| Season: | 4 |
| Episode: | 14 |
| Director: | Jeffrey Lynch |
| Production: | 9F12 |
| Guests: |
|
| Blackboard: | "The Principal's toupee is not a frisbee" |
| Couch Gag: | The rear wall rotates, taking the family to another room and leaving an empty couch behind. |
| Commentary: | Matt Groening Al Jean Mike Reiss Jon Vitti Jeffrey Lynch |
| Prev: | Selma's Choice |
| Next: | I Love Lisa |
"Brother from the Same Planet" is the fourteenth episode of the fourth season of the American animated television series The Simpsons. It first aired on Fox in the United States on February 4, 1993. In the episode, Bart, furious with Homer for taking too long to pick him up from soccer practice on a rainy day, turns to the Bigger Brothers Agency, which pairs up fatherless boys with adult male role models. Meanwhile, Lisa becomes addicted to the Corey hotline, a phone service where television fans can listen to the voice of a teen idol.
The episode was written by Jon Vitti and directed by Jeffrey Lynch. The producers tried to cast Tom Cruise for the role of Tom, but Cruise declined and they chose Phil Hartman instead. "Brother from the Same Planet" received favorable reception in books and in the media; a contemporary review in Entertainment Weekly said it "may be the best Simpsons show ever"[2] and it was named one of the five best episodes of the series by the writers of King of the Hill.
On a rainy day, Bart waits for Homer to pick him up from soccer practice. However, Homer forgets to pick Bart up for many hours; by the time Homer finally picks Bart up, Bart is soaked from the rain. Furious with Homer, Bart goes to the Bigger Brothers Agency, a mentor program which pairs up fatherless boys with positive male role models. Bart claims that his father was an alcoholic gambler who abandoned him (which is true, but Bart exaggerates the details). The receptionist pairs him up with Tom, a handsome military test pilot. Bart and Tom enjoy a variety of activities together, though Bart begins to feel guilty for taking up Tom's time despite not actually being fatherless. Homer finds out about Tom and confronts Bart. Homer decides to get revenge by becoming a Bigger Brother himself. A poor young boy named Pepi comes to the agency and asks if he can have a Bigger Brother. Taking pity on Pepi, Homer decides to become his Bigger Brother.
Meanwhile, Marge discovers that the cost of her family's monthly phone bill is abnormally high. She soon finds out why — Lisa has been making lengthy calls to the Corey hotline, a premium rate phone service where fans can listen to the voice of a teen heartthrob. Lisa promises to stop making calls to the hotline on the family's phone. However, she continues to call the hotline by using phones in Dr. Hibbert's office, the Springfield Retirement Castle, and Springfield Elementary School. After Principal Skinner sees Lisa using the school's phone, he calls a meeting with Lisa and Marge. Marge suggests that Lisa try to go until midnight without calling the hotline; if she can do so, she will have conquered her addiction. Lisa is tempted throughout the rest of the day, but she ultimately beats her addiction.
Some time later, Homer, Pepi, Bart, and Tom attend Bigger Brothers Day at Marine World, where the Bigger Brothers and their boys attend to celebrate. Homer runs into Bart and Tom and reveals to Tom that he is Bart's father. Tom punches Homer, leading to a brawl between the two men. The fight rages across Springfield and ends when Homer lands on a fire hydrant, severely injuring his back. Homer is sent to a hospital on a stretcher. Feeling remorseful, Bart decides to forgive Homer. Tom laments how he will miss being a Bigger Brother, while Pepi is sad over losing his Bigger Brother. Bart suggests Tom become Pepi's big brother; they happily agree and walk into the sunset holding hands. After Homer recovers, Bart asks Homer to teach him how to fight.
The episode was written by Jon Vitti and directed by Jeffrey Lynch. It originally aired in the United States on February 4, 1993, on Fox. The role of Tom was written for Tom Cruise. However, when offered the part, Cruise repeatedly turned it down, so the producers used Phil Hartman.[3] Corey is a composite of Corey Feldman and Corey Haim, known as The Two Coreys.[4] Pepi was based on the title character of the daily comic strip Dondi.[4]
Bart and Tom watch The Ren & Stimpy Show. The producers contacted Nickelodeon to get authorization to use the two characters for that sequence.[4] Nickelodeon was strict about what The Simpsons was allowed to do, and the producers were not allowed to have the savageness that they wanted.[4] The Ren & Stimpy Show's animators offered to do the layouts of Ren and Stimpy for the episode.[5] The show Bart watches, Tuesday Night Live, is a parody of NBC's Saturday Night Live. Krusty appears in a sketch called "The Big Ear Family", and says that the sketch goes on for twelve more minutes, even though the joke's punchline has already been established.[5] That was Vitti's way of criticizing Saturday Night Live for having overlong sketches with thin joke premises.[5] The sequence originally had a longer version of the Tuesday Night Live band playing into the commercial break, but it was cut because Vitti, who was a writer on Saturday Night Live during the 1985–86 season along with fellow Simpsons writers George Meyer and John Swartzwelder, did not want to come off as being bitter.[5]
The writers were looking for an ending, and executive producer Sam Simon suggested they watch The Quiet Man. The writers came in on a Saturday to watch it, and were inspired by the fight scene between John Wayne and Victor McLaglen to do a fight scene between Homer and Tom.[5] The scene was difficult for the producers to sound-mix because they wanted it to be funny but not horrifying. They discovered that the more realistic the effects used sounded, the funnier the scene became.[6] The producers tried all sorts of different sounds for when Homer cracks his back on the fire hydrant and chose the tiniest realistic sound, because they believed that it was the most painful and "hilarious".[6]
The title of the episode is a reference to The Brother from Another Planet (1984).[7] Milhouse and two other kids say they're going to sneak into an R-Rated movie, chanting "Barton Fink!" The scene where Milhouse writes "Trab pu kcip!" on the wall is a reference to Stanley Kubrick's The Shining (1980).[8] [9] The woman Bart mistakes for Homer is singing the Helen Reddy song "I Am Woman". While Bart is stuck in the storm waiting for Homer, a nun is lifted by the wind, a reference to the TV series The Flying Nun, and explodes. Bart and Tom watch The Ren & Stimpy Show. When Homer watches TV, the announcer says "Tonight, on Wings" before trailing off: "...ah, who cares." He also watches an NFL Films production about Bart Starr, the quarterback on the Green Bay Packers who led the team to victory in the first two Super Bowls.
