Conversion of mosques into non-Islamic places of worship explained

The conversion of mosques into non-Islamic places of worship has occurred for centuries. The most prominent examples of such took place after and during the Reconquista.[1]

Conversion of mosques into churches

This table lists former mosques with identified original buildings or ruins. It also includes those churches where the original structure of the mosque no longer survives and the church was built at the site of a former mosque. It also includes those that were originally churches that were converted to mosques and later reconverted to churches.

Current NameMosque NameImagesCityCountryYear OpenedYear ClosedNotesRef.
Mosque–Cathedral of CórdobaGreat Mosque of Córdoba (Qurṭuba), Aljama MosqueCórdobaSpainearly 8th century1236After the Muslim conquest of the Visigothic Kingdom (710~), the site of former main Visigothic church of Cordoba was divided and shared between Muslims and Christians for seven decades. Later, Abd al-Rahman I purchased the Christian part and built the large mosque in 785. Major extensions were added in the 9th and 10th centuries until a final extension in the 10th century under Almanzor. After Christians recaptured Cordoba in 1236, King Ferdinand III of Castile converted the mosque into a cathedral. Later, a cathedral was built at the center of the old mosque, configuring the current Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba. It was the second largest mosque in the world after Great Mosque in Makkah from the around 9th century, until the Sultan Ahmed Mosque, Istanbul was built in 1588. It had a surface area of 23400m2 and accommodated an estimated 32,000 to 40,000 worshipers. The current mosque structure dates from 784 to 987.[2] [3]
Mosque of Cristo de la LuzMezquita Bab-al-MardumToledoSpain9991186Converted into a church. One of the best preserved Moorish mosques in Spain.
GiraldaGreat Mosque of SevilleSevilleSpain1248Only minaret remains. Mosque comparable in size to Great mosque of Cordoba, destroyed by earthquake in 1365. Minaret used as a church bell tower was built higher in 16th century.
Almonaster la Real MosqueAlmonaster la RealSpain10th centuryBuilt on site of 5th-century Visigoth basilica. Converted into a church after Reconquista. National Monument since 1931.
Mezquita del Alcázar de Jerez la FronteraJerez de la Frontera (Jerez)Spain11th centurymid 13th centuryLocated within former Moorish fortress of Alcazar of Jerez de la Frontera. Only surviving mosque building of 18 former mosques in the Jerez city. Converted into a church after Reconquista.
Mosque of las TorneríasAl-MustimimToledoSpain1060[4] Unusual two-storied mosque. Was built in a busy commercial neighborhood (Arrabal de Francos). Used as a church until 1498–1505, and other uses since. Restoration and preservation done recently.[5]
Mezquita de TórtolesTarazonaSpain15th centuryMosque remains almost not altered in the later centuries. Current building was built in 2 stages, one early 15th century, other late 15th century. It is attached to the remains of the old fortified tower of town castle. Converted into a church in 1526.[6]
Aljama Mosque of Medina AzaharaAljama Masjid of Madinat al-ZahraCórdobaSpain9401010A mosque in Madinat al-Zahra, a vast, fortified Moorish palace-city built by Abd-ar-Rahman III (912–961). The marbled, jeweled complex was plundered & destroyed first by Muslims, then by Christians when the civil war ended the Caliphate of Córdoba. A UNESCO World Heritage site since 2018.[7]
San Sebastián de ToledoAl-Dabbagin MasjidToledoSpain1085~Converted into a church after the 1085 Christian conquest of the area. Renovated several times but the original interior structure remains. The building is now used as a concert & exhibition hall. Belltower built in the 15th century shows characteristics of a former minaret. Ruins of Arab Baths of Tenerías remain lower below on slope.[8] A short reference to mosque exists by Ibn Baskuwal (1101–83) reported by Fath ibn Ibrahim.[9]
Small Royal mosque inside Aljafería PalaceZaragozaSpain10th centuryLocated inside the great fortified palace. A small octagonal mosque, designed as a private oratory for the king and his family. Mosque architecture inspired by the Córdoba mosque. Aljafería is a UNESCO World Heritage site since 1986.[10]
Mezquita-Iglesia de El Salvador, ToledoToledoSpain9th century1085Mosque built on former Visigoth or Roman substrate. Now a rebuilt church but excavations revealed 9th-century structures & elements of a mosque - horseshoe arch arcade, primitive stone minaret, flooring, courtyard with a cistern.[11] [12]
Alminar de Árchez, Alminar Mudéjar (Mudejar Minaret of Árchez)Masyid al-Ta`ibin, Mezquita de los Conversos (Mosque of convert)ÁrchezSpain14th centuryOnly 15-meter tall minaret remains, used as the belfry of Árchez church built on mosque location. The minaret is an Almohade architecture monument and the only remaining jewel of the Nazarí period.[13]
San Sebastian Minaret (Alminar De San Sebastian)RondaSpain1485Only minaret of the medium-size mosque in Plaza Abul Beka neighborhood remains. Minaret was expanded and used as a bell tower. The mosque was converted to a church but destroyed in the 1600s during Morisco Revolts. Ronda was a Muslim city for 700 years. The city had 7 or 8 mosques, none survive today.[14]
