Centre-left coalition (Italy) explained

Centre-left coalition
Native Name:Coalizione di centro-sinistra
Leader:Elly Schlein
Founder:Romano Prodi
Colours:Red
Seats2 Title:Senate of the Republic
Seats3 Title:European Parliament
Seats4 Title:Regional Government
Seats5 Title:Regional Councils
Country:Italy

The centre-left coalition (Italian: coalizione di centro-sinistra) is a political alliance of political parties in Italy active under several forms and names since 1995, when The Olive Tree was formed under the leadership of Romano Prodi. The centre-left coalition has ruled the country for more than fifteen years between 1996 and 2021; to do so, it had mostly to rely on a big tent that went from the more radical left-wing, which had more weight between 1996 and 2008, to the political centre, which had more weight during the 2010s, and its main parties were also part of grand coalitions and national unity governments.

The coalition mostly competed with the centre-right coalition led by Silvio Berlusconi. In the 1996 Italian general election, The Olive Tree consisted of the majority of both the left-wing Alliance of Progressives and the centrist Pact for Italy, the two losing coalitions in the 1994 Italian general election, the first under a system based primarily on first-past-the-post voting. In 2005, The Union was founded as a wider coalition to contest the 2006 Italian general election, which later collapsed due to Clemente Mastella during the 2008 Italian political crisis, with the fall of the second Prodi government.

In the late 2000s and early 2010s, the centre-left coalition has been built around the Democratic Party (PD), which was established in 2007 from a merger of Democrats of the Left and Democracy is Freedom, the main parties affiliated to both The Olive Tree and The Union. The centre-left coalition was part of Italian governments from November 2011 to June 2018, when a coalition government between the Five Star Movement (M5S) and the League was formed.

In September 2019, the centre-left returned to power in coalition with the M5S, with centre-left parties participating in the national unity government of Mario Draghi, who was the country's prime minister from February 2021 until the 2022 Italian government crisis in July that led to the 2022 Italian general election. Under an electoral law (Rosatellum) that favoured unity and coalitions, a divided centre-left, M5S, and PD's centrist split parties suffered a loss to the centre-right coalition, which won a majority of seats since the 2008 Italian general election. Since 2023, PD, M5S, Greens and Left Alliance (AVS) and minor leftist parties often run within the same coalition at local and regional level in the Progressive Camp.[1] [2]

History

Road to The Olive Tree

See main article: The Olive Tree (Italy). Following the 1994 Italian general election, which was won by the centre-right coalition of Silvio Berlusconi, the left-wing Alliance of Progressives and the centrist Pact for Italy started a parliamentary cooperation, which brought in March 1995 to the foundation of The Olive Tree.[3] The historical leader and ideologue of these coalitions was Romano Prodi, Professor of Economics and former member of Christian Democracy (DC), who invented the name and the symbol of The Olive Tree with Arturo Parisi in 1995.[4]

In 1995, Lega Nord exited the Pole of Freedoms and supported Lamberto Dini's technocratic government, together with the Pact for Italy and the Alliance of Progressives. On 21 April 1996, The Olive Tree won 1996 Italian general election with the Communist Refoundation Party (PRC) as an external ally, making Romano Prodi the Prime Minister of Italy.[5] The Olive Tree's largest partner was the Democratic Party of the Left (PDS), which contained the bulk of the former Italian Communist Party. The PDS supplied 16 ministers and 10 junior ministers; it was the first time that former PCI members had taken part in government since 1947. One of their leaders, Walter Veltroni, who ran in ticket with Prodi in a long electoral campaign, was Deputy Prime Minister of Italy. On 9 October 1998, the first Prodi government fell when PRC left the alliance. Since 21 October 1998, The Olive Tree was the core of the governments led by Massimo D'Alema and by Giuliano Amato. When D'Alema became the new prime minister, it was the first time ever in both Italy and Western Europe that an heir of the Communist party tradition came to lead a government. On 13 May 2001, led by Francesco Rutelli, who ran in ticket with Piero Fassino, the centre-left coalition lost the general elections against Berlusconi and the House of Freedoms.

