Internet homicide explained

Internet homicide, also called internet assassination, refers to killing in which victim and perpetrator met online, in some cases having known each other previously only through the Internet.[1] [2] [3] Also Internet killer is an appellation found in media reports for a person who broadcasts the crime of murder online or who murders a victim met through the Internet.[4] Depending on the venue used, other terms used in the media are Internet chat room killer, Craigslist killer, Facebook serial killer. Internet homicide can also be part of an Internet suicide pact or consensual homicide.[5] Some commentators believe that reports on these homicides have overemphasized their connection to the Internet.[6]

Serial killers

Serial killers are murderers who target three or more victims sequentially, with a "cooling off" period between each murder, and whose motivation for killing is largely based on psychological gratification.[7] [8] Such killers have used forms of social networking to attract victims long before the advent of the Internet. For example, between 1900 and 1914, Hungarian serial killer Béla Kiss lured his 24 victims by using personal ads published in newspapers.[9]

According to Paul Bocj, the author of Cyberstalking: Harassment in the Internet Age and How to Protect Your Family, "The idea that a serial killer may have operated via the Internet is, understandably, one that has resulted in a great deal of public anxiety."[10] In Harold Schecter's A to Z Encyclopedia of Serial Killers, the entry for "Internet" reads in part: "If the Internet has become a very useful tool for people interested in serial killers, there's some indication that it may also prove to be a resource for serial killers themselves." Maurice Godwin, a forensic consultant, argued that "There are some sadistic predators that rely on the Mardi Gras Effect ["the ability to hide one's identity on the Internet"] to lure and murder repeatedly."[11] The first serial killer known to have used the Internet to find victims was John Edward Robinson, who was arrested in 2000 and was referred to in Law Enforcement News as the "USA's first Internet serial killer" and "the nation's first documented serial killer to use the Internet as a means of luring victims."[12] [13]

Venues

Online predators, participants in internet suicide and suicide-homicide pacts, and internet killers may seek out victims through internet forums, chat rooms, listservs, email, bulletin boards, social networking sites, online role playing games, online dating services, Yahoo groups, or Usenet.[14] [15] [16]

Chat rooms

Online chatrooms are sometimes used by killers to meet and bait potential victims.[2] [3] [17] For example, the Japanese serial murderer Hiroshi Maeue is known to have found victims by using online suicide chat rooms.[18] The killer Lisa Marie Montgomery is reported to have met her victim in an online chatroom for rat terrier lovers called "Ratter Chatter."[19]

Online chatrooms are also used, in some cases, to plan consensual homicides. For example, in 1996, a Maryland woman, Sharon Lopatka, apparently agreed to be killed by torture and strangulation in a conversation with a man in an online chatroom.[20] [21] Robert Frederick Glass pleaded guilty to killing Lopatka and later died in prison while serving his sentence. In a case that might be regarded as a quasi-consensual homicide, "John," a teenage boy from Altrincham, England, allegedly tricked another teenager into killing him using long conversations in an online chatroom. The other teenager, Mark, apparently believed he was being recruited by a female Secret Service agent. The suicide-by-homicide failed and on May 29, 2004 John pleaded guilty to inciting someone to murder him and was sentenced to three years supervision. Mark pleaded guilty to attempted murder and was sentenced to two years supervision. The boys were forbidden to contact each other.[22]

Online advertisements

As an article in the New York Daily News explained in 2009, "Long before there was a craigslist or dot-com dating, there were places where men and women who were too shy or busy to meet face to face could find romance. Calling themselves "matrimonial bureaus," these organizations were known mostly as the "lonely hearts clubs," and they flourished through the middle of the 20th century."[23] It was in venues like these—print media such as newspaper classified ads and personal or lonely hearts club ads—that 20th century murderers such as Harry Powers, the so-called "Matrimonial Bureau Murderer,"[23] and Harvey Carignan, "the Want Ad Killer"[24] met their victims.