Alminar de San Juan (Minaret of San Juan)CórdobaSpain930Only minaret remains of the mosque built in 930 during 1st Spanish Umayyad caliph 'Abd al-Rahman III. Now it's the belfry of San Juan church.[15]
Iglesia de Santiago del Arrabal, ToledoToledoSpainConverted to a church in 1223–25. Caliphate era minaret survives. The church is a Mudéjar style masterpiece, built in 1245–47 on prior structures of a mosque and Visigoth building.[16]
Church of Nuestra Señora de la Encarnación (Benaque, Macharaviaya)MacharaviayaSpainOne of few preserved mosques with original minaret and solid block building built of brick & masonry. Interior single rectangular prayer hall now a church nave. Drilling Mecca facing wall in 2003 showed original mosque construction and 19th-century work. Reconquista era document says "...While it was the visitation and reformation of the houses in the alcayua (or alamiya) in Benaque, the inhabitants used mosque as a parish church, where they had images and heard Mass...".[17] [18]
Church of Nossa Senhora da AnunciaçãoAljama mosque of MartulahMértola (Alentejo)Portugal9th CenturyBest identifiable and unique former mosque in Portugal; a mixture of Almohad and Manueline post-Gothic architecture. The mosque was last rebuilt in the second half of 12th century but some elements date to the 9th century. In 1532 the, church modified the mosque building reducing its size from 6 sections & 20 columns to 4 sections & 12 columns.[19] [20]
Church of São Clemente (Loulé)Loulé (Algarve)Portugal11th CenturyOnly some parts of the original minaret of a former mosque exist, used as a church bell tower. It's 22.7 meters tall and 4.2 meters across. The church was built in the 13th century and is the oldest in Loulé. Across it lies the old Arab cemetery of Jardim dos Amuados. The square plan and misalignment in the orientation of the church building also indicate the presence of a former mosque.[21] [22]
Igreja de Santa Maria do Castelo (Tavira)Tavira(Algarve)Portugal12th CenturyA mosque stood at the highest point within the fortified Medina of Tavira on the location where the Church of Santa Maria stands. Recent excavations unearthed rubbish heaps with 11-12th century materials and dwellings from the first half of the 12th century. A slight canonical disorientation of the church is indicative of the structure originally being a mosque. In 1718, a tomb was found with a corpse accompanied by a Moorish Alfange blade.[23] [24]
Downtown Candlemas Church of the Blessed Virgin MaryMosque of Pasha QasimPécsHungary16th Century1702The current building, a hundred steps in length and in width, was built by Pasha Qasim the Victorious between 1543 and 1546. The mosque was converted to a church in 1702, after Habsburg-Hungarian troops reconquered the city. The minaret was destroyed by the Jesuits in 1766. One of the largest Ottoman constructions remaining in Hungary, the building still retains many Turkish architectural characteristics.[25]
Shrine of Our Lady of EuropeEuropa PointGibraltar1309The mosque was built by Muslim troops at Europa Point, the southernmost part of Gibraltar. In 1309, King Ferdinand IV of Castile took Gibraltar, driving the Muslim troops back across the strait to Africa. The King converted the ancient mosque into a Christian Shrine. The Muslims again captured Gibraltar 24 years later in 1333. In 1462 King Henry IV recaptured Gibraltar and restored the devotion to Our Lady of Europe initiated by his grandfather, Ferdinand, once again transforming the ancient mosque into a Christian Shrine.[26]
Cathedral of St. Mary the CrownedGibraltarGibraltar1462The current cathedral stands at the site of the principal mosque in the center of the city. After the reconquest of the city, the mosque was stripped of its Islamic past and consecrated as the parish church (named Santa Maria la Coronada y San Bernardo). However, under the rule of the Catholic Monarchs, the old building was demolished and a new church was erected, in Gothic style. The cathedral's small courtyard is the remnant of the larger Moorish court of the mosque.[27] [28]
Seven Saints ChurchBlack MosqueSofiaBulgaria15281878The Black Mosque was built on the order of Suleiman the Magnificent with the intention to be more impressive and beautiful than the Christian churches in the city. The mosque is popularly attributed to the famous Ottoman architect Mimar Sinan, although this is uncertain. The mosque is called the Black Mosque, after the dark granite from which its minaret was made.[29]
Church of the AssumptionUzundzhovoBulgaria16th Century1878The mosque is believed to have been built by celebrated Ottoman architect Mimar Sinan and was originally a part of a caravanserai. It was consecrated into a church in 1906.[30] [31]
Church of the Holy Archangels Michael and GabrielBrăilaRomania17th Century19th CenturyOriginally built by the Ottomans, it was converted into a church after the transfer of the city to Wallachia following the Treaty of Adrianople.
Saint Nicholas ChurchIbrahim Pasha MosqueKavalaGreece15301920sThe mosque was built in 1530 by Ibrahim Pasha, the Vizier of Suleiman II and was the largest mosque of Kavala. In the 1920s the mosque was transformed into a church and the base of the minaret was used to build the bell tower. [32]

