Cyclone Xynthia Explained

Cyclone Xynthia
Formed:26 February 2010
Dissipated:7 Μarch 2010
Lowest Pressure:967
Highest Winds:148
Countries Affected:Belgium, Denmark, France, England, Germany, Poland, Portugal, Spain and Sweden
Damages:€1.3–3 billion[1]
Fatalities:63;[2] 12 missing

Cyclone Xynthia was an exceptionally violent European windstorm which crossed Western Europe between 27 February and 1 March 2010. It reached a minimum pressure of on 27 February.[3] In France—where it was described by the civil defence as the most violent since Lothar and Martin in December 1999—at least 51 people were killed, with 12 more said to be missing. A further six people were killed in Germany, three in Spain, one in Portugal, one in Belgium and another one in England.[4] Most of the deaths in France occurred when a powerful storm surge topped by battering waves up to high, hitting at high tide, smashed through the sea wall off the coastal town of L'Aiguillon-sur-Mer.[5] A mobile home park built close to the sea wall was particularly hard-hit.[5] The sea wall was about two hundred years old, built in the time of Napoleon; critics said that situating a mobile home park so close to the sea wall showed poor coastal development practices.[5] The storm cut power to over a million homes in France and a million customers in Portugal lost power.

Effects

One million homes were left without power in western France. In the Hautes-Pyrénées, falling trees damaged vehicles, the roofs of houses and barns were blown away, and rocks were falling onto the road.[6] In the département of Vendée, cities like La Faute-sur-Mer, L'Aiguillon-sur-Mer, La Tranche-sur-Mer were flooded with water levels reaching up to . Flooding affected parts of the Charente-Maritime département (Suburbs of La Rochelle,[7] cities of Fouras, Marennes, Châtelaillon as well as and Oléron Island[8]) where high speed wind were registered .[9]

Flooded railway tracks led to railway delays in France and the rail services in northern Spain were also severely affected. 70 flights from Paris-Charles de Gaulle Airport were cancelled by Air France.[10]

The storm also caused damage in Portugal and Spain. The strongest wind gust recorded in Portugal was [11] while in Spain a gust of was recorded.[12] In France a wind gust was recorded at the Pic du Midi.

The storm may have been exacerbated by the spread of volcanic ash from the Soufrière Hills volcano.[13] A cloud of ash from the volcano was dragged over the United Kingdom, forming a visible haze to the north-west of Xynthia on visible satellite imagery.

On 11 March 2010, catastrophe risk modelling firm EQECAT estimated wind losses for affected countries excluding Portugal and Spain as follows: Mean damage: €1.3 billion (approximately US$1.8 billion); Mean insured gross loss: €994 million (approximately US$1.4 billion).[14] One year after the event, the insurance industry loss aggregator PERILS AG published its final loss estimate for Xynthia of €1.32bn, excluding the French indemnified losses.[15]

Response

Météo-France issued its second highest warning (orange) for 27 February and early 28 February for Andorra, Ain, Ariège, Cantal, Finistère, Haute-Garonne, Gironde, Isère, Loire, Haute-Loire and Hautes-Pyrénées. It issued its highest warning level (red) for the Charente-Maritime, Vendée, Deux-Sèvres and Vienne.

Helicopters were sent to rescue people on their roofs following flooding in Charente-Maritime and Vendée, France. An emergency meeting was held on 28 February by French Prime Minister François Fillon following the effects in France.

The Portuguese Institute of Meteorology issued red warnings for the northern parts of the country for winds up to, the rest of the country being with orange warnings for wind gusts up to .

Aftermath

The French Government declared the 2010 floods a "catastrophe".[16] A historical study of coastal surges in France conducted after the storm indicated that there had been no previous coastal surge in France with such a high death toll.[16]

In response to the coastal flooding brought by Xynthia, the French Government announced on 8 April 2010 that it had decided to destroy 1,510 houses in the affected areas of which 823 were in the Vendée and 595 were in Charente-Maritime.[16] The government promised to fully compensate all home-owners, based on the value of the real estate prior to the storm, with the ministry of finance stating that they would pay €250,000 per house.[16] In Vendée of the 823 homes designated by the French state to be destroyed, nearly 700 homeowners accepted the compensation terms by the state with demolition taking place in March 2011.[16] In 2011 there remained 79 people who decided to fight the destruction of their homes via the legal system.[16]

The French Government produced a document called Rapid inundation plan: coastal floods, flash floods and dike failures -"Plan submersions rapides: submersions marines, crues soudaines et ruptures de digues" in February 2011.[16] This plan details the policy response brought about not only as a result of Xynthia in February 2010, but also severe June 2010 flash flooding in the Var Department in southern France that led to the deaths of 25 people.[16]

Observed wind gusts

Wind gusts recorded during Xynthia storm in France and Switzerland:[17]