Electronic advertising has gradually replaced printed ads and the Internet is now a venue where murderers who employ a similar modus operandi can meet their victims; in Schecter's Encyclopedia, the entry for "Ads" mentions Internet dating and the use of Internet ads by the so-called "Internet Cannibal" Armin Meiwes.[25] Since 2007, several accused and convicted killers have contacted victims through advertising services such as Craigslist, a popular classified advertising website. These killers are sometimes referred to in the media as "Craigslist killers";[26] [27] [28] the first use of the term Craigslist killings may date to October 31, 2007, when the phrase appeared in a headline in the Saint Paul Pioneer Press in Minnesota, in reference to the murder of Katherine Olson by Michael John Anderson, who was then dubbed "the Craigslist killer".[29]

Since 2007, several suspected and convicted perpetrators have met their victims or solicited murder through Craigslist. Of those cases, two were convicted for crimes in the three-month period encompassing February to April 2009 and a further four were accused of crimes during the 13-month span of March 2008 through April 2009.[26] [27] [28] Although, by definition, Craigslist will have been the initial contact point and a killing will have taken place in order for the suspected, accused, or convicted perpetrator to be dubbed a Craigslist killer, the actual motivations of these criminals are varied. The victims' deaths may result from a robbery or a sexual encounter that turned violent. Some of these perpetrators may not have intended to commit murder, but killed their victims during the course of a struggle or to prevent capture. Each case is different.

Internet dating

In 1995, Match.com was launched as the first online dating application. In the following decades internet dating has become the second largest paid Internet industry. However, often people suffering from relatedness frustration will seek affection and care online, but find their needs are not met. The self-esteem enhancement was found to produce problematic usage of internet dating apps due to the sex motive.[30]

According to Michael Largo, the author of Final Exits: The Illustrated Encyclopedia of How We Die,[31] "Internet dating is becoming very popular, but since 1995, there's been[...] over 400 instances where a homicide has been related to the person that [the victim] met online."[32]

Criticism of the concept

Several legal and technology experts have questioned the idea that there is a phenomenon of Internet killings. A legal theorist pressed for an Internet angle on a murder by a journalist related that "I asked her whether, if I called her up and asked her out on a blind date and murdered her, she would think it was a "telephone-related murder"?".[33]

Leslie Harris, CEO of the Center for Democracy and Technology said of the term "Craigslist Killer" that "A great many of the tragic incidents that tangentially involve the Internet have little or nothing to do with the Internet itself. The Craigslist case is the latest example of that phenomenon. Craigslist is an innovative and valuable resource, which frankly, is being unfairly smeared because it is an Internet site."[6] The book Hypercrime argues that "The more one looks, the more these widely circulated instances of 'cyberkilling' appear to vanish into the smoke of a 'cyberspace'."[5]

Susan Brenner, a professor of law and technology wrote that "Is it a cybercrime for John to meet Mary on the Internet, correspond with her and use e-mail to lure her to a meeting where he kills her? News stories often describe conduct such as this as a cybercrime, or as 'Internet murder.' But why is this anything other than murder? We do not, for example, refer to killings orchestrated over the telephone as 'tele-murder' or by snail mail as 'mail murder.' It seems that this is not a cybercrime, that it is simply a real-world crime the commission of which happens to involve the use of computer technology," but she conceded that "there may be reasons to treat conduct such as this differently and to construe it as something other than a conventional crime."[34]

Notable Internet homicides

The following individuals have been arrested and/or convicted of crimes in which police claimed that Internet services such as chat rooms and Craigslist advertisements were used to contact victims or hire a murderer. Despite sharing a similar method of contacting victims, they apparently have varied motivations. In the list below, the victims' deaths may have been premeditated, especially if the perpetrator is a serial killer, but they may also have resulted from a robbery, insurance fraud, or a sexual encounter that turned violent.