Marge tells Lisa that, as a girl, she had a crush on Bobby Sherman, to Lisa's amusement. The scene where Homer accuses Bart of seeing his big brother is a reference to Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? (1966), where Richard Burton accuses Elizabeth Taylor of adultery. In the story Homer tells Pepi, Bart tells Homer to shut up and shoves half a grapefruit in his face, a reference to James Cagney in The Public Enemy (1931). Bart watches Tuesday Night Live, a parody of NBC's Saturday Night Live. During the fight scene between Homer and Tom, the background music is a parody of the music used in the fight scene in The Quiet Man (1952), and the fighting pose Tom makes is a parody of the Street Fighter II introduction sequence. Skinner's disturbing monologue about his mother watching him is a parody of Norman Bates' similar dialogue from Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho (1960).[10]
In its original broadcast, "Brother from the Same Planet" finished 18th in ratings for the week of February 1–7, 1993, with a Nielsen rating of 14.9, equivalent to approximately 13.9 million viewing households. It was the highest-rated show on the Fox network that week, beating Martin.[11]
In their section on the episode in the book I Can't Believe It's a Bigger and Better Updated Unofficial Simpsons Guide, Warren Martyn and Adrian Wood comment: "We love Homer sitting at home trying to remember to pick up Bart—he's watching a TV show about a football star called Bart, with pictures of Bart on all sides, and even Maggie seems to be calling her brother's name."[12] Writing in the compilation work The Psychology of The Simpsons, Robert M. Arkin and Philip J. Mazzocco reference a scene from the episode where Homer "argues with his own brain about a desired course of action" to illustrate self-discrepancy theory, the idea that "humans will go to great lengths to attain and preserve self-esteem".[13]
The writers of King of the Hill named "Brother from the Same Planet" as one the five best episodes of The Simpsons, along with "Homer the Heretic", "Lisa's Wedding", "Lisa's Substitute", and "Behind the Laughter".[14] Mikey Cahill of the Herald Sun highlighted the quote "PickupBart? What the hell is PickupBart?" by Homer in his list of "Fab Fives" related to The Simpsons.[15] When asked to pick his favorite season out of The Simpsons seasons one through twenty, Paul Lane of the Niagara Gazette picked season four and highlighted "Brother from the Same Planet" and "Mr. Plow" which he called "excellent", along with "the sweetly funny" "Lisa's First Word", and "Homer the Heretic".[16] In a review of The Simpsons season four, Lyndsey Shinoda of Video Store cited "Brother from the Same Planet" and "I Love Lisa" among her "personal favorites" from the season.[17]
Reviewing season four in Entertainment Weekly, Ken Tucker called the episode "a masterpiece of tiny, throwaway details that accumulate into a worldview. When Bart and his Bigger Brother, Tom, go to a baseball game, for example, it’s Tomato Day at the stadium; the pregame festivities include a speech by 'the recruiter for the Springfield Communist Party,' a grizzled old man who gets booed and pelted with red, rotting fruit before he opens his mouth.
A subplot involves Lisa’s crush on a vapid teen idol named Corey, and her uncontrollable urge to call a 900 number (only '$4.95 a minute') that features taped messages of Corey reciting things like 'words that rhyme with Corey' ('Um, story… allegory… Montessori'). How did Lisa learn about Corey and his money-leeching phone service? We notice that her bedroom contains a copy of Non-Threatening Boys magazine.
Groening’s writers tend to make their sharpest points quickly, matter-of-factly... Earlier, Bart’s schoolteacher Mrs. Krabappel (her nicely sour voice supplied by Marcia Wallace of the ’70s sitcom The Bob Newhart Show) thanked our little antihero for bringing in a deadly looking, U.S. Navy-made 'neural-disrupter' gun for show-and-tell. 'Don’t thank me,' says Bart briskly, 'thank an unprecedented eight-year military buildup.'”[2]