The Union

See main article: The Union (Italy). The Union was the direct heir of The Olive Tree. While The Union was an heterogenous alliance that also included Communist parties, they were not part of The Olive Tree. Prodi won the 2006 Italian general election by a very narrow margin due to the new electoral law enacted by Roberto Calderoli; Berlusconi refused to acknowledge defeat. Prodi's coalition proved to be extremely frail, as the two-vote margin in the Senate of the Republic allowed almost any party in the coalition to veto legislation and political views inside the coalition spanned from communists to Christian democrats.

On 7 May 2006, the centre-left coalition officially endorsed Giorgio Napolitano as its candidate in the 2006 Italian presidential election that began on 8 May. The Holy See endorsed him as the president of Italy through its official newspaper, L'Osservatore Romano, just after The Union named him as its candidate, as did Marco Follini, former secretary of the Union of Christian and Centre Democrats (UDCC), a member party of the House of Freedoms. On 10 May 2006, Napolitano was elected in the fourth round of voting, the first of those requiring only an absolute majority, unlike the first three which required two-thirds of the votes, with 543 votes (out of a possible 1009). At the age of 80, he became the first former PCI member to become president of Italy

On 21 February 2007, less than a year after he had won the elections, Prodi tendered his resignation to Napolitano after the government was defeated in the Senate by two ballots in a vote on foreign policy. On 24 February, Napolitano invited Prodi to return to office and face a vote of confidence. Major causes of friction inside the coalition were the 2006 Pardon Act (it was criticised by the centre-right coalition and by the Italy of Values party), a draft bill to establish civil unions (vetoed by Christian democrats), Italy's continued involvement in Afghanistan (strongly opposed by left-wing parties), and the much publicised house-arrest of Clemente Mastella's wife (then a prominent politician at the regional level) over a corruption scandal. Mastella's party Union of Democrats for Europe held enough seats in the Senate that his eventual decision to withdraw its support for the government meant the end of the legislature on 6 February 2008. Mastella, who also resigned from his office as Minister of Justice, cited the proposed reform of the electoral system that would have made it difficult for small parties like his own to gain seats in the Italian Parliament, as well as the lack of personal support from his coalition partners' as one of the reasons behind his decision.[6]

Foundation of the Democratic Party

See main article: Democratic Party (Italy). The Democratic Party (PD) was founded on 14 October 2007 as a merger of various centre-left parties that had been part of The Union in the 2006 general election. At foundation, the majority of the PD was formed by the Democrats of the Left (DS), heirs of the PCI, and the largely Catholic-inspired Democracy is Freedom – The Daisy.[7] Within the party, an important role is played by Christian leftists, who are direct heirs of the former DC's left wing.[8] After the resignation of Silvio Berlusconi as prime minister in November 2011, the PD gave external support to Mario Monti's technocratic government.[9] [10]

Following the 2013 Italian general election and the 2014 European Parliament election in Italy, the PD was the largest party in the Chamber of Deputies, the Senate, and the European Parliament, respectively. Since April 2013, due to the inconclusive results of the 2013 general election held in February despite being the largest party and Pier Luigi Bersani's Italia. Bene Comune centre-left coalition, the PD member Enrico Letta was prime minister at the head of a government sustained by a grand coalition including The People of Freedom, which was later replaced by the New Centre-Right as the new Forza Italia (FI) went to the opposition, Civic Choice, and the Union of the Centre (UdC), the renamed UDCC that was later replaced by the Populars for Italy. Following his election as party leader in February 2014, Matteo Renzi called for "a new phase" and consequently the party's national board voted to ask Letta to resign. Subsequently, Renzi was sworn in as prime minister at the head of the same coalition.

