Bảo Đại Explained

Emperor Bảo Đại
保大帝
Succession:Emperor of Đại Nam and Empire of Vietnam
Reign:8 January 1926 –
25 August 1945
Predecessor:Khải Định
Successor:Monarchy abolished
Hồ Chí Minh
Succession2:Chief of State of Vietnam
Reign2:13 June 1949 –
26 October 1955
Predecessor2:Position established
Nguyễn Văn Xuân
Successor2:Position abolished
Ngô Đình Diệm
Succession3:1st Prime Minister of the State of Vietnam
Reign3:14 July 1949 –
21 January 1950
Predecessor3:Position established
Successor3:Nguyễn Phan Long
Succession4:Supreme Advisor to the Government of the Democratic Republic of Vietnam
Reign4:10 September 1945 –
16 March 1946
Predecessor4:Position established
Successor4:Position abolished
Birth Name:Nguyễn Phúc Vĩnh Thụy
Birth Date:22 October 1913
Birth Place:Doan-Trang-Vien Palace, Imperial City of Huế, French Indochina
Death Place:Val-de-Grâce, Paris, France
Burial Place:Passy Cemetery
Spouse:
Bùi Mộng Điệp
Lê Thị Phi Ánh
Christiane Bloch-Carcenac
Era Dates:Bảo Đại (1926–1945)
House:Nguyễn Phúc
Father:Khải Định
Mother:Hoàng Thị Cúc
Religion:Confucianism
Mahayana Buddhism
Roman Catholicism
Signature:BaoDaiSignature.svg

Bảo Đại (in Vietnamese ɓa᷉ːw ɗâːjˀ/, Vietnamese: {{linktext|保|大, lit. "keeper of greatness", 22 October 191331 July 1997),[1] born Nguyễn Phúc (Phước) Vĩnh Thụy, was the 13th and final emperor of the Nguyễn dynasty, the last ruling dynasty of Vietnam.[2] From 1926 to 1945, he was emperor of Annam and de jure monarch of Tonkin, which were then protectorates in French Indochina, covering the present-day central and northern Vietnam. Bảo Đại ascended the throne in 1932.

The Japanese ousted the Provisional French administration in March 1945 and ruled through Bảo Đại, who proclaimed the Empire of Vietnam. He abdicated in August 1945 when Japan surrendered.

From 1949 to 1955, Bảo Đại was the chief of state of the non-communist State of Vietnam. Viewed as a puppet ruler, Bảo Đại was criticized for being too closely associated with France and spending much of his time outside Vietnam. He was eventually ousted in a referendum in 1955 by Prime Minister Ngô Đình Diệm, who was supported by the United States.

Early life

Bảo Đại was born on 22 October 1913 and given the name of Prince Nguyễn Phúc Vĩnh Thụy in the Palace of Doan-Trang-Vien, part of the compound of the Purple Forbidden City in Huế, the capital of Vietnam. He was later given the name Nguyễn Vĩnh Thụy. His father was Emperor Khải Định of Annam. His mother was the emperor's second wife, Tu Cung, who was renamed 'Doan Huy' upon her marriage. She held various titles over the years that indicated her advancing rank as a favored consort until she eventually became Empress Dowager in 1933. Vietnam had been ruled from Huế by the Nguyễn dynasty since 1802. The French government, which took control of the region in the late 19th century, split Vietnam into three areas: the protectorates of Annam and Tonkin and the colony of Cochinchina. The Nguyễn dynasty was given nominal rule of Annam.

At the age of nine, Prince Nguyễn Phúc Vĩnh Thụy was sent to France to study at the Lycée Condorcet and, later, the Paris Institute of Political Studies. He became emperor on 8 January 1926, after his father's death, and took the era name Bảo Đại ("Protector of Grandeur" or "Keeper of Greatness").[3] [4] He did not yet ascend to the throne and returned to France to continue his studies.