See also

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. Psychiatric mental health nursing, Katherine M. Fortinash, Patricia A. Holoday-Worret, 2007 - Page 509, definition: "Internet Homicide: Luring a person from a chat room to an actual meeting. Can turn deadly."
  2. http://www.napavalley.edu/Projects/189/Chapter_022_4th_ed__handout.pdf{{dead link|date=May 2017 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }} Napa Valley College teaching text: Chapter 22, definition: "Internet Homicide: Luring a person from a chat room to an actual meeting. May turn deadly."
  3. Killers on the Web: True Stories of Internet Cannibals, Murderers and Sex Criminals by Christopher Berry-Dee and Steven Morris, John Blake Publishing, 2006.
  4. Criminal Profiling: An Introduction to Behavioral Evidence Analysis by Brent E. Turvey, 2008 ("... the Internet enables offenders to gain control of their victims.")
  5. Book: McGuire, Michael. Hypercrime: the new geometry of harm. Routledge. 2007. 9781904385530.
  6. News: Because "Classified Ad Killer" Doesn't Have the Same Ring. Harris. Leslie. 24 April 2009. Huffington Post. 2009-06-10.
  7. Holmes and Holmes, Contemporary, p. 1
  8. Encyclopedia: Burkhalter Chmelir . Sandra . Robert Kastenbaum . Macmillan Encyclopedia of Death and Dying . Serial Killers . 2003 . Macmillan Reference USA/Thomson/Gale . 2 . New York, New York . 1 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090503121235/http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_gx5214/is_2003/ai_n19132282/?tag=content;col1 . 2009-05-03 . dead .
  9. Greig, Charlotte (2005). Evil Serial Killers: In the Minds of Monsters. New York: Barnes & Noble. p. 194.
  10. Cyberstalking: Harassment in the Internet Age and How to Protect Your Family by Paul Bocj, Praeger Publishers, 2004
  11. Web site: CyberMurder.com. Godwin. Maurice. Summer 2005. Web Mystery Magazine. 2009-06-10. https://archive.today/20130103195620/http://lifeloom.com/III1Godwin.htm. 2013-01-03. dead.
  12. Web site: Bistate task force thinks it has USA's first Internet serial killer - L.E.N. Vol. XXVI, No. 536 . . June 30, 2000 . April 24, 2009 . John Robinson posed first as a kindly philanthropist eager to help troubled young women out of poverty, then as "Slavemaster," a sadomasochist seeking like-minded partners. Now, investigators assigned to a Kansas-Missouri task force believe they may have in custody the nation's first documented serial killer to use the Internet as a means of luring victims. . May 3, 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090503195032/http://www.lib.jjay.cuny.edu/len/2000/06.30/ . dead .
  13. Clues from killers: serial murder and crime scene messages. Dirk Cameron Gibson, 2004
  14. http://www.Microsoft.com/protect/family/guidelines/predators.mspx "Online Predators: Help minimize the risk"
  15. Web site: Williams. Pete. Pete Williams (journalist). MySpace, Facebook attract online predators. NBC News. 2006-02-03. 2006-12-08 .
  16. Web site: Burt. David. David Burt (filtering advocate). Playstation Pedophiles. Filtering Facts. 2009-03-16. 2009-03-16. [G]aming consoles such as PlayStation, Wii, and Xbox have become Internet-enabled, interactive devices. This provides an opportunity for pedophiles to befriend and groom minors.. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20090405143950/http://filteringfacts.org/2009/03/16/playstation-pedophiles/. 2009-04-05.
  17. Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing, Katherine M. Fortinash and Patricia A. Holoday-Worret, 2007 - Page 509, definition: "Internet Homicide: Luring a person from a chat room to an actual meeting. Can turn deadly."
  18. News: Suicide websites an aid to murder . . August 12, 2005 . April 23, 2009 .
