Chandra X-ray Observatory explained

Chandra X-ray Observatory
Names List:	Advanced X-ray Astrophysics Facility (AXAF)
Mission Type:	X-ray astronomy
Operator:	NASASAOCXC
Cospar Id:	1999-040B
Satcat:	25867
Website:	https://chandra.harvard.edu/
Mission Duration:	Planned: 5 years Elapsed:
Manufacturer:	TRW Inc.
Launch Mass:	12930lb^[1]
Dry Mass:	10560lb
Dimensions:	Deployed: 13.8xx^[2] Stowed: 38.7xx
Power:	2,350 W
Launch Date:	UTC^[3]
Launch Rocket:	(STS-93)
Launch Site:	Kennedy, LC-39B
Orbit Reference:	Geocentric
Orbit Regime:	Highly elliptical
Orbit Semimajor:	80795.9km (50,204.2miles)
Orbit Eccentricity:	0.743972
Orbit Periapsis:	14307.9km (8,890.5miles)
Orbit Apoapsis:	134527.6km (83,591.6miles)
Orbit Inclination:	76.7156°
Orbit Period:	3809.3 min
Orbit Raan:	305.3107°
Orbit Arg Periapsis:	267.2574°
Orbit Mean Anomaly:	0.3010°
Orbit Mean Motion:	0.3780 rev/day
Orbit Epoch:	September 4, 2015, 04:37:54 UTC^[4]
Orbit Rev Number:	1358
Apsis:	gee
Telescope Type:	Wolter type 1^[5]
Telescope Diameter:	3.9order=flipNaNorder=flip
Telescope Focal Length:	32.8order=flipNaNorder=flip
Telescope Area:	0.04m2
Telescope Wavelength:	X-ray 0.12–12 nm (0.1–10 keV)^[6]
Telescope Resolution:	0.5 arcsec
Instruments List:	Acronym1: ACIS Acronym2: HRC Name2: High Resolution Camera Acronym3: HETG Name3: High Energy Transmission Grating Acronym4: LETG Name4: Low Energy Transmission Grating
Programme:	NASA Great Observatories
Previous Mission:	Compton
Next Mission:	Spitzer
Programme2:	Large Strategic Science Missions Astrophysics Division
Previous Mission2:	Compton
Next Mission2:	Webb

The Chandra X-ray Observatory (CXO), previously known as the Advanced X-ray Astrophysics Facility (AXAF), is a Flagship-class space telescope launched aboard the during STS-93 by NASA on July 23, 1999. Chandra was sensitive to X-ray sources 100 times fainter than any previous X-ray telescope, enabled by the high angular resolution of its mirrors. Since the Earth's atmosphere absorbs the vast majority of X-rays, they are not detectable from Earth-based telescopes; therefore space-based telescopes are required to make these observations. Chandra is an Earth satellite in a 64-hour orbit, and its mission is ongoing .

Chandra is one of the Great Observatories, along with the Hubble Space Telescope, Compton Gamma Ray Observatory (1991–2000), and the Spitzer Space Telescope (2003–2020). The telescope is named after the Nobel Prize-winning Indian astrophysicist Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar. Its mission is similar to that of ESA's XMM-Newton spacecraft, also launched in 1999 but the two telescopes have different design foci, as Chandra has a much higher angular resolution and XMM-Newton higher spectroscopy throughput.

In response to a decrease in NASA funding in 2024 by the US Congress, Chandra is threatened with an early cancellation despite having more than a decade of operation left. The cancellation has been referred to as a potential "extinction-level" event for X-ray astronomy in the US. A group of astronomers have put together a public outreach project to try to get enough American citizens to persuade the US Congress to provide enough funding to avoid early termination of the observatory.^[7]

History

In 1976, the Chandra X-ray Observatory (called AXAF at the time) was proposed to NASA by Riccardo Giacconi and Harvey Tananbaum. Preliminary work began the following year at Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) and the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory (SAO), where the telescope is now operated for NASA^[8] at the Chandra X-ray Center in the Center for Astrophysics Harvard & Smithsonian. In the meantime, in 1978, NASA launched the first imaging X-ray telescope, Einstein (HEAO-2), into orbit. Work continued on the AXAF project throughout the 1980s and 1990s. In 1992, to reduce costs, the spacecraft was redesigned. Four of the twelve planned mirrors were eliminated, as were two of the six scientific instruments. AXAF's planned orbit was changed to an elliptical one, reaching one third of the way to the Moon's at its farthest point. This eliminated the possibility of improvement or repair by the Space Shuttle but put the observatory above the Earth's radiation belts for most of its orbit. AXAF was assembled and tested by TRW (now Northrop Grumman Aerospace Systems) in Redondo Beach, California.

