed by helicopter after an emergency tracheotomy and IV administration were performed on the track.
There is an ongoing debate as to why Senna was not declared dead at the track. Under Italian law, collisions resulting in a fatality must be investigated for any criminal culpability. The activities that cause the fatality, such as a sporting event, must be suspended forthwith and the scene of the crash secured.
The former Director of the Oporto (Portugal) Legal Medicine Institute, Professor José Eduardo Pinto da Costa, has stated the following:
Professor José Pratas Vital, Director of the Egas Moniz Hospital in Lisbon, a neurosurgeon and Head of the Medical Staff at the Portuguese GP, offered a different opinion:
Rogério Morais Martins, creative director of Ayrton Senna Promotions (which became the Ayrton Senna Institute after Senna's death), stated that:
The Williams team was entangled for many years in Italian criminal court proceedings after prosecutors instigated manslaughter charges against key team officials. On 16 December 1997, Frank Williams and five others were acquitted of the charges, ending the threat of a boycott of Formula One in Italy.[52] In a 381-page ruling, Judge Antonio Costanzo concluded that steering column failure was the probable cause of Senna's crash; however, there was no proof of negligence on the part of Head or Newey, or that they had designed the modifications in the first place. On 22 November 1999, an appeals court upheld the acquittals, rejecting a request from prosecutors to give one-year suspended sentences to Head and Newey.[53] In April 2002, Senna's FW16 chassis number 02 was returned to the Williams team. Although an initial report by Autosport stated the car had been destroyed by the team (as it was in an advanced state of deterioration), a spokesman stated otherwise, but also stated that the car's ultimate fate would be a 'private matter'. Senna's helmet was returned to Bell, and was incinerated. The car's engine was returned to Renault, where its fate is unknown.[54] [55]
In January 2003, the Italian Supreme Court reopened the case, ruling that "material errors" had been made in the Bologna court of appeal.[56] On 27 May 2005, the court gave a full acquittal to Adrian Newey, while the case against Head was "timed out" under a statute of limitations.[53] A retrial was ordered by Italy's highest court in 2005.[57]
On 13 April 2007, the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation delivered its own verdict (number 15050) stating that: "It has been determined that the accident was caused by a steering column failure. This failure was caused by badly designed and badly executed modifications. The responsibility for this falls on Patrick Head, culpable of omitted control". However, Head was not arrested since the Italian statute of limitations for culpable homicide was 7 years and 6 months, and the verdict was pronounced 13 years after the crash.[58] The Williams team conceded to this failure but only as caused by the crash impact. In the weeks preceding the San Marino Grand Prix, Senna reportedly had asked his team to alter the steering column in order to give him more room in the cockpit. Head and Adrian Newey satisfied Senna's request by having the FW16's existing shaft cut and extended with a smaller-diameter piece of tubing that was welded together with reinforcing plates. The modification was carried out in this manner as there was insufficient time to instead manufacture a new steering shaft in time for the race.
A 600-page technical report was submitted by the University of Bologna under Professor of Engineering Enrico Lorenzini and his team of specialists. The report concluded that fatigue cracks had developed through most of the steering column at the point where it had broken.[59] Lorenzini stated: "It had been badly welded together about a third of the way down and couldn't stand the strain of the race. We discovered scratches on the crack in the steering rod. It seemed like the job had been done in a hurry but I can't say how long before the race. Someone had tried to smooth over the joint following the welding. I have never seen anything like it. I believe the rod was faulty and probably cracked even during the warm-up. Moments before the crash only a tiny piece was left connected and therefore the car didn't respond in the bend."[60]
An analysis of the onboard camera video was submitted by Cineca, which tracked the movement of the steering wheel during the race. Having rotated in a fixed arc during the previous laps, during the final seconds a yellow button on the wheel moved several centimetres away from its normal trajectory, with the steering wheel tilting in its own plane, indicating a breaking steering column.[61] Williams introduced its own video to prove the movement was normal in which David Coulthard manhandled an FW16B steering wheel, the effort required to deflect the wheel termed as "quite considerable". Michele Alboreto testified that the steering wheel movement was abnormal, stating that the video "proves that something was broken in Senna's Williams. No steering wheel moves a few centimetres."[62] [63] [64] [65]
In May 2011, Williams FW16 designer Adrian Newey expressed his views about the crash:
Patrick Head, technical director of Williams, believed that Senna had made a driving error. Michael Schumacher had told him after the race that Senna's car looked 'nervous' the previous lap.[66] Damon Hill said he is convinced that Senna made a mistake.[67] [68]
Adrian Newey, who designed Senna's car, said he believes a tyre puncture may have caused Senna to crash. There was debris on the track following the JJ Lehto crash.[69] [70] [71] Riccardo Patrese suffered a right rear tyre failure at Tamburello during practice for the 1992 Grand Prix, yet his car (an active suspension FW14B) was seen to be spinning before even leaving the track.[72]