List of canceled nuclear reactors in the United States explained

See main article: List of nuclear reactors. This is a list of canceled nuclear reactors in the United States.

History

The late 1960s and early 1970s saw a rapid growth in the development of nuclear power in the United States. By 1976, however, many nuclear plant proposals were no longer viable due to a slower rate of growth in electricity demand, significant cost and time overruns, and more complex regulatory requirements. Also, there was considerable public opposition to nuclear power in the US by this time, which contributed to delays in licensing planned nuclear power stations, and further increased costs.[1]

In 1969, a different type of reactor, Alvin Weinberg's molten salt reactor experiment at ORNL was shut down, after proving that molten salt combined with nuclear fuel can work without a LOCA (loss of cooling accident). Although just experimental, continued and aggressive development could have paved the way to much safer and less expensive reactors.[2] and [3]

By the end of the 1970s it became clear that nuclear power would not grow nearly as dramatically as once believed. This was particularly galvanized by the Three Mile Island accident in 1979. Eventually, more than 120 reactor orders were ultimately cancelled[4] and the construction of new reactors ground to a halt. Al Gore has commented on the historical record and reliability of nuclear power in the United States:

Of the 253 nuclear power reactors originally ordered in the United States from 1953 to 2008, 48 percent were cancelled, 11 percent were prematurely shut down, 14 percent experienced at least a one-year-or-more outage, and 27 percent are operating without having a year-plus outage. Thus, only about one fourth of those ordered, or about half of those completed, are still operating and have proved relatively reliable.[5]

A cover story in the February 11, 1985, issue of Forbes magazine commented on the overall management of the nuclear power program in the United States:

The failure of the U.S. nuclear power program ranks as the largest managerial disaster in business history, a disaster on a monumental scale ... only the blind, or the biased, can now think that the money has been well spent. It is a defeat for the U.S. consumer and for the competitiveness of U.S. industry, for the utilities that undertook the program and for the private enterprise system that made it possible.[6]

During the 2000s, aging infrastructure, growing power use and fears of global climate change all prompted what was then called the "nuclear renaissance". Engineering companies noted that the commissioning process was a major barrier to further construction, and changes to the system were carried out by the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission as part of the Energy Policy Act of 2005, along with new tax incentives and loan guarantees. As many as 30 new reactors were planned by 2009.[7]

, only two new reactors are still under construction, both at Vogtle. The project has announced significant delays and budget overruns. Most of the other new builds and the equally extensive list of upgrades to existing reactors have been shelved https://www.nationalreview.com/2023/01/new-red-tape-makes-new-nuclear-reactors-impossible/.