AXAF was renamed Chandra as part of a contest held by NASA in 1998, which drew more than 6,000 submissions worldwide.^[9] The contest winners, Jatila van der Veen and Tyrel Johnson (then a high school teacher and high school student, respectively), suggested the name in honor of Nobel Prize–winning Indian-American astrophysicist Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar. He is known for his work in determining the maximum mass of white dwarf stars, leading to greater understanding of high energy astronomical phenomena such as neutron stars and black holes.^[10] Fittingly, the name Chandra means "moon" in Sanskrit.^[11]

Originally scheduled to be launched in December 1998, the spacecraft was delayed several months, eventually being launched on July 23, 1999, at 04:31 UTC by during STS-93. Chandra was deployed by Cady Coleman^[12] from Columbia at 11:47 UTC. The Inertial Upper Stage's first stage motor ignited at 12:48 UTC, and after burning for 125 seconds and separating, the second stage ignited at 12:51 UTC and burned for 117 seconds.^[13] At 22753kg (50,162lb), it was the heaviest payload ever launched by the shuttle, a consequence of the two-stage Inertial Upper Stage booster rocket system needed to transport the spacecraft to its high orbit.

Chandra has been returning data since the month after it launched. It is operated by the SAO at the Chandra X-ray Center in Cambridge, Massachusetts, with assistance from MIT and Northrop Grumman Space Technology. The ACIS CCDs suffered particle damage during early radiation belt passages. To prevent further damage, the instrument is now removed from the telescope's focal plane during passages.

Although Chandra was initially given an expected lifetime of 5 years, on September 4, 2001, NASA extended its lifetime to 10 years "based on the observatory's outstanding results."^[14] Physically Chandra could last much longer. A 2004 study performed at the Chandra X-ray Center indicated that the observatory could last at least 15 years.^[15] It is active as of 2024 and has an upcoming schedule of observations published by the Chandra X-ray Center.^[16]

In July 2008, the International X-ray Observatory, a joint project between ESA, NASA and JAXA, was proposed as the next major X-ray observatory but was later canceled.^[17] ESA later resurrected a downsized version of the project as the Advanced Telescope for High Energy Astrophysics (ATHENA), with a proposed launch in 2028.^[18]

On October 10, 2018, Chandra entered safe mode operations, due to a gyroscope glitch. NASA reported that all science instruments were safe.^{[19] [20]} Within days, the 3-second error in data from one gyro was understood, and plans were made to return Chandra to full service. The gyroscope that experienced the glitch was placed in reserve and is otherwise healthy.^[21]

In March 2024, Congress decided to reduce funding for NASA and its missions.This may lead to the premature end of this mission.^[22] In June 2024, Senators urged NASA to reconsider the cuts to Chandra.^[23]

Example discoveries

The data gathered by Chandra has greatly advanced the field of X-ray astronomy. Here are some examples of discoveries supported by observations from Chandra:

