Corruption in Singapore explained

The Republic of Singapore is generally perceived as one of the least corrupt countries in the world. Cases are mostly handled by the Singapore Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB), a government agency in Singapore that investigates and prosecutes corruption in the public and private sectors.[1] According to a Transparency International survey, an overwhelming majority of people in Singapore do not hear cases of corruption by public officials or institutions through media in their lifetime. In 2020, Singapore's public sector was ranked by Transparency International as the fourth least corrupt in the world and the most transparent in Asia.[2]

Overview

Transparency International's 2023 Corruption Perceptions Index scored 180 countries on a scale from 0 ("highly corrupt") to 100 ("very clean") and ranked the countries by score. Singapore received a score of 83 and was ranked 5th, where the country ranked first is perceived to have the most honest public sector.[3] For comparison with worldwide scores, the best score was 90 (ranked 1), the average score was 43, and the worst score was 11 (ranked 180).[4] For comparison with regional scores, the highest score among the countries of the Asia Pacific region was 85only New Zealand outscored Singapore in the regionthe average score was 45 and the lowest score was 17.[5]

According to Transparency International's 2015 "Government Defence Anti-Corruption Index" the highest corruption risk area is "Operations" followed by "Finance".[6]

Business executives surveyed in the World Economic Forum's 2014–2015 Global Competitiveness Report reported no problems doing business in Singapore.[7]

A strain of political reasoning behind Singapore's low corruption theorizes that compared to neighboring nations such as Thailand and Malaysia, a theory that the powers of the state were able to pressure private interests into funneling capital into sectors that would ultimately benefit the public in the long term.[8]

Indicators of corruption

Common measurements of corruption in Singapore
Year Corruption Perceptions IndexBribes Payer IndexControl of Corruption
Rank Score Rank ScoreRank Score
2023 5/180 83/100[9] - - - -
2022 5/180 83/100[10] - - - -
2021 4/180 85/100[11] - - - -
2020 4/180 85/100 - - - -
2019 4/180 85/100 - - - -
2018 3/180 85/100 - - - -
2017 6/180 84/100 - - - -
2016 7/168 84/100 - - - -
2015 8/168 85/100 - - - -
2014 7/175 84/100 - - - -
2013 5/177 86/100 - - - -
2012 5/176 87/100 - - - -
2011 5/183 9.2/10 8/28 8.3/10 - -
2010 1/178 9.3/10 --99% 2.18370827

Notable incidents

Below are notable Singaporean corruption-related incidents in both the public[12] and private[13] sector.

Tan Kia Gan (1966)

In August 1966, Tan Kia Gan, a former Minister for National Development (1960–1963), was investigated for attempting to assist businessman Lim Tjin Hauw and his son William Lim in securing the sale of a Boeing aircraft to Malaysian Airways. In exchange, he received 70,000 shares valued at S$1 each. As Tan lost his parliamentary seat in the 1963 general elections, he was administratively relieved of all his public appointments by the Singaporean government.[14] [15]

Wee Toon Boon (1975)

In 1975, Wee Toon Boon, a Minister of State for Defence and the Environment, was found guilty of corruption and sentenced to four years and six months in prison, which was reduced to 18 months upon appeal.[16] [17]

Phey Yew Kok (1979)

In 1979, Phey Yew Kok, the chairman of the National Trades Union Congress and a Member of Parliament for Boon Teck SMC, was charged for misuse of union funds and criminal breach of trust.[18] Phey went on the run for the next 35 years until he surrendered to the Singapore embassy in Bangkok in 2015. Phey later pleaded guilty to 12 of the 34 charges against him and was sentenced to 60 months imprisonment.[19]

Teh Cheang Wan (1986)

In 1986, Teh Cheang Wan, the Minister for National Development, was investigated by the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) for alleged corruption. Teh committed suicide on 14 December 1986 before he could be charged in court.[20] [21]

Koh Seah Wee & Christopher Lim Chai Meng (2011)