Cancelled nuclear reactors

Name UnitTypeModel*StatusLocationNet
capacity
in MW
Gross
capacity
in MW
Contract
year
Construction
start
Project
close
Refs
Allens Creek1BWRGEWallis, 1,1601,2071973-1982-09-01
Allens Creek2BWRGEWallis, 1,1601,2071973-1976-09-01
Alabama Power Co1BWRGESelma, ---
Alabama Power Co2BWRGESelma, ---
Atlantic
(offshore)
1PWRAtlantic City, 1,1501,2111972-1978-12-01
Atlantic
(offshore)
2PWRAtlantic City, 1,1501,2111972-1978-12-01
Atlantic
(offshore)
3PWRAtlantic City, 1,1501,2111973-1978-12-01
Atlantic
(offshore)
4PWRAtlantic City, 1,1501,2111973-1978-12-01
Bailly
(converted to coal)
1BWRGEWestchester Township, Porter County, Indiana, 66068619671974-01-011981-08-01
Barton1BWRGEClanton, 1,2091,2541972-1977-11-01
Barton2BWRGEClanton, 1,2091,2541972-1977-11-01
Barton3BWRGEClanton, 1,2091,2541974-1975-11-01
Barton4BWRGEClanton, 1,2091,2541974-1975-11-01
Bell Bend1PWRAreva European Pressurized Water ReactorSalem, 1,6001,720---
Bell Station1Lansing, 8381967-1972
Bellefonte1PWRB&W Model 205Scottsboro, 1,2351,26319701974-09-011988-01-01
Bellefonte2PWRB&W Model 205Scottsboro, 1,2351,26319701974-09-011988-01-01
Bellefonte3PWRWH AP1000Scottsboro, 1117---
Bellefonte4PWRWH AP1000Scottsboro, 1117---
Black Fox1BWRGEInola, 1,1501,22619731978-07-011982-02-01
Black Fox2BWRGEInola, 1,1501,22619731978-07-011982-02-01
Blue Hills (formerly Sunken Log)1PWRJasper, 9309571973-1978-08-01
Blue Hills (formerly Sunken Log)2PWRJasper, 9309571974-1978-08-01
Bodega Bay1BWRGEBodega Head, 313589-19581964
Callaway2PWRCallaway, 1,1201,17619731975-10-011981-10-01
Callaway2PWRAreva European Pressurized Water ReactorCallaway, 1,6002008-2015-8
Calvert Cliffs3PWRAreva European Pressurized Water ReactorCalvert County, 1,6001,720--2015-06-08
Carroll County1PWRSavanna, 1,1201,1501978-1988-12-01
Carroll County2PWRSavanna, 1,1201,1501978-1988-12-01
Central Iowa1BWRGE1,1001,160--1975-09-01
1PWRGaffney, 1,2801,34319731976-06-011983-04-01
Cherokee2PWRGaffney, 1,2801,34319731976-06-011982-11-01
Cherokee3PWRGaffney, 1,2801,34319731976-06-011982-11-01
Clinch River Breeder Reactor1FBRUnited States Atomic Energy CommissionOak Ridge, 3503801973-1983-11-01
Clinton2BWRGEClinton, 93398519731975-10-011983-10-01
Columbia (WNP-1/WPPSS-1)1PWRRichland, 1,2591,33919721975-08-011983-01-01
Columbia (WNP-4/WPPSS-4)4PWRRichland, 1,2501,34019741975-08-011982-01-01
Comanche Peak3PWRSomervell County, 1,700--2013-11-07
Comanche Peak4PWRSomervell County, 1,700--2013-11-07
Crystal River4PWRCrystal River, 8979401971-1972-07-01
Davis Besse2PWROak Harbor, 9109601973-1980-01-01
Davis Besse3PWROak Harbor, 9109601973-1980-01-01
Douglas Point (US)1BWRGECharles County, 1,1781,2061972-1980-05-01
Douglas Point (US)2BWRGECharles County, 1,1781,2061972-1978-01-01
Erie1PWRBerlin Heights, 1,2601,3001976-1980-01-01
Erie2PWRBerlin Heights, 1,2601,3001976-1980-01-01
Floating1PWRJacksonville, 1,1501,211--1979-01-01
Floating2PWRJacksonville, 1,1501,211--1979-01-01
Forked River1PWRForked River, 1,0701,12319691973-08-011980-11-01
Fort Calhoun2PWRFort Calhoun, 1,1361,1821972-1977-02-01
Fulton1HTGRGALancaster, 1,1601,2001971-1976-03-01
Fulton2HTGRGALancaster, 1,1601,2001971-1976-03-01
Galena1SFRToshiba 4SGalena, 102008--
Grand Gulf2BWRGEPort Gibson, 1,2501,30219721974-05-011990-12-01
Grand Gulf3BWRGEPort Gibson, 1,5201,6001973-2015-02-09
Greene County1PWRClementon, 1,1911,2771974-1979-04-01
