Economy for the Common Good explained
Economy for the Common Good (ECG) is a global social movement that advocates an alternative economic model, which is beneficial to people, the planet and future generations. The common good economy puts the common good, cooperation and community in the foreground. Human dignity, solidarity, ecological sustainability, social justice and democratic participation are also described as values of the common good economy. The movement behind the model started off in Austria, Bavaria and South Tyrol in 2010 and quickly spread to many countries throughout the EU. It now has active groups in Africa, Latin America, North America and Asia.[1] As of 2021, the movement consists of over 11,000 supporters, 180 local chapters[2] and 35 associations.[3]
Christian Felber coined the term "Gemeinwohl-Ökonomie" (Economy for the Common Good) in a best-selling book, published in 2010.[4] According to Felber, it makes much more sense for companies to create a so-called "common good balance sheet" than a financial balance sheet. The common good balance sheet is a value-based measurement tool and reporting method for businesses, individuals, communities, and institutions, which shows the extent to which a company abides by values like human dignity, solidarity and economic sustainability.[5]
More than 2,000 organizations, mainly companies,[6] but also schools, universities, municipalities, and cities, support the concept of the Economy for the Common Good. A few hundred have used the Common Good Balance sheet as a means to do their “non-financial” reporting.[7] These include Sparda-Bank Munich,[8] the Rhomberg Group and Vaude Outdoor.[9] Worldwide nearly 60 municipalities are actively involved in spreading the idea.
The ECG movement sees itself in a historical tradition from Aristotle to Adam Smith[10] and refers to the fundamental values of democratic constitutions.
Overview
The model has five underlying goals:[11]
- Reuniting the economy with the fundamental values guiding society in general. Encouraging business decisions that promote human rights, justice, and sustainability.
- Transitioning to an economic system that defines serving the “common good” as its principal goal. The business community and all other economic actors should live up to the universal values set down in constitutions across the globe. These include dignity, social justice, sustainability, and democracy. These do not include profit maximization and market domination.
- Shifting to a business system that measures success according to the values outlined above. A business is successful and reaps the benefits of its success not when it makes more and more profits, but when it does its best to serve the public good.
- Setting the cornerstones of the legal framework for the economy democratically, in processes which result in concrete recommendations for reforming and reevaluating national constitutions and international treaties.
- Closing the gaps between feeling and thinking, technology and nature, economy and ethics, science and spirituality.
The Economy for the Common Good calls for reevaluating economic relations by, for example, putting limits on financial speculation and encouraging companies to produce socially-responsible products.
[12]
Common Good Balance Sheet
The common good balance sheet is an assessment procedure for private individuals, communities, companies and institutions to check the extent to which they serve the common good.[13] Ecological, social and other aspects are assessed.[14] [15] The procedure is part of the common good economy and was developed by Christian Felber. In conventional balance sheets, only economic value categories such as profit are taken into account, whereas the common good balance sheet allows reporting on value to society and environment, for example.
Common good balance sheets should be easy for everyone to understand;[16] companies should be able to make their common good performance transparent on a single page.[17] [13] In doing so, companies can decide whether to prepare the balance sheet on their own, assess each other in a "peer-group", or appoint an independent auditor.[18] [13] This distinguishes the common good balance sheet from conventional sustainability reports, which are prepared by the companies themselves.[14] The balancing process for small companies is relatively cheap (1,000 Euros).[19]
To date, around 250 companies in the German-speaking world prepare their balance sheets according to Gemeinwohl guidelines,[14] [20] [21] [22] in Europe there are 350-400 companies (as of early 2016).[23] [24] [25] In total, there are 590 German, 631 Austrian, 67 Swiss and 70 South Tyrolean companies that have registered as supporters of Gemeinwohl-Bilanz.[26] [27] All peer-group and externally audited Gemeinwohl-Bilanzen are publicly available.[28]
According to proponents of the movement, the success of a company should not be determined by how much profit it makes, but rather by the degree to which it contributes to the common good.[29] Companies receive more points in this balance sheet when, for example, employees are satisfied with their jobs or when the top managers do not receive exorbitantly more than the lowest paid worker.[30]
Further reading
Change Everything: Creating an Economy for the Common Good, ZED Books 2015, .
