Bull Site Explained
Bull Site |
Map Type: | West Bank relief |
Relief: | true |
Map Size: | 200 |
Coordinates: | 32.4092°N 35.3236°W |
Location: | Dhahrat et-Tawileh |
Region: | West Bank |
Type: | Cult installation |
Epochs: | Iron IA |
Length: | 23 metres |
Width: | 21 metres |
Altitude M: | 455 |
Area: | 380 sqr metres |
Material: | Stone, bedrock |
Built: | 12th century BCE |
Abandoned: | 12th century BCE |
Cultures: | Canaanite, Israelite, or migratory population |
Discovered: | 1977 |
Excavations: | Apr 1978, Sept 1981 |
Archaeologists: | Amihai Mazar |
Condition: | In ruins |
The so-called Bull Site is a 12th-century BCE open air ancient cult installation[1] found at Dhahrat et-Tawileh[2] (also spelled Daharat et-Tawileh),[3] in the West Bank. The site is named for the bronze sacred bull statuette which was found at the site in 1977.
Location
The site is located on the Dhahrat et-Tawileh ridge in the hills of the northern West Bank[4] in Jenin Governorate, 75 meters above the ancient road[5] [6] through the Zababdeh valley[7] between Dothan and Tirzah.[8] It lies approximately 6 km south of Jenin, and 4 km east of Qabatiya. The site provides commanding views of other high points in northern Canaan including Mount Carmel to the west, Mount Tabor and Mount Meron to the north, Mount Gilboa to the northeast, and to the south Jebel Tamun[9] (also spelled Jabal Tammun, 'Mount Tammun', some 2 km SSE of the town of Tammun, altitude 588 m, prominence 291 m[10]).
Discovery
The site was discovered in 1977 by Ofer Broshi, a member of Kibbutz Shamir and soldier in the Israeli army, where he unearthed an ancient bull statuette. He brought the figurine back to his kibbutz where it was put on display with other antiquities owned by the kibbutz.[11] [12] While on display it was spotted by archaeologist Amihai Mazar who arranged its transfer to the Israel Museum where it is now part of the permanent collection.[13] Based on Broshi's description Mazar was able to locate the discovery site at Dhahrat et-Tawileh and begin excavations.[14]
Excavation history
Two short excavations were conducted by Mazar in April 1978 and September 1981 on behalf of the Institute of Archaeology at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.[15] Results of the excavation show that the site was single-phase (Iron IA)[16] [17] and was abandoned after only a short period of use.[9] [18] The archaeological evidence indicates the site's use as a cultic installation[19] though the flint and pottery assemblage discovered potentially indicates domestic use.[20] Israel Finkelstein's dating of the site to the Middle Bronze Age[21] is, according to Mazar, based on a misreading of the pottery evidence[22] and as such an early 12th-century dating should be retained.[23]
Cult installation
Though there are a number of Iron Age I settlements in the area,[24] the Bull Site lacks any evidence of settlement. Instead it sits on the summit of Dhahrat et-Tawileh and is thought to have served as a cult site for the surrounding settlements due to its hilltop location.[9] [25]
Built on bedrock in the 12th century, the site comprises a perimeter wall made from large boulders brought in from elsewhere,[26] and what is thought to be a standing stone or altar with a paved area in front of it next to the enclosure's eastern entrance.[27] Mazar, the excavation director, speculates that a sacred tree likely grew within the site's walls.[28] [29]
There is no agreement on the ethnicity of the local settlers who used the site, with suggestions ranging from the Israelites due to the site's location in Mannaseh's tribal allotment (17:1–13 ),[1] [30] [31] the Canaanites,[32] or migrants from north of Canaan.[33]
Alternative views are that the site could have been a home for a family and their animals, or an enclosure for livestock.[32]
Calf statuette
The statuette, found close to the western wall of the site,[34] is of a Zebu bull measuring 17.5 cm long by 12.4 cm high and is made of bronze.[35] It is notable not only for its naturalistic ears and eyes,[35] but for being the largest such bull statuette found in Palestine.[34] Though Mazar suggests it may be the product of a local Israelite craftsman,[25] other scholars such as Ahlström believe it came either from Galilee, or further north again above the land of Canaan.[33]
There is no consensus about which deity the statuette represents;[36] it could be an image of Baal[37] or Yahweh.[38] [39]
See also
Bibliography
- Ahlström . Gösta W. . November 1990 . The Bull Figurine from Dhahrat et-Tawileh . . 280 . 280 . 77–82 . 1357311 . 10.2307/1357311 . 163751741 .
- Book: Alpert Nakhai, Beth . 2001 . Archaeology and the Religions of Canaan and Israel . Boston, MA . American Schools of Oriental Research . 978-0897570572 .
- Bloch-Smith . Elizabeth . Alpert Nakhai . Beth . 1999 . A Landscape Comes to Life . . 62 . 2 . 10.2307/3210703 . 3210703 . 163482783 .
- Coogan . Michael David . Michael Coogan. 1987 . Of Cults and Cultures: Reflections on the Interpretation of Archaeological Evidence . . 119 . 1 . 1–8 . 10.1179/peq.1987.119.1.1 .
- Book: Dorsey, David A. . 1991 . The Roads and Highways of Ancient Israel . The ASOR Library of Biblical and Near Eastern Archaeology . Wipf and Stock . 978-1-5326-6089-4 .
- Book: Faust, Avraham . Avraham Faust. 2006 . Israel's Ethnogenesis: Settlement, Interaction, Expansion and Resistance . London and New York . Routledge . 9781845534561 .