Greenwood2PWRPort Huron, 1,2081,2681972-1980-03-01
Greenwood3PWRPort Huron, 1,2081,2681972-1980-03-01
HartsvilleA1BWRGEHartsville, 1,2331,26919721976-04-011984-08-01
HartsvilleA2BWRGEHartsville, 1,2331,26919721976-04-011984-08-01
HartsvilleB1BWRGEHartsville, 1,2331,26919721976-04-011982-08-01
HartsvilleB2BWRGEHartsville, 1,2331,26919721976-04-011982-08-01
Haven1PWRHaven, 9009601973-1980-02-01
Haven2PWRHaven, 9009601974-1978-05-01
Hope Creek2BWRGEHancocks Bridge, 1,0671,11819691976-03-011981-12-01
Jamesport1PWRJamesport, 1,1501,1821973-1980-01-01
Jamesport2PWRJamesport, 1,1501,1821974-1980-01-01
Koshkonong1PWRCancelled PlanJefferson County, Wisconsin9009001973-1977-01-10
Koshkonong2PWRCancelled PlanJefferson County, Wisconsin9009001973-1977-01-10
Levy County1PWRLevy County, 1,1172008-2013-08-01
Levy County2PWRLevy County, 1,1172008-2013-08-01
Malibu1PWRCorral Canyon, 4621963-1972
Marble Hill1PWRPaynesville, 1,0301,09019731977-07-011984-01-01
Marble Hill2PWRPaynesville, 1,1301,19019731977-07-011984-01-01
Mayport1Mayport, 1969--
Mayport2Mayport, 1969--
Midland1PWRMidland, 49152619681973-03-011986-07-01
Midland2PWRMidland, 81685519681973-03-011986-07-01
Montague1BWRGEMontague, 1,1501,2981974-1980-12-01
Montague2BWRGEMontague, 1,1501,2981974-1980-12-01
Newbold Island
(relocated to Hope Creek)
1BWRGEBordentown, ---
Newbold Island
(relocated to Hope Creek)
2BWRGEBordentown, ---
New England (NEP)1PWRCharlestown, 1,1501,1941974-1980-01-01
New England (NEP)2PWRCharlestown, 1,1501,1941974-1980-01-01
New Haven1PWRNew Haven, 1,2501,3001977-1980-01-01
New Haven2PWRNew Haven, 1,2501,3001977-1980-01-01
Nine Mile Point3PWRScriba, 1,6002008-2013-11-25
North Anna3PWRMineral, 90795019711971-06-011982-11-01
North Anna4PWRMineral, 90795019711971-12-011980-11-01
North Coast (formerly Aguirre/Isolte)1PWRArecibo, 5836141970-1978-12-01
North Coast (formerly Aguirre/Isolte)2PWRArecibo, --1973--
NYSE&G1PWR1,250-1977-1980
NYSE&G2PWR1,250-1977-1980
Orange/Orlando1PWROrlando, 1,3001,3601974-1975-12-01
Orange/Orlando2PWROrlando, 1,3001,3601974-1975-12-01
Palo Verde4PWRTonopah, 1,2701,3071977-1979-07-01
Palo Verde5PWRTonopah, 1,2701,3071977-1979-07-01
Pebble Springs1PWRArlington, 1,2601,3141973-1982-09-01
Pebble Springs2PWRArlington, 1,2601,3141974-1982-09-01
Perkins1PWRMocksville, 1,2871,3451973-1982-02-01
Perkins2PWRMocksville, 1,2871,3451973-1982-02-01
Perkins3PWRMocksville, 1,2871,3451973-1982-02-01
Perry2BWRGEPerry, 1,2051,25019741974-10-011984-04-01
Perryman1PWRBaltimore, 8458801972-1972-11-01
Perryman2PWRBaltimore, 8458801972-1972-11-01
Phipps Bend1BWRGEKingsport, 1,2331,26919741977-10-011982-08-01
Phipps Bend2BWRGEKingsport, 1,2331,26919741977-10-011982-08-01
Pilgrim2PWRPlymouth, 1,1801,2401972-1981-09-01
Pilgrim3PWRPlymouth, 1,1801,240--1974-07-01
Quanicassee1PWRBay City, 1,1501972-1974
Quanicassee2PWRBay City, 1,1501972-1974
Ravenswood1PWRLong Island, 5001962-1964-01-06
Ravenswood2PWRLong Island, 5001962-1964-01-06
River Bend2BWRGESt. Francisville, 93499119731975-08-011984-01-01
River Bend3BWRGESt. Francisville, 15201600--2015-12-04
San Joaquin Nuclear Project1Kern County, 13001973-1978-03-31
San Joaquin Nuclear Project2Kern County, 13001973-1978-03-31
San Joaquin Nuclear Project3Kern County, 13001973-1978-03-31
San Joaquin Nuclear Project4Kern County, 13001973-1978-03-31
