Chemical elements in East Asian languages explained

The names for chemical elements in East Asian languages, along with those for some chemical compounds (mostly organic), are among the newest words to enter the local vocabularies. Except for those metals well-known since antiquity, the names of most elements were created after modern chemistry was introduced to East Asia in the 18th and 19th centuries, with more translations being coined for those elements discovered later.

While most East Asian languages use—or have used—the Chinese script, only the Chinese language uses logograms as the predominant way of naming elements. Native phonetic writing systems are primarily used for element names in Japanese (Katakana), Korean (Hangul) and Vietnamese (chữ Quốc ngữ).

Chinese

In Chinese, characters for the elements are the last officially created and recognized characters in the Chinese writing system. Unlike characters for unofficial varieties of Chinese (e.g., written Cantonese) or other now-defunct ad hoc characters (e.g., those by the Empress Wu), the names for the elements are official, consistent, and taught (with Mandarin pronunciation) to every Chinese and Taiwanese student who has attended public schools (usually by the first year of middle school). New names and symbols are decided upon by the China National Committee for Terminology in Science and Technology.[1]

Native characters

Some metallic elements were already familiar to the Chinese, as their ores were already excavated and used extensively in China for construction, alchemy, and medicine. These include the long-established group of "Five Metals" (五金) — gold (金), silver (銀/银), copper (銅/铜), iron (鐵/铁), and tin (錫/锡) — as well as lead (鉛/铅) and mercury (汞).

Some non-metals were already named in Chinese as well, because their minerals were in widespread use.[2] For example,

Characters based on European pronunciations

However, the Chinese did not know about most of the elements until they were isolated during the Industrial Age. These new elements therefore required new characters, which were invented using the phono-semantic principle. Each character consists of two parts, one to signify the meaning and the other to hint at the sound:

The semantic (meaning) part is also the radical of the character. It refers to the element's usual state at room temperature and standard pressure. Only four radicals are used for elements: Chinese: /Chinese: (jīn "gold; metal") for solid metals, Chinese: (shí "stone, rock") for solid non-metals, Chinese: /Chinese: (shuǐ "water") for liquids, and Chinese: ( "air, steam") for gases.

The phonetic (sound) part represents the character's pronunciation and is a partial transliteration of the element. For each element character, this is a unique phonetic component. Since 118 elements have been discovered, over 100 phonetic components are used in naming the elements. Because many characters in modern Chinese are homophones, including for tone, two different phonetic components can be pronounced the same. Current practice dictates that new names should avoid being homophonous with previous element names or with organic functional groups. However, this rule was not rigorously followed in the past, and confusingly, the names of tin (锡) and selenium (硒) both have the pronunciation with the same tone. The alternative pronunciation for tin is recommended by the National Committee for Approval of Terms in Science and Technology (全国科学技术名词审定委员会).

锡 (tin) and 硒 (selenium) are not homophones in Nanjing Mandarin, which was the prestige dialect of Chinese when most elements were named, which was until the late 19th century. The phonetic component of 锡, 易 (), was accurate when the character was invented around 3000 years ago, but not now because of sound change. In Middle Chinese 锡 was an entering tone character, a closed syllable ending in -p/-t/-k (or -ʔ in some modern dialects). But 硒 was constructed in the late 19th century using the (still accurate) phonetic 西 (), which in Middle Chinese was a level tone character, an open syllable with a vowel ending. In Beijing Mandarin, the variety on which Standard Modern Chinese is based, stop consonant endings of syllables were dropped, and the entering tone was merged into the other tones in a complex and irregular manner by the 16th–17th centuries, and 锡 and 西 both became Tone 1 (high tone) characters. In dialects that preserve the entering tone, like Nanjing Mandarin and Shanghainese and Cantonese, 锡 retains a -k or -ʔ ending and 锡 and 西 (硒) are pronounced differently.

This sometimes causes difficulty in verbal communication, as Sn and Se can both be divalent and tetravalent. Thus, SnO2 二氧化锡 and SeO2 二氧化硒 would be pronounced identically, as èryǎnghuàxī, if not for the variant for 锡. To avoid further confusion, P.R.C. authorities avoided using the name 矽 (or any tonal variants) for silicon. (In Taiwan 矽 is pronounced .)