- Finkelstein . Israel. Israel Finkelstein . 1998 . Two notes on Northern Samaria: the 'Einun Pottery' and the date of the 'Bull Site' . Palestine Exploration Quarterly . 130 . 2 . 94–98. 10.1179/peq.1998.130.2.94 .
- Mazar . Amihai . Summer 1982 . The "Bull Site": An Iron Age I Open Cult Place . Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research . 247 . 27–42 . 1356477 . 10.2307/1356477 . 164091738 .
- Mazar . Amihai . September–October 1983 . Bronze Bull Found in Israelite "High Place" from the Time of the Judges . . 9 . 5 . subscription .
- Encyclopedia: Mazar . Amihai . Amihai Mazar. Stern . Ephraim . Ephraim Stern. The New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land . 'Bull' Site . 1993 . Carta . 1 . 0-13-276296-X.
- Mazar . 1999 . The 'Bull Site' and the 'Einun Pottery' Reconsidered . Palestine Exploration Quarterly . 131 . 2 . 144–148 . 10.1179/peq.1999.131.2.144 .
- Book: Miller, Patrick D. . 2000 . Israelite Religion and Biblical Theology: Collected Essays . Journal for the study of the Old Testament Supplement Series . 267 . . 9781841271422 . Patrick D. Miller.
- Book: Miller II, Robert . Lapp . Nancy. Nancy Lapp . Preliminary Excavation Reports and other Archaeological Excavations, Tell Qarqur; Iron I Sites in the North-Central Highlands of Palestine . American Schools of Oriental Research . 2003 . The Annual of The American Schools of Oriental Research . 56 . Gazetteer of Iron I Sites in the North-Central Highlands . Boston, MA . 0-89757-026-X.
- Book: Miller II, Robert D. . 2005 . Chieftains of the Highland Clans: A History of Israel in the Twelfth and Eleventh Centuries B.C. . Grand Rapids, MI; Cambridge, U.K. . . 978-0802809889 .
- Encyclopedia: Mullins . Robert . Encyclopedia of the Bible and Its Reception . The Bull Site . 2012 . De Gruyter . 4 . 978-3110183559.
- Book: Na'aman, Nadav . Finkestein . Israel . Na'aman . Nadav . From Nomadism to Monarchy . . 1994 . The 'Conquest of Canaan' in the Book of Joshua and in History . 965-217-117-4.
- Alpert Nakhai . Beth . 1994 . What's a Bamah? How Sacred Space Functioned in Ancient Israel . Biblical Archaeology Review . 20 . 3 . subscription .
- Book: Parker, Simon B. . 1997 . Ugaritic Narrative Poetry . 9 . SBL Writings from the Ancient World . Atlanta, GA . Scholars Press . 978-0788503375 .
- Book: Smith, Mark S. . Mark S. Smith . 2002 . The Early History of God: Yahweh and the Other Deities in Ancient Israel . Grand Rapids, MI; Cambridge, U.K.; Dearborn, MI . William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company . 9781845534561 .
- Book: Zertal, Adam . Adam Zertal . 2008 . The Manasseh Hill Country Survey, Volume II, The Eastern Valleys and the Fringes of the Desert . Leiden; Boston . . 978-9004163690 .
- Book: Zevit, Ziony . Ziony Zevit . Dever . William. William G. Dever . Gitin . Seymour. Seymour Gitin. Symbiosis, Symbolism, and the Power of the Past: Canaan, Ancient Israel, and Their Neighbors from the Late Bronze Age through Roman Palaestina . . 2003 . False Dichotomies in Descriptions of Israelite Religion: A Problem, Its Origin, and a Proposed Solution . 978-1575060811.
Notes and References
- Bloch-Smith & Alpert Nakhai (1999), p. 76.
- Ahlström (1990)
- Mazar (1982)
- Mazar (1982), pp. 32-33.
- Dorsey (1991), pp. 144-145.
- Miller II (2003), p. 161.
- Zertal (2008), p. 29.
- Alpert Nakhai (2001), p. 170.
- Mazar (1982), p. 33.
- https://peakvisor.com/peak/jabal-tammun.html Jabal Tammun
- Mazar (1982), p. 41.
- Mazar (1983), p. 34.
- Web site: Israel Museum Collection - Bull Statuette. www.imj.org.il.
- Mazar (1983), pp. 34-35.
- Mazar (1993), pp. 266-267.
- Mullins (2012), pp. 590-592.
- Faust (2006), p. 119.
- Ahlström (1990), pp. 80-81.
- Mazar (1983), pp. 35-36.
- Miller II (2005), p. 46.
- Finkelstein (1998), pp. 94-98.
- Na'aman (1994), pp. 167-169.
- Mazar (1999), pp. 144-148.
- Khirbet Abu Ghamam, Khirbet Tanin, Khirbet Anahum, Khirbet esh-Sheik Seffrin, and esh-Zababde. See Mazar (1983), p. 36.
- Mazar (1983), p. 39.
- Zevit (2003), p. 233.
- Mazar (1982), p. 34.
- Mazar (1982), p. 35.
- Mazar (1983), p. 37.
- Mazar (1982), p. 38.
- Alpert Nakhai (1994), pp. 19-29.
- Coogan (1987), p. 1.
- Ahlström (1990), p. 81.
- Ahlström (1990), p. 79.
- Mazar (1982), p. 27.
- Ahlström (1990), p. 80.
- Miller (2000), p. 32.
- Smith (2002), pp. 83-84.
- Bloch-Smith & Alpert Nakhai (1999), pp. 76-77.