- The ‘economy for the common good’, job quality and workers’ well-being in Austria and Germany by Ollé-Espluga L, Muckenhuber J, and Hadler M. The Economic and Labour Relations Review. 2021;32(1):3-21. doi:10.1177/1035304620949949.
- The New Systems Read: Alternatives to a Failed Economy, Edited by James Gustave Speth and Kathleen Courrier, Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, New York and London, 2020, ISBN 978-0-367-31339-539-5.
- A corporate balance sheet with a little added love, Chris Bryant, Financial Times, Nov. 19, 2014.
- Microvinyas: ethical vineyards producing wine for the common good, Trevor Baker, The Guardian, Jan. 21, 2014.
- Can we create an 'Economy for the Common Good'?, Bruce Watson, The Guardian, Jan. 6, 2014.
- Economy for the Common Good, Diego Isabel, Article for Network of Wellbeing, May. 08, 2014.
- The Economy for the Common Good, DowneastDem, Daily Kos, Dec. 9, 2013.
- Climate Summit Trap: Capitalism's March toward Global Collapse, Harald Welzer, Spiegel Online, Dec. 9, 2013.
- Christian Felber: Die Gemeinwohl-Ökonomie, Eine demokratische Alternative wächst. Aktualis. u. erw. Neuausg., Zsolnay 2012,, .
- Christian Felber: Die Gemeinwohl-Ökonomie - Das Wirtschaftsmodell der Zukunft, 2010, .
- Article on Economy for the Common Good from the P2P Foundation
- Die Furche: Die Gemeinwohl-Ökonomie, August 26, 2010
- The Common Good, by Manuel Velasquez, Claire Andre, Thomas Shanks, S.J., and Michael J. Meyer
- Den Menschen soll es gut gehen, by Donato Nicolaidi, Sueddeutsche Zeitung, July 6, 2020
Notes and References
- Web site: Lindner. Matthias. Who is ECG. 2021-04-26. Economy for the common good. en-US.
- Web site: Local Chapters. live. 2021-04-26. Economy for the common good. en-US. https://web.archive.org/web/20200712065658/https://www.ecogood.org/who-is-ecg/local-chapters/ . 2020-07-12 .
- Web site: Economy for the Common Good - Official Website. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20091121063730/http://ecogood.org:80/ . 2009-11-21 .
- Book: Felber, Christian. Die Gemeinwohl-Ökonomie – Das Wirtschaftsmodell der Zukunft. 2010. Deuticke. 978-3-552-06137-8.
- News: Meier. Susanne. Menschlichkeit statt Finanzgewinn 16 Tiroler Pionier-Unternehmen erstellen erstmals eine Gemeinwohlbilanz, indem sie ihre Firma in Punkten wie soziale Gerechtigkeit und ökologische Nachhaltigkeit bewerten.. Tiroler Tageszeitung. Nov 17, 2012.
- Web site: Pionierunternehmen. web.ecogood.org. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20200812213537/https://web.ecogood.org/de/die-bewegung/pionier-unternehmen/ . 2020-08-12 .
- Web site: What is ECG. live. 2021-04-26. Economy for the common good. en-US. https://web.archive.org/web/20200702031308/https://www.ecogood.org/what-is-ecg/ . 2020-07-02 .
- https://www.sparda-m.de/gemeinwohlbericht.php Common Good Report from the Sparda Bank Munich, Germany, 2011
- News: Spengler. Hanna. November 8, 2012. Kooperation statt Konkurrenz - Die "Gemeinwohl-Ökonomie". aktuell.