Examples of characters derived from European pronunciations
Semantic PhoneticSource
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: = Chinese: /Chinese: ()lithium
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: jiǎ= Chinese: /Chinese: (jiǎ)kalium, Latin name for potassium
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: /Chinese: nèi or = Chinese: /Chinese: () natrium, Latin name for sodium
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: or = Chinese: /Chinese: (Taiwan / Mainland tī*) stibium, Latin name for antimony
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: niè= Chinese: /Chinese: (niè) nickel
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: = Chinese: /Chinese: () cadmium
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: /Chinese: = Chinese: /Chinese: () wolframium, Latin name for tungsten
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: = Chinese: /Chinese: () bismuth
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: yóu= Chinese: /Chinese:
   (Taiwan yòu* / Mainland yóu)
uranium
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: /Chinese: = Chinese: /Chinese: () aluminium
Chinese: +Chinese: diǎn= Chinese: (diǎn)iodine
Chinese: +Chinese: hài= Chinese: (hài) helium
Chinese: +Chinese: = Chinese: () fluorine
Chinese: +Chinese: nǎi= Chinese: (nǎi) neon
Chinese: +Chinese: = Chinese: (Taiwan xì* / Mainland ) silicon. Mainly used in R.O.C. (Taiwan), Hong Kong, and Macau
Chinese: guī= Chinese: (guī)silicon. Derived from Japanese transliteration '珪' (kei, けい) of archaic Dutch keiaarde. Mostly used in P.R.C.

† Chinese: /Chinese: is primarily pronounced as nèi, but less commonly as , the source of Chinese: /Chinese: . Likewise, the primary pronunciation of Chinese: is , but the alternate reading of gave rise to Chinese: /Chinese: .

* The derived pronunciation differs (in tone or in sound) from the pronunciation of the element.

The "water" radical (Chinese: ) is not used much here, as only two elements (bromine and mercury) are truly liquid at standard room temperature and pressure. Their characters are not based on the European pronunciation of the elements' names. Bromine (Chinese: ), the only liquid nonmetal at room temperature, is explained in the following section. Mercury (Chinese: ), now grouped with the heavy metals, was long classified as a kind of fluid in ancient China.

Meaning-based characters

A few characters, though, are not created using the above "phono-semantic" design, but are "semantic-semantic", that is, both of its parts indicate meanings. One part refers to the element's usual state (like the semanto-phonetic characters), while the other part indicates some additional property or function of the element. In addition, the second part also indicates the pronunciation of the element. Such elements are:

SemanticSemanticEnglishNote
Chinese: /Chinese: +Chinese: bái (white) = Chinese: /Chinese: platinumThe character is repurposed.[3]
Chinese: +Chinese: chòu (stinky) = Chinese: xiù[4] bromineodorous (Greek Greek, Modern (1453-);: βρῶμος brómos also means "stench")
Chinese: +Chinese: yáng, short for Chinese: /Chinese: yǎng (to nourish/foster) = Chinese: yǎngoxygenA continuous supply of oxygenated air nourishes almost all animals
Chinese: +Chinese: /Chinese: jīng, short for Chinese: /Chinese: qīng (light-weight) = Chinese: /Chinese: qīnghydrogenthe lightest of all elements
Chinese: +Chinese: /Chinese: , short for Chinese: /Chinese: 绿 (green) = Chinese: /Chinese: [5] chlorinegreenish yellow in color
Chinese: +Chinese: yán, short for Chinese: dàn (diluted) = Chinese: dànnitrogendilutes breathable air
Chinese: +Chinese: lín, short for Chinese: lín (glow) = Chinese: línphosphorusemits a faint glow in the dark

Usage in the nomenclature for simple inorganic compounds

Simple covalent binary inorganic compounds EmXn are named as

n X 化 (huà) m E   (with n and m written as Chinese numerals),

where X is more electronegative than E, using the IUPAC formal electronegativity order. 化 as a full noun or verb means 'change; transform(ation)'. As a noun suffix, it is equivalent to the English suffixes -ized/-ated/-ified. It is the root of the word 化学 (huàxué) 'chemistry'.