In 2011, Koh Seah Wee, a former deputy director of technology and infrastructure in the Singapore Land Authority (SLA), and Christopher Lim Chai Meng, a former manager in the SLA, were found guilty by the High Court of cheating and money laundering charges. Koh was sentenced to 22 years in prison after admitting to 59 charges and Lim was sentenced to 15 years after admitting to 49 charges. Of the S$12.2 million laundered, S$7.5 million was recovered from Koh. Koh and Lim had cheated the SLA by using false invoices issued by former swimming coach Ho Yen Teck, who had set up seven sole proprietorships to provide fake IT maintenance services and goods that were not delivered. Ho was jailed for 10 years for the conspiracy.[22]

Peter Lim Sin Pang (2012)

On 19 December 2011, Peter Lim Sin Pang, former commissioner of the Singapore Civil Defence Force,[23] was arrested by the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) while Ng Boon Gay, former chief of the Central Narcotics Bureau, was also taken in for questioning by the CPIB on 4 January 2012.[24] Both men were being investigated in connection with the Prevention of Corruption Act relating to an IT contract,[25] and in late January 2012, it was announced that they also faced disciplinary action by the Public Service Commission, which oversees the conduct of civil servants. The two men were then interdicted, a step only taken when an individual "faces serious offences for which criminal proceedings or proceedings for his dismissal or reduction in rank are being contemplated."[26]

Lee Hsien Loong, the Prime Minister, promised that the CPIB would follow through with the probe.[27] The CPIB's subsequent silence on the investigations came under the scrutiny of some Members of Parliament during a parliamentary sitting in February 2012. Teo Chee Hean, the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Home Affairs, defended the CPIB, stating that any announcement on the outcome of the probe would have been premature and might have compromised the investigations. He also assured Parliament that all the findings of the investigations would be publicly reported once they had been finalised.[28]

In 2013, Lim was found guilty of corruptly obtaining sexual gratification from three women and sentenced to six months' imprisonment,[29] while Ng was acquitted of four charges of corruptly obtaining sexual gratification from a woman.[30] [31]

Bernard Lim Yong Soon (2012)

In July 2012, the purchase of 26 Brompton foldable bicycles (at the cost of S$2,000 each) by the National Parks Board (NParks) sparked a nationwide uproar after it was revealed by a whistleblower on online forum HardwareZone of possible corruption and numerous red flags in the way the procurement was done.[32] Khaw Boon Wan, the Minister of National Development, initially defended the NParks's purchase of the foldable bicycles.[33]

A subsequent investigation by the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) resulted in the arrest of Bernard Lim Yong Soon, an assistant director at NParks. Lim was found guilty of lying to auditors about his relationship with the bicycle firm which was awarded the tender, and given the maximum fine of S$5,000.[34] [35]

Edwin Yeo Seow Hiong (2013)

On 23 July 2013, Edwin Yeo Seow Hiong of the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) was charged with misappropriating at least S$1.7 million from the CPIB between 2008 and 2012.[36] Yeo was interdicted from his position as head of field research and technical support at the CPIB to assist in a Commercial Affairs Department probe into his suspected financial impropriety. Eight of the charges were for misappropriating funds and criminal breach of trust, one was for forgery and the rest were in using part of his ill-gotten gains to gamble at the Marina Bay Sands casino.[37] On 20 February 2014, Yeo was sentenced to 10 years in prison.[38]

Lim Cheng Hoe (2014)

On 20 February 2014, Lim Cheng Hoe, a former protocol chief at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, was sentenced to 15 months' jail for cheating. From February 2008 to May 2012, Lim had made false claims for S$89,000 worth of pineapple tarts and wine as gifts for foreign diplomats.[39] [40]

Victor Wong Chee Meng (2016)

In 2016, Victor Wong Chee Meng, the general manager and secretary of Ang Mo Kio Town Council, was removed from his position and investigated by the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau after a complaint was lodged in September 2016 over "the way he handles contracts and dealings in the town council". Wong, a Public Service Medal recipient, was concurrently an employee of CPG Facilities Management, the appointed managing agent of the town council.[41] [42] On 14 March 2018, Wong was charged with 55 counts of corruption for receiving some S$107,000 in bribes from Chia Sin Lan and Alisa Yip Fong Yin, the directors of two building and repair companies.[43] Wong and Chia pleaded guilty during the trial and were sentenced to 27 months and 21 months in prison respectively.[44] After appealing against their sentences, both had their sentences extended to 39 months and 33 months respectively.

