Bake Off: The Professionals Explained

Alt Name:Bake Off: Crème de la Crème
Director:Emma Reynolds
Theme Music Composer:Tom Howe
Country:United Kingdom
Language:English
Num Series:9
Num Episodes:79
Producer:Kate Baller, Laura Smith
Runtime:60 minutes
Company:Love Productions
Channel:BBC Two (2016–2017)
Channel 4 (2018–)
Last Aired:present
Related:The Great British Bake Off

Bake Off: The Professionals is a British television baking competition featuring teams of professional pastry chefs pitted against one another over two challenges. The series is a spin-off from The Great British Bake Off, and was originally titled Bake Off: Crème de la Crème on the BBC. Its first episode was screened on BBC Two on 29 March 2016.[1] The third series screened on Channel 4 and was renamed Bake Off: The Professionals to join The Great British Bake Off after the BBC failed to renew the series.[2]

The eight-episode first series of the programme was presented by Tom Kerridge, with Benoit Blin, Cherish Finden and Claire Clark serving as judges.[3] The second series was presented by Angus Deayton, and Claire Clark did not return as a judge.[4] On Channel 4, the series was originally presented by comedian Tom Allen and former GBBO competitor Liam Charles. In 2022 Tom Allen was replaced by Stacey Solomon, and from 2023 it has been presented by Charles and comedian Ellie Taylor.[5]

The first series was won by the Squires Kitchen Cookery School team led by Mark Tilling,[6] followed by a team of military chefs led by Liam Grime, a team from London Hilton Park Lane with Emmanuel Bonneau, Thibault Marchand and Erica Sangiorgi from Kimpton Fitzroy London Hotel, and Laurian Veaudor and Thibault Courtoisier from Cocorico Patisserie. Andrew Minto and Michael Coggan from Gin and Bake in Cardiff won in 2021.

Format

The series is a competition between teams of professional pastry chefs from high-end hotels and restaurants, as well as supermarkets, armed forces and other companies and organisations. The competition aims to find the finest pastry chefs in the country, who can turn the ordinary into the extraordinary and can create desserts that have "stunning visual impact, phenomenal flavour, and texture". Teams of pastry chefs are chosen for the competition, with three pastry chefs in each team in the first two series, one of them the team captain. From the third series onwards, teams of two competed. In the heats, the three teams are given two challenges and are awarded marks from the judges for each of their creations, the team with the best total score after both challenges is guaranteed a place in the semifinal. The team with the highest total score throughout the whole of the heats is also guaranteed a place within the semifinal.[3] Each episode consists of two challenges:

Miniature Challenge: In this challenge each team have to create a batch of three types of miniatures. Each must be uniform in appearance, finished to the very highest professional standards and will only have three hours to make all 108 pastries. Each miniature is marked out of 30 with a total of 90 points available. Other challenges may replace the miniature challenge. For example, there may be a secret recipe challenge for one of the heat rounds where the contestants are not given information beforehand on the bakes they have to do, and only given a recipe on the day before they start baking.[7]
  • Showpiece Challenge: In this challenge each team are asked to reinvent a popular British dessert and present it as a fine-dining showpiece display. Each judge has 50 points they can award with a total of 150 points available.
  • The format changed from the first series to the third. The first series started with 15 teams, three teams in each of the five heats, with the winning team each episode guaranteed a place in the semifinals, with one additional wild card from the heats. Three teams were selected from the two semifinals to compete in the final. The second series started with ten teams separated into two groups of five, with one team eliminated each episode over two sets of three heats before the semifinal.[4] The two winners from the two semifinal then compete in the final. From the third series onward, the competition started with twelve teams, in two groups of six, again with one team eliminated in three sets of heats.[8] The remaining six teams, three from each group, then competed for a place in the quarterfinal, followed by the semifinal, leaving three teams in the final.