By 2015, other than the national government, the PD led fifteen regional governments out of twenty and functioned as coalition partner in Trentino-Alto Adige/Südtirol. The 2016 Italian constitutional referendum was supported by the majority of the centre-left coalition. Inside the centre-left coalition, UdC, the Federation of the Greens, Autonomy Liberty Participation Ecology, Progressive Valdostan Union, Slovene Union, and Christian Popular Union campaigned for the "No" vote. The referendum was lost with 41% of "Yes" against 59% of "No" votes. After the referendum, Renzi tendered his resignation as prime minister and Paolo Gentiloni, also a member of the PD, became his successor. In the 2018 Italian general election, the centre-left coalition led by with Renzi obtained its worst result ever at 22.9% of the vote, well behind the centre-right coalition and the Five Star Movement (M5S). Following the defeat, Renzi resigned from secretary of the PD, and his deputy Maurizio Martina functioning afterwards as acting secretary.[11]

In September 2019, the PD formed a coalition government with the M5S and the PD's left-wing split Free and Equal (LeU), which was supported by the members of the centre-left coalition in 2018.[12] [13] Following the 2021 Italian government crisis, which was caused by Renzi's Italia Viva (IV) centrist party, Giuseppe Conte was replaced by Mario Draghi. In February 2021, a national unity government including the PD, MS5, IV, Article One, and Berlusconi's FI and Matteo Salvini's rebranded and renamed League. The Draghi government collapsed during the 2022 Italian government crisis, leading to Draghi's resignation as prime minister that July and a snap general election being called for September. For the 2022 Italian general election, the centre-left coalition centered around the PD's Democratic and Progressive Italy electoral list, which was allied with the Civic Commitment, Greens and Left Alliance,[14] and More Europe lists. Due to the Italian electoral law of 2015 that was supported by Renzi and that favoured unity and coalition, the centre-left coalition, which was not able to form alliances with the M5S (accused of causing the fall of Draghi's government) and the PD's centrist party splits that were opposed to the left-wing parties of the coalition,[15] was defeated by the centre-right coalition led Brothers of Italy (the sole centre-right coalition to oppose the Draghi's government) of Giorgia Meloni, who returned to power for the first time since 2011.

The Olive Tree (1995–2005)

See main article: The Olive Tree (Italy).

1996–1998

In the 1996 Italian general election and during the first Prodi government, the coalition was composed of the following parties:

PartyIdeologyLeader
Democratic Party of the Left (PDS)Democratic socialismMassimo D'Alema
Italian People's Party (PPI)Christian democracyFranco Marini
Italian Renewal (RI)LiberalismLamberto Dini
Federation of the Greens (FdV)Green politicsCarlo Ripa di Meana

The coalition had the following regional partners:

PartyRegionIdeologyLeader
Lega Autonomia Veneta (LAV)VenetoRegionalismMario Rigo
Sardinian Action Party (PSd'Az)SardiniaSardinian nationalismFranco Meloni

The Olive Tree presented candidates of The Network and the Ladin Autonomist Union in some first-past-the-post constituencies. The coalition also made an agreement of desistance with the Communist Refoundation Party in some first-past-the-post constituencies,[16] which ran under the banner of the Progressives.

1998–2001

In 1998, the Communist Refoundation Party brought down the first Prodi government.[17] with a splinter faction forming the Party of Italian Communists.[18] In 1998–2001, during the two governments led by Massimo D'Alema (1998–2000) and the one led by Giuliano Amato (2000–2001), the coalition was composed of eight parties:

PartyIdeologyLeader
Democrats of the Left (DS)Social democracyWalter Veltroni
Italian People's Party (PPI)Christian democracyFranco Marini / Pierluigi Castagnetti
The Democrats (Dem)Social liberalismRomano Prodi / Arturo Parisi
Italian Renewal (RI)LiberalismLamberto Dini
Party of Italian Communists (PdCI)CommunismArmando Cossutta / Oliviero Diliberto
Italian Democratic Socialists (SDI)Social democracyEnrico Boselli
Federation of the Greens (FdV)Green politicsLuigi Manconi / Grazia Francescato
Democratic Union for the Republic (UDR)Christian democracyClemente Mastella
Union of Democrats for Europe (UDEUR)

2001 general election

In the 2001 Italian general election, the coalition was led by Francesco Rutelli, and was composed of nine parties:

PartyIdeologyLeader
Democrats of the Left (DS)Social democracyWalter Veltroni
Democracy is Freedom (DL) Social liberalism / Christian leftFrancesco Rutelli
The SunflowerGreen politics / Social democracyGrazia Francescato / Enrico Boselli
Party of Italian Communists (PdCI)CommunismOliviero Diliberto
New Country (PN)Single-issue politicsNone

The coalition had the following regional partners:

PartyRegionIdeologyLeader
South Tyrolean People's Party (SVP)Trentino-Alto AdigeRegionalismSiegfried Brugger
With Illy for TriesteFriuli-Venezia GiuliaRegionalismRiccardo Illy

The Olive Tree made an agreement of desistance with the Communist Refoundation Party in the first-past-the-post constituencies.

