Battle of Dunsinane explained

Conflict:Battle of Dunsinane
Date:27 July 1054
Place:Dunsinane Hill
Coordinates:56.4703°N -3.2778°W
Map Type:Scotland Perth and Kinross
Result:English victory
Combatant1:Kingdom of Scotland
Combatant2:Kingdom of England
Commander1:Macbeth, King of Scotland
Commander2:Siward, Earl of Northumbria
Malcolm Canmore
Casualties1:3,000
Casualties2:1,500
Notes:Casualty numbers from the Annals of Ulster

The Battle of Dunsinane, also known as the Battle of the Seven Sleepers, was fought between the forces of Macbeth, King of Scotland and forces led by Siward, Earl of Northumbria and Malcolm Canmore on 27 July 1054. The battle was part of a campaign launched by Siward in support of Malcolm's claim to the Scottish throne, which Macbeth had gained after killing Malcolm's father, Duncan I of Scotland, at the Battle of Pitgaveny in 1040. Ending in victory for Siward and Malcolm the battle of Dunsinane was fought in Perthshire, traditionally on Dunsinane Hill.

Following their victory Siward returned home, leaving Malcolm in control of lands from where he was able to further challenge Macbeth. Macbeth would later be killed during the battle of Lumphanan in 1057 while fighting against Malcolm. While Macbeth's stepson Lulach was initially made king, he would also fall in battle against Malcolm and in 1058 Malcolm was crowned Malcolm III of Scotland.

Background

As the ruler of Moray, Macbeth came into conflict with Duncan I of Scotland. This resulted in Duncan's death on 14 August 1040 in the battle of Pitgaveny, near Elgin, after which Macbeth became King of Scotland. Following the death of Duncan, his son Malcolm Canmore became an exile living with the court of Edward the Confessor, King of England.

In 1054 Malcolm was present when his uncle, Siward, Earl of Northumbria, invaded Scotland on his behalf. Some sources state this was on the orders of Edward the Confessor, in which case it is possible that Edward sought a puppet king in Scotland to strengthen his hand against Norman and Scandinavian factions who challenged his succession. An alternative scenario is that Siward hoped a friendly king in Scotland would aid his claim to the rule of Cumbria and took the chance to act while Edward was busy in the south.

The 14th-century historian John of Fordun writes that the invasion caused confusion among the locals who were unsure who to support, suggesting that there may have been Scots loyal to Malcolm fighting alongside the English under Siward. On Macbeth's side were some Norman allies, including two knights who had been expelled from England in 1052 and had been taken into service by Macbeth.

Battle

The decisive battle of Siward's campaign was fought in Perthshire, north of the river Tay, traditionally on Dunsinane Hill although this connection is based on literary as much as historical tradition. The battle is also known as the battle of the Seven Sleepers, as it was fought on the day of the Seven Sleepers (27 July).

The battle ended in defeat for Macbeth. According to the Annals of Ulster 3,000 Scots and 1,500 English were killed. Siward's son Osbeorn and his nephew, also called Siward, were both killed in the battle.

Aftermath

According to the 12th-century chronicler Henry of Huntingdon, Siward ravaged the kingdom after his victory over the Scots and their Norman allies. The earl returned home relatively quickly with much plunder, weakening the invading force. Siward would die in York in 1055.

After his defeat Macbeth was forced to give lands and position to Malcolm. The exact positions are unknown but it is probable that Macbeth still controlled the area north of the Mounth while Malcolm controlled the area south of the rivers Forth and Clyde, with the area in between possibly disputed territory. From this position Malcolm was able to challenge Macbeth, with Macbeth being defeated and killed at Lumphanan in Mar on 15 August 1057. Following Macbeth's death his stepson Lulach was installed as king. Malcolm ambushed and killed Lulach near Rhynie in Strathbogie in March 1058 before himself being crowned king. Once king, he would begin the long process of removing the Gaelic culture from the mainstream of Scotland.

In popular culture

William Shakespeare's play The Tragedy of Macbeth is based on the life of Macbeth, King of Scots, with the historical details being drawn from Ralph Holinshed's Chronicles, published in 1577. In this version Malcolm has his forces cut branches from the trees of Birnam Wood which are then used to camouflage their approach to Dunsinane, fulfilling a prophecy made within the play that Macbeth would not be defeated until Birnam Wood came to Dunsinane. In Shakespeare's telling Macbeth is killed by Macduff during the battle of Dunsinane, running together several encounters in different places, including the battle of Lumphanan. Historic Environment Scotland have highlighted that the connection between Dunsinane Hill and Macbeth in literary tradition has given the site a place in the national consciousness of Scotland.

Sources