Bat bridge explained

A bat bridge is a structure of varying construction crossing a new or altered road to aid the navigation of bats following the destruction of a hedgerow, and to cause the bats to cross the roadway at a sufficient height to avoid traffic. Bats are thought to follow the lines of hedgerows and woods, and removing these may confuse the bats.

The theory is that these "bridges" will be seen by the bats' sonar as linear features sufficiently similar to the old hedgerows as to provide an adequate substitute.[1] The English Highways Agency is performing a study of those on the Dobwalls bypass to determine if this assumption is justified.

Usage

France

The first bridge to be installed in France is on the A65 motorway between junctions for Roquefort and Caloy in the Landes department.[2]

Two additional bat bridges were completed in November 2012 near Balbigny, on the A89 motorway.[3] [4]

Germany

Two metal bridges were built in 2013 to protect the Mouse-eared Bat at Biberach an der Riss, Baden-Wuerttemberg. The structures cost £375,000 (400,000 €).[5]

United Kingdom

Bat bridges have been implemented in the United Kingdom by various agencies, including the Highways Agency, with support of the Bat Conservation Trust.[6]

At A38 Dobwalls Bypass, the bridges are more elaborate and sophisticated than the earlier Welsh structures, which consisted of cables strung from poles.[7] [8]

Bat bridges in the United Kingdom
Name Road Opened Approx. lengthSingle or dual carriageway Placement Approx. cost Other detailsRef.
Stainburn and Great Clifton Bypass December 2002 Gantry Single (three-lane carriageway)
High and Low Newton April 2008 33 m Dual In cutting £45,000
Dobwalls
(2 Structures)
June 2008 Structure 1: 59.47 m, Structure 2: 70 m Dual At Grade/In Cutting £300,000 One structure consists of three steel towers with cables suspended between them carrying mesh panels. The other consists of a single span of cables and mesh panels between concrete and steel anchors either side of a cutting. In the Dobwalls scheme, a third bat-crossing consisted of a raised parapet modification to a new road bridge, Havett Road.
Parton to Lillyhall Dec 2008 34 m Dual On embankment £34,133
Haydon Bridge April 2009 19.5 Single In cutting £60,000
2006 Single At Grade A bat bridge was installed following the upgrade of the A497 to help the six species of bats in the area to cross the road.[9]
A112014 Dual Various £350,000 Six bat bridges.[10]
2007 Dual Embankment Two bat bridges were constructed during road upgrade in locations where full bridges previously stood.[11]
2010 Single The road runs through the Glynllifon Special Area of Conservation which is home to a lesser horseshoe bat colony.[12]
2017 Dual £1,000,000 Seven bat bridges on the Norwich Northern Distributor Road.[13] [14]

Criticism

The overall cost of bat bridges was criticised by Lord Marlesford in the House of Lords in 2011, for being funded "at a time when we're having to cut a lot of public spending".[15]

A team from the University of Leeds examined the effectiveness of bat bridges, gantries and underpasses. They found that one underpass, placed on a commuting route, was used by 96% of bats, but few bats used the other underpasses and gantries, preferring routes which put them in the path of traffic.[16] [17]

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: New bypass going 'batty' to help the environment . Western Morning News, The Plymouth (UK) . April 5, 2008. 2009-09-12.
  2. http://www.sudouest.fr/2012/02/28/un-couloir-a-chauves-souris-644852-706.php Un couloir à chauves-souris, Sud-Ouest, février 2012
  3. http://rhone-alpes.france3.fr/2012/11/21/balbigny-une-passerelle-pour-chauve-souris-au-dessus-de-l-a89-148988.html Reportage de France 3
  4. http://www.denisriou.com/autoroute-a89-chiropteroduc Photographies de l'installation des ouvrages
  5. News: 2013-11-02 . Warum fliegen die nicht einfach drüber? . . 2 April 2015 . https://web.archive.org/web/20131106092905/http://www.ksta.de/panorama/umstrittene-fledermausbruecke-warum-fliegen-die-nicht-einfach-drueber-%2C15189504%2C24882430%2Cview%2CprintVersion.html . 2013-11-06 . Rund 400 000 Euro wurden dafür ausgegeben . Print version . Around 400,000 euros were spent on it.
  6. News: 2014-08-04 . A11 Elveden bypass to be shut for bat bridges . BBC News . 2015-04-02.
  7. Web site: New Bat bridge for bypass : Marishal Thompson Group - Tree Subsidence, Arboriculture, Ecology and Landscape Architecture throughout the UK . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20091107135016/http://marishalthompson.co.uk/news/new-bat-bridge-for-bypass/ . 2009-11-07 . 2009-09-12 . Marishalthompson.co.uk.
  8. Web site: House of Lords Written Answers 10 November 2009: Bats . 5 June 2011 . United Kingdom Parliament.
  9. News: 2006-05-02 . UK | Wales | North West Wales | 'Green' road helps bats to cross . BBC News . 2009-09-12.
  10. News: 22 October 2015 . Bats reject 'safe way' bridges over Norfolk - Suffolk dual carriageway . BBC News . 27 January 2020.
  11. News: Roberts . Geneviève . 2007-03-31 . How did the bats cross the road? By using the special 'bat bridge' - Nature, Environment . The Independent . London . 2009-09-12.
  12. News: 30 January 2010 . Road closure for new aerial bat crossing . BBC News . 5 June 2011.
  13. News: 26 Jan 2020 . Norwich NDR bat bridges 'are not working' . BBC News . 26 Jan 2020.
  14. News: 21 Apr 2015 . Detailed section plan of the NDR . Norfolk County Council . 11 Dec 2017.
  15. News: Bridges too far? The £500,000 bat crossings.
  16. Berthinussen. Anna. Altringham. John. Fenton. Brock. Do Bat Gantries and Underpasses Help Bats Cross Roads Safely?. PLOS ONE. 13 June 2012. 7. 6. e38775. 10.1371/journal.pone.0038775. 22719941. 3374807. free.
  17. Web site: Bat bridges don't work. University of Leeds. 15 June 2014. 14 June 2012.