Marriages

On 20 March 1934, age 20, at the imperial city of Huế, Bảo Đại married Marie-Thérèse Nguyễn Hữu Thị Lan (died 15 September 1963, Chabrignac, France), a commoner from a wealthy Vietnamese Catholic family. After the wedding, she was given the title Empress Nam Phương. The couple had five children: Crown Prince Bảo Long (4 January 1936 – 28 July 2007), Princess Phương Mai (1 August 1937 – 16 January 2021), Princess Phương Liên (born 3 November 1938), Princess Phương Dung (born 5 February 1942), and Prince Bảo Thắng (9 December 1943 – 15 March 2017). Although Bảo Đại later had additional children with other women, these are the only ones listed in the clan genealogy.

Mistresses

Nam Phương was granted the title of empress in 1945. By one count, Bảo Đại had relationships with eight women and fathered 13 children. Those named "Phương" are daughters, while those named "Bảo" are sons.[5]

!Name!Title!Issue!Note
Nguyễn Hữu Thị LanEmpress
Nam Phương
Crown Prince Bảo Long (1936–2007)

Princess Phương Mai (1937–2021)

Princess Phương Liên (b. 1938)

Princess Phương Dung (b. 1942)

Prince Bảo Thắng (1943–2017)

The emperor's first wife. "Nam Phương" translates as "Southern virtue".
Bùi Mộng ĐiệpThứ phi Phương Thảo (b. 1946)

Bảo Hoàng (1954–1955)

Bảo Sơn (1957–1987)

Called thứ phi phương Bắc ("Northern secondary consort").
Lý Lệ HàMistressWon Vietnam's first beauty contest in 1938 in Hà Đông. She publicly dated Bảo Đại in Hanoi in 1946. The couple later lived together in Hong Kong, according to her account.[6]
Variously called Huang Xiaolan, Hoàng Tiểu Lan, Jenny Woong, and Trần NỷMistressPhương AnMixed Chinese-Vietnamese Hong Kong actress who had an affair with Bảo Đại 1946 when he was in Hong Kong.
Lê Thị Phi ÁnhThứ phiPhương Minh (1949–2012)

Bảo Ân (b. 1953)

Sister-in-law of Prime Minister Phan Văn Giáo
VickyMistressPhương Từ (1955)This daughter by a French woman has "a half European Asian beauty."
Christiane Bloch-CarcenacMistressPatrick-Édouard Bloch-Carcenac (b. 1958)Affair occurred in 1957–1970
Monique BaudotImperial princessSelf-styled Empress Thái PhươngSecond wife. She was a French citizen whom Bảo Đại married in 1972.

Independence and abdication

See main article: Empire of Vietnam and Abdication of Bảo Đại.

In 1940, during the second World War, coinciding with their ally Nazi Germany's invasion of France, Imperial Japan took over French Indochina. While they did not eject the French colonial administration, the occupation authorities directed policy from behind the scenes in a parallel of Vichy France.The Japanese promised not to interfere with the court at Huế, but in 1945, after ousting the French, coerced Bảo Đại into declaring Vietnamese independence from France as a member of Japan's "Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere"; the country then became the Empire of Vietnam.

Bảo Đại, however, appeared to believe that independence was an irreversible course. In 1944, he wrote to General de Gaulle, leader of the Free French:

The Japanese had a Vietnamese pretender, Prince Cường Để, waiting to take power in case the new emperor's "elimination" was required. Japan surrendered to the Allies in August 1945, and the Viet Minh (under the leadership of communist Hồ Chí Minh) aimed to take power in a free Vietnam. Due to his popular political stand against the French and the 1945 famine, Hồ was able to persuade Bảo Đại to abdicate on 25 August 1945, handing power over to the Việt Minh – an event which greatly enhanced Hồ's legitimacy in the eyes of the Vietnamese people.[7] Bảo Đại was appointed the "supreme advisor" to Hồ's Democratic Republic of Vietnam (DRV) in Hanoi, which declared its independence on 2 September 1945. The DRV was then ousted by the newly formed French Fourth Republic in November 1946.[8]

Return to power and Indochina War

See main article: State of Vietnam.