    Series overview

    SeriesEpisodesPremiereFinalWinning teamRunners-upChannel
    1829 March 2016 17 May 2016Squires Kitchen Cookery SchoolLondon Hilton Park LaneBBC Two
    Boulangerie Jade
    294 April 201731 May 2017Military ChefsCocorico Patisserie
    3106 May 20188 July 2018London Hilton Park LaneSweet Art LabChannel 4
    Resorts World Birmingham
    41030 April 201914 June 2019Kimpton Fitzroy London Hotel
    South Place Hotel
    51026 May 202028 July 2020Cocorico PatisseriePark Plaza Westminster Bridge
    The Ivy
    610 25 May 202127 July 2021Gin & BakeJulien Plumart
    The Lanesborough
    710 24 May 202226 July 2022Nathan Rave and Kevin MarmionHotel Café Royal
    Puddles Bespoke Patisserie
    810 4 July 20235 September 2023The Landmark HotelHarwoods Patisserie
    The Dorchester
    910 10 June 20248 July 2024InterContinental London - The O2The Royal Air Force Club
    Soko Patisserie

    Series 1

    The first series of the competition was filmed at Welbeck Abbey in Nottinghamshire,[9] It was presented by Tom Kerridge, and the competition was judged by Benoit Blin, Cherish Finden and Claire Clark.[3]

    There were fifteen teams of pastry chefs in the first round. The team from Marks & Spencer, British Armed Forces, London's Boulangerie Jade, London Hilton on Park Lane, and Leed's Lauden Chocolate winning their respective heats to reach the semifinal, while Squires Kitchen Cookery School from Surrey also went through as the best scoring runners-up. The Squires Kitchen and Hilton teams won their semifinals, with Boulangerie Jade chosen for the third spot in the final. The competition was won by the team from Squires Kitchen led by Mark Tilling with his former pupils Helen Vass and Samantha Rain.[10]

    Series 2

    The second series was filmed at Firle Place, East Sussex. It was presented by Angus Deayton, with Blin and Finden as the two returning judges.

    Ten teams competed in this series, some of whom also competed in the first series. Two teams competed in the final, which was between a returning team, the Military Chefs, and a team from Cocorico Patisserie of Cardiff.[11] The competition was won by the Military Chefs with Liam Grime the team captain and two other RAF chefs, Ian Mark and Chris Morrell.[12]

    Series 3

    The third series was moved to Channel 4 and retitled Bake Off: The Professionals, with Tom Allen and Liam Charles taking over as presenters.[13] It was again filmed at Firle Place, East Sussex, and Blin and Finden returned as judges.[14] Twelve teams, with only two pastry chefs in a team, competed in this series. The final was between three pairs: Emmanuel Bonneau and returning contestant Sam Leatherby from London Hilton on Park Lane, Darryl Collins and Bharat Chandegra from Resorts World in Birmingham and Hideko Kawa and Theo Beauchet, representing Sweet Art Lab in London. The competition was won by Emmanuel and Sam from London Hilton on Park Lane.[15]

    Series 4

    The fourth series was filmed at Firle Place, East Sussex The same presenters and judges returned for series 4, and again with 12 pairs of pastry chefs competing using the same format as series 3.[16] The competition was won by Thibault Marchand and Erica Sangiorgi from Kimpton Fitzroy London Hotel, beating teams from Pennyhill Park Hotel and South Place Hotel.[17]

    Series 5

    Bake Off: The Professionals returned for a fifth series on 25 May 2020 with 12 teams of pastry chefs.[18] The competition for 2020 was won by Laurian Veaudor and Thibault Courtoisier from Cocorico Patisserie, in Cardiff, beating Domenico and Alessandra from Park Plaza Westminster Bridge and Clanny and Ryan from The Ivy.[19]

    Series 6

    The show returned on 25 May 2021 with 12 teams of pastry chefs with the same presenters and judges.[20] Cardiff produced a second consecutive win as Michael Coggan and Andrew Minto from Gin & Bake took the silver platter, beating Julien Plumart from Brighton and The Lanesborough from London.[21]

    Series 7

    The seventh series premiered on 24 May 2022 with 12 pairs of pastry chefs, the same judges and Stacey Solomon replacing Tom Allen. The competition was won by London-based French pastry chefs Nathan Rave and Kevin Marmion, with I Shan and Jojo from Hotel Café Royal and Jemima and Zack from Puddles Bespoke Patisserie taking second place.

