Conan chronologies explained

This article covers some of the major Conan chronologies that have been advanced over the years. From the 1930s onward a number of fans and scholars have analyzed the numerous Conan the Barbarian stories by Robert E. Howard and later writers, and attempted to organize them into a chronological timeline.[1]

Going beyond a simple fan activity, these efforts have had a significant impact on the development of the popular conception of the character of Conan as well as economic consequences on the Conan franchise. As Paolo Bertetti observes, the focus on the creation of a character chronology outside the work of the original author begins a "process that tends to transform the character into a social object of inter-individual construction and public debate, rendering it independent of texts in which it was born," and in the case of Conan, this has led to the exploitation of the character for commercial reasons and perhaps encouraged and justified the proliferation of pastiche stories and novels over the years.[2]

A number of factors have prevented the establishment of a consensus on the order of the Conan stories, most notably the fact that Howard himself apparently had little more than a general idea of the character's career path and intentionally wrote the stories out of chronological sequence.

Clearly, the stories where Conan is a thief are at the early part of his career and those of King Conan – in the later part. But the middle part – the various tales of his being a pirate, brigand, and mercenary at various locations around the world – are more difficult to arrange in neat order. While the earliest (Miller/Clark) timeline had at least partial endorsement from Howard, the addition of stories discovered and published after Howard's death in 1936 are more difficult to place. Fragments and synopses that were never completed are even more problematic and some contain what appear to be internal inconsistencies.[3]

Miller/Clark/de Camp chronologies

The essay A Probable Outline of Conan's Career (1936) was completed during Howard's lifetime by P. Schuyler Miller and John D. Clark. Howard, who reviewed it in the draft and made a few corrections, stated it followed his vision of Conan's career "pretty closely."[4] The version subsequently published in the Howard fanzine The Hyborian Age (1938) incorporated Howard's corrections.

Over the years, Miller and Clark revised the chronology with L. Sprague de Camp to take into account additional Conan material, including previously unpublished stories by Howard and newly written stories by others. These revised versions of the chronology guided the order in which the stories were arranged when they were compiled into book form in the early series published by Gnome Press (1950–1957), Lancer/Ace (1966–1977), and Bantam (1978–1982), and text from the chronology was used in these series to bridge gaps between the stories.

The subsequent versions include An Informal Biography of Conan the Cimmerian (1952), a revision by Clark and de Camp used to bridge stories in the first hardcover edition of the Conan stories, published by Gnome Press. De Camp's final version of the chronology, Conan the Indestructible (1984), incorporated the first seven volumes of the series of Conan pastiches published by Tor Books.[5]

While the chronology had Howard's general approval in regard to its placement of the stories covered by its earliest published version, such authority is lacking for later versions' placement of stories discovered after Howard's death. Most post-Howard Conan stories were written to conform to it. The chronology has been criticized for missing some in-story chronological indications pointing to a slightly different arrangement (such as "Xuthal of the Dusk" preceding "The Devil in Iron"),[6] [7] for force-fitting posthumously discovered Howard tales into its scheme (e.g. "The Black Stranger," in which Howard has Conan turn pirate between his stints as general and king in Aquilonia, rewritten by de Camp to omit the piratical interlude), and for having Conan wander "all over the Hyborian world in a scattered and illogical pattern, and at a break-neck pace."

Order (earliest and latest forms)

All stories added after the earliest version are indented, stories written by people other than Howard are marked with an asterisk, and stories written by Howard but published after his death are marked with a dagger (†).

Robert Jordan chronology

A Conan Chronology by Robert Jordan (1987) was the attempt of Conan writer Robert Jordan to create a new Chronology including all Conan material written up to that point, including fifteen of the first sixteen volumes of the series of Conan pastiches published by Tor Books (omitting the eighth, Conan the Valorous). It was first published in Conan the Defiant, by Steve Perry (Tor Books, 1987). It was heavily influenced by the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology, though deviating from it in some respects, and covers more of the Tor series. Jordan seldom provided his reasoning on his departures from the earlier chronology.[8]

Order

William Galen Gray chronology

Timeline of Conan's Journeys (1997, rev. 2004), was William Galen Gray's attempt to create "a chronology of all the stories, both Howard and pastiche." It is based on a close reading of all the stories and drawing on the earlier Miller/Clark/de Camp and Jordan chronologies. Where the earlier chronologies differ Gray sometimes adopts one's placement, sometimes the other, and occasionally departs from both, in each case explaining his reasons for the placement. The Gray chronology incorporated all then-published Conan stories, including all the Tor volumes, but treated inconsistently Tor pastiches whose portrayals of Conan's early life contradict Howard's account of it. Three of these, the movie adaptations Conan the Barbarian and Conan the Destroyer and the John M. Roberts novel Conan the Bold, Gray rejected as apocryphal "Legends." The fourth, Harry Turtledove's Conan of Venarium, he accepted.[9]

Order

Apocryphal:

