Anthropodermic bibliopegy explained

Anthropodermic bibliopegy is the practice of binding books in human skin., The Anthropodermic Book Project has examined 31 out of 50 books^[1] in public institutions supposed to have anthropodermic bindings, of which 18 have been confirmed as human and 13 have been demonstrated to be non-human leather instead.^[2]

Etymology

Bibliopegy is a rare^[3] synonym for 'bookbinding'. It combines the Ancient Greek Greek, Ancient (to 1453);: [[wikt:βιβλίον|βιβλίον]] ("book") and Greek, Ancient (to 1453);: πηγία (from, "to fasten").^[4] The earliest reference in the Oxford English Dictionary dates from 1876; Merriam-Webster gives the date of first use as ^[5] and the OED records an instance of 'bibliopegist' for a bookbinder from 1824.

Anthropodermic, combining the Ancient Greek Greek, Ancient (to 1453);: [[wikt:ἄνθρωπος|ἄνθρωπος]] ("man" or "human") and Greek, Ancient (to 1453);: [[wikt:δέρμα|δέρμα]] ("skin"), does not appear in the Oxford English Dictionary and seems to be unused in contexts other than bookbinding. The phrase "anthropodermic bibliopegy" has been used at least since Lawrence S. Thompson's article on the subject, published in 1946. The practice of binding a book in the skin of its author – as with The Highwayman – has been called 'autoanthropodermic bibliopegy' (from Greek, Ancient (to 1453);: [[wikt:αὐτός|αὐτός]],, meaning "self").

History

An early reference to a book bound in human skin is found in the travels of Zacharias Conrad von Uffenbach. Writing about his visit to Bremen in 1710:

During the French Revolution, there were rumours that a tannery for human skin had been established at Meudon outside Paris.^[6] The Carnavalet Museum owns a volume containing the French Constitution of 1793 and Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen described as "passing for being made in human skin imitating calf".^[6]

The majority of well-attested anthropodermic bindings date from the 19th century.

Examples

Criminals

Surviving examples of human skin bindings have often been commissioned, performed, or collected by medical doctors, who have access to cadavers, sometimes those of executed criminals, such as the case of John Horwood in 1821 and William Corder in 1828.^[7] The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh preserves a notebook bound in the skin of the murderer William Burke after his execution and subsequent public dissection by Professor Alexander Monro in 1829.^[8]

What Lawrence Thompson called "the most famous of all anthropodermic bindings" is exhibited at the Boston Athenaeum, titled The Highwayman: Narrative of the Life of James Allen alias George Walton. It is by James Allen, who made his deathbed confession in prison in 1837 and asked for a copy bound in his own skin to be presented to a man he once tried to rob and admired for his bravery, and another one for his doctor.^[9] Once he died, a piece of his back was taken to a tannery and utilized for the book.^[10]

Dance of Death

An exhibition of fine bindings at the Grolier Club in 1903 included, in a section of 'Bindings in Curious Materials', three editions of Holbein's 'Dance of Death' in 19th-century human skin bindings;^[11] two of these belong to the John Hay Library at Brown University. Other examples of the Dance of Death include an 1856 edition offered at auction by Leonard Smithers in 1895^[12] and an 1842 edition from the personal library of Florin Abelès was offered at auction by Piasa of Paris in 2006. Bookbinder Edward Hertzberg describes the Monastery Hill Bindery having been approached by "[a]n Army Surgeon ... with a copy of Holbein's Dance of Death with the request that we bind it in a piece of human skin, which he brought along."^[13]

Other examples

Another tradition, with less supporting evidence, is that books of erotica^[14] have been bound in human skin.

A female admirer of the French astronomer Camille Flammarion supposedly bequeathed her skin to bind one of his books. At Flammarion's observatory, there is a copy of his French: La pluralité des mondes habités on which is stamped French: reliure en peau humaine 1880 ("human skin binding, 1880").^[15] This story is sometimes told instead about French: Les terres du ciel and the donor named as the Comtesse de Saint-Ange.The Newberry Library in Chicago owns an Arabic manuscript written in 1848, with a handwritten note that it is bound in human skin, though "it is the opinion of the conservation staff that the binding material is not human skin, but rather highly burnished goat". This book is mentioned in the novel The Time Traveler's Wife, much of which is set in the Newberry.^[16]

The National Library of Australia holds a 19th-century poetry book with the inscription "Bound in human skin" on the first page.^[17] The binding was performed 'before 1890' and identified as human skin by pathologists in 1992.

