Kalanos Explained

Kalanos, also spelled Calanus (Greek, Ancient (to 1453);: Καλανός)^[1] (– 323 BCE), was an ancient Indian gymnosophist,^{[2] [3] [4]} a Brahmin sage,^{[5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14]} and philosopher from Taxila^[15] who accompanied Alexander the Great to Persis and later self-immolated, after falling ill, entered himself into a pyre, in front of Alexander and his army. Diodorus Siculus called him Caranus (Greek, Ancient (to 1453);: Κάρανος).^[16]

According to the Greek sources, he did not flinch as his body burned. He bade goodbye to some of the Greek soldiers who were his students, but not to Alexander. He communicated to Alexander that he would meet him in Babylon and curiously Alexander died exactly a year later in Babylon. ^[17] It was from Kalanos that Alexander learned of Dandamis, the leader of their group, whom Alexander later went to meet in the forest.^[18]

Early life

Plutarch indicates his real name was Sphínēs and that he was from Taxila, but since he greeted people with the word "Kalē!" - perhaps kallāṇa (mitta) "Greetings (friend)" - the Greeks called him Kalanos.^{[19] [20] [21] [22]} Kalanos lived at Taxila and led an austere religious life.^[23]

Some scholars have claimed that Kalanos was a Jain.^{[2] [15]} but modern scholarship rejects this notion as Jain ascetics are forbidden from using fire and intentional self-harm due to their convictions about Sallekhana. Moreover, there is no evidence of Jain occupation in Taxila at the time of Alexander.^[24]

Considering the dominant Brahmanical presence in Taxila, it's likely that the ascetics Alexander met, including Kalanos, were Brahmanical. Johannes Bronkhorst states that it's highly unlikely that Buddhists and Jains were present in the areas Alexander visited.^[25]

Meeting Alexander

Plutarch records that when first invited to meet Alexander, Kalanos "roughly commanded him to strip himself and hear what he said naked, otherwise he would not speak a word to him, though he came from Jupiter himself."^[26] Kalanos refused the rich gifts offered by Alexander, saying that man's desire cannot be satisfied by such gifts.^[22] The gymnosophists believed that even if Alexander killed them "they would be delivered from the body of flesh now afflicted with age and would be translated to a better and purer life."^[22]

Alexander's representative Onesicritus^[27] had a discussion with several gymnosophists and Alexander was attracted by their thoughts on Greek philosophy, of which they generally approved, but criticized the Greeks for preferring custom to nature and for refusing to give up clothing.^[23]

Alexander persuaded Kalanos to accompany him to Persis^[19] and stay with him as one of his teachers. Alexander even hinted use of force to take him to his country, to which Kalanos replied philosophically, that "what shall I be worth to you, Alexander, for exhibiting to the Greeks if I am compelled to do what I do not wish to do?" Kalanos lived as a teacher to Alexander and represented "eastern honesty and freedom".^[28]

Death and prophecy

He was seventy-three years of age at time of his death. When the Persian weather and arduous travels had weakened him, he informed Alexander that he would prefer to die rather than live as an invalid. He decided to take his life by self-immolation. Although Alexander tried to dissuade him from this course of action, upon Kalanos' insistence the job of building a pyre was entrusted to Ptolemy.^[29] Kalanos is mentioned also by Alexander's admirals, Nearchus and Chares of Mytilene.^[30] The city where this immolation took place was Susa in the year 323 BC.^[21] Kalanos distributed all the costly gifts he got from the king to the people and wore just a garland of flowers and chanted vedic hymns.^{[31] [32] [33]} He presented his horse to one of his Greek pupils named Lysimachus.^[34] He did not flinch as he burnt to the astonishment of those who watched.^{[22] [35] [36]} Although Alexander was not personally present at time of his immolation, his last words to Alexander were "We shall meet in Babylon".^{[37] [38] [39]} He is said to have thus prophesied the death of Alexander in Babylon, even though at the time of death of Kalanos, Alexander did not have any plans to go to Babylon.^{[40] [41]}