Bảo Đại spent nearly a year as "supreme advisor" to the DRV, during which period Vietnam descended into armed conflict between rival Vietnamese factions and the French. He left this post in 1946 and moved to Hong Kong, where the French and Việt Minh both attempted unsuccessfully to solicit him for political support.[9]

Eventually a coalition of Vietnamese anti-communists (including future South Vietnamese leader Ngô Đình Diệm and members of political/religious groups such as the Cao Dai, Hòa Hảo, and VNQDĐ) formed a National Union and declared to support Bảo Đại on the condition he would seek independence for Vietnam. This persuaded him to reject Việt Minh overtures and enter into negotiations with the French. On 7 December 1947, Bảo Đại signed the first of the Ha Long Bay Agreements with France. Despite ostensibly committing France to Vietnamese independence, it was considered minimally binding and transferred no actual authority to Vietnam. The agreement was promptly criticized by National Union members, including Diệm. In a possible attempt to escape the resulting political tension, Bảo Đại travelled to Europe and commenced on a four-month pleasure tour which earned him the sobriquet "night club emperor". After persistent efforts by the French, Bảo Đại was persuaded to return from Europe and sign a second Ha Long Bay Agreement on 5 June 1948. This contained similarly weak promises for Vietnamese independence and had as little success as the first agreement. Bảo Đại once again travelled to Europe whilst warfare in Vietnam continued to escalate.

After months of negotiations with French President Vincent Auriol, he finally signed the Élysée Accords on 9 March 1949, which led to the establishment of the State of Vietnam with Bảo Đại as Chief of State (國長, Quốc trưởng); the French also oversaw the creation of the Domain of the Crown where he was still officially considered to be the Emperor, this territory existed until 1955.

However, the country was still only partially autonomous, with France initially retaining effective control of the army and foreign relations. Bảo Đại himself stated in 1950: "What they call a Bảo Đại solution turned out to be just a French solution... the situation in Indochina is getting worse every day".

As Diệm and other hardcore nationalists were disappointed in the lack of autonomy and refused high government posts, Bảo Đại mainly filled his government with wealthy figures strongly connected to France. He then spent his own time in the resort towns of Da Lat, Nha Trang, and Buôn Ma Thuột, largely avoiding the process of governing. All this contributed to his reputation as a French puppet and a rise in popular support for the Việt Minh, whose armed insurgency against the French-backed regime was developing into a full-fledged civil war. Nonetheless, in 1950 he attended a series of conferences in Pau, France where he pressed the French for further independence. The French granted some minor concessions to the Vietnamese, which caused a mixed reaction on both sides.

In addition to the increasing unpopularity of the Bảo Đại government, the communist victory in China in 1949 also led to a further revival of the fortunes of the Việt Minh. When China and the Soviet Union recognized the DRV government, the United States reacted by extending diplomatic recognition to Bảo Đại's government in March 1950. This and the outbreak of the Korean War in June led to U.S. military aid and active support of the French war effort in Indochina, now seen as anti-communist rather than colonialist. Despite this, the war between the French colonial forces and the Việt Minh started to go badly for the French, culminating in a major victory for the Việt Minh at Điện Biên Phủ. This led to the negotiating of a 1954 peace deal between the French and the Việt Minh, known as the Geneva Accords, which partitioned Vietnam at the 17th parallel. The north side was given to the DRV, with the State of Vietnam receiving the south. Bảo Đại remained "Head of State" of South Vietnam, but moved to Paris and appointed Ngô Đình Diệm as his prime minister.[10]

Second removal from power

See main article: 1955 State of Vietnam referendum.

At first, Ngô Đình Diệm exercised no influence over South Vietnam: the Việt Minh still had de facto control of somewhere between sixty and ninety percent of the countryside (by French estimates), whilst the rest was dominated by the various religious sects. Meanwhile, the new capital of Saigon was under the total control of criminal group Bình Xuyên. According to Colonel Lansdale, it had paid Bảo Đại a "staggering sum" for control of local prostitution and gambling and of Saigon's police force.