Alleged Keppel Corporation bribery (2017)

According to United States prosecutors, Keppel Corporation's offshore and marine arm, Keppel O&M, agreed to pay a US$422 million settlement to avoid a criminal trial for bribing Brazilian officials. Court documents released by the United States Department of Justice revealed that Keppel O&M paid US$55 million in bribes between 2001 and 2014, to win 13 contracts with Petrobras and Sete Brasil – two Brazilian oil companies deeply mired in the country's wide-ranging Operation Car Wash graft scandal.[45] Keppel Corporation is one of the government-linked companies (GLCs) under Temasek Holdings.[46] It was the biggest corruption case involving a GLC in Singapore's history.[47]

The Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau started investigations on the six former Keppel O&M employees who were involved in the case.[48] The investigations had to be closed in 2023 due to insufficient evidence and the inability to summon key witnesses from other countries.[49] Six former Keppel O&M employees received warnings in lieu of prosecution.

Rajkumar Padmanathan (2018)

Rajkumar Padmanathan, a former Republic of Singapore Air Force engineer, was sentenced to 25 months and six weeks' imprisonment on 27 July 2018 on 28 counts of corruption, cheating, and breaching the Official Secrets Act while working at Tengah Air Base and Sembawang Air Base. He had leaked tender quotations in order to secure contracts for companies set up by his wife Jayashree, his friend Jeevan Arumugam, and his acquaintance Kamal Kishore. The total value of contracts awarded to Goodwill Aviation Systems, Eagle Flight Aviation Services, Duratech and Global Trade Well set up for the scam was S$1,817,379.87 from 2008 to 2014.[50]

S. Iswaran (2023)

See main article: Prosecution of S Iswaran. In July 2023, the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) formally opened an investigation into S. Iswaran, the Minister for Transport, and arrested him along with property tycoon Ong Beng Seng. Although both men were released on bail, Iswaran was interdicted and his ministerial pay was reduced to S$8,500.[51]

On 9 January 2024, Chan Chun Sing, the Minister-in-charge of the Public Service and Minister for Education, issued a parliamentary reply that investigations into Iswaran were completed and that the Attorney General's Chambers was reviewing the case.[52] Nine days later, Iswaran arrived at the State Courts where the charges against him were read for the first time.

Iswaran became the first minister to be investigated for corruption in Singapore since 1986 and the first minister to be charged and to face trial in court since 1975. 27 charges were handed down against Iswaran:[53] [54] two charges were for corruptly obtaining favours to advance Ong's business interests through contracts between the Singapore Tourism Board and a private company chaired by Ong; 24 charges were for obtaining valuable items from Ong without any consideration; and one charge was for obstructing the course of justice. Iswaran was represented by Davinder Singh during his trial.

On 24 September 2024, some charges were amended and Iswaran entered a guilty plea. On 3 October, he was sentenced to 12 months' imprisonment on four charges of obtaining gifts worth about S$403,300 over seven years as a public servant, and one count of obstruction of the course of justice.

