Daniel Daly Explained

Daniel Daly should not be confused with Daniel A. Dailey.

Daniel Daly
Birth Name:Daniel Joseph Daly
Birth Date:11 November 1873
Birth Place:Glen Cove, New York, U.S.
Death Place:New York City, U.S.
Placeofburial:Cypress Hills National Cemetery
Allegiance:United States
Branch:United States Marine Corps
Serviceyears:1899–1929
Rank:Sergeant Major
Battles:

Daniel Joseph Daly (November 11, 1873 – April 27, 1937) was a United States Marine and one of nineteen U.S. servicemen to have been awarded the Medal of Honor twice. Daly and Major General Smedley Butler are the only Marines who earned two Medals of Honor for two separate acts of valor.

Daly is among the most decorated U.S. Marines in history, and over a thirty year career saw action in all the major Marine Corps campaigns from 1899 to the end of World War I. He earned his first Medal of Honor during the Boxer Rebellion in 1900 and the second in Haiti in 1915. Butler described Daly as "the fightingest Marine I ever knew...It was an object lesson to have served with him." General John A. Lejeune called Daly "the outstanding Marine of all time."[1]

In World War I, Daly became further cemented into Marine Corps lore when he is said to have yelled, "Come on, you sons of bitches, do you want to live forever?" to his company before charging the Germans at the Battle of Belleau Wood, though there is considerable evidence that the battle cry was the invention of an enthusiastic war correspondent. He was also awarded the Navy Cross and the Distinguished Service Cross for his actions in France.

Daly's Medals of Honor are on display at the National Museum of the Marine Corps in Triangle, Virginia, which also features the "live forever" quote etched in the stone of the building's rotunda.[2] [3]

Early life

Daniel Joseph Daly was born on November 11, 1873, in Glen Cove, New York, on Long Island. He was a Roman Catholic of Irish descent.[4] He spent his youth in New York City, working as a newsboy and a laborer. Despite his slight build—5inchesft6inchesin (ftin) tall and weighing —Daly occasionally fought as a semi-pro boxer.

Military career

Early career

Daly enlisted in the United States Marine Corps on January 10, 1899, at the age of 25. His first posting was with the Asiatic Fleet aboard the cruiser USS Newark. In 1900, the Newark arrived in China as part of the China Relief Expedition during the Boxer Rebellion. On July 15, 1900, during the 55-day Siege of the International Legations in Peking, Private Daly and his commanding officer, Captain Newt H. Hall, set out to reconnoiter a position on the Tartar Wall while under siege by the Boxers.[5] A working party, scheduled to follow to construct defenses, never arrived. Daly volunteered to hold the position while Captain Hall returned for the working party,[6] and single-handedly fought off a furious all-night Boxer attack, an action which earned him his first Medal of Honor.

After leaving China, the Newark sailed for the Philippines in 1901, where Daly saw duty in the Philippine–American War. Later that year, Daly had two run-ins with military discipline: He was court-martialed once for drunkenness on post and spent three weeks in the brig at the Boston Navy Yard, and again three weeks later for drunkenness and verbal abuse of the sergeant of the guard.

After serving in the Philippines, Daly was assigned to various ships in the Caribbean area, seeing duty in Panama, Puerto Rico, and Cuba.[7] He also trained recruits, worked as a guard at the Portsmouth Naval Prison, and gained a reputation as an excellent boxer. He was promoted to corporal in 1906 and sergeant in 1909.[8] On March 14, 1911, Daly was garrisoned at the United States Naval Station in San Juan, Puerto Rico, when he spotted a gasoline fire that was spreading from the forecastle of the merchant schooner Springfield. Daly, with a party of nine other Marines and sailors, successfully extinguished the fire, though he spent several weeks hospitalized with severe burns. Daly received commendations from both the Secretary of the Navy and the Commandant of the Marine Corps for his actions.