    Series 8

    The eighth series premiered on 4 July 2023 with 11 pairs of pastry chefs. Ellie Taylor replaced Stacey Solomon as new co-host.[22] The competition was won by the London-based Landmark team: Italian pastry chef Mauro Di Lieto and his teammate Daniel Schevenels from Belgium.

    Series 9

    The ninth series premiered on 10 June 2024 with 12 pairs of pastry chefs with the same presenters and judges.[23] The competition was won by London-based Tanuj and Narayan from the InterContinental London - The O2. Gerol and Michael from The Royal Air Force Club and Bharat and John from Soko Patisserie were runners-up.[24]

    Reception

    Early reviews were largely negative, with many reviewers comparing it unfavourably to The Great British Bake Off, suggesting that it had lost the crucial elements that made the original Bake Off a success.[25] Michael Hogan of The Daily Telegraph complained that the new show "bore no resemblance to it whatsoever, thus seemed to be merely piggybacking cynically on the Bake-Off "brand". He also found two of the judges' accents as well as the scoring system "impenetrable", the baking "bafflingly scientific" and the teams not "terribly likeable". He concluded that Creme de la Creme "was nice but dull", and that as "a Bake-Off spin-off, it was a soggy-bottomed disaster".[26] Many of the viewing public concurred with the assessments of the critics and found the show lacking the "charm, fun and warmth" of the original.[27] Chitra Ramaswamy of The Guardian thought that when the professional version of Bake Off becomes serious means that "it gets silly", and he "found the format convoluted, which telly like this should never be".[28] Gabriel Tate of The Times found the show a to be a "bloodless, uninvolving affair at once frenetically busy and yawningly free of incident, full of astounding technical proficiency and jawdropping invention, but devoid of passion and identity".[29]

    The version on Channel 4 was given a lukewarm reception by the critics. Although Michael Hogan of The Daily Telegraph considered the new pairing of Allen and Charles an improvement as presenters, he found it "lacking the warmth, wit and charm" of its parent programme.[30] Lucy Mangan of The Guardian thought that, unlike the original programme, the professional version failed to get viewers invested in the contestants, and that "watching professionals get it wrong" was "a cold, slightly embittering experience".[31] James Jackson of The Times described it as a "format fluff" that is "like a smaller, colder moon orbiting the warm Jupiter giant that is the GBBO mother show".[32]

    International versions

    The French version Le Meilleur Patissier: Les Professionnels is broadcast on M6.[33]

    Ratings

    The ratings figures are from BARB.[34]

    Series 1

    Episode
    no.
    Broadcast
    date
    Viewers
    (millions)
    BBC Two
    weekly ranking
    1 4.63 2
    2 4.09 2
    3 4.15 2
    4 3.81 2
    5 3.59 2
    6 3.59 1
    7 3.39 1
    8 3.68 1

    Series 2

    Episode
    no.
    Broadcast
    date
    Viewers
    (millions)
    BBC Two
    weekly ranking
    1 2.66 4
    2 2.85 3
    3 2.60 3
    4 2.66 1
    5 2.70 3
    6 2.49 3
    7 2.66 3
    8 2.22 6
    9 2.35 6

    Series 3

    Viewing figures for Channel 4 are total numbers including +1.

    Episode
    no.
    Broadcast
    date
    Viewers
    (millions)
    Channel 4
    weekly ranking
    1 2.21 4
    2 2.19 3
    3 2.29 2
    4 2.13 4
    5 1.52 7
    6 1.92 3
    7 1.84 4
    8 1.83 4
    9 1.59 5
    10 2.17 3

    Series 4

    Viewing figures given since September 2018 are total figures from multiple-screen viewings that include other viewing platforms in addition to television, such as computers and smartphones.[35]

    Episode
    no.
    Broadcast
    date
    Viewers
    (millions)[36]
    Channel 4
    weekly ranking
    1 2.38 2
    2 2.04 2
    3 1.83 4
    4 2.17 3
    5 1.71 4
    6 2.18 1
    7 2.09 3
    8 1.92 6
    9 1.94 7
    10 2.05 4