A portion of the binding in the copy of Dale Carnegie's Lincoln the Unknown that is part of Temple University's Charles L. Blockson Collection was "taken from the skin of a Negro at a Baltimore Hospital and tanned by the Jewell Belting Company".^[18]

Identification

The identification of human skin bindings has been attempted by examining the pattern of hair follicles, to distinguish human skin from that of other animals typically used for bookbinding, such as calf, sheep, goat, and pig. This is a necessarily subjective test, made harder by the distortions in the process of treating leather for binding. Testing a DNA sample is possible in principle, but DNA can be destroyed when skin is tanned, degrades over time, and can be contaminated by human readers.^[19]

Instead, peptide mass fingerprinting (PMF) and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) have recently been used to identify the material of bookbindings. A tiny sample is extracted from the book's covering and the collagen analysed by mass spectrometry to identify the variety of proteins which are characteristic of different species. PMF can identify skin as belonging to a primate; since monkeys were almost never used as a source of skin for bindings, this implies human skin.

The Historical Medical Library of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia owns five anthropodermic books, confirmed by peptide mass fingerprinting in 2015,^[20] of which three were bound from the skin of one woman.^[21] This makes it the largest collection of such books in one institution. The books can be seen in the associated Mütter Museum.

The John Hay Library at Brown University owns four anthropodermic books, also confirmed by PMF:^[22] Vesalius's De Humani Corporis Fabrica, two nineteenth-century editions of Holbein's Dance of Death, and Mademoiselle Giraud, My Wife (1891).

Three books in the libraries of Harvard University have been reputed to be bound in human skin, but peptide mass fingerprinting has confirmed only one:^[23] French: Des destinées de l'ame by Arsène Houssaye, held in the Houghton Library.^[24] The other two books at Harvard were determined to be bound in sheepskin, the first being Ovid's Metamorphoses,^[25] held in the Countway Library, the second being a treatise on Spanish law, Latin: Practicarum quaestionum circa leges regias Hispaniae,^[26] held in the library of Harvard Law School.^[27] In 2024, Harvard University announced they had removed the human skin from Des destinées de l'ame and were working towards a respectful disposition of the human remains.^[28]

The Harvard skin book belonged to Dr Ludovic Bouland of Strasbourg (died 1932), who rebound a second, Latin: De integritatis & corruptionis virginum notis,^[29] now in the Wellcome Library in London. The Wellcome also owns a notebook labelled as bound in the skin of 'the Negro whose Execution caused the War of Independence', presumably Crispus Attucks, but the library doubts that it is actually human skin.

Ethical and legal issues

Due to containing human remains, books bound in human skin are inherently problematic in relation to issues such as human trophy collecting, the repatriation and reburial of human remains, and the British Human Tissue Act 2004. Librarian Paul Needham is one of the most outspoken advocates against their preservation.^{[30] [31]} In 2024, Harvard University removed the human skin, stolen post mortem off an unidentified female hospital patient, from Des destinées de l'âme due to ethical concerns.^{[32] [33]}