• The first light image, of supernova remnant Cassiopeia A, gave astronomers their first glimpse of the compact object at the center of the remnant, probably a neutron star or black hole.^{[24] [25]}
• In the Crab Nebula, another supernova remnant, Chandra showed a never-before-seen ring around the central pulsar and jets that had only been partially seen by earlier telescopes.^[26]
• The first X-ray emission was seen from the supermassive black hole, Sagittarius A*, at the center of the Milky Way.^[27]
• Chandra found much more cool gas than expected spiraling into the center of the Andromeda Galaxy.
• Pressure fronts were observed in detail for the first time in Abell 2142, where clusters of galaxies are merging.
• The earliest images in X-rays of the shock wave of a supernova were taken of SN 1987A.
• Chandra showed for the first time the shadow of a small galaxy as it is being cannibalized by a larger one, in an image of Perseus A.
• Anew type of black hole was discovered in galaxy M82, mid-mass objects purported to be the missing link between stellar-sized black holes and super massive black holes.^[28]
• X-ray emission lines were associated for the first time with a gamma-ray burst, Beethoven Burst GRB 991216.^[29]
• High school students, using Chandra data, discovered a neutron star in supernova remnant IC 443.^[30]
• Observations by Chandra and BeppoSAX suggest that gamma-ray bursts occur in star-forming regions.
• Chandra data suggested that RX J1856.5-3754 and 3C58, previously thought to be pulsars, might be even denser objects: quark stars. These results are still debated.
• Sound waves from violent activity around a super massive black hole were observed in the Perseus Cluster (2003).
• TWA 5B, a brown dwarf, was seen orbiting a binary system of Sun-like stars.
• Nearly all stars on the main sequence are X-ray emitters.^[31]
• The X-ray shadow of Titan was seen when it transited the Crab Nebula.
• X-ray emissions from materials falling from a protoplanetary disc into a star.^[32]
• Hubble constant measured to be 76.9 km/s/Mpc using Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect.^[33]
• 2006 Chandra found strong evidence that dark matter exists by observing super cluster collision.^[34]
• 2006 X-ray emitting loops, rings and filaments discovered around a super massive black hole within Messier 87 imply the presence of pressure waves, shock waves and sound waves. The evolution of Messier 87 may have been dramatically affected.^[35]
• Observations of the Bullet cluster put limits on the cross-section of the self-interaction of dark matter.^[36]
• "The Hand of God" photograph of PSR B1509-58.
• Jupiter's x-rays coming from poles, not auroral ring.^[37]
• A large halo of hot gas was found surrounding the Milky Way.^[38]
• Extremely dense and luminous dwarf galaxy M60-UCD1 observed.^[39]
• On January 5, 2015, NASA reported that CXO observed an X-ray flare 400 times brighter than usual, a record-breaker, from Sagittarius A*, the supermassive black hole in the center of the Milky Way galaxy. The unusual event may have been caused by the breaking apart of an asteroid falling into the black hole or by the entanglement of magnetic field lines within gas flowing into Sagittarius A*, according to astronomers.^[40]
• In September 2016, it was announced that Chandra had detected X-ray emissions from Pluto, the first detection of X-rays from a Kuiper belt object. Chandra had made the observations in 2014 and 2015, supporting the New Horizons spacecraft for its July 2015 encounter.^[41]
• In September 2020, Chandra reportedly may have made an observation of an exoplanet in the Whirlpool Galaxy, which would be the first planet discovered beyond the Milky Way.^{[42] [43] [44]}
• In April 2021, NASA announced findings from the observatory in a tweet saying "Uranus gives off X-rays, astronomers find". The discovery would have "intriguing implications for understanding Uranus" if it is confirmed that the X-rays originate from the planet and are not emitted by the Sun.^[45]

Technical description

Unlike optical telescopes which possess simple aluminized parabolic surfaces (mirrors), X-ray telescopes generally use a Wolter telescope consisting of nested cylindrical paraboloid and hyperboloid surfaces coated with iridium or gold. X-ray photons would be absorbed by normal mirror surfaces, so mirrors with a low grazing angle are necessary to reflect them. Chandra uses four pairs of nested mirrors, together with their support structure, called the High Resolution Mirror Assembly (HRMA); the mirror substrate is 2 cm-thick glass, with the reflecting surface a 33 nm iridium coating, and the diameters are 65 cm, 87 cm, 99 cm and 123 cm.^[46] The thick substrate and particularly careful polishing allowed a very precise optical surface, which is responsible for Chandra's unmatched resolution: between 80% and 95% of the incoming X-ray energy is focused into a one-arcsecond circle. However, the thickness of the substrate limits the proportion of the aperture which is filled, leading to the low collecting area compared to XMM-Newton.

Chandra's highly elliptical orbit allows it to observe continuously for up to 55 hours of its 65-hour orbital period. At its furthest orbital point from Earth, Chandra is one of the most distant Earth-orbiting satellites. This orbit takes it beyond the geostationary satellites and beyond the outer Van Allen belt.^[47]

With an angular resolution of 0.5 arcsecond (2.4 μrad), Chandra possesses a resolution over 1000 times better than that of the first orbiting X-ray telescope.

CXO uses mechanical gyroscopes,^[48] which are sensors that help determine what direction the telescope is pointed.^[49] Other navigation and orientation systems on board CXO include an aspect camera, Earth and Sun sensors, and reaction wheels. It also has two sets of thrusters, one for movement and another for offloading momentum.

Instruments

The Science Instrument Module (SIM) holds the two focal plane instruments, the Advanced CCD Imaging Spectrometer (ACIS) and the High Resolution Camera (HRC), moving whichever is called for into position during an observation.