  19. News: Law Center: Couple allegedly showed off kidnapped baby; Dad united with daughter . [CNN] . December 20, 2004 . April 27, 2009 . [Montgomery], using a fictitious name, contacted Stinnett on Wednesday through an Internet chat room about looking at rat terriers the Stinnetts sold over the Internet. [...] The Internet chat room "Ratter Chatter," a haven for rat terrier lovers in cyberspace, was overwhelmed with responses from its users, many of whom indicated they knew both the victim and suspect in the case..
  20. Web site: FoRK Archive: Networking With Stranger Was Fatal. www.xent.com.
  21. Web site: Internet Assisted Suicide: The Story of Sharon Lopata by Rachael Bell, at CrimeLibrary.com . 2009-04-27 . https://web.archive.org/web/20030406115408/http://www.crimelibrary.com/notorious_murders/classics/sharon_lopatka/1.html?sect=13 . 2003-04-06 . dead .
  22. News: Boy used chat room to get himself killed . Nigel Bunyan . . May 30, 2004 . April 26, 2009.
  23. News: Lonely Hearts Murderer' . . April 5, 2009 . April 22, 2009 . Long before there was a craigslist or dot-com dating, there were places where men and women who were too shy or busy to meet face to face could find romance. Calling themselves "matrimonial bureaus," these organizations were known mostly as the "lonely hearts clubs," and they flourished through the middle of the 20th century. [...] (The article is a sidebar to a story about Philip Markoff, a "Craigslist killer" and it describes the murders committed in 1931 by Harry F. Powers, the so-called "Matrimonial Bureau Murderer," also known as "The West Virginia Bluebeard" and "The Butcher of Clarksburg.") . Mara . Bovsun . April 9, 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090409144911/http://www.nydailynews.com/news/ny_crime/2009/04/05/2009-04-05_lonely_hearts_murderer.html . dead .
  24. "The Want Ad Killer" by Ann Rule, 1983 . (This book is about the serial killer Harvey Carignan.)
  25. The A to Z Encyclopedia of Serial Killers, Harold Schechter, Pocket Books, 1997, Revised Updated edition July 4, 2006
  26. News: Craigslist Killer Michael John Anderson . . April 2, 2009 . April 21, 2009 . April 2, 2009: New York Daily News refers to Michael John Anderson as "Craigslist Killer." . April 6, 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090406095030/http://www.nydailynews.com/news/us_world/2009/04/02/2009-04-02_craigslist_killer_michael_john_anderson_.html . dead .
  27. Web site: Alleged Craigslist Killer: 'Cash for Story' . . March 30, 2009 . April 21, 2009 . March 30, 2009: The Advocate refers to John Katehis as "Craigslist Killer." . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20090403083505/http://www.advocate.com/news_detail_ektid76839.asp . April 3, 2009 .
  28. News: Cops have Philip Markoff, suspected 'Craigslist Killer' of model Julissa Brisman, in custody . . April 20, 2009 . April 21, 2009 . Suspected "Craigslist killer" may have robbed his victims to pay off gambling debts. . Beverly . Ford . Erica . Pearson . Helen . Kennedy . April 21, 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090421231105/http://www.nydailynews.com/news/ny_crime/2009/04/20/2009-04-20_massachussetts_police_arrest_suspect_in_craigslist_killer_case.html . dead .
  29. News: Craigslist killings: Police say suspect Michael John Anderson left a trail of evidence. . . October 31, 2007 . April 23, 2009 . New York . April 6, 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090406095030/http://www.nydailynews.com/news/us_world/2009/04/02/2009-04-02_craigslist_killer_michael_john_anderson_.html . dead .
  30. Bonilla-Zorita . Gabriel . Griffiths . Mark D. . Kuss . Daria J. . December 2021 . Online Dating and Problematic Use: A Systematic Review . International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction . en . 19 . 6 . 2245–2278 . 10.1007/s11469-020-00318-9 . 219590611 . 1557-1874. free .
  31. Final Exits: The Illustrated Encyclopedia of How We Die by Michael Largo, HarperCollins, 2006,
  32. Web site: the original . bot: unknown . https://web.archive.org/web/20071012224908/http://videojug.com/interview/loved-to-death . 12 October 2007 . archived from Web site: the original. 2009-04-27. https://web.archive.org/web/20090421145814/http://www.videojug.com/interview/loved-to-death#how-dangerous-is-internet-dating. 2009-04-21. dead.