CountryLocationSpeedComments
km/hknmph
France 238km/h at 2877m (9,439feet)
France 209km/h at 1415m (4,642feet)
France Le Markstein172km/h at 1184m (3,885feet)
France 161km/h plain maximum value for the storm
France 160km/h
France Paris (Tour Eiffel) 155km/h
France 148km/h
France 147km/h
France 144km/h
France Saint Agnant, Pointe de Chassiron (Ile d'Oléron) 140km/h
France 138km/h
France 137km/h
France 136km/h
France 132km/h 1999 records beaten for Châteauroux and Blois
France 131km/h
France 130km/h
France 128km/h
France 127km/h
France 126km/h
France 125km/h
France 123km/h
France Paris (Montsouris) 122km/h
France 105km/h
Switzerland148.3km/h at 2966m (9,731feet)
Switzerland 147.2km/h at 449m (1,473feet) high
Switzerland Evionnaz124.9km/h at 480m (1,580feet) high
Switzerland La Dole121.1km/h at 1677m (5,502feet)
Switzerland 119.9km/h at 3451m (11,322feet)
Switzerland 115.6km/h respectively at 420 and 2002m (6,568feet)
Switzerland 112km/h at 830m (2,720feet) high
Switzerland 108.7km/h at 375m (1,230feet) high
Switzerland 105.1km/h at 381m (1,250feet) high
Switzerland Glaris101.9km/h at 1478m (4,849feet)

Highest wind gust per country

Country GustLocation
166 km/h
136 km/hStavelot
165 km/h
146 km/hNordborg
238 km/hPic du Midi de Bigorre
180 km/hBrocken
172 km/h
155 km/hEschen
144 km/h
116 km/hVaalserberg
176 km/hŚnieżka
145 km/h
164 km/hSäntis
119 km/hBruray

External links

Notes and References

  1. News: AIR Estimates Windstorm Xynthia Insured Losses at $2 to $4.1 Billion. International News. ClaimsJournal.com. 3 March 2010. AIR Worldwide. Wells Publishing, Inc. 18 March 2010.
  2. News: Storm batters Europe, at least 55 dead. Europe. CNN. 28 February 2010. Cable News Network. 28 February 2010. Paris, France.
  3. Web site: CAT Updates. RMS. Storm Xynthia. Risk Management Solutions, Inc.. RMS.com. 23 June 2010. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20100306182233/http://www.rms.com/ClientResources/Catupdates/CatUpdatePublic.asp?event_id=3036. 6 March 2010.
  4. News: Violent winter storm kills 62 in western Europe. https://web.archive.org/web/20100426223243/http://news.xinhuanet.com/english2010/world/2010-03/03/c_13194575.htm. dead. April 26, 2010. English.news.cn. Xinhuanet. 3 March 2010. Xinhua News Agency. 18 March 2010.
  5. Staff (1 March 2010) "Weak sea walls blamed for France storm disaster " BBC News
  6. News: Au moins 40 morts après le passage de la tempête Xynthia. 28 February 2010. lemonde.fr. fr. 28 February 2010.
  7. News: Rescapés des eaux. 28 February 2010. sudouest.com. fr. 7 March 2010.
  8. News: Un cataclysme en Oléron. 28 February 2010. sudouest.com. fr. 7 March 2010.
  9. News: La tempête Xynthia des 27-28 février 2010. 28 February 2010. meteofrance.com. fr. 7 March 2010.
  10. News: At least 50 dead in western Europe storms. 28 February 2010. BBC News. 28 February 2010.
  11. News: Intensidade de vento no Continente . 1 March 2010. www.meteo.pt. pt. 1 March 2010.
  12. News: Estación C072-Orduña Información del dato validado. 28 February 2010. euskalmet.euskadi.net. es. 28 February 2010.
  13. Web site: Volcanoes, dust, and storms . Wyss . Yim . Judy . Huang . Johnny C.L. . Chan . June 2010 . . 19 August 2014.
  14. Web site: EQECAT Estimates Losses for Wind Storm Xynthia . 11 March 2010 .
  15. Web site: Inside Newsletter . April 2011 . PERILS AG . 2012-09-26 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140108013917/http://www.perils.org/dms/perils/documents/newsletter/PERILS-Inside-03/PERILS%20Inside%2003.pdf . 2014-01-08 . dead .
  16. Lumbroso. D. M.. Vinet, F.. A comparison of the causes, effects and aftermaths of the coastal flooding of England in 1953 and France in 2010. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences. 2011. 11. 8. 2321–2333. 10.5194/nhess-11-2321-2011. 4 July 2013. 2011NHESS..11.2321L . free.
  17. http://france.meteofrance.com/france/actu/bilan/archives/2010/bilanxynthia?page_id=12002 Météo France