At the outbreak of the Battle of Veracruz on April 21, 1914, Sergeant Daly landed in Veracruz, Mexico, with a combined force of 1,200 U.S. Marines and sailors. The American objective was to seize the customs house to prevent a shipment of German weapons—200 machine guns and 15 million rounds of ammunition, potentially to be used against the United States—from reaching shore.[9] The ensuing battle saw intense street fighting, and the day after landing, Daly's platoon was pinned down in an arroyo, facing heavy sniper fire from a rooftop. Daly covertly crawled out of the ditch, entered the building from the rear and killed its entire seven man garrison, five by rifle fire and two by bayonet. By the end of the day, the Americans had captured the city.[10]

Daly earned his second Medal of Honor in Haiti with the U.S. Marines supporting the Haitian government in a fight against Cacos insurgents. On the night of October 24–25, 1915, during the Battle of Fort Dipitié, Gunnery Sergeant Daly was on mounted patrol with a detachment of three squads—40 Marines total—from the 15th Company, 2nd Marine Regiment, under the command of Major Smedley Butler. The Marines were ambushed by a force of some 400 Cacos while crossing a river near the fort, and the horse carrying their machine gun was killed, its carcass sinking to the riverbed. With the battle raging throughout the night, Daly left the Marines' defensive position, swam the river under constant fire until he located the horse, freed the machine gun from its restraints, and carried the of weaponry and ammunition more than a mile back to the Marines' position. Butler wrote that Daly performed this feat on his own initiative, and that the major was surprised to see the machine gun, which he had been resigned to fighting without, set up back at the Marine camp. Butler further wrote that Daly moved "coolly and deliberately" and that he himself "wouldn't have had the courage" to undertake such an exploit.[11] [12] At daybreak, the Marines, rearmed and with Daly in command of one of the squads, routed the Cacos, capturing and destroying Fort Dipitié.[13]

Three weeks later, on November 17, 1915, the Americans fought the Cacos once again in the decisive Battle of Fort Rivière. A combined force of U.S. Marines and sailors delivered a crushing blow to the final insurgent stronghold, ending the First Caco War. In a report to the commander of the 1st Marine Regiment, Captain William P. Upshur wrote that from October 15 to November 30, Daly showed "exceptional coolness and leadership of the men under fire," resulting in Daly receiving a letter of commendation from Secretary of the Navy Josephus Daniels. In Major Butler's report on the Fort Rivière campaign, he wrote that Daly was "the most conspicuous figure among the enlisted personnel. Daly is a real red-blooded marine and it was an object lesson to have served with him." Daniels, in announcing the Medal of Honor citations for the campaign, wrote that Daly displayed "conspicuous gallantry" at both the Battle of Fort Dipitié and the Battle of Fort Rivière.[14]

World War I

Daly's service in World War I began with his arrival in France on November 4, 1917, as first sergeant of 73rd Company, 6th Marine Regiment, 4th Marine Brigade, attached to the U.S. Army's 2nd Infantry Division. The division initially trained in the Toulon Sector, near Verdun (March–May 1918), and saw action at the Third Battle of the Aisne. At the outbreak of the Battle of Belleau Wood on June 1, 1918, Daly's regiment was placed in a gap in the line left by the French 43rd Division, with the intent to stop the German advance toward Paris. The Marines drove back an attack by the German 28th Division on June 2. On June 5, a German shell landed in an ammunition dump at Lucy-le-Bocage, starting a fire. Daly quickly led a party from his company into the flames to extinguish the blaze, preventing the arsenal from exploding.

On June 6, the Marines went on the offensive. The Germans were entrenched in a forest, separated from the Marines by of open wheat field. Facing 1,200 Germans with 200 machine guns, the 73rd Company was pinned down by intense fire. As the Marines took cover at nightfall, Daly walked openly to each of his machine gun positions, rallying and coordinating his men. On June 10, a German machine gun unit advanced close to Daly's position. Daly immediately charged the weapon, destroying it with three grenades, shot the unit's commanding officer with his .45 caliber pistol, and took its remaining 14 soldiers prisoner. As the battle raged later in the day, Daly exposed himself to enemy fire while evacuating the wounded. For his actions from June 5–10, Daly was awarded the Navy Cross, the Army's Distinguished Service Cross, and the French Médaille militaire.