ACIS consists of 10 CCD chips and provides images as well as spectral information of the object observed. It operates in the photon energy range of 0.2–10 keV. The HRC has two micro-channel plate components and images over the range of 0.1–10 keV. It also has a time resolution of 16 microseconds. Both of these instruments can be used on their own or in conjunction with one of the observatory's two transmission gratings.

The transmission gratings, which swing into the optical path behind the mirrors, provide Chandra with high resolution spectroscopy. The High Energy Transmission Grating Spectrometer (HETGS) works over 0.4–10 keV and has a spectral resolution of 60–1000. The Low Energy Transmission Grating Spectrometer (LETGS) has a range of 0.09–3 keV and a resolution of 40–2000.

Summary:^[50]

• High Resolution Camera (HRC)
• Advanced CCD Imaging Spectrometer (ACIS)
• High Energy Transmission Grating Spectrometer (HETGS)
• Low Energy Transmission Grating Spectrometer (LETGS)

Gallery

See also

• AGILE (satellite), an Italian orbital X-ray telescope
• Great Observatories program
• List of deep fields
• List of space telescopes
• List of X-ray space telescopes
• Lynx X-ray Observatory, possible successor
• NuSTAR
• Suzaku, a sister satellite originating from AXAF-S (spectrometer)
• X-ray astronomy

Further reading

• Swartz . Douglas A. . Wolk . Scott J. . Fruscione . Antonella . Chandra's First Decade of Discovery . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America . 107 . 16 . 7127–7134 . April 20, 2010 . 10.1073/pnas.0914464107 . 20406906 . 2867717 . 2010PNAS..107.7127S . free .

External links

• Chandra X-ray Observatory at NASA.gov
• Chandra X-ray Observatory at Harvard.edu
• Chandra X-Ray Center (CXC) at Harvard.edu
• Chandra X-ray Observatory at YouTube
• Chandra podcast (2010) by Astronomy Cast