See also

Notes and References

  1. News: Chong. Elena. Ex-police officer charged with warning dance clubs on raids. https://web.archive.org/web/20151206061833/http://mypaper.sg/top-stories/ex-police-officer-charged-warning-dance-clubs-raids-20151204. dead. 6 December 2015. 4 December 2015. my paper.
  2. News: Ho. Olivia. Singapore ranked fourth least corrupt country in the world, cleanest in Asia. 26 March 2021. Straits Times.
  3. Web site: The ABCs of the CPI: How the Corruption Perceptions Index is calculated . 20 December 2021 . 4 April 2024 . Transparency.org. en.
  4. Web site: Corruption Perceptions Index 2023: Singapore . 4 April 2024 . Transparency.org . 30 January 2024 . en.
  5. Web site: CPI 2023 for Asia Pacific: Regional Stagnation Marked by Inadequate Delivery of Anti-corruption Commitments . 4 April 2024 . Transparency.org. 30 January 2024 . en.
  6. Web site: Singapore. Government Defence Anti-Corruption Index. Transparency International. 4 December 2015.
  7. Web site: Global Competitiveness Report 2013-2014. The World Economic Forum. 25 February 2014.
  8. Doner. Richard F.. Ritchie. Bryan K.. Slater. Dan. April 2005. Systemic Vulnerability and the Origins of Developmental States: Northeast and Southeast Asia in Comparative Perspective. International Organization. en. 59. 2. 327–361. 10.1017/S0020818305050113. 15652250. 1531-5088.
  9. Web site: Corruption Perceptions Index 2023: Singapore . 4 April 2024 . Transparency.org . 30 January 2024 . en.
  10. Web site: Corruption Perceptions Index 2022: Singapore . 4 April 2024 . Transparency.org . 31 January 2023 . en.
  11. Web site: Corruption Perceptions Index 2021 for Singapore. 26 March 2022. Transparency.org. 25 January 2022 . en.
  12. Web site: Public Sector Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau . www.cpib.gov.sg . 16 April 2022 . en.
  13. Web site: Private Sector Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau . www.cpib.gov.sg . 16 April 2022. en.
  14. Web site: Politicians . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20151003194257/https://www.cpib.gov.sg/cases-interest/cases-involving-public-sector-officers/politicians . 3 October 2015 . 5 December 2015 . CPIB . Government of Singapore.
  15. Web site: Iswaran charged: A look at some past corruption cases involving high-ranking government officials. 18 January 2024. Channel News Asia.
  16. News: Ang . Michelle . 31 August 1996 . 'If only I had said yes' . . 3.
  17. News: Hwang . T.F. . 14 July 1976 . Charge four 'clearly wrong'—so 3-year jail sentence is out... . . 1.
  18. Web site: Probe into union's losses completed . 2021-02-24 . eresources.nlb.gov.sg . en-SG.
  19. Web site: hermes . 2018-10-25 . Ex-NTUC chairman Phey Yew Kok, jailed for criminal breach of trust, completes sentence . 2021-02-24 . The Straits Times . en.
  20. Web site: Politicians . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20151003194257/https://www.cpib.gov.sg/cases-interest/cases-involving-public-sector-officers/politicians . 3 October 2015 . 5 December 2015 . CPIB . Government of Singapore.
  21. Jeyaretnam Joshua Benjamin v Lee Kuan Yew [1992] SGCA 27 at [4].
  22. Web site: Ex-SLA employees sentenced to at least 15 years' jail. sg.news.yahoo.com. 4 November 2011 .
  23. News: Gallery: Corruption trial of ex-SCDF chief Peter Lim underway. 13 January 2015. MediaCorp Press Ltd.
  24. Web site: CPIB: Top men were arrested, being probed for graft . Leonard Lim . Straits Times. 26 January 2012.
  25. Web site: Woman in centre of CPIB probe leads double life. AsiaOne. 28 January 2012. 29 December 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20160719090538/http://news.asiaone.com/News/Latest%2BNews/Singapore/Story/A1Story20120128-324386.html. 19 July 2016. dead.
  26. Web site: CPIB probe: Duo facing civil service disciplinary proceedings as well . Toh Yong Chuan . Straits Times. 28 January 2012.
  27. Web site: Govt will follow through on CPIB probe into 2 top men: PM Lee. Chua Lee Hoong. Straits Times. 28 January 2012.
  28. Web site: Premature announcement would have compromised CPIB investigations: DPM Teo . AsiaOne . AsiaOne . 14 February 2012.