    Series 5

    Episode
    no.
    Broadcast
    date
    Viewers
    (millions)
    Channel 4
    weekly ranking
    1 2.97 3
    2 2.84 3
    3 2.82 5
    4 2.49 2
    5 2.60 2
    6 2.91 2
    7 2.75 2
    8 2.81 2
    9 2.67 1
    10 2.86 1

    Series 6

    Episode
    no.
    Broadcast
    date
    Viewers
    (millions)
    Channel 4
    weekly ranking
    1 3.02 1
    2 2.50 2
    3 2.20 2
    4 2.28 2
    5 1.88 6
    6 2.16 2
    7 1.92 3
    8 2.16 3
    9 2.28 2
    10 2.34 2

    Series 7

    Ratings from this series onward are 7-day consolidated and exclude viewership on devices.

    Episode
    no.
    Broadcast
    date
    Viewers
    (millions)
    Channel 4
    weekly ranking
    1 2.06 2 [37]
    2 1.75 4 [38]
    3 1.81 5 [39]
    4 1.78 6 [40]
    5 1.74 5 [41]
    6
    7
    8 1.63 4 [42]
    9 1.73 1 [43]
    10 1.49 1 [44]

    Notes and References

    1. News: Everything you need to know about Bake Off: Creme de la Creme . Saffron. Alexander . 29 March 2016 . The Daily Telegraph. subscription.
    2. News: Harrison. Ellie. Bake Off spin-off Crème de la Crème will also leave the BBC for Channel 4. https://web.archive.org/web/20180430053356/http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2017-10-20/bake-off-spin-off-creme-de-la-creme-will-also-leave-the-bbc-for-channel-4/ . 30 April 2018 . 21 November 2017. Radio Times. en.
    3. News: Great British Bake Off gets professional spin-off show . 2 December 2015 . BBC .
    4. News: Bake Off Creme de la Creme is staying on the BBC – with a new host . Radio Times. 20 January 2017 .
    5. Web site: Tom Allen joins Bake Off : News 2018 : Chortle : The UK Comedy Guide. www.chortle.co.uk.
    6. Web site: Team Tilling crowned winners of BBC2's Bake Off: Crème de la Crème . The Caterer . Lisa Jenkins . 17 May 2016 .
    7. Web site: Bake Off: The Professionals . Jane . Rackham . Radio Times .
    8. Web site: Hosts with the most: Bake Off: The Professionals . 3 May 2018. The Great British Bake Off .
    9. Web site: The grand home of Bake Off Crème de la Crème - Welbeck Abbey . 29 March 2016 . Radio Times .
    10. Web site: Bake Off: Crème de la Crème – the final. Howard . Middleton . 18 May 2016 . Great British Chefs.
    11. Web site: Cardiff's Cocorico Patisserie have narrowly lost out in the final of Bake Off: Creme de la Creme . Wales Online . 31 May 2017 . Nathan . Bevan .
    12. Web site: Military team triumphs as winner of Bake Off: Crème de la Crème . Lisa . Jenkins . The Caterer . 31 May 2017 .
    13. News: Bake Off The Professionals: Who are presenters Liam Charles and Tom Allen? . Caroline . Westbrook. 6 May 2018. Metro .
    14. News: Bake Off: The Professionals start date, presenters and who are the judges? . Caroline . Westbrook. 1 May 2018. Metro .
    15. News: Who are the winners of Bake Off: The Professionals 2018?. 2018-07-09. en.
    16. Web site: Everything you need to know about Bake Off: The Professionals . 30 April 2019 . Emmy. Griffiths. Hello! .
    17. News: Bake Off: The Professionals winners crowned after grueling 11-hour challenge . Emily . Baker. 15 June 2019. Metro .
    18. Web site: Meet the teams on Bake Off: The Professionals 2020 . Emma . Bullimore. 19 May 2020. Radio Times.
    19. News: Bake Off: The Professionals winner is Cardiff-based Cocorico Patisserie. Katie-Ann. Gupwell. 28 July 2020 . Wales Online.
    20. Web site: Meet the contestants on Bake Off: The professionals . Hello! . 25 May 2021 . Francesca . Shillcock .
    21. News: Cardiff pastry chefs win Bake Off: The Professionals. Ffion. Lewis. 27 July 2021 . Wales Online.
    22. Web site: Bake Off: The Professionals 2023 cast - Confirmed contestants for new season. radiotimes.com. 12 July 2023.