Notes and References

1. Web site: Chandra X-ray Observatory Quick Facts . Marshall Space Flight Center . September 16, 2017 . February 12, 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220212002150/https://www.nasa.gov/centers/marshall/news/background/facts/cxoquick.html .
2. Web site: Chandra Specifications . NASA/Harvard . September 3, 2015.
3. Web site: International Flight No. 210: STS-93 . Spacefacts.de . April 29, 2018.
4. Web site: Chandra X-Ray Observatory - Orbit . Heavens Above . September 3, 2015 . September 3, 2015.
5. Web site: The Chandra X-ray Observatory: Overview . Chandra X-ray Center . September 3, 2015.
6. Book: Ridpath, Ian . The Dictionary of Astronomy . Oxford University Press . 2nd . 82 . 2012 . 978-0-19-960905-5.
7. Web site: Act Now . Save the Chandra X-ray Observatory . May 25, 2024 .
8. Web site: Chandra X-ray Center . CXC.CFA.Harvard.edu . February 21, 2022 .
9. Web site: Tyrel Johnson & Jatila van der Veen - Winners of the Chandra-Naming Contest - Where Are They Now? . Center for Astrophysics Harvard & Smithsonian . Wallace . Tucker . October 31, 2013 . January 12, 2014 .
10. Web site: And the Co-Winners Are... . Center for Astrophysics Harvard & Smithsonian . 1998 . January 12, 2014 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140112205117/http://chandra.harvard.edu/contest/co_winners.html .
11. Web site: Meaning, origin and history of the name Chandra . Behind the Name . June 19, 2024 .
12. Web site: NASA . Image: July 23, 1999, Chandra X-ray Observatory Awaits Deployment . Phys.org . February 21, 2022 .
13. Web site: Chandra X-ray Observatory Status Report: July 23, 1999 6:00 p.m. EDT . Marshall Space Flight Center Status Reports . NASA . Dave . Drachlis . July 23, 1999 . https://web.archive.org/web/20000226004401/http://www1.msfc.nasa.gov/NEWSROOM/news/status/chandrastatus/chandrastatus27.html . February 26, 2000 .
14. Web site: Chandra's Mission Extended to 2009 . Center for Astrophysics Harvard & Smithsonian . September 28, 2001.
15. The Development and Scientific Impact of the Chandra X-Ray Observatory . International Journal of Modern Physics D . Daniel A. . Schwartz . 13 . 7 . 1239–1248 . August 2004 . 10.1142/S0218271804005377 . astro-ph/0402275 . 2004IJMPD..13.1239S. 858689 .
16. Web site: CXO Long-term Schedule . CXC.Harvard.edu . February 21, 2022 .
17. Web site: International X-ray Observatory . NASA . https://web.archive.org/web/20080303062108/http://constellation.gsfc.nasa.gov/ . March 3, 2008 .
18. News: X-ray Space Telescope of the Future Could Launch in 2028 . Space.com . Elizabeth . Howell . November 1, 2013 . January 1, 2014 .
19. News: Another NASA space telescope just went into safe mode . CNET . Amanda . Kooser . October 12, 2018 . October 14, 2018 .
20. Web site: Chandra Enters Safe Mode; Investigation Underway . NASA . Brian . Dunbar . October 12, 2018 . October 14, 2018 . November 11, 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20221111213927/https://www.nasa.gov/feature/chandra-enters-safe-mode-investigation-underway/ .
21. Web site: Chandra Operations Resume after Cause of Safe Mode Identified . . Felicia . Chou . Molly . Porter . Megan . Watzke . October 24, 2018 . June 19, 2024 .
22. News: The Chandra X-ray spacecraft may soon go dark, threatening a great deal of astronomy . Space.com . Monisha . Ravisetti . March 23, 2024 . June 13, 2023 .
23. News: Congressional letter asks NASA to rescind Chandra cuts . Spacenews.com . Jeff . Foust . June 13, 2024 . June 13, 2024 .
24. Web site: Hall . Alan . Chandra Sees Its 'First Light' . September 27, 2023 . Scientific American .
25. The Compact Central Object in Cassiopeia A: A Neutron Star with Hot Polar Caps or a Black Hole? . . Pavlov . G. G. . Zavlin . V. E. . Aschenbach . B. . Trumper . J. . Sanwal . D. . 531 . 1 . L53–L56 . 2000 . astro-ph/9912024 . 10.1086/312521 . 10673413 . 2000ApJ...531L..53P . 16849221 .
26. Discovery of Spatial and Spectral Structure in the X-Ray Emission from the Crab Nebula . . Weisskopf . M. C. . Hester . J. J. . Tennant . A. F. . Elsner . R. F. . Schulz . N. S. . Marshall . H. L. . Karovska . M. . Nichols . J. S. . Swartz . D. A. . Kolodziejczak . J. J. . O'Dell . S. L. . 9 . 536 . 2 . L81–L84 . 2000 . astro-ph/0003216 . 10.1086/312733 . 10859123 . 2000ApJ...536L..81W. 14879330 .
27. Rapid X-ray flaring from the direction of the supermassive black hole at the Galactic Centre . . F. K. . Baganoff . M. W. . Bautz . W. N. . Brandt . G. . Chartas . E. D. . Feigelson . G. P. . Garmire . Y. . Maeda . M. . Morris . G. R. . Ricker . L. K. . Townsley . F. . Walter . 9 . 413 . 6851 . 45–48 . 2001 . astro-ph/0109367 . 10.1038/35092510 . 11544519 . 2001Natur.413...45B. 2298716 .