2004 EP election

In the 2004 European Parliament election in Italy, the United in the Olive Tree joint list, was composed of four parties:

PartyIdeologyLeader
Democrats of the Left (DS)Social democracyPiero Fassino
Democracy is Freedom – The Daisy (DL)Social liberalismFrancesco Rutelli
Italian Democratic Socialists (SDI)Social democracyEnrico Boselli
European Republicans Movement (MRE)Social liberalismLuciana Sbarbati

The list was connected with the following regional partners:

PartyIdeologyLeader
South Tyrolean People's Party (SVP)RegionalismSiegfried Brugger
Valdostan Union (UV) RegionalismManuela Zublena

The Union (2005–2008)

See main article: The Union (Italy).

2006 general election

In the 2006 Italian general election, the coalition was composed of thirteen parties:

PartyIdeologyLeader
Democrats of the Left (DS)Social democracyPiero Fassino
Democracy is Freedom – The Daisy (DL)Social liberalismFrancesco Rutelli
Communist Refoundation Party (PRC)CommunismFausto Bertinotti
Italian Democratic Socialists (SDI)Social democracyEnrico Boselli
Italian Radicals (RI)LiberalismEmma Bonino
Italy of Values (IdV)Anti-corruption politicsAntonio Di Pietro
Party of Italian Communists (PdCI)CommunismOliviero Diliberto
Federation of the Greens (FdV)Green politicsAlfonso Pecoraro Scanio
Union of Democrats for Europe (UDEUR)Christian democracyClemente Mastella
Pensioners' Party (PP)Pensioners' interestsCarlo Fatuzzo
The Italian Socialists (SI)Social democracyBobo Craxi
Consumers' List (LC) Consumer protectionRenato Campiglia
United ConsumersConsumer protectionBruno De Vita
Italian Democratic Socialist Party (PSDI)Social democracyGiorgio Carta
European Republicans Movement (MRE)Social liberalismLuciana Sbarbati
United Democratic Christians (DCU)Christian democracyGiovanni Mongiello

The coalition had the following regional partners:

PartyRegionIdeologyLeader
Autonomy Liberty Democracy (ALD)Aosta ValleyRegionalismCarlo Perrin
South Tyrolean People's Party (SVP)Trentino-Alto AdigeRegionalismElmar Pichler Rolle
Lega per l'Autonomia – Alleanza Lombarda (LAL)LombardyRegionalismMatteo Brivio
Liga Fronte Veneto (LFV)VenetoRegionalismFabrizio Comencini

The coalition was supported by the Autonomists for Europe, Radicals of the Left, and the New Action Party.

PD-led coalitions (2008–present)

2008 general election

In the 2008 Italian general election, the coalition was led by Walter Veltroni,[19] and was composed of three parties:

PartyIdeologyLeader
Democratic Party (PD)Social democracyWalter Veltroni
Italy of Values (IdV)Anti-corruption politicsAntonio Di Pietro

The coalition also had the following regional partners:

PartyRegionIdeologyLeader
South Tyrolean People's Party (SVP)Trentino-Alto AdigeRegionalismPhilipp Achammer
Autonomy Liberty Democracy (ALD)Aosta ValleyRegionalismRoberto Louvin

2013 general election

See main article: Italy. Common Good. In the 2013 Italian general election, the coalition ran as Italy. Common Good under the leadership of Pier Luigi Bersani,[20] and was composed of the following parties:

PartyIdeologyLeader
Democratic Party (PD)Social democracyPier Luigi Bersani
Left Ecology Freedom (SEL)Democratic socialismNichi Vendola
Democratic Centre (CD)Christian leftBruno Tabacci
Italian Socialist Party (PSI)Social democracyRiccardo Nencini
Moderates (Mod.)LiberalismGiacomo Portas