Joe Marek chronology

Joe Marek's chronology is limited to stories written (or devised) by Howard, though within that context it is essentially a revision of the Miller/Clark/de Camp tradition. Noting Howard's general approval of the Miller/Clark chronology, he tends to follow it when it does not contradict the internal evidence of the stories or force Conan into what he perceives as a "mad dash" around the Hyborian world within timeframes too rapid to be credible. Marek considers four changes from this chronology as central to his own:

  1. that "The Frost-Giant's Daughter" is the first Conan tale.
  2. that the four thief stories ("The Tower of the Elephant", "The Hall of the Dead", "The God in the Bowl" and "Rogues in the House") occur in a direct east-to-west sequence (note, however, that this is not really a change; while other chronologies may intersperse pastiches in the sequence, all except the Dale Rippke chronology place these stories in the same order).
  3. that "Xuthal Of The Dusk" (a.k.a. "The Slithering Shadow") has to occur before "The Devil In Iron", as the events of the former are referenced by Conan in the latter.
  4. that "The Vale Of Lost Women" occurs later in the series than previously assumed.

Marek provides arguments for his story placements, though he fails to incorporate into his scheme the chronologically wide gap between "Beyond the Black River" and "Wolves Beyond the Border" he admits to being indicated by Howard's version of "The Black Stranger" as he believed doing anything more to filling the hole would require a major reordering of the stories that would take attention away from his four primary changes. Additionally, Marek divided his timeline into five parts that would constitute about 250 paperback pages each.

Order

The Coming of Conan

Conan the Barbarian

The Sword of Conan

King Conan

Conan The Conqueror

Dale Rippke chronology

In 2003 Dale Rippke published The Darkstorm Conan Chronology, a completely revised chronology, including only those stories written (or devised) by Howard. Completions of Howard works by other hands and post-Howard works are not included. Rippke bases his story placements on the texts as Howard wrote them, which leads him to some of the same conclusions as Marek. Most of his differences with Marek fall in the middle of their respective efforts. This is used as the basis for the Conan Dark Horse comic series, which mostly follows this chronology.[10]

Order

Compared order

StoryREH's
writing
order
RippkeMarekde CampJordanGrayNotes
The Hyborian Age, Part One01historical essay, portion covering the period before Conan's time
Cimmeria (poem)02poem establishing, describing and meditating on Conan's birthplace; placed before the stories in the collection The Coming of Conan the Cimmerian
Conan the Barbarian (2011 novel) (part 1)film adaptation; chapters 1–11 cover Conan's early life from birth to the eve of Venarium
Conan of Venarium01final chapters contradict Howard's account (and all others) of Conan's first entry into the civilized countries – Conan was about 14/15 at the Battle of Venarium per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
Conan the BoldAcontradicts Howard's account (and all others) of Conan's first entry into the civilized countries; would go between Conan of Venarium and "Legions of the Dead" if anywhere
"Legions of the Dead"010102
Conan the Barbarian (1982 novel)02Afilm adaptation contradicting Howard's account (and all others) of Conan's early life; treated by de Camp as an alternative account
"The Thing in the Crypt"030203
Conan the Defiant0304
Conan the Hunter05
Conan the Indomitable06
Conan the Free Lance07
Conan the Formidable08
"The Tower of the Elephant"040304040409
Conan and the Sorcerer110510Conan's age and internal references in the story fit Jordan's placement; de Camp argues Conan's behavior is too mature for his depicted age and places it later – – Conan was about 17 according to Offutt and 23 according to de Camp, per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
Conan the Mercenary120611Conan's age and internal references in the story fit Jordan's placement; de Camp argues Conan's behavior is too mature for his depicted age and places it later
130712Conan's age and internal references in the story fit Jordan's placement; de Camp argues Conan's behavior is too mature for his depicted age and places it later
Conan the Destroyer0508Afilm adaptation; sequel to the 1982 Conan the Barbarian novel and a poor fit chronologically as anything but that, though de Camp and Jordan work it into their schemes regardless
Conan the Outcast13
Conan the Magnificent060914
Conan the Invincible071015
"The Hall of the Dead"0405081116early fragment not published in Howard's lifetime
Conan the Fearless1217
"The God in the Bowl"030206091318
Conan the Warlord1419
"Rogues in the House"110507101620
Conan the Victorious141721
Conan the Unconquered151822
"The Hand of Nergal"0608161923early fragment not published in Howard's lifetime
"The City of Skulls"172024
Conan the Hero25
"The People of the Summit"182126
"The Curse of the Monolith"192227
Conan the Valiant2328
Conan and the Spider God202729
"The Blood-Stained God"212430
Conan the Valorous31
"The Frost Giant's Daughter"020103222532
"The Lair of the Ice Worm"232633
Conan the Relentless34
Conan the Savage35
Conan the Defender242836
Conan the Triumphant253037
Conan the Guardian38
"Queen of the Black Coast" (chapter 1)06a09a10a263139
Conan the Rebel273240
"Queen of the Black Coast" (chapters 2–5)06b09b10b283341
Conan at the Demon's Gate (main narrative)42
"The Vale of Lost Women"121719293443
"The Castle of Terror"303544
"The Snout in the Dark"1011313645early fragment not published in Howard's lifetime
Conan the Barbarian (2011 novel) (part 2)film adaptation; chapters 12–33 set in the wake of Conan's piratical career on the Black Coast and subsequent sojourn in the Black Kingdoms
Conan the Gladiator46
Conan and the Emerald Lotus47
"Hawks Over Shem"323748
"Black Colossus"070809343849
"Shadows in the Dark"353950Conan was nearly 30 at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
332951
Conan the Renegade4052
"Shadows in the Moonlight"080712364153
Conan of the Red Brotherhood54
Conan, Scourge of the Bloody Coast55
Conan the Champion1556
"The Road of the Eagles"374257
"A Witch Shall be Born"161213384358Conan was about 30 at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
"Black Tears"394459Conan was about 32 at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
Conan and the Manhunters60
"Shadows in Zamboula"201514404561
Conan the Raider4662
"The Star of Khorala"414763
Conan and the Death Lord of Thanza64
Conan and the Amazon65
"The Devil in Iron"131316424866
"The Flame Knife"434967
Conan and the Shaman's Curse68
"The People of the Black Circle"141417445069Conan was in his early 30s at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
Conan the Marauder5170
Conan and the Mists of Doom71
"The Slithering Shadow"091115455272
"Drums of Tombalku"1618465373fragment not published in Howard's lifetime
"The Gem in the Tower"475474Conan was about 35 at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
Conan and the Grim Grey God75
"The Pool of the Black One"101820485576Conan was about 37 at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
Conan the Buccaneer495677Conan was in his late 30s at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
"Red Nails"212121505778
Conan and the Gods of the Mountain79
"Jewels of Gwahlur"172222515880
"The Ivory Goddess"525981
Conan and the Treasure of Python82
Conan, Lord of the Black River83
Conan the Rogue84
"Beyond the Black River"181923536085Conan was about 39 at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
"Moon of Blood"546186
"The Treasure of Tranicos"
"The Black Stranger"
192024556287
"Wolves Beyond the Border"2325566388draft not published in Howard's lifetime
Conan the Liberator576489Conan was in his early 40s at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
"The Phoenix on the Sword"012426586590
"The Scarlet Citadel"052527596691
The Hour of the Dragon152628606792Conan was about 45 at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
The Return of Conan616893
Conan the Great94time setting indicated in-piece to be between The Return of Conan and "The Witch of the Mists"
"The Witch of the Mists"626995Conan was in his late 50s at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
"Black Sphinx of Nebthu"637096
"Red Moon of Zembabwei"647197
"Shadows in the Skull"657298
Conan of the Isles667399Conan was in his 60s at this time per the Miller/Clark/de Camp chronology
Conan at the Demon's Gate (frame sequence)time setting stated in-piece to be six years after Conan's abdication from the Aquilonian throne and into the reign of his successor
Death-Song of Conan the Cimmerian (poem)time setting indicated in-piece to occur at Conan's death
The Hyborian Age, Part Two29historical essay, portion covering the period after Conan's time
Notes On Various Peoples of the Hyborian Age30
Letters31