For example, P4S10 is called 十硫化四磷 (shíliúhuàsìlín) (literally: 'ten sulfur of four phosphorus', 'decasulfide of tetraphosphorus'). As in English nomenclature, if m = 1, the numerical prefix of E is usually dropped in covalent compounds. For example, CO is called 一氧化碳 (yīyǎnghuàtàn) (literally: 'one oxygen of carbon', 'monoxide of carbon').

However, for compounds named as salts, numerical prefixes are dropped altogether, as in English. Thus, calcium chloride, CaCl2, is named 氯化钙 (literally: 'chloride of calcium'). The Chinese name for FeCl3, 氯化铁, literally means 'chlorinated iron' and is akin to the archaic English names 'muriated iron' or 'muriate of iron'. In this example, 氯 is 'chlorine' and 铁 is 'iron'.

There is a Chinese analog of the -ic/-ous nomenclature for higher/lower oxidation states: -ous is translated as 亚 (, 'minor; secondary'): for example, FeCl2 is 氯化亚铁 and FeCl3 is 氯化铁. In a four-way contrast, hypo- is translated as 次 (, 'inferior; following') and per- is translated as 高 (gāo, 'high, upper'). For example, the acid HClO is 次氯酸 "inferior chlorine acid", HClO2 is 亚氯酸, HClO3 is 氯酸, and HClO4 is 高氯酸. In this example, the character 酸 (suān, 'sour') means (organic or inorganic) acid. The more modern Stock nomenclature in which oxidation state is explicitly specified can also be used: thus, tin(IV) oxide (SnO2) is simply 氧化锡(IV).

Recently discovered elements

In 2015, IUPAC recognised the discovery of four new elements. In November 2016, IUPAC published their formal names and symbols: nihonium (113Nh), moscovium (115Mc), tennessine (117Ts), and oganesson (118Og).

Subsequently, in January 2017, the China National Committee for Terms in Sciences and Technologies published four naming characters for these elements.[1] The National Academy for Educational Research under the Ministry of Education of the Republic of China on Taiwan published an almost identical list (the only differences being the use of the traditional Chinese metal radical '釒' in place of the simplified Chinese form '钅' for nihonium and moscovium) in April 2017.[6]

For traditional Chinese, nihonium and moscovium were then existing characters; while in simplified Chinese, only moscovium already existed in the Unicode Standard. The missing characters were added to Unicode version 11.0 as urgently-needed characters in June 2018.[7]

The Chinese characters for these symbols are:

Nihonium: Traditional: Simplified: ()

Moscovium: Traditional: Simplified: ()

Tennessine: Both Traditional and Simplified: (tián)

Oganesson: Both Traditional and Simplified: (ào)

In the periodic table

Pronunciations for some elements differ between mainland China and Taiwan, as described in the article. Simplified characters and mainland Chinese pronunciations are shown above. Some of the characters for the superheavy elements may not be visible depending on fonts.

Notes

Comparison of mainland China, Taiwan and SAR names
EnglishZMainland ChinaTaiwanHong Kong/Macau
14Chinese: guīChinese: Chinese: gwai1, Chinese: zik6
43Chinese: Chinese: Chinese: daap1, Chinese: dak1
71Chinese: Chinese: liúChinese: lou5, Chinese: lau4
85Chinese: àiChinese: èChinese: ngaai6, Chinese: ngo5
87Chinese: fāngChinese: Chinese: fong1, Chinese: faat3
93Chinese: Chinese: nàiChinese: noi6, Chinese: naa4
94Chinese: Chinese: Chinese: bat1
95Chinese: méi Chinese: méiChinese: mei4, Chinese: mui4
97Chinese: péi Chinese: běi Chinese: pui4, Chinese: bak1
98Chinese: kāiChinese: Chinese: hoi1, Chinese: kaa1
99Chinese: āiChinese: ài Chinese: oi1, Chinese: oi3
A minority of the "new characters" are not completely new inventions, as they coincide with archaic characters, whose original meanings have long been lost to most people. For example, 鈹 (beryllium), 鉻 (chromium), 鑭 (lanthanum), and 鏷 (protactinium), are obscure characters meaning "needle", "hook", "harrow", and "raw iron", respectively.