A drinking contest was held in response to his death. According to Plutarch, citing Chares of Mytilene, Promachus of Macedon drank the equivalent of 13 litres of unmixed wine and won the first prize of a golden crown worth a talent. He died three days later and forty-one other contestants allegedly died of alcohol poisoning as well.^[42]

Legacy

A letter written by Kalanos to Alexander is preserved by Philo.^[43]

A painting by Jean Baptiste de Champaigne depicts "Alexander the Great receiving the news of the death by immolation of the gymnosophist Calanus" is displayed at Chateau de Versailles et de Trianon, Versailles.^[44]

See also

• Peregrinus Proteus
• Zarmanochegas

Notes and References

1. https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg047.perseus-grc1:8 Plutarch, Life of Alexander, §8
2. Book: Wheeler . James Talboys . The History of India: India from the earliest ages: Hindu, Buddhist, and Brahmanical revival . 1973 . Cosmo Publications . 171–72 . 23 July 2019 . en.
3. Book: Hunter . William Wilson . The Imperial Gazetteer of India . 1887 . Trübner & Company . 173 . 23 July 2019 . en.
4. Book: Classica Et Mediaevalia . 1975 . Librairie Gyldendal . 271–76 . 23 July 2019 . en.
5. Book: Lucian (of Samosata.) . Lucian: Selected Dialogues . Costa . C. D. N. . December 2005. OUP Oxford . 978-0-19-925867-3 . 258 . en.
6. Book: Aelian . 1997 . Harvard University Press . 978-0-674-99535-2 . 113 . en.
7. Book: Turley . Jeffrey Scott . The Commentaries of D. García de Silva y Figueroa on his Embassy to Shāh ʿAbbās I of Persia on Behalf of Philip III, King of Spain . Souza . George Bryan . 2017-06-06 . BRILL . 978-90-04-34632-1 . 226 . en.
8. Book: Honigman . Sylvie . Times of Transition: Judea in the Early Hellenistic Period . Nihan . Christophe . Lipschits . Oded . 2021-06-30 . Penn State Press . 978-1-64602-145-1 . 264 . en.
9. Book: Vasunia, Phiroze . The Classics and Colonial India . 2013-05-16 . OUP Oxford . 978-0-19-920323-9 . 61 . en.
10. Book: Worthington, Ian . Alexander the Great: Man and God . 2014-07-10 . Routledge . 978-1-317-86644-2 . en.
11. Book: Overtoom, Nikolaus Leo . Reign of Arrows: The Rise of the Parthian Empire in the Hellenistic Middle East . 2020-05-11 . Oxford University Press . 978-0-19-088834-3 . 71 . en.
12. Book: Brill's Companion to the Reception of Alexander the Great . 2018-09-11 . BRILL . 978-90-04-35993-2 . 632 . en.
13. Book: Athenaeus (Mechanicus.) . On Machines: (Περὶ Μηχανημάτων) . 2004 . Franz Steiner Verlag . 978-3-515-08532-8 . en.
14. Book: Athenaeus (Mechanicus.) . On Machines: (Περὶ Μηχανημάτων) . 2004 . Franz Steiner Verlag . 978-3-515-08532-8 . 70 . en.
15. Halkias. Georgios. The Self-immolation of Kalanos and other Luminous Encounters Among Greeks and Indian Buddhists in the Hellenistic World. Journal of the Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies. 2015. 8. 163–186. 30 May 2015.
16. https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0060.tlg001.perseus-grc3:17.107 Diodorus Siculus, Library, 17.107.1
17. Book: Bar-Kochva, Bezalel . The image of the Jews in Greek literature : the Hellenistic Period . 2010 . University of California Press . Berkeley . 9780520253360. 60–63 .
18. Book: Stoneman . Richard . The Legends of Alexander the Great . 2012 . 43–47 . Bloomsbury Academic . 9781848857858 .
19. Book: M'Crindle, J.W. . The invasion of India by Alexander the Great . 2004 . Kessinger Pub. . . 9780766189201 . 46, 315, 388–9, 346 .