References

Notes and References

  1. Book: Nielsen, Leon . Robert E. Howard: A Collector's Descriptive Bibliography of American and British Hardcover, Paperback, Magazine, Special and Amateur Editions, with a Biography . 2015 . McFarland & Co . 9781476604244 . 88–90 . May 12, 2020.
  2. Book: Bertetti, Paolo . Transmedia Archaeology: Storytelling in the Borderlines of Science Fiction . 2014 . Palgrave Macmillan . 9781137434371 . 15–38 . Conan the Barbarian: Transmedia Adventures of a Pulp Hero . May 12, 2020.
  3. Book: Howard, Robert E. . The Hyborian Age: Facsimile Edition . 2015 . Wilder Publications . 978-1-63384-846-7 . x . Imtroduction . 974231484.
  4. Howard . Robert E. . Robert E. Howard . P. S. Miller . Chronology of Conan and in-universe geography . 1936-03-10 . . 1953 . http://www.barbariankeep.com/millerlet.html . 2023-06-11.
  5. Web site: De Camp . L. Sprague . Conan the Indestructible . https://web.archive.org/web/20080510182300/http://www.amrathelion.com/conan_indestructible/default.html . May 10, 2008.
  6. Marek, Joe. "Some Comments On Chronologies In Regards To The Conan Series." (REHUPA No. 148 and #149), 1997–1998 Online version
  7. Rippke, Dale. Article series: "Can Anything Good Come Out of Cimmeria?" (REHUPA #180), "Go East, Young Man…" (REHUPA #181), "Black Flag, Scarlet Skull… Black Flag, Golden Lion…" (REHUPA #182), combined in Rippke, Dale. "The Dark Storm Conan Chronology." Also published in Rippke, Dale. The Hyborian Heresies. Wild Cat Books, October 25, 2004.
  8. Book: Jordan, Robert . Conan the Defiant . Tor Books . 1987 . A Conan Chronology.
  9. Web site: Gray . William Galen . 2000-03-20 . The Conan timeline . The Barbarian Keep . 2023-06-11.
  10. Book: Busiek, Kurt . The Colossal Conan . November 2013 . Dark Horse Books . Introduction.