Satsop (WNP-3/WPPSS-3)3PWRCombustion EngineeringElma, 1,2401,32419731977-04-011983-01-01
Satsop (WNP-5/WPPSS-5)5PWRCombustion EngineeringElma, 1,2401,31619741977-04-011982-01-01
Seabrook2PWRSeabrook, 1,1491,19919721976-07-011988-01-01
Sears Isle1PWRSears Island, 1,1501974-1977
Shearon Harris2PWRWH 3-LoopBonsal, 90096019711978-01-011983-12-01 (2013)
Shearon Harris3PWRWH 3-LoopBonsal, 90096019711978-01-011983-12-01 (2013)
Shearon Harris4PWRWH 3-LoopBonsal, 90096019711978-01-011983-12-01
Shearon Harris2PWRWH AP1000Bonsal, 1,1171,250--2013-05-02
Shearon Harris3PWRWH AP1000Bonsal, 1,1171,250--2013-05-02
Skagit-Hanford1BWRGESedro Woolley, 1,2751,3351973-1983-08-01
Skagit-Hanford2BWRGESedro Woolley, 1,2751,3351974-1983-08-01
Somerset1BWRGESomerset, 1,1901,2471974-1977-05-01
Somerset2BWRGESomerset, 1,1901,2471974-1977-05-01
South Dade1PWRMiami-Dade County, 1,1501,2101975-1977-05-01
South Dade2PWRMiami-Dade County, 1,1501,2101975-1977-05-01
South River1PWR1,1501,2001973-1979-01-01
South River2PWR1,1501,2001973-1979-01-01
South River3PWR1,1501,2001973-1974-12-01
South Texas3BWRToshiba Advanced Boiling Water ReactorMatagorda County, 2018[8]
South Texas4BWRToshiba Advanced Boiling Water ReactorMatagorda County, 2018
Stanislaus1BWRGEStanislaus County, 1,1001,2001971-1979
Stanislaus2BWRGEStanislaus County, 1,1001,2001971-1979
Sterling1PWROswego, 1,1501,1851973-1980-01-01
Summit1HTGRGAWhitehall, 7707811971-1975-11-01
Summit2HTGRGAWhitehall, 7707811971-1975-11-01
Sundesert1PWRBlythe, 9349781975-1978-05-01
Sundesert2PWRBlythe, 9349781975-1978-05-01
Surry3PWRLouisa County, 85991919721974-01-011977-03-01
Surry4PWRLouisa County, 85991919721974-01-011977-03-01
Tyrone1PWRDurand, 1,1501,1881973-1979-07-01
Tyrone2PWRDurand, 1,1501,1881973-1975-12-01
Vandalia (Iowa)1PWRVandalia, 1,2701,3001976-1982-02-01
Vidal1HTGRGAVidal Valley, 7701972-1974
Vidal2HTGRGAVidal Valley, 7701972-1974
V.C. Summer2PWRWH AP1000Jenkinsville, 1,1171,25020082013-03-092017-07-31
V.C. Summer3PWRWH AP1000Jenkinsville, 1,1171,25020082013-03-092017-07-31
Verplanck
(formerly Indian Point-4)
1BWRGEBuchanan, 1,1001,1151968-1975
Verplanck
(formerly Indian Point-5)
2BWRGEBuchanan, 1,1001,1151968-1975
Victoria County Station1BWRGEHVictoria County,1,5352008-2012-08-28
Victoria County Station2BWRGEHVictoria County, 1,5352008-2012-08-28
3PWRWH 4-LoopBurke County, 1,1131973-1974
4PWRWH 4-LoopBurke County, 1,1131973-1974
Yellow Creek1PWRCorinth, 1,2851,33919741978-02-011984-08-30
Yellow Creek2PWRCorinth, 1,2851,33919741978-02-011984-08-30
Zimmer
(converted to coal)
1BWRGEMoscow, 81084019691972-10-011984-01-01
Zimmer2BWRGEMoscow, 1,1251,1721974-1984-01-01

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. https://books.google.com/books?id=CK48AAAAIAAJ&pg=PA16 Nuclear power: Futures, Costs, and Benefits
  2. Web site: Time Warp: Molten Salt Reactor Experiment—Alvin Weinberg's magnum opus | ORNL .
  3. Web site: History | Molten Salt Reactor | ORNL .
  4. https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RL33442.pdf Nuclear Power: Outlook for New U.S. Reactors
  5. Al Gore (2009). Our Choice, Bloomsbury, p. 157.
  6. "Nuclear Follies", a February 11, 1985 cover story in Forbes magazine.
  7. J. Matthew Roney, "US Nuclear Power In Decline", Earth Policy Institute, 10 September 2013
  8. Web site: Toshiba scraps project to build ABWRs in Texas - World Nuclear News.