Some elements' names were already present as characters used in the names of members of the House of Zhu. In the early Ming dynasty, the Hongwu Emperor established a rule that his descendants' given names must follow the order of the Five Phases per generation, and should have a character including the radical for one of the Five Phases. Some later descendants had to adopt rarely used characters, and even created new characters to fit this rule, which were later readopted for chemical elements. For example,

Most element names are the same in Simplified and Traditional Chinese, merely being variants of each other, since most of the names were translated by a single body of standardization before the PRC-ROC split. However, elements discovered close to, during, or after the split sometimes have different names in Taiwan and in mainland China. In Hong Kong, both Taiwanese and mainland Chinese names are used.[8] A few pronunciations also differ even when the characters are analogous: cobalt gǔ (PRC) / gū (ROC); palladium bǎ (PRC) / bā (ROC); tin xī (PRC) / xí (ROC); antimony tī (PRC) / tì (ROC); polonium pō (PRC) / pò (ROC); uranium yóu (PRC) / yòu (ROC); bohrium bō (PRC) / pō (ROC).[9]

The isotopes of hydrogen – protium (1H), deuterium (D) and tritium (T) – are written 氕 piē, 氘 dāo and 氚 chuān, respectively, in both simplified and traditional writing.鑀 is used in Taiwan for both einsteinium (mainland China: 锿) and ionium, a previous name for the isotope thorium-230.

History

In 1871, John Fryer and Shou Xu proposed the modern convention of exclusively using single characters for element names.[10]

Japanese

Like other words in the language, elements' names in Japanese can be native (yamatokotoba), from China (Sino-Japanese) or from Europe (gairaigo).

Names based on European pronunciations

Even though the Japanese language also uses Chinese characters (kanji), it primarily employs katakana to transliterate names of the elements from European languages (often German/Dutch or Latin [via German] or English). Elements not listed in any of the tables below have their names follow English, like tungsten.

EnglishJapaneseNote
from English; other major European languages refer to this element as wolfram or tungsten with some additional syllable (-o, -e, etc.).
The first element discovered in Japan. Named after Japan (Nihon).
Latin: natrium in Latin
Latin: kalium in Latin
German: Titan in German
German: Chrom in German
German: Mangan in German. Formerly written with ateji as Japanese: 満俺.
German: Selen in German
German: Niob in German
German: Molybdän in German
From either Dutch Dutch; Flemish: antimoon or German German: Antimon
German: Tellur in German
German: Lanthan in German
German: Praseodym in German
German: Neodym in German
German: Tantal in German
German: Uran in German
approximates flu-. Similar to the Chinese: Chinese: , plus the "air" radical (气). As Japanese: is not a commonly used kanji, it is often written Japanese: フッ素, using katakana.
or German German: {{linktext|Jod + . Chinese uses Chinese: (Chinese: diǎn), the second syllable of iodine.

Native names

On the other hand, elements known since antiquity are Chinese loanwords, which are mostly identical to their Chinese counterparts, albeit in the Shinjitai, for example, iron is tetsu (Tang-dynasty loan) and lead is namari (native reading). While all elements in Chinese are single-character in the official system, some Japanese elements have two characters. Often this parallels colloquial or everyday names for such elements in Chinese, such as 水銀/水银 for mercury and 硫黃/硫黄 for sulfur. A special case is tin (suzu), which is more often written in katakana (Japanese: スズ).

EnglishJapaneseChinese Note
mercuryChinese: (gǒng) "watery silver" aka. quicksilver, like the element's symbol, Hg (Latin/Greek hydro-argyrum, "water-silver"). In the Greater China Region, 水銀/水银 is more generally used than 汞, because 汞 is not taught until the chemistry class (or physics class as in "汞液柱" while teaching atmospheric pressure) but 水銀/水银 is the word used in daily life; for example, when people talk about the mercury liquid in the thermometer, most people would say "水銀/水银" but not 汞. This kind of thermometer is called "水銀溫度計/水银温度计" ("watery silver thermometer") in Chinese instead of "汞溫度計/汞温度计" ("mercury thermometer"), which is not used at all.