The coalition had the following regional partners:

PartyRegionIdeologyLeader
Autonomy Liberty Democracy (ALD) Aosta ValleyRegionalismSeveral
South Tyrolean People's Party (SVP)Trentino-Alto AdigeRegionalismRichard Theiner
The Megaphone – Crocetta ListSicilyRegionalismRosario Crocetta

2018 general election

In the 2018 Italian general election, the coalition was led by Matteo Renzi, and was composed of four electoral lists:

PartyIdeologyLeader
Democratic Party (PD)Social democracyMatteo Renzi
More Europe (+E)LiberalismEmma Bonino
Italy Europe Together (IEI)ProgressivismGiulio Santagata
Popular Civic List (CP)Christian democracyBeatrice Lorenzin

The coalition had the following regional partners:

PartyRegionIdeologyLeader
Valdostan Union (UV)Aosta ValleyRegionalismEnnio Pastoret
Progressive Valdostan Union (UVP)RegionalismLaurent Viérin
Valdostan Autonomist Popular Edelweiss (EPAV)RegionalismMauro Baccega
South Tyrolean People's Party (SVP)Trentino-Alto AdigeRegionalismPhilipp Achammer
Trentino Tyrolean Autonomist Party (PATT)RegionalismFranco Panizza

The centre-left coalition was also supported by the Ladin Autonomist Union[21] and the Slovene Union.[22]

2022 general election

In the 2022 Italian general election, the alliance was formed by four parties:

PartyIdeologyLeader
Democratic Party – Democratic and Progressive Italy (PD–IDP)Social democracyEnrico Letta
More Europe (+E)LiberalismEmma Bonino
Civic Commitment (IC)CentrismLuigi Di Maio
Greens and Left Alliance (AVS)Eco-socialismAngelo Bonelli

The coalition contested the election in some regions under the following banners:

PartyRegionIdeologyLeader
Aosta Valley (VdA)Aosta ValleySeveralSeveral
Democratic Alliance for Autonomy (ADU)Trentino-Alto AdigeSeveralSeveral

There were regional agreements between the centre-left coalition and Action – Italia Viva in Trentino for the Senate election and in Aosta Valley for both Chamber and Senate elections. The Italian Left ran instead with the Five Star Movement and Democratic Area in Aosta Valley.

Electoral results

Italian Parliament

ElectionLeaderChamber of DeputiesSenate of the Republic
Votes % Seats +/– Position Votes % Seats +/– Position
199616,355,985 43.6 New 1st14,548,006 44.6 New 1st
200116,209,944 43.5 75 2nd13,282,495 39.2 41 2nd
200619,036,986 49.8 101 1st17,118,364 49.2 30 2nd
200813,689,303 37.5 109 2nd12,457,182 38.7 28 2nd
201310,047,603 29.5 106 1st9,686,683 31.6 3 1st
20187,506,723 22.9 223 3rd6,947,199 23.0 69 3rd
20227,337,975 26.1 37 2nd7,161,688 25.4 14 2nd

Regional Councils

width=19%Regionwidth=13%Election yearwidth=16%Voteswidth=7%% width=1%Seatswidth=6%+/−
Aosta Valley202010,106 (3rd) 15.5
Piedmont2019936,099 (2nd)35.2
Lombardy2023945,148 (2nd)32.8
South Tyrol202366,353 23.6
Trentino202378,545 (2nd)33.8
Veneto2020337,454 (2nd)16.4
Friuli-Venezia Giulia2023117,469 (2nd)29.7
Emilia-Romagna20201,040,482 (1st)48.1
Liguria2020242,652 (2nd) 38.7
Tuscany2020764,123 (1st)47.1
Marche2020227,183 (2nd)36.5
Umbria2019153,784 (2nd)36.8
Lazio2023519,066 (2nd)33.6
Abruzzo2024262,565 (2nd)45.3
Molise202348,936 (2nd)34.6
Campania20201,616,540 (1st)68.6
Apulia2020759,732 (1st)45.3
Basilicata2024108,135 (2nd)41.4
Calabria2021208,980 (2nd)27.4
Sicily2022341,252 (3rd)16.1
Sardinia2024293,288 (2nd)42.5