See also

• Dark Archives

Further reading

• The Anthropodermic Book Project
• Jim Chevallier, 'Human Skin: Books (In and On)', Sundries: An Eighteenth Century Newsletter, #26 (April 15, 2006)
• Anita Dalton, Anthropodermic Bibliopegy: A Flay on Words, Odd Things Considered, 9 November 2015
• Gordon . Jacob . In the Flesh? Anthropodermic Bibliopegy Verification and Its Implications . RBM: A Journal of Rare Books, Manuscripts, and Cultural Heritage . 2150-668X . 2016 . 17 . 2 . 118–133 . 10.5860/rbm.17.2.9664 . free .
• Graham . Rigby . Bookbinding with Human Skin . The Private Library . 0032-8898 . 1965 . series 1, 6 . 1 . 14–18 . 2019-02-24 . 2019-02-25 . https://web.archive.org/web/20190225111453/https://www.plabooks.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Journals-vol_6_number_1_863.pdf#page=9 . dead .
• Guelle . Laura Ann . Anthropodermic Book-Bindings . Transactions & Studies of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia . 0010-1087 . December 2002 . series 5, 24 . 85–89 . 12800321 . (discusses John Stockton Hough's books)
• Kerner . Jennifer . Anthropodermic Bibliopegy: an Extensive Survey and Re-appraisal of the Phenomenon . Research Report . Université Paris-Nanterre . 2019 . en.
• Book: Kerner . Jennifer . Reliures de livres avec la peau du condamné : hommage et humiliation autour des corps criminels . Vivas . Mathieu . (Re)lecture archéologique de la justice en Europe médiévale et moderne : actes du colloque international tenu à Bordeaux les 8–10 février 2017 . 2019 . Ausonius . Bordeaux . 978-2-35613-243-7 . 195–211 . fr .
• Marvin . Carolyn . The Body of the Text: Literacy's Corporeal Constant . Quarterly Journal of Speech . May 1994 . 80 . 2 . 129–149 . 10.1080/00335639409384064 . – also available on academia.edu
• Rosenbloom . Megan . A Book by its Cover: Identifying & Scientifically Testing the World's Books Bound in Human Skin . The Watermark: Newsletter of the Archivists and Librarians in the History of the Health Sciences . Summer 2016 . 39 . 3 . 20–22 . 1553-7641 . Rosenbloom2016a. .
• Web site: Rosenbloom . Megan . A Book by Its Cover . Lapham's Quarterly . 24 December 2018 . en . 19 October 2016 . Rosenbloom2016a. .
• Book: Rosenbloom . Megan . Dark Archives: A Librarian's Investigation into the Science and History of Books Bound in Human Skin . 2020 . Farrar, Straus and Giroux . New York . 9780374134709. .
• Samuelson . Todd . Still Life . Printing History: The Journal of the American Printing History Association . 2014 . new series, 16 . 42–50.
• Book: Smith, Daniel K. . Bound In Human Skin: A Survey of Examples of Anthropodermic Bibliopegy. Joanna Ebenstein . . The Morbid Anatomy Anthology. Morbid Anatomy Press. 9780989394307 . Brooklyn, New York. 2014 . First.
• Sorgeloos . Claude . LHistoire de la reliure de Josse Schavye . The History of Bookbinding by Josse Schavye . In Monte Artium . 2012 . 5 . 119–167 . 10.1484/J.IMA.1.103005 . fr . 2507-0312.
• Lawrence S.. Thompson. Lawrence S. Thompson. Tanned Human Skin. Bulletin of the Medical Library Association. April 1946. 34. 2. 93–102. 194573. 16016722.
• Book: Thompson . Lawrence S. . Religatum de Pelle Humana . http://www.historyofscience.com/pdf/Thompson.pdf . Bibliologia Comica, or, Humorous aspects of the caparisoning and conservation of books . 1968 . Archon Books . Hamden (Conn.) . 119–160 . (originally issued separately in 1949 as University of Kentucky Libraries Occasional Contributions no. 6)

To use with caution

• Book: Harrison, Perry Neil . Anthropodermic Bibliopegy in the Early Modern Period . Larissa Tracy . Flaying in the Pre-Modern World : Practice and Representation . 2017 . 366–383 . D.S. Brewer . Woodbridge, Suffolk, UK. 9781843844525 . https://www.academia.edu/16407615. (Read with caution: This work is mostly obsolete. The two examples of allegedly anthropodermic bindings cited by Harrison (Richeome's French: L'Idolatrie Huguenote from University of Memphis and French: L'office de l'Eglise en françois from Berkeley) have since been proven by PMF analysis to be not of human origin. See the Table Supposed examples confirmed as animal skin.)