28. Hot Plasma and Black Hole Binaries in Starburst Galaxy M82 . . R. E. . Griffiths . A. . Ptak . E. D. . Feigelson . G. . Garmire . L. . Townsley . W. N. . Brandt . R. . Sambruna . J. N. . Bregman . 290 . 5495 . 1325–1328 . 2000 . 10.1126/science.290.5495.1325 . 11082054 . 2000Sci...290.1325G .
29. Observation of X-ray lines from a gamma-ray burst (GRB991216): evidence of moving ejecta from the progenitor . . L. . Piro . G. . Garmire . M. . Garcia . G. . Stratta . E. . Costa . M. . Feroci . P. . Meszaros . M. . Vietri . H. . Bradt . D. . Frail . F. . Frontera . J. . Halpern . J. . Heise . K. . Hurley . N. . Kawai . R. M. . Kippen . F. . Marshall . T. . Murakami . V. V. . Sokolov . T. . Takeshima . A. . Yoshida . 9 . 290 . 5493 . 955–958 . 2000 . astro-ph/0011337 . 10.1126/science.290.5493.955 . 11062121 . 2000Sci...290..955P. 35190896 .
30. Students Using NASA and NSF Data Make Stellar Discovery; Win Science Team Competition . NASA . Release 00-195 . December 12, 2000 . https://web.archive.org/web/20130510130847/http://quest.nasa.gov/dso/news/press_release/12-11-00.txt . May 10, 2013 .
31. Schmitt & Liefke, 2004
32. An X-ray outburst from the rapidly accreting young star that illuminates McNeil's nebula . . J. H. . Kastner . M. . Richmond . N. . Grosso . D. A. . Weintraub . T. . Simon . A. . Frank . K. . Hamaguchi . H. . Ozawa . A. . Henden . 430 . 6998 . 429–431 . 2004 . astro-ph/0408332 . 10.1038/nature02747 . 15269761 . 2004Natur.430..429K. 1186552 .
33. Determination of the Cosmic Distance Scale from Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect and Chandra X-Ray Measurements of High-Redshift Galaxy Clusters . Bonamente . Massimiliano . Joy . Marshall . LaRoque . Samuel . Carlstrom . John . Reese . Erik . Dawson . Kyle . August 10, 2006 . The Astrophysical Journal . 647 . 1 . 25–54 . 10.1086/505291 . astro-ph/0512349 . 2006ApJ...647...25B . 15723115 .
34. A Direct Empirical Proof of the Existence of Dark Matter . Clowe . Douglas . Bradač . Maruša . Gonzalez . Anthony . Markevitch . Maxim . Randall . Scott . Jones . Christine . Zaritsky . Dennis . August 30, 2006 . The Astrophysical Journal . 648 . 2 . L109–L113 . 10.1086/508162 . astro-ph/0608407 . 2006ApJ...648L.109C . free .
35. Roy . Steve . Watzke . Megan . Chandra Reviews Black Hole Musical: Epic But Off-Key . Center for Astrophysics Harvard & Smithsonian . October 2006.
36. Recent and Future Observations in the X-ray and Gamma-ray Bands: Chandra, Suzaku, GLAST, and NuSTAR . Astrophysical Sources of High Energy Particles and Radiation. June 20–24, 2005. Torun, Poland. . AIP Conference Proceedings . Greg . Madejski . 801 . 21 . 2005 . 10.1063/1.2141828 . astro-ph/0512012 .
37. News: Puzzling X-rays from Jupiter . NASA . March 7, 2002 . July 12, 2022 .
38. Web site: J. D. . Harrington . Janet . Anderson . Peter . Edmonds . September 24, 2012 . NASA's Chandra Shows Milky Way is Surrounded by Halo of Hot Gas . NASA .
39. Web site: M60-UCD1: An Ultra-Compact Dwarf Galaxy . NASA . September 24, 2013.
40. Web site: Chou . Felicia . Anderson . Janet . Watzke . Megan . RELEASE 15-001 - NASA's Chandra Detects Record-Breaking Outburst from Milky Way's Black Hole . January 5, 2015 . . January 6, 2015.
41. Web site: X-Ray Detection Sheds New Light on Pluto . . September 14, 2016 . https://web.archive.org/web/20161017110547/http://jhuapl.edu/newscenter/pressreleases/2016/160914.asp . October 17, 2016 .
42. News: Paul . Rincon . October 25, 2021 . Signs of first planet found outside our galaxy . BBC News . https://web.archive.org/web/20211025214850/https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-59044650 . October 25, 2021 . live .
43. News: Crane . Leah . Astronomers May Have Found the First Planet in Another Galaxy . September 23, 2020 . . September 25, 2020 .
44. Di Stefano . R. . et al. . M51-ULS-1b: The First Candidate for a Planet in an External Galaxy . 2009.08987 . September 18, 2020 . astro-ph.HE .
45. Web site: Mohon . Lee . March 30, 2021 . First X-rays from Uranus Discovered . July 25, 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220725172011/https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/chandra/images/first-x-rays-from-uranus-discovered.html . NASA .
46. Web site: The HRMA User's Guide . Chandra X-ray Center . T. J. . Gaetz . Diab . Jerius . January 28, 2005 . https://web.archive.org/web/20060210070532/http://cxc.harvard.edu/cal/Hrma/users_guide/hrma-notes.pdf . February 10, 2006.
47. Web site: Gott . J. Richard . Juric . Mario . 2006 . Logarithmic Map of the Universe . Princeton University .
48. Web site: Technical Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) . James Webb Space Telescope . NASA . December 14, 2016 .
49. Web site: Spacecraft: Motion, Heat, and Energy . Chandra X-ray Observatory . NASA . March 17, 2014 . December 14, 2016 .
50. Web site: Science Instruments . Center for Astrophysics Harvard & Smithsonian . November 17, 2016 .