  33. Book: Turkle, Sherry. Technological Visions: The Hopes and Fears that Shape New Technologies. Marita Sturken . Douglas Thomas . Sandra Ball-Rokeach. Temple University Press. 2004 . 20. 1: "Spinning" Technology. 9781592132270. registration.
  34. Brenner. Susan W.. Fall 2004. Cybercrime Metrics: Old Wine, New Bottles?. Virginia Journal of Law & Technology. University of Virginia. 9. 13.
  35. Web site: Internet Assisted Suicide: The Story of Sharon Lopatka by Rachael Bell, at CrimeLibrary.com . 2009-04-27 . https://web.archive.org/web/20030406115408/http://www.crimelibrary.com/notorious_murders/classics/sharon_lopatka/1.html?sect=13 . 2003-04-06 . dead .
  36. News: Murder By Internet . Wired.
  37. News: Israel's 'First Internet Murder' . Wired . 19 January 2001 . Hershman, Tania . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20121025113122/http://www.wired.com/politics/law/news/2001/01/41300 . October 25, 2012 .
  38. Web site: The Murder of Ofir Rahum . 2013-11-12 . https://web.archive.org/web/20071022111226/http://www.gov.il/FirstGov/TopNavEng/EngSubjects/SafeSurfingEng/TeenagersEng/SSETSurfSafetly/SSETSTOphirRachum/ . 2007-10-22 . dead .
  39. News: אמנה מונא הורשעה בגרימת מותו של אופיר רחום. October 21, 2003. ynet. וייס . אפרת .
  40. News: מאסר עולם לאמנה מונא על רצח הנער אופיר רחום. November 6, 2003. ynet. וייס . אפרת .
  41. The Man Who Ate His Lover . Body Shock (Channel 4 TV, UK) . 2009-04-27 . 2008-09-25 . https://web.archive.org/web/20080925123146/http://www.channel4.com/science/microsites/S/science/body/bodyshock_cannibal.html . dead .
  42. Web site: Kacie Woody Foundation. September 20, 2021.
  43. 'Internet Slave Master' by John Glatt, 2001, St. Martin's Paperbacks.
  44. 'Anyone You Want Me to Be: A True Story of Sex and Death on the Internet' by John Douglas and Stephen Singular.
  45. Gribben, Mark. "John E. Robinson, Sr.: The Slavemaster". Crime Library. truTV.
  46. Web site: Internet suicide chat room killer held. United Press International. January 10, 2003. April 23, 2009.
  47. Web site: Extraordinary scenes at start of Carly Ryan murder trial - The Advertiser . 2019-08-30 . 2019-10-12 . https://web.archive.org/web/20191012110645/https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/news/south-australia/extraordinary-scenes-at-start-of-carly-ryan-murder-trial/news-story/b8def169051def97c91c9ad3bd648662 . dead .
  48. Web site: Mother of murdered teen Carly Ryan still fighting online predators - Sydney Morning Herald. 25 February 2017.
  49. The internet chatroom murder . Assignment (BBC World Service) . November 2007 . 2007 . 10 June 2009.
  50. News: An IM Infatuation Turned to Romance. Then the Truth Came Out. Labi. Nadya. 21 August 2007. Wired. 2009-06-10.
  51. Web site: Talhotblond. www.imdb.com.
  52. News: Craigslist Killer Michael John Anderson . . October 31, 2007 . April 23, 2009 . The 19-year-old Savage man used Craigslist to lure Katherine Ann Olson to his home for a fictitious baby-sitting job, then shot her in the back, according to the criminal complaint filed Tuesday..
  53. News: Warrants detail how murder victim, suspect met online, after e-mailing, they set up a meeting in person, documents say . . March 22, 2008 . April 23, 2009.
  54. Web site: California Woman Targeted For Murder On Craigslist . . January 26, 2008 . April 23, 2009 . Craigslist has gained some level of notoriety for ads posted by prostitutes and the killing of a Minnesota woman last year who responded to an ad for a baby sitter. However, authorities and company officials say the murder-for-hire scheme appears to be the first of its kind. . https://web.archive.org/web/20090503122954/http://wjz.com/watercooler/craigslist.murder.for.2.638791.html . 2009-05-03 . dead.
  55. Web site: Caught up in a violent Web . . April 19, 2009 . April 23, 2009 . Law enforcement officials warn that the slaying of Julissa Brisman is far from the only violent crime linked to Craigslist..