    23. Web site: Bake Off: The Professionals 2024 - who are the hosts, judges and line-up?. uk.news.yahoo.com. 11 June 2024. 12 June 2024.
    24. Web site: Bake Off: The Professionals crowns 2024 winners. digitalspy.com. 9 July 2024.
    25. Web site: Bake Off: Creme de la Creme gets a creaming from the critics . 30 March 2016 . The Week .
    26. News: Bake Off Crème de la Crème, review: 'a soggy-bottomed disaster' . Michael. Hogan . 30 March 2016 . The Daily Telegraph. subscription.
    27. News: Bake Off: Crème de la Crème is The Great British Bake Off without the 'charm, fun and warmth' according to Twitter . Jack . Shepherd . 30 March 2016 . The Independent .
    28. News: Three teams of professional pastry chefs compete in the Bake Off: Crème de la Crème . Chitra. Ramaswamy. 30 March 2016. The Guardian.
    29. News: Bake Off: Creme de la Creme; The A Word . Gabriel . Tate . 30 March 2016 . The Times. subscription.
    30. News: Bake Off: the Professionals – lacking in warmth and wit, review . Michael. Hogan . 6 May 2018 . The Daily Telegraph. subscription.
    31. News: Bake Off: The Professionals review – an infuriating imitation of the real thing . Lucy . Mangan. 30 April 2019 . The Guardian.
    32. News: TV review: Bake Off — The Professionals; In Sight of Home . James . Jackson. The Times . 1 May 2019. subscription.
    33. Web site: RECAP - Le Meilleur pâtissier : les professionnels (M6) : Et le gagnant est.... 18 June 2018 . Télé7 Jours .
    34. Web site: Weekly Top 10 Programmes. Broadcasters' Audience Research Board (BARB).
    35. Web site: Multiple-screen viewing FAQs . BARB .
    36. Web site: Four-screen dashboard . BARB .
    37. Web site: Top programmes report - week 21, May 23–29 - Channel 4. Thinkbox . 6 June 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220606224842/https://www.thinkbox.tv/research/barb-data/top-programmes-report/?tag=CH4 . 6 June 2022.
    38. Web site: Top programmes report - week 22, May 30 - June 05 - Channel 4. Thinkbox . 14 June 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220614133512/https://www.thinkbox.tv/research/barb-data/top-programmes-report/?tag=CH4 . 14 June 2022.
    39. Web site: Top programmes report - week 23, June 06–12 - Channel 4. Thinkbox . 20 June 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220620151606/https://www.thinkbox.tv/research/barb-data/top-programmes-report/?tag=CH4 . 20 June 2022.
    40. Web site: Top programmes report - week 24, June 13–19 - Channel 4. Thinkbox . 20 June 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220629164046/https://www.thinkbox.tv/research/barb-data/top-programmes-report/?tag=CH4 . 29 June 2022.
    41. Web site: Top programmes report - week 25, June 20–26 - Channel 4. Thinkbox . 4 July 2022 . 5 July 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220705154219/https://www.thinkbox.tv/research/barb-data/top-programmes-report/?tag=CH4 . 5 July 2022.
    42. Web site: Top programmes report - week 28, July 11–17 - Channel 4. Thinkbox . 25 July 2022 . 1 August 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220801005123/https://www.thinkbox.tv/research/barb-data/top-programmes-report/?tag=CH4 . 1 August 2022.
    43. Web site: Top programmes report - week 29, July 18–24 - Channel 4 (cached). Thinkbox . 1 August 2022 . 8 August 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220808145634/https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:WLeQacyhkGEJ:https://www.thinkbox.tv/research/barb-data/top-programmes-report/%3Ftag%3DCH4+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk . 8 August 2022.
    44. Web site: Top programmes report - week 30, July 25–31 - Channel 4. Thinkbox . 8 August 2022 . 8 August 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220808144837/https://www.thinkbox.tv/research/barb-data/top-programmes-report/?tag=CH4 . 8 August 2022.