Notes and References

1. Web site: The Anthropodermic Book Project. The Anthropodermic Book Project. en. 2020-03-27. 2016-03-07. https://web.archive.org/web/20160307164122/http://anthropodermicbooks.org/. live.
2. Megan Rosenbloom clarifies in this interview with Joanna Ebenstein in The Morbid Anatomy Online Journal, 16 April 2020, that these figures do not include books tested from individuals' private collections, as opposed to libraries and museums.
3. Web site: Google Ngram Viewer. books.google.com. 2019-09-08. 2020-10-30. https://web.archive.org/web/20201030052425/https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=bibliopegy&year_start=1800&year_end=2000&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url=t1%3B%2Cbibliopegy%3B%2Cc0t1;,bibliopegy;,c0. live.
4. http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/18644 OED entry for bibliopegy
5. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/bibliopegy Merriam-Webster definition for bibliopegy
6. Rosenbloom, Lapham's Quarterly.
7. Web site: Killer cremated after 180 years. BBC News. 4 July 2007. 17 August 2004. 10 August 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20170810133421/http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/suffolk/3573244.stm. live.
8. Web site: Pocketbook made from Burke's skin – Surgeons' Hall Museums, Edinburgh. https://web.archive.org/web/20161010124807/https://museum.rcsed.ac.uk/the-collection/key-collections/key-object-page/pocketbook-made-from-burkes-skin. dead. October 10, 2016. museum.rcsed.ac.uk.
9. Web site: Narrative of the life of James Allen, alias George Walton, alias Jonas Pierce, alias James H. York, alias Burley Grove, the highwayman: being his death-bed confession, to the warden of the Massachusetts State Prison [i.e. Charles Lincoln, Jr.]]. James. Allen. Charles. Lincoln. Low Peter. 25 August 2017. Harrington & Co. 01624942 . 25 August 2017. catalog.bostonathenaeum.org Library Catalog. 3 August 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20180803015452/http://catalog.bostonathenaeum.org/vwebv/holdingsInfo?bibId=353244. live.
10. Web site: Boston Athenaeum Skin Book . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20200518115916/https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/boston-athenaeum-skin-book . 2020-05-18 . 2022-04-21 . Atlas Obscura . en.
11. The Grolier Club of the City of New York. Exhibition of silver, embroidered and curious bookbindings, April 16 to May 9, 1903 ([New York City]: The De Vinne Press, [1903]), exhibits 177–179 (pp. 58–59).
12. Callum James, Leonard Smithers: Human Skin Binding, Front Free Endpaper (May 27, 2009)
13. Book: Hertzberg, Edward . Forty-four years as a bookbinder . 1933 . Ernst Hertzberg and Sons Monastery Hill Bindery . Chicago . 43.
14. Joanna Ebenstein, Interview with Megan Rosenbloom, The Morbid Anatomy Online Journal (April 16, 2020): 'everyone knows about de Sade: Justine, and Juliette, but I can't find any actual Justine and Juliette anywhere in an actual public library, so if it exists at all it's probably in a private collection'
15. Aymard. Colette. Mayeur. Laurence-Anne. 2016. L'observatoire de Juvisy-sur-Orge, l'" univers d'un chercheur " à sauvegarder. The Juvisy-sur-Orge observatory, a 'world of research' worthy of protection. fr. In situ: Revue des patrimoines. 29. 29. 10.4000/insitu.13211. free.
16. Web site: Time Traveler's Wife – Newberry. www.newberry.org. 25 August 2017. 25 August 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20170825185811/https://www.newberry.org/time-traveler-s-wife. live.
17. News: Poems bound up in a human skin. https://web.archive.org/web/20160310131406/http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/poems-bound-up-in-a-human-skin-20110807-1wv7c.html. dead. 10 March 2016. Canberra Times. 8 August 2011.
18. Temple University Libraries and Charles L. Blockson, Catalogue of the Charles L. Blockson Afro-American Collection: A Unit of the Temple University Libraries, Temple University Press, 1990, p. 16.