  56. News: 'Germany's First Internet Killer,' Christian G, Admits Murdering Women He Met Online. Huffington Post. January 15, 2009. April 23, 2009.
  57. News: 'Internet killer' admits murdering women he met in online chat rooms. London Telegraph. January 15, 2009. April 23, 2009.
  58. News: Police warn of internet danger after office worker jailed for life for murder . https://web.archive.org/web/20090526010325/http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/politics/lawandorder/5309259/Police-warn-of-internet-danger-after-office-worker-jailed-for-life-for-murder.html. dead. May 26, 2009. 11 May 2009. Daily Telegraph. 2009-05-13 . London.
  59. News: Web murderer given life sentence. 11 May 2009. BBC News. 2009-05-13.
  60. Web site: Police: Slain Reporter Met Teen Killer on Craigslist . . March 25, 2009 . April 20, 2009.
  61. News: Ore. Woman accused of killing mother-to-be - on Deadline - USATODAY.com . USA Today . August 13, 2010 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20090610224303/http://blogs.usatoday.com/ondeadline/2009/06/ore-woman-accused-of-killing-mothertobe-baby-cut-from-womb.html . June 10, 2009 .
  62. Web site: Butiwantcake . The Murder of Asia McGowan . BlogHer . 2009-04-28 . 2014-04-11 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140322003707/http://www.blogher.com/murder-asia-mcgowan . 2014-03-22 . dead .
  63. Web site: Monday . YouTube Facebook Murder: Black Woman Slaughtered by Crazed Fellow YouTuber and Facebook Stalker-Detroit Police Ignored Warnings by YouTubers . What About Our Daughters . 2009-04-13 . 2014-04-11 . 2010-05-29 . https://web.archive.org/web/20100529084834/http://www.whataboutourdaughters.com/2009/04/youtube-facebook-murder-black-woman-slaughtered-by-crazed-fellow-youtuber-and-facebook-stalker-detroit-police-ignored-warnings-by-youtubers/ . dead .
  64. Web site: Asia McGowan (20) was shot and killed in a murder-suicide . MyDeathSpace.com . 2014-04-11.
  65. News: DA: Markoff fashioned 'primitive scalpel' to kill himself . 2010-08-17 . 2010-08-18 . Boston Globe . Finucane, Martin.
  66. Web site: Horrorcore rapper 'Syko Sam' arrested for gruesome crime . 6 October 2009 . International Business Times, Oct 6, 2009 .
  67. Web site: UK Man Impersonates BMTH's Oliver Sykes, Jailed for Attempted Murder of California Woman . SMNnews.com . 2011-10-05 . 2014-04-11 . https://web.archive.org/web/20150716054943/http://www.smnnews.com/2011/10/05/uk-man-impersonates-bmths-oliver-sykes-jailed-for-attempted-murder-of-california-woman/ . 2015-07-16 . dead .
  68. News: Palmer . Kim . Ohio judge sentences convicted Craigslist killer to death . Reuters . April 4, 2013 . 2014-04-11 . 2013-12-20 . https://web.archive.org/web/20131220182922/http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/04/04/us-usa-crime-craigslist-idUSBRE9330LS20130404 . live .
  69. News: The Craigslist killers. The Observer. Hannah Rosin. Hannah Rosin. 10 November 2013. 10 November 2013. https://web.archive.org/web/20131110114916/http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/nov/10/craigslist-killers-murder-story-family-breakdown. 2013-11-10.
  70. News: Murder by Craigslist. 14 August 2013. 29 December 2013. Hannah Rosin. The Atlantic. Hannah Rosin.
  71. News: Draznin, Haley, Welch, Chris. Candiotti, Susan. Woman accused in Craigslist slaying tells newspaper: I've killed lots of others. CNN. February 16, 2014.
  72. News: Scant evidence of satanic 'Craigslist killer' Miranda Barbour's claims of mass murder: authorities . ABC News. December 7, 2013.
  73. News: Newlyweds Accused of Thrill-Kill Craigslist Murder. NY Daily News. February 19, 2014. New York.
  74. News: Police: Woman held in D.C. lawyer's slaying planned only to rob him. Washington Post.
  75. Web site: District Woman Sentenced to 24 Years in Prison for Murder of Man at Northwest Washington Hotel . 21 August 2015 .