20. Book: Enemies of the Roman order: treason, unrest, and alienation in the empire By Ramsay MacMullen . 1992 . 317 . 9780415086219 . MacMullen . Ramsay . Routledge .
21. Book: Yādnāmah-ʾi Panjumīn Kungrih-ʾi Bayn al-Milalī-i Bāstānshināsī va Hunar-i Īrān . 1972 . Ministry of Culture and Arts, Iran. Vizārat-i Farhang va Hunar . 224 .
22. Book: Chatterjee, Suhas . Indian civilization and culture . 1998 . M.D. Publications . New Delhi . 9788175330832 . 129 .
23. Book: Sastri, Kallidaikurichi Aiyah Nilakanta . Age of the Nandas and Mauryas . 1988 . Motilal Banarsidass . Delhi . 9788120804654 . 105–106 .
24. Powers . Nathan . 1998 . Onesicritus, Naked Wise Men, and the Cynics' Alexander . Syllecta Classica . 9 . 1 . 73 . 10.1353/syl.1998.0001 . 2160-5157.
25. Book: Bronkhorst, Johannes . How the Brahmins won: from Alexander to the Guptas . 2016 . Brill . 978-90-04-31519-8 . Handbook of oriental studies . Leiden . 34–35.
26. Book: Plutarch . The Lives of the Noble Grecians and Romans . 1998 . The Modern Library (Random House Inc) . New York . 9781853267949 . 847.
27. Book: Williams Jackson, A.V. . History of India Vol. IX . 2009 . Cosimo Inc. . New York . 9781605205328 . 65–70 .
28. Book: Niehoff, Maren R. . Philo on Jewish identity and culture . 2001 . Mohr Siebeck . Tübingen . 9783161476112 . 153–154 .
29. Book: Alexander the Great . 1973 . Robin Lax Fox . 416 . 9780713905007 .
30. Book: The Sháhnáma of Firdausí By Arthur George Warner, Edmond Warner . 2001 . 61 . 9780415245432 . Warner . Arthur George . Warner . Edmond . Psychology Press .
31. Book: The calcutta review. 1867. 400. 5 March 2017.
32. Book: The Cyclopædia of India and of Eastern and Southern Asia ..., Volume 1 By Edward Balfour. 1885. 434. 5 March 2017. Balfour. Edward.
33. Book: Hunter, W.W. . The Indian empire : its people, history, and products (1886) . 2005 . Asian Educational Services . New Delhi . 9788120615816 . 169 .
34. Book: Sagar, Krishna Chandra . Foreign influence on ancient India . 1992 . Northern Book Centre . New Delhi . 9788172110284 . 69 .
35. Book: Defending the West: a critique of Edward Said's Orientalism Front Cover by Ibn Warraq . 2007 . Prometheus Books . 108 . 9781591024842 .
36. Book: The Cambridge History of Hellenistic Philosophy edited by Keimpe Algra . 1999 . 243 . 9780521250283 . Algra . Keimpe . Barnes . Jonathan . Jaap Mansfeld. Mansfeld . Jaap . Schofield . Malcolm .
37. Book: Elledge, C. D. . Life after death in early Judaism the evidence of Josephus . 2006 . Mohr Siebeck . Tübingen . 9783161488757 . 121–124 .
38. Book: Borruso, Silvano . History of Philosophy . 2007 . Paulines Publications Africa . 9789966082008 . 50.
39. Book: National Geographic, Volume 133 . 1968 . 64 .
40. Book: National Geographic, Volume 133 . 1968 . 64 .
41. Book: The philosophical books of Cicero . 1989 . Duckworth . 186 . 9780715622148 .
42. Web site: Plutach . The Parallel Lives: The Life of Alexander . 4 March 2022 . 7, 70.
43. Book: Sullivan, Denis F. . Siegecraft : two tenth-century instructional manuals by "Heron of Byzantium". 2000 . Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and Collection . Washington, D.C. . 9780884022701. 168 .
44. Book: Exploring cultural history : essays in honour of Peter Burke . 2010 . Ashgate . Farnham, Surrey, England . 9780754667506 . 259 . Melissa Calaresu . Filippo de Vivo . Joan-Pau Rubiés .