| Butler Lake | |
| Pushpin Map: | New York |
| Pushpin Map Caption: | Location of Butler Lake within New York |
| Location: | Herkimer County, New York |
| Coords: | 43.3667°N -75.9121°W |
| Area: | 11acres |
| Elevation: | [1] |
| Cities: | Wilmurt |
Butler Lake is a small lake south of Wilmurt in Herkimer County, New York. It drains north via an unnamed creek that flows into West Canada Creek. Butler Lake is home to a pair of loons who migrate in each spring to rear their young. The lake is only just large enough as they require a "long runway" of water from which to take off. Atwood Lake is located east of Butler Lake.