Regardless, Diệm's forces embarked on a campaign against the Bình Xuyên, with fighting breaking out in the streets on 29 March 1955. In an attempt to protect his clients, Bảo Đại ordered Diệm to travel to France, but he was disobeyed and Diệm eventually succeeded in pushing his opponents out of the city. Using a divide and conquer strategy, Diệm then employed a mixture of force and bribery to sway the remaining religious sects to his side. Now with a broad range of support, a new Popular Revolutionary Committee (formed by Diệm's brother Ngô Đình Nhu) was able to call for a referendum to remove Bảo Đại and establish a republic with Diệm as president. The campaign leading up to the referendum was punctuated by personal attacks against the former emperor, whose supporters had no way to refute them since campaigning for Bảo Đại was forbidden.

The official results showed a tally of 98.9% in favor of a republic, with the number of votes for a republic exceeding the total number of registered voters by 155,025 in Saigon, while the total number of votes exceeded the total number of registered voters by 449,084, and the number of votes for a republic exceeded the total number of registered voters by 386,067.[11]

Bảo Đại was removed from power, with Diệm declaring himself president of the new Republic of Vietnam on 26 October 1955.

Life in exile

In 1957, during his visit to Alsace region, he met Christiane Bloch-Carcenac with whom he had an affair for several years. The relationship with Bloch-Carcenac resulted in the birth of his last child, Patrick-Édouard Bloch-Carcenac, who still lives in Alsace in France.[12] [13]

In 1972, Bảo Đại issued a public statement from exile, appealing to the Vietnamese people for national reconciliation, stating, "The time has come to put an end to the fratricidal war and to recover at last peace and accord". At times, Bảo Đại maintained residence in southern France, and in particular, in Monaco, where he sailed often on his private yacht, one of the largest in Monte Carlo harbor. He still reportedly held great influence among local political figures in the Quảng Trị and Thừa Thiên provinces of Huế. The Communist government of North Vietnam sent representatives to France hoping that Bảo Đại would become a member of a coalition government which might reunite Vietnam, in the hope of attracting his supporters in the regions wherein he still held influence.

As a result of these meetings, Bảo Đại publicly spoke out against the presence of American troops in South Vietnam, and he criticized President Nguyễn Văn Thiệu's regime in South Vietnam. He called for all political factions to create a free, neutral, peace-loving government which would resolve the tense situation that had taken form in the country. In 1982, Bảo Đại, his wife Monique, and other members of the former imperial family of Vietnam visited the United States. His agenda was to oversee and bless Buddhist and Caodaist religious ceremonies, in the California and Texas Vietnamese American communities.

In 1988, Bảo Đại was baptised in France as Roman Catholic.[14] [15] [16]

Throughout Bảo Đại's life in both Vietnam and in France, he remained unpopular among the Vietnamese populace as he was considered a political puppet for the French colonialist regime, for lacking any form of political power, and for his cooperation with the French and for his pro-French ideals. The former emperor clarified, however, that his reign was always a constant battle and a balance between preserving the monarchy and the integrity of the nation versus fealty to the French authorities. Ultimately, power devolved away from his person and into ideological camps and in the face of Diem's underestimated influences on factions within the empire.[17] Bảo Đại died at Val-de-Grâce, a military hospital in Paris, on 30 July 1997. He was interred in the Cimetière de Passy.

Perception of Bảo Đại

In Vietnam

The Communist Party of Vietnam (CPV) considered him to be a traitor. After he was once again helped by France as the Head of State of Vietnam, Ho Chi Minh said in an interview with Chinese media: "Vĩnh Thụy brought the French invading army back to Vietnam and killed more compatriots. Vĩnh Thụy is a true traitor. The French colonists conspired to restore slavery in Vietnam. Vĩnh Thụy is the confidant of the colonists. Although Vietnamese law is very tolerant to those who have lost their way, they will severely punish the traitorous orphans. The Vietnamese people are determined to defeat all colonial conspiracies and fight for true independence and reunification."[18] [19]

On one hand, Bảo Đại remains a highly discussed figure. While labelling him as traitor, the CPV does not treat him entirely harshly compared to subsequent leaders of the later South Vietnam, whom the communists engaged in an extensive vilification, and his role continues to be studied, ranging from a somewhat sympathetic figure to the Việt Minh to a moderate figure who tried to avoid war, given Bảo Đại himself agreed to abdicate in 1945 to give power for the Việt Minh.[20]