Daly later fought in the Battle of Saint-Mihiel and the Battle of Blanc Mont Ridge. His final campaign was the Meuse–Argonne offensive.[15] By the war's end, he had suffered a bullet wound in the shoulder and two shrapnel wounds in the leg. After serving in the American occupation force in Germany,[16] Daly left active duty for the United States Marine Corps Reserve in 1919, and officially retired on February 6, 1929, at the rank of sergeant major.[17]

Legacy

According to Marine Corps lore, Daly rallied his men at the Battle of Belleau Wood by yelling, "Come on, you sons-o'-bitches, do you want to live forever?"[18] This quote first appeared in And They Thought We Wouldn't Fight, a 1918 memoir by war correspondent Floyd Gibbons of The Chicago Tribune. Gibbons, who was attached to Major Benjamin Berry's 3rd Battalion, 5th Marine Regiment, attributed the line to an unnamed gunnery sergeant in that unit. Popular legend eventually credited Daly (already well known as a double Medal of Honor winner) with the rallying cry, despite discrepancies in the story—Daly was not a member of the 5th Marine Regiment but the 6th, which was positioned to the south of where Gibbons was reporting, and Daly was a first sergeant, not a gunnery sergeant. Historian Alan Axelrod wrote that "nobody has been found who actually heard [Daly] say it." Regardless, in May 1919, less than a year after the battle, Daly's story at Belleau Wood—incorporating the quote—was featured in "The Wood of Fair Water," one of six short films in The Rothapfel Unit Program, a motion picture directed by Marine veteran Samuel L. Rothapfel.[19] [20] [21] [22]

For his part, Daly told a Marine Corps historian that he yelled, "For Christ's sake, men—come on! Do you want to live forever?" Axelrod noted that Gibbons utilized artistic license "to impose order on chaos, to make sense of it, to extract some greater meaning from it" and that the details do not "diminish the reality the legend is based on." Irrespective of its origin, the quote has become deeply entrenched in Marine Corps lore, exemplified by the closing line of a 1954 eulogy of Daly in the Marine Corps Gazette: "But the Dan Daly of China, Haiti and France will remain part and parcel of our tradition as long as the Marine Corps contains any SOBs who want to live forever."

Later life

After leaving the Marines, Daly lived a quiet life with his sister in New York, working as a bank guard on Wall Street and avoiding publicity. He died of a heart attack in Glendale, Queens, New York, on April 27, 1937, aged 63. Instead of being interred at Arlington National Cemetery, Daly's family honored his wish that he remain near his home,[23] and was buried at Cypress Hills National Cemetery in Brooklyn, New York.

Decorations and honors

Honors

A was named in honor of Daly and was commissioned on March 10, 1943.

On November 10, 2005, the United States Postal Service issued its "Distinguished Marines" stamps in which Daly was honored alongside John Basilone, John A. Lejeune, and Chesty Puller.[24]

Medals

Daly's decorations and medals includes two Medals of Honor; the Navy Cross; Distinguished Service Cross; two Purple Hearts; Good Conduct Medal with two bronze stars; the China Relief Expedition Medal; the Philippine Campaign Medal; the Marine Corps Expeditionary Medal with one bronze star; the Mexican Service Medal; the Haitian Campaign Medal; the World War I Victory Medal with Aisne, St. Mihiel, Meuse-Argonne, and Defensive-Sector clasps and Citation Star; three letters of commendation; the Médaille militaire; the Croix de Guerre with Palm; and the Fourragère. The last three awards are from the French government. Only the Croix de Guerre is authorized for wear by U.S. personnel, though a special exception is made for Marines assigned to the 5th and 6th Marine Regiments, who are permitted to wear the Fourragère with their service and dress coats or jackets.[25]

Medal of Honor (first award)Medal of Honor (second award)
Navy CrossDistinguished Service CrossPurple Heart
with 1 service star
Marine Corps Good Conduct Medal
with 2 service stars
China Relief Expedition MedalPhilippine Campaign MedalMarine Corps Expeditionary Medal
with 1 service star
Mexican Service Medal
Haitian Campaign MedalWorld War I Victory Medal
with Aisne, St. Mihiel,
Meuse-Argonne, and
Defensive-Sector clasps,
and Citation Star
Médaille militaire (France)Croix de Guerre
with bronze Palm (France)
Croix de Guerre Fourragère

Medal of Honor

First award: 1901

Citation:

Second award: 1915

Citation:

Distinguished Service Cross

Citation:

Navy Cross

Citation:

Citation Star

In 1932 the Silver Citation Star became the Silver Star, a full sized decoration. All personnel awarded the Silver Citation Star were authorized to wear the Silver Star, the USA's third highest decoration for heroism in combat.

