| Butterfly | |
| Director: | Matt Cimber |
| Producer: | Matt Cimber |
| Based On: | The Butterfly by James M. Cain |
| Starring: | Stacy Keach Orson Welles Lois Nettleton Edward Albert Stuart Whitman James Franciscus Pia Zadora |
| Music: | Ennio Morricone |
| Cinematography: | Eduard van der Enden |
| Editing: | Thierry J. Couturier Brent Schoenfeld Stan Siegel |
| Studio: | Par-Par Productions |
| Distributor: | Analysis Releasing |
| Runtime: | 108 minutes |
| Country: | United States |
| Language: | English |
| Budget: | $3.5 million[1] |
Butterfly is a 1982 American independent crime drama film co-written and directed by Matt Cimber, based on the 1947 novel The Butterfly by James M. Cain. The starring cast includes Stacy Keach, Pia Zadora, Lois Nettleton, Ed McMahon, James Franciscus, Edward Albert, and Orson Welles. The original music score was composed by Ennio Morricone. Financed by Zadora's husband, Israeli multimillionaire Meshulam Riklis, at an estimated cost of US$3.5 million,[2] the plot follows a silver mine caretaker who is reunited with his estranged teenage daughter who wants to take silver from the mine.
In 1937, in a small mining town on the Nevada–Arizona border, Jess Tyler is the caretaker of an unused silver mine. His wife, Belle Morgan, deserted him 10 years earlier and took their daughters, Janey and Kady, when she ran off with another man, Moke Blue. Seventeen year old Kady shows up at Jess's place, telling him her mother Belle is running a brothel, and one of the clients got Kady pregnant with a son, Danny. Danny's father is Wash Gillespie, son of the wealthy mine owner, who refused to marry her. Kady is money-hungry and has returned home to steal silver from the mine. Jess, initially opposed to stealing silver from the mine, relents and says they can take small scraps after she seduces him. They work in the mine together; afterwards, while Kady takes a bath, Jess ends up giving her a massage but stops short of having sex.
Soon after, Wash comes to town and proposes to Kady, and she accepts. Belle, suffering from severe tuberculosis, arrives with Blue and a mutual friend, Ed Lamey, ostensibly to celebrate the engagement. Blue insinuates that he knows about the theft, and while the others are out of the house, Belle stabs him with a hat pin, and he kills her in self-defence.
Jess realizes that Ed must have witnessed the theft and told Blue. Jess rushes to the mine, where Blue is frantically pillaging for silver and taunts him. Jess sees a "butterfly" birthmark near his navel, similar to one on baby Danny, and believes that Blue is Danny's father. Enraged, Jess shoots him. Before Jess leaves him to die, Blue reveals that Kady is his daughter.
Returning to the Gillespies, Jess lies and tells them that Danny is Blue's son. Wash decides to break off the engagement, but Jess stops him from talking to Kady about it himself. When Wash fails to arrive on the day of the wedding, she despondently resorts to her original plan to steal the silver. She goes to the mine with Jess, where the two have sex while Ed looks on. The police arrive with warrants for the arrests of Jess and Kady, and they are charged with incest.
At the hearing, Judge Rauch calls it "a crime against nature, shocking and repulsive to every basic sense of propriety, decency, and good citizenship." Jess pleads guilty, saying he forced her, so that Kady will not be punished. Jess is sentenced to ten years in prison, and Kady objects, saying that their relationship was consensual. The judge threatens her with reform school, ten years in prison, and Danny becoming a ward of the state. Jess reveals that Moke Blue is Kady's real father and the proof is the birthmark. Ed then reveals he is Moke Blue's half-brother and has the same birthmark and did not tell her because of the silver. The case is dismissed.
Wash is waiting outside the courthouse for Kady, who realizes what Jess did and is angry, but quickly forgives him. She says she loves him, but differently from how she loves Wash. She chooses Wash because of the life he can provide for Danny.
As of 2022, the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes holds a "Rotten" approval rating of 40% based on 5 reviews.[3]
The film received ten nominations for the 3rd Golden Raspberry Awards (including Worst Picture), with Zadora winning Worst Actress and Worst New Star, and McMahon winning Worst Supporting Actor. Nevertheless, Zadora won Best Female Newcomer at the 39th Golden Globe Awards for her role (over Elizabeth McGovern and Kathleen Turner). This occurred after her husband flew members of the Hollywood Foreign Press Association to Las Vegas to hear Zadora sing, producing accusations that the award had been "bought".[4] Welles' portrayal of Judge Rauch was nominated for both supporting actor categories at the Golden Globes and at the Razzies.
| Award | Category | Recipients | Result | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Golden Globe Awards | Best Supporting Actor – Motion Picture | Orson Welles | [5] | |
| Best Original Song – Motion Picture | "It's Wrong for Me to Love You" Music by Ennio Morricone; Lyrics by Carol Connors | |||
| New Star of the Year – Actress | Pia Zadora | |||
| Golden Raspberry Awards | Worst Picture | Matt Cimber | [6] | |
| Worst Director | ||||
| Worst Actress | Pia Zadora | |||
| Worst Supporting Actor | Ed McMahon | |||
| Orson Welles | ||||
| Worst Supporting Actress | Lois Nettleton | |||
| Worst Screenplay | Screenplay by John F. Goff and Matt Cimber; Adapted for the Screen by Matt Cimber; Based on the novel by James M. Cain | |||
| Worst Musical Score | Ennio Morricone | |||
| Worst Original Song | "It's Wrong for Me to Love You" Music by Ennio Morricone; Lyrics by Carol Connors | |||
| Worst New Star | Pia Zadora |