Brooks Brothers riot explained

Duration:	November 22, 2000
Location:	Miami-Dade County, Florida
Motive:	Disrupt recount of votes in the 2000 United States presidential election
Target:	Officials canvassing the vote
Patrons:	-->
Organizers:	-->
Outcome:	Election of George W. Bush
Blank Data:	-->
Blank1 Data:	-->
Blank2 Data:	-->

The Brooks Brothers riot was a demonstration led by Republican staffers at a meeting of election canvassers in Miami-Dade County, Florida, on November 22, 2000, during a recount of votes made during the 2000 United States presidential election, with the goal of shutting down the recount. After demonstrations and acts of violence, local officials shut down the recount early.

The name referenced the protesters' corporate attire; described by Paul Gigot in an editorial for The Wall Street Journal as "50-year-old white lawyers with cell phones and Hermès ties", differentiating them from local citizens concerned about vote counting. Many of the demonstrators were Republican staffers.^[1] Both Roger Stone and Brad Blakeman take credit for managing the riot from a command post, although their accounts contradict each other. Republican New York Representative John E. Sweeney gave the signal that started the riot,^[2] telling an aide to "shut it down".^[3]

Background

In the 2000 United States presidential election between candidates George W. Bush and Al Gore, in the state of Florida, George W. Bush achieved an election night majority by 1,784 votes, a very close margin. Due to the closeness of the race, and irregularities such as hanging chads, the Gore campaign successfully advocated for a recount of certain ballots. Miami-Dade County was one of the counties where ballots were recounted.

The Miami-Dade County Democratic Party chairman suspected that thousands of ballots in this county might have been affected by a voting machine glitch.^[4] He suspected that these ballots, after re-tallying, would help candidate Al Gore. Miami-Dade County official canvassers, in order to meet a court-ordered deadline, decided to limit the county's recount to the 10,750 ballots that their tabulation machines had been unable to tally. They moved the counting process to a smaller room, closer to the ballot-scanning equipment, to speed up the process, at a distance from the media. Republican officials objected to this change.

Demonstration

Hundreds of people, including many Republican staffers,^[2] descended upon South Florida to protest the state's recounts.^[5] The demonstration was organized by these operatives, sometimes referred to as the "Brooks Brothers Brigade",^[6] to oppose the recount of ballots during the Florida election recount. The official canvassers, to speed up the process and meet their deadline, moved the counting process into a new room, and members of the media were restricted to a distance of 25 feet away.

Republicans objected to this change of plans. John E. Sweeney of New York, nicknamed "Congressman Kick-Ass" by President Bush for his work in Florida,^[7] set the incident in motion^[8] by telling an aide to 'stop them'^{[9] [3]} and to "Shut it down."^[3] The demonstration turned violent and, according to The New York Times, "several people were trampled, punched or kicked when protesters tried to rush the doors outside the office of the Miami-Dade supervisor of elections. Sheriff's deputies restored order." Democratic National Committee aide Luis Rosero claimed to be kicked and punched outside of Leahy's office.^[10] Within two hours after the event, the canvassing board unanimously voted to shut down the count, in part due to perceptions that the process was not open or fair, and in part because the court-mandated deadline had become impossible to meet, due to the interference.^[11]

Sweeney defended his actions, arguing that his aim was not to stop the hand recount, but to restore the process to public view.^[2] Other Bush supporters acknowledged they hoped to end the recount. "We were trying to stop the recount; Bush had already won," said Evilio Cepero, a reporter for WAQI, an influential Spanish talk radio station in Miami. "We were urging people to come downtown and support and protest this injustice." A Republican lawyer commented, "People were pounding on the doors, but they had an absolute right to get in." The protest interfered with attendance by official observers and hindered access by members of the press.^[12] In a radio interview in Albany on November 28, Sweeney said, "What I essentially told my people is, 'You've got to stop them'." "Whether I said, 'You've got to shut it down' or 'stop them,' I frankly don't quite recall."^[2]

Several of the protestors were identified as Republican congressional staffers.^[2] A number of the demonstrators later took jobs in the incoming Bush administration.

Participants

A partial list:^[13]

• Brad Blakeman, Republican strategist.
• Chuck Royal, legislative assistant to Sen. Jim DeMint (R-S.C.)^[14]
• Duane Gibson, a Don Young aide on the House Resources Committee who worked for Ted Stevens, then became a lobbyist associated with Jack Abramoff^[15]
• Garry Malphrus, who became deputy director of the White House Domestic Policy Council during the Bush administration
• Joel Kaplan, who became a policy advisor in the Bush administration, and later Vice President of U.S. Public Policy for Facebook, Inc^{[16] [17]}
• Kevin Smith, a former GOP House aide
• Layna McConkey Peltier, a former Senate and House aide^[18]
• Marjorie Strayer, an aide to New Mexico's Republican congresswoman, Heather Wilson.^[5]
• Matt Schlapp, a former Rep. Todd Tiahrt (R-KS) House aide, becoming the White House political director during the Bush administration, and director of the American Conservative Union in 2014.^[19]
• Roger Morse, a former House aide who became a lobbyist
• Roger Stone,^[20] a self-described "GOP Hitman"^[21] and former member of Nixon's Committee for the Re-Election of the President
• Rory Cooper, a former staffer for the National Republican Congressional Committee and later the White House Homeland Security Council
• Steven Brophy, a former GOP Senate aide to Senators Fred Thompson, Bill Frist, and in 2003, Representative Marsha Blackburn, and later became V.P. at Dollar General^[22]
• Tom Pyle, a former Tom DeLay (R-Tex.) staffer who later worked for Koch Industries