References

Notes and References

  1. https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2024/03/04/sondaggio-la7-centrosinistra-m5s-centrodestra-meloni-fratelli-ditalia/7468445/ I sondaggi e l’effetto Todde, il campo progressista a un solo punto dal centrodestra. Fratelli d’Italia al secondo ribasso di fila
  2. https://www.repubblica.it/politica/2024/03/09/news/giuseppe_conte_m5s_elezioni_regionali_abruzzo-422279829/ Conte: “Meloni non dura e il M5S da solo non vince. Nel campo progressista il Pd è un protagonista”
  3. Book: Roberto Biorcio. Italy. Ferdinand Muller-Rommel. Thomas Poguntke. Green Parties in National Governments. https://books.google.com/books?id=ndz9AQAAQBAJ&pg=PA42. 2002. Routledge. 978-1-135-28826-6. 42–44.
  4. Web site: Ulivo, L' nell'Enciclopedia Treccani. www.treccani.it.
  5. Book: Christina Holtz-Bacha. Gianpietro Mazzoleni. The Politics of Representation: Election Campaigning and Proportional Representation. 2004. Peter Lang. 978-0-8204-6148-9. 60.
  6. BBC, 16 January 2008 Italian justice minister resigns
  7. Book: Hans Slomp. Europe, a Political Profile: An American Companion to European Politics. 13 August 2013. 2011. ABC-CLIO. 978-0-313-39181-1. 406.
  8. Book: Vespa, Bruno . Il Cuore e la Spada: Storia politica e romantica dell'Italia unita, 1861-2011 . Mondadori . 2010 . 650 . 9788852017285 .
  9. News: Via libera definitivo a Monti "Clima nuovo, ce la faremo". Corriere della Sera. 19 November 2011. 6 June 2013.
  10. News: Camera, fiducia ampia Il Pdl: esecutivo di tregua, l' Ici si può riesaminare. Corriere Della Sera. 19 November 2011. 6 June 2013.
  11. Web site: Dimissioni Renzi: La guida del partito va a Martina - Corriere.it.
  12. News: Johnson . Miles . 2019-05-21 . Italy’s centre-left confident it can challenge the populists . Financial Times . 2023-08-14.
  13. Web site: 2019-08-21 . Italy’s center left green-lights potential coalition with 5Stars . 2023-08-14 . Politico . en.
  14. News: Amante . Angelo . 2022-08-06 . Italian centre-left alliance boosted as another group signs up . en . Reuters . 2023-08-14.
  15. News: Italy's centre-left suffers blow as centrist party quits electoral pact . www.euractiv.com . 8 August 2022.
  16. Book: Giuseppe Ieraci. Governments and Parties in Italy: Parliamentary Debates, Investiture Votes and Policy Positions (1994-2006). 2008. Troubador Publishing Ltd. 978-1-906221-72-0. 24.
  17. Book: Giuseppe Ieraci. Governments and Parties in Italy: Parliamentary Debates, Investiture Votes and Policy Positions (1994-2006). 2008. Troubador Publishing Ltd. 978-1-906221-72-0. 87.
  18. Book: Gianfranco Pasquino. The political context 1996-2001. James L. Newell. The Italian General Election of 2001: Berlusconi's Victory. https://books.google.com/books?id=zZhiuXDq8K4C&pg=PA33. 2002. Manchester University Press. 978-0-7190-6100-4. 33–.
  19. Web site: Berlusconi declares election win . BBC News . 14 April 2008.
  20. News: Italian election results: gridlock likely – as it happened. 26 February 2013. Guardian. 27 February 2013.
  21. Web site: Union Autonomista Ladina. www.facebook.com. 14 August 2018.
  22. Web site: Vodstvo SSk se je sestalo z neodvisnim kandidatom za senat Riccardom Illyjem. www.slovenskaskupnost.org. 14 August 2018. 12 June 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20180612142443/http://www.slovenskaskupnost.org/news/detail/879. dead.