1930 Canadian federal election explained

Election Name:1930 Canadian federal election
Country:Canada
Flag Year:1921
Type:parliamentary
Ongoing:no
Party Colour:no
Party Name:no
Previous Election:1926 Canadian federal election
Previous Year:1926
Next Election:1935 Canadian federal election
Next Year:1935
Seats For Election:245 seats in the House of Commons
Majority Seats:123
Turnout:73.5%[1] (5.8pp)
Election Date:July 28, 1930
Elected Members:17th Canadian Parliament
Outgoing Members:16th Canadian Parliament
Image1:Richard Bedford Bennett (cropped2).jpg
Leader1:R. B. Bennett
Leader Since1:1927
Leaders Seat1:Calgary West
Last Election1:91
Seats1:137
Seat Change1:46
Popular Vote1:1,863,115
Percentage1:47.79%
Swing1:3.08pp
Leader2:W. L. Mackenzie King
Leader Since2:1919
Leaders Seat2:Prince Albert
Last Election2:116
Seats2:89
Seat Change2:27
Popular Vote2:1,716,798
Percentage2:44.03%
Swing2:1.13pp
Image4:JohnEBrownlee (cropped).jpg
Leader4:John E. Brownlee
Leaders Seat4:Did not run[2]
Last Election4:11
Seats4:9
Seat Change4:2
Popular Vote4:56,968
Percentage4:1.46%
Swing4:0.55pp
Leader5:None
Leaders Seat5:None
Last Election5:11
Seats5:3
Seat Change5:8
Popular Vote5:70,822
Percentage5:1.82%
Swing5:2.41pp
Map Size:350px
Prime Minister
Posttitle:Prime Minister after election
Before Election:William Lyon Mackenzie King
After Election:R. B. Bennett
Map2 Image:Chambre des Communes 1930.png
Map2 Size:350px
Map2 Caption:The Canadian parliament after the 1930 election

The 1930 Canadian federal election was held on July 28, 1930, to elect members of the House of Commons of the 17th Parliament of Canada. Richard Bedford Bennett's Conservative Party won a majority government, defeating the Liberal Party led by Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King.[3]

3,922,481 votes were cast in this election.https://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=ele&dir=turn&document=index&lang=e

Background

The first signs of the Great Depression were clearly evident by the 1930 election, and Conservative party leader Richard Bennett campaigned on a platform of aggressive measures in order to combat it.

Part of the reason for Bennett's success lay in the Liberals' own handling of the rising unemployment of 1930. Touting the Liberal formula as the reason for the economic prosperity of the 1920s, for example, left the Liberals carrying much of the responsibility, whether deserved or not, for the consequences of the crash of the American stock market.

King was apparently oblivious to the rising unemployment that greeted the 1930s, and continued to laud his government's hand in Canada's prosperity. Demands for aid were met with accusations of being the part of a great "Tory conspiracy," which led King to make his famous "five-cent piece" outburst, alienating a growing number of voters. In retrospect, one can understand King's reasoning. Both the Western mayors and provincial Premiers who had visited King with requests of relief were overwhelmingly Conservative: in the Premiers' case, seven out of nine. King concluded in Parliamentary debates that though aid was a provincial jurisdiction, the fact that he believed there to be no unemployment problem meant that the requests from the provinces appeared to be nothing more than political grandstanding. The Federal Conservatives had certainly exaggerated the Depression in its early stages solely to attack King's government.

Several other factors entered into King's defeat. Although obtaining funds from sometimes dubious sources was not a problem, the Liberal election machine was not as efficient as it once was, primarily due to the cause of the age and poor health of many chief strategists. King's campaign was the epitome of Murphy's law: every campaign stop appeared to meet the Prime Minister with some kind of mishap.

By contrast, Bennett's Conservatives were electric. The self-made man who led them had practically rebuilt his party (a significant part of it with his own funds) and developed an election machine which could rival the Liberals'. Aside from superior party organization, the Tories used it. They bought out newspapers in key areas (notably the Liberal strongholds of the West, and Quebec) and ensured that pro-Tory slants were kept. In the first election where radio played an important role, Bennett's vibrant, zealous voice was extremely preferable to King's. (The Tory machine, of course, ensured that only the best radio spots were available to Bennett.)

Also, Bennett's tariff policy, epitomized by his infamous promise to "blast" Canada's way into world markets, was extremely well received in the key Liberal strongholds of the West and Quebec. In the West, agricultural production had been hurt by worldwide overproduction, and certain agricultural groups in Quebec firmly endorsed Bennett's tariff policy. Bennett's Conservatives won much of the former Progressive and Farmers' vote in the West, and they were elected with 44% of the popular vote in Quebec as a protest vote.

