Captive Primate Safety Act Explained

The Captive Primate Safety Act (H.R. 8164; S.4206) is proposed United States legislation that modifies the Lacey Act Amendments of 1981 to treat nonhuman primates as prohibited wildlife species, allowing exemptions for zoos and research facilities. The bill would eliminate the use of primates in the domestic pet trade at a federal level. A December 2023 review found that the "U.S. ranked third out of 171 countries in the ease of purchasing a pet primate online, behind Indonesia and Vietnam."[1] [2] The bill, if passed, would raise U.S. standards to resemble those of the European Union, United Kingdom, Italy, the Netherlands, and other countries where pet primates are strictly regulated.[3] [4]

In April 2024, the Captive Private Safety Act was introduced in Congress by U.S. Senator Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), U.S. Representative Earl Blumenauer (D-OR), and U.S. Congressman Brian Fitzpatrick (R-PA).[5] In September 2024, Blumenthal held a press conference with Friends of Animals to promote the Act in the wake of the HBO series Chimp Crazy,[6] which highlights disturbing examples of primate "pets".

The Captive Primate Safety Act was first introduced in 2005 and has been passed by the House of Representatives multiple times but, as of 2024, has not made it past both houses for a vote.

The legislation is endorsed by Animal Welfare Institute, Friends of Animals, Born Free USA, Humane Society of the United States, Animal Legal Defense Fund, International Fund for Animal Welfare, Four Paws USA, Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries, Association of Zoos and Aquariums, American Society of Primatologists, Small and Rural Law Enforcement Executives Association, and National Sheriffs Association, among others.[7]

History

The Captive Primate Safety Act was first introduced in the United States House of Representatives by Rep. Eddie Johnson on March 16, 2005.[8] The bill was reintroduced by Rep. Mark Kirk[9] in February 2009 following the widely publicized mauling of Charla Nash by a pet chimpanzee Travis.[10] Rep. Rob Bishop argued against the bill during the floor debate, noting it would cost $4 million annually and do nothing directly to prevent chimpanzee attacks on humans; he also noted such attacks are relatively rare.[11] Twenty states and the District of Columbia already had laws banning primates as pets.[12] On 23 February 2009 the House voted 323 to 95 in favor of the bill. Several Republicans who opposed to the bill said that animal control was a "states issue, not a federal issue."[13] Early versions of the bill exempted monkey helpers.[11]

CongressShort titleBill number(s)Date introducedSponsor(s)
  1. of cosponsors
Latest status
109th CongressCaptive Primate Safety ActMarch 16, 2005Eddie Bernice Johnson(D-TX)47Died in committee
Captive Primate Safety Act of 2005July 27, 2005Jim Jeffords(I-VT)6Passed Senate (unanimous consent)
110th CongressCaptive Primate Safety ActJuly 10, 2007Eddie Bernice Johnson(D-TX)25Passed House
May 24, 2007Barbara Boxer(D-CA)5Died in committee
111th CongressJanuary 6, 2009Earl Blumenauer(D-OR)27Passed House
February 24, 2009Barbara Boxer(D-CA)8Died in committee
112th CongressMarch 29, 2012Mike Fitzpatrick(R-PA)9Died in committee
July 5, 2011Barbara Boxer(D-CA)6Died in committee
113th CongressJuly 30, 2013Mike Fitzpatrick(R-PA)152Died in committee
August 1, 2013Barbara Boxer(D-CA)25Died in committee
114th CongressJune 25, 2015Mike Fitzpatrick(R-PA)75Died in committee
116th CongressMarch 14, 2019Earl Blumenauer(D-OR)66Died in committee
September 26, 2019Richard Blumenthal(D-CT)12Died in committee
117th CongressMay 12, 2021Earl Blumenauer(D-OR)67Referred to committee
May 12, 2021Richard Blumenthal(D-CT)11Referred to committee
118th CongressH.R. 8164April 30, 2024Earl Blumenauer  (D-OR-3)42Referred to committee
S.4206April 30, 2024Richard Blumenthal(D-CT)6Referred to committee

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Seaboch . Melissa . March 1, 2024 . The pet primate trade in the U.S. . September 1, 2024 . Open Access Government.
  2. Vincent . Nijman . December 2023 . Global online trade in primates for pets . Environmental Development . 48 . Science Direct.
  3. Web site: September 20, 2012 . Wild Pets in the European Union . September 1, 2024 . ENDCAP.
  4. News: Ahmadi . Ali Abbas . February 27, 2024 . Primates: New rules make it harder to keep them as pets . September 1, 2024 . BBC News.
  5. Web site: May 1, 2024 . Blumenthal, Blumenauer, & Fitzpatrick Introduce Bipartisan, Bicameral Legislation to Ban Private Possession of Primates . September 3, 2024 . Richard Blumenthal.
  6. News: Sanchez . Sara . September 5, 2024 . Connecticut senator hoping 'Chimp Crazy' popularity will help pass primate legislation . September 7, 2024 . Fox61.
  7. Web site: May 1, 2024 . Blumenthal, Blumenauer, & Fitzpatrick Introduce Bipartisan, Bicameral Legislation to Ban Private Possession of Primates . September 1, 2024 . Richard Blumenthal (US Senator, CT).
  8. Web site: September 7, 2024 . H.R.1329 - Captive Primate Safety Act . September 7, 2024 . Congress.gov.
  9. Web site: Ben Smith's Blog: The Primate Act of '09 . Politico.Com . 23 February 2009. 2010-07-26.
  10. Web site: Topic Galleries . Courant.com . 2010-07-26 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20090226225556/http://www.courant.com/news/local/hc-webchimp0223feb24%2C0%2C7133079.story . 2009-02-26 .
  11. Peter Urban, House approves primate pet ban, Connecticut Post, February 24, 2009. Retrieved February 24, 2009.
  12. http://blogs.usatoday.com/ondeadline/2009/02/house-tightens.html House tightens restrictions on chimps as pets
  13. News: February 25, 2009 . House responds to chimpanzee attack . September 5, 2024 . The Billings Gazette . 2.