Citation:

See also

References

Bibliography

Notes and References

  1. Dieckmann Sr. . Edward A. . November 1960 . Dan Daly: Reluctant Hero . . . 24 . 2024-06-07.
  2. Web site: Iconic Artifacts . . National Museum of the Marine Corps . 2022-12-21.
  3. Book: Warren, Paul . 2016 . Adventurer Floyd Gibbons: Eye Street's Eyewitness to History . Washington, D.C. . Warren Communications News . 99 . 978-1535418188.
  4. Book: Robison, Ken . 2019 . Montanans in the Great War: Open Warfare Over There . Charleston, South Carolina . . 83 . 978-1-4671-4099-7.
  5. Book: Dye, Julia . 2011 . Backbone: History, Traditions, and Leadership Lessons of Marine Corps NCOs . Oxford, England . Osprey . 121 . 978-1-84908-548-9.
  6. Book: Clark, George B. . 2001 . Treading Softly: U.S. Marines in China, 1819-1949 . Westport, Connecticut . Praeger . 178 . 0-275-97078-7.
  7. Web site: 2015-09-09 . Sergeant Major Daniel "Dan" Joseph Daly . . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20150922191021/https://www.mcu.usmc.mil/historydivision/Pages/Who%27s%20Who/D-F/Daly_DJ.aspx . 2015-09-22.
  8. Hough . Frank O. . November 1954 . Dan Daly . . . 51 . 2023-12-01.
  9. Book: Sweetman, Jack . 1968 . The Landing at Veracruz: 1914 . Annapolis, Maryland . . 44 . .
  10. Book: Quirk, Robert E. . 1967 . An Affair of Honor: Woodrow Wilson and the Occupation of Veracruz . New York . W. W. Norton . 102 . .
  11. Book: Musicant, Ivan . 1990 . The Banana Wars: A History of the United States Military Intervention in Latin America from the Spanish-American War to the Invasion of Panama . New York . MacMillan . 196–201 . 0-02-588210-4.
  12. Book: Thomas, Lowell . 1933 . Old Gimlet Eye: The Adventures of Smedley D. Butler . New York . Farrar & Rinehart . 194 . .
  13. Book: 1917 . Record of Medals of Honor Issued to the Officers and Enlisted Men of the United States Navy, Marine Corps, and Coast Guard, 1862-1917 . Washington, D.C. . . 30–31 . .
  14. Web site: Daniel Joseph Daly . Congressional Medal of Honor Society . 2024-07-14.
  15. Book: Beede . Benjamin R. . 1994 . The War of 1898 and U.S. Interventions, 1898-1934: An Encyclopedia . New York . Garland . 157 . 0-8240-5624-8.
  16. Book: Schuon, Karl . 1963 . U.S. Marine Corps Biographical Dictionary . New York . Franklin Watts . 53 . .
  17. Web site: Paths to Glory: Medal of Honor Recipients Smedley Butler and Dan Daly. 26 December 2007.
  18. Book: Ermey, R. Lee . 2013 . Gunny's Rules: How to Get Squared Away Like a Marine . Washington, D.C. . Regnery . 132 . 978-1-62157-159-9.
  19. . 1919-05-03 . 5 . 22 . Rothapfel Gives Details of First Unit Program Bill; Central Effect Its Key . Exhibitor's Trade Review . Sergt. Dan Daly is shown issuing his famous challenge, "Come on you ——, do you want to live forever?" . 4 . 2022-12-20.
  20. . May 1919 . Recruiters, Watch for This Movie! . The Recruiters' Bulletin . 22 . 2022-12-20.
  21. News: . 1919-04-06 . In the News Net . . 52 . The photodramatic feature...contains scenes made by Sergeant Owens of the Marine Corps, one of which shows Sergeant Dan Daly in the trenches issuing his taunt to the Germans, "Come on, you ——, do you want to live forever?".
  22. News: . 1919-09-26 . Theatrical Notes . . 12 . 2023-01-07.
  23. News: . 1937-04-28 . Kin of Daly, War Hero, Bans Arlington Rites . . 15 . 2024-06-08.
  24. Web site: 2010-10-05 . Distinguisted Marines . . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20051220102101/http://shop.usps.com/cgi-bin/vsbv/postal_store_non_ssl/browse_content/stampReleaseDisplay.jsp?OID=8610 . 2005-12-20 .
  25. Web site: Marine Corps Uniform Regulations . 2018-05-01 . . 2023-12-05.