In Japanese too, exists but is very rare and literary, having an alternative obsolete reading mizugane. It is used in shōkō "mercuric chloride" (which also exists in Chinese as shēnggǒng).

sulfurChinese: (liú) (ō) means "yellow", to distinguish from other characters pronounced the same.
zincChinese: 鋅/锌 (xīn) meaning "light lead"; 鉛 is "lead" in Japanese and Chinese.
platinum Chinese: (bó) "white gold". Like 水銀/水银 and 汞 in Chinese, 白金 is the "daily"/colloquial word, and 鉑/铂 is the formal name and usually won't be taught until the chemistry class. In mainland China, jewelry stores usually use the word "白金" or "铂金".
arsenic Chinese: (shēn) hi < hi-shimo, the Chinese name for arsenic trioxide (Chinese: pīshuāng). In modern Chinese, arsenic is instead shēn (砷), an approximation of the second syllable of arsenic.The kanji Japanese: is quite rare. Often written Japanese: ヒ素 using katakana.
boron Chinese: (péng) (Japanese: ホウ) <, the Chinese name for borax (Chinese: péngshā). Boron is still called péng in modern Chinese. The kanji Japanese: is extremely rare. Mostly written Japanese: ホウ素 using katakana.

Meaning-based names

Some names were later invented to describe properties or characteristics of the element. They were mostly introduced around the 18th century to Japan, and they sometimes differ drastically from their Chinese counterparts. The following comparison shows that Japanese does not use the radical system for naming elements like Chinese.

EnglishJapaneseChineseNote
hydrogen Chinese: 氫/氢 (qīng) translation of the hydro- prefix, or translation of the Dutch word for hydrogen, Dutch; Flemish: waterstof ("Water substance"), or the German word German: Wasserstoff
carbon Chinese: (tàn) translation of the Dutch word for carbon, Dutch; Flemish: koolstof ("coal substance").
nitrogen Chinese: (dàn) translation of the Dutch word for nitrogen, Dutch; Flemish: stikstof ("suffocating substance"). While nitrogen is not toxic per se and in fact constitutes the majority of air, air-breathing animals cannot survive breathing it alone (without sufficient oxygen mixed in).
oxygen Chinese: (yǎng) similar to the Dutch word for oxygen, Dutch; Flemish: zuurstof ("sour substance"), the German word German: Sauerstoff or the Greek-based oxygen ("acid maker").
Many 19th-century European chemists erroneously believed that all acids contain oxygen. (Many common ones do—called oxyacid, but not all—the ones that are called hydracid.)
silicon Chinese: (guī) same as Chinese; the kanji Japanese: is extremely rare. Often written Japanese: ケイ素 using katakana. Its origin lies in the Dutch word keiaarde; kei is a partial calque. The Chinese word is an orthographical loan from Japanese.
phosphorus Chinese: (lín) similar to Chinese, except the "fire" radical replacing the "stone" radical. The kanji Japanese: is rare. Usually written Japanese: リン using katakana.
chlorine Chinese: (lǜ) together with sodium make up common table salt (NaCl); Japanese: is the Shinjitai version of Japanese: .
bromine Chinese: (xiù)similar to Chinese, except the lack of the "water" radical.

Korean

As Hanja (Sino-Korean characters) are now rarely used in Korea, all of the elements are written in Hangul.Since many Korean scientific terms were translated from Japanese sources, the pattern of naming is mostly similar to that of Japanese. Namely, the classical elements are loanwords from China, with new elements from European languages. But recently, some elements' names were changed. For example:

EnglishKorean (before 2014)Source(South) Korean (after 2014)
gold geum (금) from Chinese jin (金) geum (금)
silver eun (은) from Chinese yin (銀) eun (은)
antimony antimon (안티몬) from German antimoni (안티모니)
tungsten teongseuten (텅스텐) from English teongseuten (텅스텐)
sodium nateuryum (나트륨) from Latin or German (Na for natrium) sodyum (소듐)
potassium kalyum (칼륨) from Latin or German kalium potasyum (포타슘)
manganese manggan (망간) from German Mangan mangganijeu (망가니즈)