Conversion of mosques into Hindu temples

This table lists former mosques with identified original buildings that have been converted into temples. It also includes those temples where the original structure of the mosque no longer survives and the temple was built at the site of a former mosque.

Current NameMosque NameImagesCityCountryNotes
Ram Janmabhoomi TempleBabri MasjidAyodhyaIndiaThe 16th-century mosque built on the birthplace of Rama under the reign of and named after Mughal Emperor Babur was demolished in 1992 by a mob of Hindu nationalists. In 2019, after a verdict by the Supreme Court of India, the decision to construct a temple at the site was accepted by the Indian parliament. Archeological Survey of India did excavations and revealed that there was a temple complex underneath the Mosque[33]
Durga MandirJama Masjid of SonipatSonipatIndiaThe imposing structure is currently being used as a Durga Mandir.[34]
Ram Leela MandirJama Masjid of FarrukhnagarFarrukhnagarIndiaMughal Emperor Farrukhsiyar had the Jama Masjid constructed as the principal mosque of Farrukhnagar town, which he founded in 1732 CE. It is now being used as a Hindu temple and Sikh Gurdwara.[35]
Bharat Mata MandirKhilij Jumma MasjidDaulatabad (Aurangabad)IndiaThe Jumma Masjid is the earliest surviving Islamic monument in the Deccan region.[36]
Bhagwan Danasher MandirDana Shir MasjidHisarIndiaThe mosque is built to the west of the courtyard of the Tomb of Dana Shir Bahlul Shah. It is completely built of small bricks and is plastered with fine white stucco.[37]

Conversion of mosques into gurdwaras

This table lists former mosques with identified original buildings that have been converted into Sikh gurdwaras.

