The Basketball Champions League Americas All-Star Five is an annual honour awarded by the Basketball Champions League Americas (BCLA) to the five most outstanding players of a given season. The selection is composed of five players and was first made after the 2022–23 season.
| ^ | Denotes players who are still active in the BCL Americas | |
| Elected to the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame | ||
| Player (X) | Denotes the number of times the player has been selected | |
| Player(in bold text) | Indicates the player who won the Most Valuable Player (MVP) in the same year | |
| G | Guard | |
| F | Forward | |
| C | Center |
| Season | Player | Team | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022–23 | G | Alexey Borges | Minas | [1] |
| G | Georginho | Sesi Franca | ||
| F | Martín Cuello | Flamengo | ||
| F | Lucas Mariano | Sesi Franca | ||
| C | Lucas Dias | Sesi Franca | ||
| 2023–24 | G | Juan Brussino | Hebraica Macabi | [2] |
| G | Franco Balbi | Flamengo | ||
| F | Brandon Robinson | Quimsa | ||
| F | Jordan Glynn | Halcones de Xalapa | ||
| C | Jordan Williams | Hebraica Macabi |