- Web site: Gemeinwohl in der Geschichte.
- Christian Felber and Gus Hagelberg. The Economy for the Common Good - A Workable, Transformative Ethics-Based Alternative. The Next System Project.
- News: Koch. Hannes. April 14, 2012. Der Finanzmissionar - Ein österreichischer Wirtschaftsprediger will den Kapitalismus von innen angreifen – ganz freundlich. Jetzt hat er sich mit einem bayerischen Banker verbündet.. die tageszeitung.
- https://www.ecogood.org/media/filer_public/73/da/73dab961-6125-4f69-bf7a-3c8613a90739/gwoe_arbeitsbuch_5_0_vollbilanz.pdf Arbeitsbuch zur Voll-Bilanz
- http://www.wiwo.de/technologie/green/biz/alternativer-geschaeftsbericht-oeko-versorger-polarstern-zieht-eine-gemeinwohlbilanz/13553970.html Öko-Versorger Polarstern zieht eine Gemeinwohlbilanz
- http://www.fona.de/de/17369 3. Internationale Gemeinwohl-Bilanz-Pressekonferenz
- http://www.stuttgarter-nachrichten.de/inhalt.vaihinger-werben-fuer-gemeinwohloekonomie-profit-ohne-maximierung.a7b8a842-852e-4599-b34b-9c645cc1e6af.html Profit ohne Maximierung
- http://www.pv-magazine.de/nachrichten/details/beitrag/gemeinwohl-konomie-und-energiewende_100022135/ Gemeinwohl-Ökonomie und Energiewende
- http://www.spiegel.de/karriere/nachhaltigkeitssiegel-fuer-unternehmen-wo-soll-ich-mich-bewerben-a-1087027.html Wie nachhaltig ist mein Unternehmen?
- https://www.merkur.de/lokales/starnberg/andechs/wirtschaftsfoerderung-unternehmerverband-druckerei-oeko-siegel-punkten-gemeinwohl-bilanz-5220038.html Punkten für Gemeinwohl-Bilanz
- http://enorm-magazin.de/ein-banker-geht-aufs-ganze Ein Banker geht aufs Ganze
- http://www.badische-zeitung.de/wirtschaft-3/gemeinwohl-bilanz-darum-will-eine-freiburger-firma-mitmachen--97159633.html Gemeinwohl-Bilanz: Darum will eine Freiburger Firma mitmachen
- http://www.forum-csr.net/News/8413/DieGemeinwohlBilanz.html Die Gemeinwohl-Bilanz, Unternehmen sollen Nutzen stiften, nicht nur Rendite
- https://diefarbedesgeldes.de/das-aktuelle-wirtschaftssystem-produziert-eine-endlosreihe-von-kollateralschaeden/ Das aktuelle Wirtschaftssystem produziert eine Endlosreihe von Kollateralschäden
- http://www.schwaebische.de/wirtschaft/aktuelle-nachrichten_artikel,-Gemeinwohl-Orientierung-bringt-Unternehmen-langfristig-Vorteile-_arid,10438392.html Gemeinwohl-Orientierung bringt Unternehmen langfristig Vorteile
- http://derstandard.at/2000034370183/Oekonomen-machen-gegen-Attac-Aktivisten-Felber-in-Lehrbuch-mobil Ökonomen wollen Ex-Attac-Aktivist Felber aus Lehrbuch streichen
- https://www.ecogood.org/de/stuttgart/unterstutze-uns/ UnterstützerInnen der Gemeinwohlökonomie
- http://www.sueddeutsche.de/reise/suedtirol-die-saubermaenner-1.2897982 Die Saubermänner
- http://balance.ecogood.org/gwoe-berichte GWOe-Berichte
- Johannes Pennekamp: Die Bessermacher. In: der Freitag Newspaper. September 26, 2011
- Guido Mingels: Die Achse der Guten. In: Der Spiegel. October 10, 2011