Current NameMosque NameCityCountryNotes
Bada GurudwaraJama Masjid of MehamMeham, HaryanaIndiaOne inscription inside the structure dates it to 1531 CE.[38]
Gurdwara Shaheed Bhai Taru SinghShaheed Ganj MosqueLahore, PunjabPakistanCommissioned during the reign of Mughal Emperor Shah Jahan and construction completed in 1722. Converted to Gurudwara in 1762.[39]
Gol GurudwaraGol MasjidAmritsar, PunjabIndiaReference[40]
Sri Guru Singh Sabha GurudwaraKhail Bazaar Jama MasjidPanipat, HaryanaIndiaIts three ribbed domes rise high above the dense marketplace and its central arch with its decorative iwan bear testimony to its Mughal influence.[41]
Gurudwara SahibPurani MasjidGidranwali, HaryanaIndiaReference
Farukh Nagar GurudwaraJama MasjidFarrukhnagar, HaryanaIndiaReference

Conversion of mosques into synagogues

This table lists former mosques with identified original buildings that have been converted into synagogues.

Current NameMosque NameCityCountryNotes
Geulat Israel synagogueWadi Hunayn mosqueNes ZionaIsraelThe former mosque now serves as a Shas-affiliated synagogue. "The Geulat Israel synagogue, founded 5708 (1948)," reads a sign at the entrance.[42]
Shaarei Zion synagogueYazuri mosqueAzurIsraelThe walls of the building have been fixed up, but a closer look at the forest of domes on the roof reveals a Mamluk style, similar to that of many buildings in Jerusalem's Old City.
Sulam Yaakov synagogueSumayil mosqueTel AvivIsraelSumayil was a village largely inhabited by Bedouins hailing from Northern Sinai. This original structure was built by them.