All those factors led to Bennett's eventual election.

Canadian voters agreed with Bennett and the Conservatives were elected with a majority of 137 seats in the House Of Commons. The incumbent Liberals under William Lyon Mackenzie King became the official opposition after being reduced to 89.

The Progressives continued their decline, winning only three seats. The United Farmers of Alberta did somewhat better - despite finishing third place in the popular vote in that province they managed to hold on to nine of its seventeen seats (of which the UFA only contested ten). This would be the last federal election the Progressives or the UFA would win any seats.

Unfortunately for Bennett and the Conservatives, the Depression brought complex problems to politicians and extreme hardship for most Canadians. Bennett and the Conservatives lost the 1935 election to the Liberals under the previous Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King, and the Conservatives would not return to government until 1957.

National results

PartyParty leader
  1. of
    candidates
SeatsPopular vote
1926Elected% Change%pp ChangeConservativeR. B. Bennett22991137 +69.6%1,863,11547.79%+3.07LiberalW. L. Mackenzie King22611688align="right"-21.1%1,716,79844.03%+1.29 10119align="right"-18.2%56,9681.46%align="right"-0.55 15112align="right"-72.7%70,8221.82%align="right"-2.41 883align="right"-62.5%44,8221.15%align="right"-0.94J.S. Woodsworth842align="right"-50.0%26,5480.68%align="right"-0.95Independent1122align="right"-21,6080.55%align="right"-0.30Progressive-Conservative 2align="right"-1 15,996 0.41%+0.1Independent Labour2115,9880.41%Independent Liberal81-align="right"-100%14,4260.37%align="right"-0.25Farmer 5align="right"-11,9990.31%Independent Conservative6-align="right"-align="right"-10,3600.27%align="right"-0.07Unknown2align="right"-align="right"-align="right"-7,4410.19%+0.08Liberal-Labour 1align="right"--align="right"-7,1950.18%+0.05Tim Buck6align="right"-4,5570.12%Labour-Farmer 2align="right"-align="right"- align="right"-3,2760.08%+0.04Liberal-Protectionist 1 align="right"-2,7230.07%Farmer-Labour 1align="right"-2,0910.05%Independent Progressive1-1,2940.03%Franc Lib 1-4290.01%Prohibitionist 1align="right"-2660.01%
Total546245245align="right"-3,898,722100%  
Sources: http://www.elections.ca -- https://web.archive.org/web/20090609211221/http://www2.parl.gc.ca/Sites/LOP/HFER/hfer.asp?Language=E History of Federal Ridings since 1867https://www.ourcommons.ca/marleaumontpetit/DocumentViewer.aspx?DocId=1001&Language=E&Sec=Ch25&Seq=11

Note:

* The party did not nominate candidates in the previous election.