Pre-modern (18th-century) elements often are the Korean pronunciation of their Japanese equivalents, e.g.,

English Korean (Hangul, hanja)
hydrogen suso (수소, 水素)
carbon tanso (탄소, 炭素)
nitrogen jilso (질소, 窒素)
oxygen sanso (산소, 酸素)
chlorine yeomso (염소, 鹽素)
zinc ayeon (아연, 亞鉛)
mercury sueun (수은, 水銀)

Vietnamese

In Vietnamese, some of the elements known since antiquity and medieval times are loanwords from Chinese, such as copper (đồng from), tin (thiếc from), mercury (thuỷ ngân from), sulfur (lưu huỳnh from), oxygen (dưỡng khí from ; oxi or oxy is the more common name) and platinum (bạch kim from ; platin is another common name). Others have native or old Sino-Vietnamese names, such as sắt for iron, bạc for silver, chì for lead, vàng for gold, kền for nickel (niken or nickel are the more common names) and kẽm for zinc. In either case, now they are written in the Vietnamese alphabet. Before the Latin alphabet was introduced, sắt was rendered as, bạc as, chì as, vàng as, kền as and kẽm as in Chữ Nôm.

The majority of elements are shortened and localized pronunciations of the European names (usually from French). For example:

A minority of elements, mostly those not suffixed with -ium, retain their full name, e.g.,

Some elements have multiple names, for instance, potassium is known as pô-tát and kali (from kalium, the element's Latin name).

Update in 2018 General Education Program, chemistry section:[11] (At page 50)

See also

References

External links

Periodic tables

Articles

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 新元素113号、115号、117号、118号的中文定名征集. zh. 2017-01-15.
  2. 10.1007/s40828-018-0065-0 . What's in a name: A comparison of Chinese and Japanese approaches to the translation of chemical elements . 2018 . Chang . Hao . Chemtexts . 4 . 3 . 186517051 . free .
  3. The original meaning of Chinese: /Chinese: is "thin sheet of gold" (now obsolete). The character was not associated with platinum until modern time, since platinum was known in the Old World only after the Age of Discovery.
  4. The pronunciation of these characters come from the second semantic characters' nearly obsolete pronunciations. Nowadays 白 (white) is normally pronounced bái in the standard Mandarin dialect, although traditionally bó was preferred. Similarly, Chinese: (stinky) is almost always pronounced chòu, as opposed to x, now an archaic reading.
  5. The apparent mismatch in pronunciation with the phonetic component is because the pronunciation is inherited from another character that provides the meaning. For example, the ultimate source of the pronunciation of Chinese: yǎng (oxygen) is not Chinese: yáng (sheep), but Chinese: /Chinese: yǎng (to nourish/foster).
  6. Web site: Chemical nouns -- overview of the names of chemical elements. 17 July 2017. 18 April 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20170418081319/http://terms.naer.edu.tw/news/84/. dead.
  7. Web site: Unicode® 11.0.0 . Unicode.org . 7 June 2018.
  8. Web site: Wong . Kin-on James. Cheuk. Kwok-hung. Lei. Keng-lon. Leung. Ho-ming. Leung. Man-wai. Pang. Hei-tung. Pau. Chiu-wah. Tang. Kin-hung. Wai . Pui-wah. Fong. Wai-hung Raymond. English-Chinese Glossary of Terms Commonly Used in the Teaching of Chemistry in Secondary Schools . Education Bureau . Hong Kong Education City Limited. 29 January 2015. 1999.
  9. https://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=18877 Language Log: Names of the chemical elements in Chinese
  10. The Great Desideratum: Chinese Chemical Nomenclature and the Transmission of Western Chemical Concepts . 43290407 . Wright . David . Chinese Science . 1997 . 14 . 35–70 .
  11. Web site: Ministry of Education and Training(Vietnam) - General Education Program _ Chemistry . 2024-02-18 . vi.