See also

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 5 Most Impressive Historic Mosques in Spain - History Lists. historylists.org. 2020-05-09.
  2. Web site: 5 Most Impressive Historic Mosques in Spain. historylists.org. 27 September 2018.
  3. Web site: Magnificent Mosques of Spain. halaltrip.com. 27 September 2018.
  4. Web site: Las Tornerías. archnet.org. 27 September 2018.
  5. Web site: Fusion of Roman, Visigoth and Muslim culture. turismocastillalamancha.es. 27 September 2018.
  6. Web site: Mosque of Tórtoles (Tarazona, ZARAGOZA). patrimonioculturaldearagon.es. 28 September 2018.
  7. Web site: Cordoba City - Madinat al-Zahra. andalucia.com. 21 March 2015 . 28 September 2018.
  8. Web site: Church (old mosque) of San Sebastián de Toledo. arteguias.com. 28 September 2018.
  9. The existence of the Al-Dabbagin mosque is attested by a short reference by Ibn Baskuwal (1101-83) reported by Fath ibn Ibrahim. see: ''Actas de las i jornadas de Cultura Islámica, Toledo'', Instituto Occidental de Cultura Islámica (ed.) 1987, p. 158
  10. Web site: Aljafería Palace (Islamic part) in Discover Islamic Art. discoverislamicart.org. 28 September 2018.
  11. Web site: Iglesia de El Salvador de Toledo. turismocastillalamancha.es. 28 September 2018.
  12. Web site: Church of the Savior. toledomonumental.com. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20180825062056/http://toledomonumental.com/savador.html. 25 August 2018. 28 September 2018.
  13. Web site: Mudejar Minaret. malaga.es. 29 September 2018.
  14. Web site: San Sebastian Minaret. rondatoday.com. 28 September 2018.
  15. Web site: Minaret of San Juan. archnet.org. 28 September 2018.
  16. Web site: Church of Santiago del Arrabal. discoverislamicart.org. 28 September 2018.
  17. Web site: Parish Church of Nuestra Señora de la Encarnación Benaque. andaluciarustica.com. 16 September 2013. 30 September 2018.
  18. Web site: Church of Our Lady of the Incarnation. Mural paintings, minaret and cemetery. - Benaque (Macharaviaya). viajerosencortomalaga.com. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20190116212313/http://viajerosencortomalaga.com/066005002c04t05.html. 16 January 2019. 30 September 2018.
  19. Web site: Discover Islamic Art - Virtual Museum - monument_ISL_pt_Mon01_10_en. 2021-01-02. islamicart.museumwnf.org.
  20. Web site: DGPC Pesquisa Geral. 2021-01-02. patrimoniocultural.gov.pt.
  21. Web site: AlgarveTips. Loulé: The #1 Guide to This Picturesque Town in the Algarve. 2021-01-02. AlgarveTips. 4 August 2018.
  22. Web site: Discover Islamic Art - Virtual Museum - monument_ISL_pt_Mon01_12_en. 2021-01-02. islamicart.museumwnf.org.
  23. Web site: Discover Islamic Art - Virtual Museum - monument_ISL_pt_Mon01_25_en. 2021-01-02. islamicart.museumwnf.org.
  24. Web site: DGPC Pesquisa Geral. 2021-01-02. patrimoniocultural.gov.pt.
  25. Book: Romváry, Ferenc. Pécs Lexikon. 2010. 978-963-06-7918-3. Pécs. 98. 729915518.
  26. Web site: History. 2021-01-03. ourladyofeurope.net. 2021-04-14. https://web.archive.org/web/20210414173423/http://www.ourladyofeurope.net/page12.html. dead.
  27. Web site: Visit Gibraltar. 2021-01-03. Visit Gibraltar.
  28. Web site: 2009-01-03. A Short History of the Diocese of Gibraltar. 2021-01-03. https://web.archive.org/web/20090103032356/http://www.catholicdiocese.gi/diocese/historyofthediocese.html. 2009-01-03.
  29. Web site: 2005-01-04. 100 години храм "Св. Седмочисленици" [Статии ЦВ]]. 2021-01-04. https://web.archive.org/web/20050104234233/http://synpress.bglink.net/15-2003/15-sedmochislenici.htm. 2005-01-04.
  30. Web site: The Uzundzhovo church (The mosque – church) – Tourist information center – Haskovо / Туристически информационен център Хасково. 2021-01-07.
  31. Web site: Church of the Assumption. 2021-01-07. Religiana.
  32. Web site: Saint Nikolaos - Mosaic. 2021-01-05. myKavala. 2021-01-10. https://web.archive.org/web/20210110004802/https://www.mykavala.gr/en/listing/agios-nikolaos/. dead.
  33. News: Phukan. Sandeep. 2020-02-05. PM announces Cabinet nod for Ram temple in Ayodhya. The Hindu. 2020-05-09. 0971-751X.
  34. Web site: Mosques turned into Temples, the other side of history. 2020-05-08. SabrangIndia. 2020-05-09.
  35. Web site: Jama Masjid turned Mandir/ Gurudwara of Farrukhnagar. 2020-02-09. Rana Safvi. 2020-05-09.
  36. Book: Haidar. Navina Najat. Sultans of the South: Arts of India's Deccan Courts, 1323-1687. Sardar. Marika. 2011. Metropolitan Museum of Art. 978-1-58839-438-5. 178.
  37. Web site: Collections-Virtual Museum of Images and Sounds. 2020-12-31. vmis.in.
  38. Web site: Jama Masjid, Rohtak. nativeplanet.com. 2020-05-09.
  39. Book: Hilal Ahmed. Muslim Political Discourse in Postcolonial India: Monuments, Memory. Routledge. 2015. 9781317559542. 344.
  40. News: 31 May 2020. Mosques that converted into Gurdwaras – A lesser known part of history. Muslim Mirror.
  41. Web site: Fatima. Nikhat. 2020-05-29. Mosques in India that were converted into Gurdwaras: a lesser known history. 2021-01-06. TwoCircles.net.
  42. News: A mosque once stood here. 2020-12-31. Haaretz.