Results by province

Party nameBCABSKMBONQCNBNSPEYKTotal ConservativeSeats:7 <--BC-->4<--Alb-->7<--Sask-->10<--Man-->59<--Ont-->24<--Que-->10<--NB-->10 <--NS-->3<--PEI-->1<--YK-->135<--Canada/Total-->Popular vote (%):49.3%<--BC-->35.0%<--Alb-->33.6%<--Sask-->44.1%<--Man-->53.9%<--Ont-->43.7%<--Que-->59.3%<--NB-->52.5%<--NS-->50.0%<--PEI-->60.3%<--YK-->47.8%<--Canada/Total-->LiberalSeats:5<--BC-->3<--Alb-->12 <--Sask-->1<--Man-->22<--Ont-->40<--Que-->1 <--NB-->4<--NS-->1<--PEI-->- <--YK-->89 <--Canada/Total-->Vote:40.9% <--BC-->30.0% <--Alb-->48.4% <--Sask-->19.6%<--Man-->42.4%<--Ont-->53.2%<--Que-->40.7%<--NB-->47.5%<--NS-->50.0%<--PEI-->39.7%<--YK-->44.0%<--Canada/Total-->UF AlbertaSeats:  <--BC-->9<--Alb-->  <--Sask-->  <--Man-->  <--Ont-->  <--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->9<--Canada/Total-->Vote: <--BC-->28.4%<--Alb--> <--Sask-->  <--Man-->  <--Ont--> <--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->1.5%<--Canada/Total-->ProgressiveSeats:  <--BC-->- <--Alb-->2 <--Sask-->- <--Man-->1 <--Ont-->  <--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS-->  <--PEI--> <--YK-->3<--Canada/Total-->Vote: <--BC-->1.9%<--Alb-->8.1%<--Sask-->6.4%<--Man-->1.8% <--Ont--> <--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->1.8%<--Canada/Total-->Liberal-ProgressiveSeats:  <--BC-->  <--Alb-->- <--Sask-->3<--Man-->  <--Ont-->  <--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS-->  <--PEI--> <--YK-->3<--Canada/Total-->Vote: <--BC--> <--Alb-->2.1%<--Sask-->16.2%<--Man-->  <--Ont--> <--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->1.2%<--Canada/Total-->LabourSeats:  <--BC-->align="right"-   <--Sask-->2 <--Man-->-<--Ont-->  <--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS-->  <--PEI-->  <--YK-->2 <--Canada/Total-->Vote: <--BC-->3.0<--Alb--> <--Sask-->8.4<--Man-->0.1<--Ont-->  <--Que-->  <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.7 <--Canada/Total-->IndependentSeats:1 <--BC-->  <--Alb-->- <--Sask-->  <--Man-->- <--Ont-->1 <--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->2<--Canada/Total-->Vote:2.6<--BC-->  <--Alb-->3.5<--Sask-->  <--Man-->0.1<--Ont-->0.3<--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.6 <--Canada/Total-->Progressive-ConservativeSeats:  <--BC-->  <--Alb-->  <--Sask-->1 <--Man--> <--Ont-->align="right"-   <--NB-->  <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->1<--Canada/Total-->Vote:<--BC--> <--Alb--> <--Sask-->2.7<--Man-->  <--Ont-->1.0<--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS-->  <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.4 <--Canada/Total-->Independent LabourSeats:1 <--BC-->  <--Alb-->  <--Sask-->align="right"-  <--Ont-->  <--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS-->  <--PEI-->  <--YK-->1<--Canada/Total-->Vote:6.5<--BC--> <--Alb--> <--Sask-->0.1<--Man-->  <--Ont-->  <--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.4 <--Canada/Total-->
Total Seats14 <--BC-->16 <--Alb-->21 <--Sask-->17 <--Man-->82<--Ont-->65 <--Que-->11 <--NB-->14 <--NS-->4<--PEI-->1<--YK-->245<--Canada/Total-->
Parties that won no seats:Independent LiberalVote:  <--BC--> <--Alb--> <--Sask-->0.4<--Man-->  <--Ont-->1.3<--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS-->  <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.4 <--Canada/Total-->FarmerVote:  <--BC--> <--Alb-->3.6<--Sask--> <--Man-->  <--Ont-->  <--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.3 <--Canada/Total-->Independent ConservativeVote: <--BC--> <--Alb-->  <--Sask-->1.2<--Man-->0.5<--Ont-->0.1<--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS-->  <--PEI-->  <--YK-->  <--Canada/Total-->UnknownVote:<--BC--> <--Alb--> <--Sask-->  <--Man-->0.5<--Ont-->  <--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS-->  <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.2 <--Canada/Total-->Liberal-LabourVote:  <--BC--> <--Alb--> <--Sask--> <--Man-->0.5<--Ont-->  <--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.2 <--Canada/Total-->Vote:0.4<--BC-->  <--Alb-->  <--Sask-->0.9<--Man-->0.1<--Ont-->  <--Que-->  <--NB-->  <--NS-->  <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.1<--Canada/Total-->Labour-FarmerVote :  <--BC-->0.6<--Alb--> <--Sask--> <--Man-->  <--Ont-->  <--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.1 <--Canada/Total-->Liberal-ProtectionistVote: <--BC--> <--Alb--> <--Sask--> <--Man-->  <--Ont-->0.3<--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.1 <--Canada/Total-->Farmer-LabourVote:  <--BC--> <--Alb-->0.6<--Sask--> <--Man-->  <--Ont-->  <--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->0.1 <--Canada/Total-->Independent ProgressiveVote: <--BC--> <--Alb--> <--Sask-->  <--Man-->  <--Ont-->0.1<--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->xx<--Canada/Total-->Franc LibVote:0.2<--BC--> <--Alb-->  <--Sask-->  <--Man--> <--Ont-->  <--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->xx <--Canada/Total-->ProhibitionistVote:0.1<--BC--> <--Alb-->  <--Sask-->  <--Man--> <--Ont-->  <--Que--> <--NB--> <--NS--> <--PEI--> <--YK-->xx <--Canada/Total-->

See also

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Voter Turnout at Federal Elections and Referendums. Elections Canada. 10 March 2019.
  2. The United Farmers of Alberta, which at the time formed the government in that province, did not have a separate party leader at the federal level. At the time of this election, party leader John E. Brownlee was the Premier of Alberta and the MLA for Ponoka in the Legislative Assembly of Alberta.
  3. Soward. Frederic H.. 1930. The Canadian Elections of 1930. American Political Science Review. en. 24. 4. 995–1000. 10.2307/1946756. 0003-0554.