19. Web site: 2015-10-19 . The Science . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20161222211251/https://anthropodermicbooks.org/about/the-science/ . 2016-12-22 . 2022-04-21 . The Anthropodermic Book Project . en.
20. Web site: Lander . Beth . 2015-10-01 . Welcome to this inaugural edition of Fugitive Leaves… . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20180717012907/http://histmed.collegeofphysicians.org/welcome/ . 2018-07-17 . 2022-04-21 . en-US.
21. Web site: Lander . Beth . 2015-10-01 . The Skin She Lived In: Anthropodermic Books in the Historical Medical Library . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20180717012917/http://histmed.collegeofphysicians.org/skin-she-lived-in/ . 2018-07-17 . 2022-04-21 . en-US.
22. Web site: Is it true the John Hay Library has books bound in human skin? - Answers . https://web.archive.org/web/20191111153727/https://library.brown.edu/hay/faq.php#7 . 2019-11-11 . 2022-04-21 . Brown University Library.
23. Web site: Des destinées de l'ame . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20220414151741/https://hollis.harvard.edu/primo-explore/search?tab=everything&search_scope=everything&vid=HVD2&lang=en_US&mode=basic&offset=0&query=lsr01,contains,005786452 . 2022-04-14 . 2016-08-27.
24. Web site: 2014-06-04 . Caveat Lecter . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20140605182606/http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/houghton/2014/06/04/caveat-lecter/ . 2014-06-05 . Houghton Library Blog.
25. Web site: Olympe, ov Metamorphose d'Ovide . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20220414151741/https://hollis.harvard.edu/primo-explore/search?tab=everything&search_scope=everything&vid=HVD2&lang=en_US&mode=basic&offset=0&query=lsr01,contains,005593425 . 2022-04-14 . 2016-08-27.
26. Web site: Practicarum quaestionum circa leges regias Hispaniæ primæ partis nouæ collectionis regiæ. Liber I et II . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20220414151741/https://hollis.harvard.edu/primo-explore/search?tab=everything&search_scope=everything&vid=HVD2&lang=en_US&mode=basic&offset=0&query=lsr01,contains,004317553 . 2022-04-14 . 2022-04-21 . hollis.harvard.edu . en.
27. Web site: 852 RARE: Old Books, New Technologies, and "The Human Skin Book" at HLS . The Harvard Law School Library Blog . Karen Beck . April 3, 2014 . April 3, 2014 . May 26, 2016 . https://web.archive.org/web/20160526235719/http://etseq.law.harvard.edu/2014/04/852-rare-old-books-new-technologies-and-the-human-skin-book-at-hls/ . live .
28. Web site: Harvard University removes human skin binding from book . BBC . 28 March 2024 . 28 March 2024.
29. Book: I. Sever. Pinaei De integritatis & corruptionis virginum notis: graviditate item & partu naturali mulierum, opuscula. II. Ludov. Bonacioli Enneas muliebris. III. Fel. Plateri De origine partium, earumque in utero conformatione. IV. Petri Gassendi De septo cordis pervio, observatio. V. Melchioris Sebizii De notis virginitatis. Séverin. Pineau. Luigi. Bonacciuoli. Felix. Platter. Pierre. Gassendi. Melchior. Sebisch. October 30, 1663. J. Ravestein. search.wellcomelibrary.org. October 30, 2021. April 14, 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20220414151749/https://search.wellcomelibrary.org/iii/encore/record/C__Rb1283248?lang=eng. live.
30. http://www.princeton.edu/~needham/Bouland.pdf A Binding of Human Skin in the Houghton Library: A Recommendation
31. ref name="da1">Book: Rosenbloom, Megan . Dark Archives: A Librarian's Investigation into the Science and History of Books Bound in Human Skin . Dark Archives . Farrar, Straus and Giroux . 2020 . 978-0-374-13470-9 . New York, New York . 27–28 . The First Printing . Megan Rosenbloom.
32. News: 2024-03-28 . Harvard University removes human skin binding from book . 2024-04-12 . en-GB.
33. Web site: A statement on Des destinées de l’âme and its stewardship Harvard Library . 2024-04-12 . library.harvard.edu . en.