  29. News: Ex-SCDF chief Peter Lim dismissed from service . MediaCorp Press Ltd . 13 January 2015.
  30. News: Ex-CNB chief Ng Boon Gay retired from public service: MHA . MediaCorp Press Ltd . 13 January 2015.
  31. Web site: Migration . 11 June 2013 . Prosecution not appealing against ex-CNB chief Ng Boon Gay's acquittal The Straits Times . 27 December 2022 . www.straitstimes.com . en.
  32. Web site: Khaw addresses bike-buy concerns . 21 August 2017 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20171029045642/http://www.asiaone.com/print/News/Latest%2BNews/Singapore/Story/A1Story20120802-362835.html . 29 October 2017 .
  33. Web site: How Hardwarezone Forum broke the Brompton bike fiasco. Mothership.sg. en-US. 18 November 2017.
  34. News: Brompton bikes case: NParks officer fined maximum $5,000 for lying to auditors. Ian. Poh. 10 June 2014. The Straits Times. 18 November 2017. en.
  35. Web site: Brompton bikes case: S$5,000 fine for former NParks official . Lee . Amanda . 11 June 2014 . TODAY . 16 February 2022.
  36. Web site: CPIB officer facing 21 charges of fraud involving at least $1.7 million. 24 July 2013. The Straits Times.
  37. Web site: Senior CPIB officer charged with stealing S$1.76 million engages lawyer. sg.news.yahoo.com.
  38. Web site: Former CPIB Assistant Director jailed 10 years. TODAYonline.
  39. Web site: Ex-MFA protocol chief Lim Cheng Hoe sentenced to 15 months' jail for cheating. 20 February 2014. The Straits Times.
  40. Web site: Former MFA protocol chief Lim Cheng Hoe pleads guilty to 10 counts of fraud. AsiaOne. 17 February 2014 .
  41. Web site: Ang Mo Kio Town Council general manager investigated by CPIB. sg.news.yahoo.com. 29 December 2016 .
  42. Web site: General manager of PAP town council removed from duties and placed under CPIB investigations. 29 December 2016. The Online Citizen. 6 January 2018. 7 January 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20180107061130/https://www.theonlinecitizen.com/2016/12/30/general-manager-of-pap-town-council-removed-from-duties-and-placed-under-cpib-investigations/. dead.
  43. Web site: Former general manager of Ang Mo Kio Town Council charged in court for alleged corruption. 14 March 2018. The Online Citizen. 14 March 2018. 14 March 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20180314090718/https://www.theonlinecitizen.com/2018/03/14/former-general-manager-of-ang-mo-kio-town-council-charged-in-court-for-alleged-corruption/. dead.
  44. Web site: AMKTC corruption case: Jail terms increased for former general manager, company director after appeals . 27 December 2022 . CNA . en.
  45. Web site: Oil, bribes, politicians: what happened to 'clean' Singapore?. South China Morning Post. 29 December 2017.
  46. Web site: Workers' Party to file Parliamentary Questions on Keppel corruption scandal. 29 December 2017. The Online Citizen. 5 January 2018. 5 January 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20180105180434/https://www.theonlinecitizen.com/2017/12/29/workers-party-to-file-parliamentary-questions-on-keppel-corruption-scandal/. dead.
  47. Web site: 2023-02-06 . Singapore's ex-Keppel execs avoid charges over 'lack of evidence' in bribery case . subscription . 2023-03-03 . South China Morning Post . en.
  48. Web site: CPIB issues stern warnings to 6 former Keppel Offshore & Marine employees over Brazil corruption case . 2023-03-03 . CNA . en.
  49. Web site: Keppel corruption case: Lack of sufficient evidence to prosecute 6 ex-employees, says Indranee Rajah . 2023-03-03 . CNA . en.
  50. Web site: Ex-RSAF engineer who cheated Government over $1.8M contracts jailed. sg.news.yahoo.com. 27 July 2018 .
  51. Web site: Iswaran's case: A timeline of events from graft probe, resignation and new charges .
  52. Web site: Iswaran charged: A timeline of CPIB's probe .
  53. Web site: Private jet flight, musical tickets: Iswaran allegedly received items worth over S$384,000 from Ong Beng Seng . 2024-01-25 . CNA . en.
  54. Web site: S Iswaran Charged for Corruption and Other Offences .