Legacy

According to conversations leaked to The Washington Post by journalist and liberal activist Sarah Ashton-Cirillo—who had worked for the Nevada Republican Party leading up to and through the November 2020 election under an assumed hard-right, Trumpist persona—a vice president at consultancy McShane LLC claimed that Republican congressman Paul Gosar was planning a "Brooks Brothers Riot" in Arizona to disrupt the counting of votes in the 2020 United States presidential election, and told Ashton-Cirillo to "get the Proud Boys out" for a similar event in Clark County, Nevada. Gosar denies having discussed any protests with the McShane vice president.^[23]

See also

• 2002 New Hampshire Senate election phone jamming scandal
• Ballot Security Task Force, a controversial group founded in 1981 by the Republican National Committee and accused of intimidating voters and discouraging voter turnout among likely Democratic voters in New Jersey.
• Bush v. Gore, the 2000 Supreme Court decision deciding the fate of the 2000 United States presidential election.
  • • Republican efforts to restrict voting following the 2020 presidential election

Notes and References

1. News: Miller. Michael E.. 2018-11-15. 'It's insanity!': How the 'Brooks Brothers Riot' killed the 2000 recount in Miami. Washington Post.
2. https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2000/11/sweeney-and-the-siege-of-miami.html "Sweeney and the Siege of Miami"
3. Dana Canedy, Dexter Filkins (November 23, 2000), "Counting the Vote: Miami-Dade County; A Wild Day in Miami, With an End to Recounting, and Democrats' Going to Court", The New York Times
4. News: 'It's insanity!': How the 'Brooks Brothers Riot' killed the 2000 recount in Miami. The Washington Post. The county’s Democratic Party chairman was worried that thousands of Miami-Dade ballots might have been affected by a voting machine glitch, potentially costing Gore the election.. October 28, 2020. October 29, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20201029080956/https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2018/11/15/its-insanity-how-brooks-brothers-riot-killed-recount-miami/. live.
5. http://content.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,89450,00.html "Mob Scene in Miami"
6. Pullizi, Henry J (August 4, 2009), "White House Brushes Off Health-Care Protests", The Wall Street Journal.
7. Staba, David (August 22, 2006), "Race Profile: The 20th District in New York", The New York Times,
8. Lantigua, John (November 28, 2000): Miami's rent-a-riot, Salon, Politics
9. News: Gigot . Paul A. . Miami Heat: A burgher rebellion in Dade County . The Wall Street Journal . November 24, 2000 . https://web.archive.org/web/20060216081537/http://opinionjournal.com/columnists/pgigot/?id=65000673 . February 16, 2006.
10. Dexter Filkins and Dana Canedy. "Protest Influenced Miami-Dade's Decision to Stop Recount", The New York Times, November 24, 2008
11. Web site: "Right-Wingers Praise Antics of Bush Thugs". New York Observer. December 3, 2000. https://web.archive.org/web/20081013001410/http://www.observer.com/node/43708. October 13, 2008.
12. News: Miami Mayor Denies Gore Urged Him to Publicly Support Recount. Clary. Mike. 2000-12-02. Los Angeles Times. 2016-03-15. December 16, 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20231216173611/https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2000-dec-02-mn-60122-story.html. live.
13. News: Kamen. Al. Miami 'Riot' Squad: Where Are They Now?. The Washington Post. January 24, 2005. https://web.archive.org/web/20080724155012/https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A31074-2005Jan23.html. 2008-07-24.
14. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2005/01/24/miami-riot-squad-where-are-they-now/8c5457b9-ebf5-4a4a-937a-68b07c5e6334/ Miami 'Riot' Squad: Where Are They Now?
15. https://www.huffingtonpost.com/shannyn-moore/artificial-protestors-are_b_254276.html Manufactured Protesters Are Killing Democracy
16. News: Rood. Justin. April 19, 2006. New WH Policy Chief Was "Brooks Brothers" Rioter. Talking Points Memo. March 28, 2019. March 28, 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20190328230017/https://talkingpointsmemo.com/muckraker/img-src-images-joelkaplan-jpg-hspace-5-vspace-5-align-left-new-wh-policy-chief-was-brooks-brothers-rioter. live.
17. Web site: Gold. Ashley. 27 March 2019. The People With Power on Facebook's Policy and Communications Team. The Information.
18. http://www.rollcall.com/news/-200577-1.htm Heard on the Hill: Still a Riot, 10 Years Later
19. https://www.politico.com/story/2014/06/matt-schlapp-american-conservative-union-108064 Matt Schlapp elected ACU chairman
20. Web site: Reinhard. Beth. May 17, 2008. Bush strategist shares insight on '00 recount. Miami Herald. July 24, 2011. March 29, 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20190329025141/http://stonezone.com/article.php?id=28. dead.
21. Web site: Sarlin. Benjamin. Nov 20, 2008. A GOP Dirty Trickster Has Second Thoughts. The Daily Beast. July 24, 2011. May 20, 2011. https://web.archive.org/web/20110520223903/http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2008-11-20/a-gop-dirty-trickster-has-second-thoughts/. live.
22. http://www.williamsonherald.com/news/article_5154776f-3760-5ee6-bb2d-4426c5711ddc.html Steve Brophy honored by Tennessee National Guard
23. News: Scherer . Michael . 2021-06-02 . To build a crowd for a pro-Trump rally, Nevada GOP consultant sought help from Proud Boys . . live . 9 August 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220419164554/https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/proud-boys-nevada-republican/2021/06/01/60da2a58-be5f-11eb-b26e-53663e6be6ff_story.html . 19 April 2022 . 0190-8286 . 1330888409 . Michael Scherer.