Vietnamese diaspora

Most Overseas Vietnamese, who are ardently anti-communist, didn't consider Bảo Đại positively, partly due to his weak-willed reputation and inability to confront with the communist threat, as well as his reclusive life and his perceived cowardice.[21] [22] His role is also studied by the diaspora, although recent studies had questioned the perception due to perceived bias by both the Vietnamese diaspora and the CPV.[23]

In popular culture

Bảo Đại coins

See main article: Bảo Đại Thông Bảo.

The last cash coin ever produced in the world bears the name of Bảo Đại in Chữ Hán. There are three types of this coin. Large cast piece with 10 văn inscription on the reverse, medium cast piece with no reverse inscription, and small struck piece. All were issued in 1933.

Quotes

Honours

National honours

Foreign honours

Reign symbols

Symbols created and / or used during the reign of Bảo Đại
Symbol Image Description
8 imperial seals created for Emperor Bảo Đại.[30] See Seals of the Nguyễn dynasty.
Personal standard of emperors Khải Định and Bảo Đại Flag ratio: 2:3.
Personal coat of arms of Bảo Đại. A sword per fess charged with the ramparts of the Purple Forbidden City in Huế, inscribed with two Traditional Chinese (Hán) characters (保大) and supported by a single dragon.
Influences:
Bảo Đại Thông Bảo
(保大通寶)
The last cash coins issued by a government in both Vietnam and the world.
Bảo Đại Bảo Giám
(保大寳鑑)
A series of silver coins bearing his reign era.
Seal as the chief of state of Vietnam. A seal with the inscriptions "Quốc-gia Việt-Nam", "Đức Bảo Đại Quốc-trưởng" written in Latin script and "保大國長" in seal script.
Personal standard Flag ratio: 2:3. Influences:

Further reading

Other languages

External links

Photos of Bảo Đại's summer palaces

Notes and References

  1. News: Philip Shenon . Bao Dai, 83, of Vietnam; Emperor and Bon Vivant . subscription . 5 April 2022 . . 2 August 1997 . 1 10.
  2. Nghia M. Vo Saigon: A History 2011 – Page 277 "Bảo Đại was born in 1913, the 13th and last monarch of the Nguyễn dynasty. He ruled from 1926 to 1944 as emperor of Annam and emperor"
  3. Chapman . Jessica M. . Staging democracy: South Vietnam's 1955 referendum to depose Bao Dai . Diplomatic History . September 2006 . 30 . 4 . 687. 10.1111/j.1467-7709.2006.00573.x .
  4. Book: Currey, Cecil B. . Bao Dai . Tucker . Spencer C. . The encyclopedia of the Vietnam War : a political, social, and military history . limited . 2011 . ABC-CLIO . Santa Barbara, CA . 9781851099610 . 94-95 . 2nd.
  5. Viet, Dan, "vua Bảo Dại co bao nhieu vọ con?," Nghệ Thuật Xưa
  6. "'Gái quê' thành vũ nữ đa tình nức tiếng", Người đưa tin, 17 January 2013.
  7. [Stanley Karnow]
  8. [David G. Marr]
  9. Book: United States. Department of Defense. The Pentagon papers : the Defense Department history of United States decisionmaking on Vietnam / 1.. 1971. Beacon Pr. Mike Gravel. 0-8070-0527-4. 1. Boston. 643945604.
  10. Interview with Ngô Đình Luyến . 31 January 1979 . WGBH Media Library and Archives .
  11. http://www.sudd.ch/event.php?lang=en&id=vn011955 Direct Democracy
  12. oral communication (Patrick-Edward Bloch-Carcenac) and sections of the "Dernières Nouvelles d'Alsace" (D.N.A), n°. 264 of 10 November 1992 and from 7 August 2007.
  13. Web site: RENAISSANCE DE HUE – Site de maguy tran – pinterville. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20150320190704/https://www.maguytran-pinterville.com/vietnam/renaissance-de-hue/. 20 March 2015. fr.
  14. News: Pearson . Richard . 1997-08-02 . BAO DAI, FORMER EMPEROR OF VIETNAM, DIES . 2024-01-08 . Washington Post . en-US . 0190-8286 . During his years in French exile, Bao Dai converted from Buddhism to Roman Catholicism and lost the greater part of his fortune..
  15. News: de Rochebouët . Béatrice . 2022-10-28 . Enchères: sous le sceau du dernier empereur du Vietnam . Auction: under the seal of the last emperor of Vietnam . subscription . https://archive.today/20230825034622/https://www.lefigaro.fr/culture/encheres/encheres-sous-le-sceau-du-dernier-empereur-du-vietnam-20221028 . 2023-08-25 . 2024-01-08 . Le Figaro . fr . Et, sur son initiative, reçut en 1988 le baptême catholique. . And, on his initiative, he received Catholic baptism in 1988..
  16. Web site: BẢO ĐẠI (NGUYỄN PHÚC VĨNH THỤY, JEAN-ROBERT, 1913–1997) . 2024-01-08 . indochine.uqam.ca . University of Quebec in Montreal . The former emperor died there, after having remarried a French woman in 1972 and converted to Catholicism in 1988..
  17. Book: A Special Relationship: The United States and Military Government in Thailand, 1947–1958 . D. Fineman . University of Hawaii Press . 1997 . 9780824818180 . 111 .
  18. Web site: Trang . Tâm . 2013-07-04 . Những cuộc trả lời phỏng vấn báo chí của Bác Hồ (Phần 4) . 2024-05-29 . Trang tin điện tử Ban quản lý lăng Chủ tịch Hồ Chí Minh . vi-vn.
  19. http://www.cpv.org.vn/cpv/Modules/News/NewsDetail.aspx?co_id=0&cn_id=29641 Trả lời điện phỏng vấn của Dân quốc nhật báo (1949)(1), Hồ Chí Minh toàn tập, Tập 5 (1947–1949)
  20. Web site: Chính phủ cách mạng lâm thời tiếp nhận sự thoái vị của Bảo Đại . 2024-05-29 . en-US.
  21. Web site: 2022-10-28 . Kiến nghị đòi lại ấn "Kim Bảo Tỷ" và kiếm "Khải Định Niên Chế" cho Nhà nước Việt Nam Tiếng Dân . 2024-05-29 . en-US.
  22. Web site: 2017-10-23 . Tạp chí Việt Nam - Bảo Đại : Từ hoàng đế Việt "lực bất tòng tâm" đến "thường dân" Pháp . 2024-05-29 . RFI . vi.
  23. News: Vua Bảo Đại và kết cục buồn cho Việt Nam . 2024-05-29 . BBC News Tiếng Việt . vi.
  24. Web site: VnExpress . 'Ngọn nến hoàng cung' - chất nhân văn nhẹ nhàng . 2024-05-08 . vnexpress.net . vi.
  25. Web site: ROLEX Ref. 6062. Philipps.
  26. News: Bao Dai Rolex Sells For More Than $5 Million At Phillips Auction, Setting A New World Record. Naas. Roberta. Forbes. 23 November 2018. en.
  27. Book: Vietnam 1945: The Quest for Power . D. G. Marr . University of California Press . London, England . 1997 . 9780520212282 .
  28. Book: Dereliction of Duty: Johnson, McNamara, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and the Lies That Led to Vietnam . registration . H. R. McMaster . 1998 . New York, NY . HarperCollins . 9780060929084 .
  29. News: 2 August 1997 . Bao Dai, 83, of Vietnam; Emperor and Bon Vivant . P. Shenon . The New York Times.
  30. Web site: No royal seal left in Hue today. VietNamNet Bridge – It is a great regret that none of more than 100 seals of the Nguyen emperors are in Hue City today.. 10 February 2016. 8 March 2021. VietNamNet Bridge. VietNam Breaking News. en. 16 July 2022. https://web.archive.org/web/20220716131720/https://www.vietnambreakingnews.com/2016/02/no-royal-seal-left-in-hue-today/. dead.