Blake F. Donaldson Explained

Blake F. Donaldson
Birth Date:6 May 1892
Birth Place:Islip, New York
Death Date:19 February 1966
Death Place:Hauppauge, New York
Occupation:Physician, writer

Blake Ferguson Donaldson (6 May 1892 – 19 February 1966) was an American physician, hunter and early advocate of a meat-only diet, which later became known as the carnivore diet.

Career

Donaldson was a physician at Long Island College Hospital in Brooklyn in 1913. Donaldson was a First Lieutenant in the medical Northeastern Department of the Red Cross Hospital sent to France during World War I.[1] In May 1917, he was assigned to duty at Governors Island.[2]

Donaldson was resident physician at New York Post-Graduate Medical School.[3] In 1921, Donaldson examined a large number of children from the East Side of New York and found that syphilis is not a great factor in the causation of heart disease.[4] In 1925, Donaldson was Clinical Instructor in Medicine at the New York Post-Graduate Medical School.[5] He was former chief medical officer at the City Hospital of New York. Donaldson was a specialist in internal medicine and his office was located at 121 East 60th Street, New York.[6]

Strong Medicine

Donaldson authored Strong Medicine which was published by Doubleday in 1962. The book advocated fresh fat meat, water and exercise to treat allergies, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, hypertension, gallstones and obesity.[7] [8] The book described "the big bad seven" foods: milk, cream, ice cream, eggs, cheese, chocolate and flour which should be eliminated from the diet.[8] Surgeon Charles G. Heyd wrote a supportive preface for the book.[7]

The diet that Donaldson put his patients on consisted of three fatty steaks a day, three cups of coffee and six glasses of water.[7] [9]

Donaldson's Strong Medicine was criticized by physician Morris Fishbein who commented that the "book is hardly scientific, so presumably what the physician was taught in his youth he has forgotten in his later years."[10] Donaldson's extreme dietary views were classified by Fredrick J. Stare as "food faddism".[11] Stare cited Donaldson as an example of a physician with no training or real understanding of modern nutrition.[11] Stare included Donaldson's Strong Medicine in a list of books on nutritional quackery, which "ought not to be on anyone's shelves".[12]

Personal life

Donaldson was the son of postmaster William W. Donaldson and Helen Scott Donaldson.[13] He married Harriott Cate. They had a son Blake Donaldson, he died age 55 in 1977.[14]

Donaldson died from a heart attack at his home in Hauppauge, New York. He was 73.[15]

Selected publications

Notes and References

  1. 1917. Medical Department With Rank of First Lieutenant. The Boston Medical and Surgical Journal. 176. 22. 783.
  2. Army Orders. Evening Star (May 20, 1917). p. 14
  3. https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015066708317&view=1up&seq=12 Thirty-Third Annual Report of the Directors of the New York Post-Graduate Hospital
  4. 1921. Syphilis in Children of School Age With Heart Disease. International Medical and Surgical Survey. 2. 7. 166.
  5. 1925. News Notes. New York State Journal of Medicine. 25. 846.
  6. https://www.nytimes.com/1966/02/21/archives/blake-donaldson-internist-author.html "Blake Donaldson, Internist, Author"
  7. 1962. Book Review: Strong Medicine by Blake F. Donaldson. Texas State Journal of Medicine. 58. 10. 868.
  8. Rice, Carl O.. 1962. Strong Medicine, Blake F. Donaldson, M.D.. Minnesota Medicine. 45. 4. 431.
  9. Allen, Ralph. (1962). The wild, weird boom in Painless Diets. Maclean's. Retrieved April 14, 2021.
  10. Hafen, Brent Q. (1975). Overweight and Obesity Causes, Fallacies, Treatment. Brigham Young University Press. p. 169.
  11. Stare, Frederick J.. 1963. Overnutrition. American Journal of Public Health and the Nation's Health. 53. 11. 1795–1802. 10.2105/ajph.53.11.1795. 14060833. 1254463.
  12. Stare, Frederick J. (March 10, 1964). Health Frauds and Quackery. In Hearing Before the Subcommittee on Frauds and Misrepresentations Affecting the Elderly of the Special Committee on Aging United States Senate Eighty-Eighth Congress Second Session Part 3. U.S. Government Printing Office. p. 298
  13. https://archive.today/20210414114816/http://www.maggieblanck.com/Land/HauppaugeFieldClub.html Donaldson, Blake, Clinton and Wallace
  14. https://www.nytimes.com/1977/10/19/archives/obituary-6-no-title.html "Deaths"
  15. Physician Dies. Anniston Star (February 21, 1966). p. 9