Bajo Nuevo Bank Explained

Disputed:yes
Bajo Nuevo Bank
Type:reef and island
Plural:yes
Other Names:Petrel Islands
Pushpin Map:Caribbean#Colombia San Andrés y Providencia#Colombia
Location:Caribbean Sea
Length Km:26
Width Km:9
Elevation M:2
Highest Mount:Unnamed location on Low Cay
Country Admin Divisions Title:Department
Country Admin Divisions:San Andres and Providencia
Population:0

Bajo Nuevo Bank, also known as the Petrel Islands (Spanish; Castilian: Bajo Nuevo, Islas Petrel), is a small, uninhabited reef with some small grass-covered islets, located in the western Caribbean Sea at, with a lighthouse on Low Cay at . The closest neighbouring land feature is Serranilla Bank, located 110km (70miles) to the west.

The reef was first shown on Dutch maps dating to 1634 but was given its present name in 1654. Bajo Nuevo was rediscovered by the English pirate John Glover in 1660. The reef is now subject to a sovereignty dispute involving Colombia and the United States. On 19 November 2012, in regard to Nicaraguan claims to the islands, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) found, unanimously, that the Republic of Colombia has sovereignty over both Bajo Nuevo and Serranilla Banks, although the judgment does not analyze or mention the competing claims of Honduras or United States.[1]

Geography

Bajo Nuevo Bank is about 26km (16miles) long and 9km (06miles) wide. The satellite image shows two distinct atoll-like structures separated by a deep channel 1.4km (00.9miles) wide at its narrowest point. The larger southwestern reef complex measures 15.4km (09.6miles) northeast-southwest, and is up to 9.4km (05.8miles) wide, covering an area of about 1000NaN0. The reef partially dries on the southern and eastern sides. The smaller northeastern reef complex measures 10.5km (06.5miles) east-west and is up to 5.5km (03.4miles) wide, covering an area of 450NaN0. The land area is minuscule by comparison.

The most prominent cay is Low Cay, in the southwestern atoll. It is 300m (1,000feet) long and 40m (130feet) wide (about 1abbr=onNaNabbr=on), no more than 2m (07feet) high, and barren. It is composed of broken coral, driftwood, and sand. The light beacon on Low Cay is a 21m (69feet) metal tower, painted white with a red top. It emits a focal plane beam of light as two white flashes of light every 15 seconds. The beacon was erected in 1982,[2] and reconstructed by the Colombian Ministry of Defence in February 2008. It is currently maintained by the Colombian Navy, and overseen by the state's Maritime Authority.[3] [4]

Territorial dispute

Bajo Nuevo Bank is the subject of conflicting claims made by a number of sovereign states. In most cases, the dispute stems from attempts by a state to expand its exclusive economic zone over the surrounding seas.

Colombia currently claims the area as part of the department of Archipelago of San Andrés, Providencia and Santa Catalina.[5] [6] Naval patrols in the area are carried out by the San Andrés fleet of the Colombian Navy.[7] Colombia maintains that it has claimed these territories since 1886, as part of the geographic archipelago of San Andrés and Providencia. This date is disputed by other claimant states, who argue that Colombia had not claimed the territory by name until recently.[8]

Jamaica's claim has been resolved since entering into a number of bilateral agreements with Colombia. Between 1982 and 1986, the two states maintained a formal agreement which granted regulated fishing rights to Jamaican vessels within the territorial waters of Bajo Nuevo and nearby Serranilla Bank.[9] [10] Jamaica's signing of this treaty was regarded by critics as a de facto recognition of Colombian sovereignty over the two banks. However, the treaty is now extinguished, as Colombia declined to renew it upon its expiration in August 1986.

In November 1993, Colombia and Jamaica agreed upon a maritime delimitation treaty establishing the Joint Regime Area to cooperatively manage and exploit living and non-living resources in designated waters between the two aforementioned banks.[11] However, the territorial waters immediately surrounding the cays themselves were excluded from the zone of joint-control, as Colombia considers these areas to be part of its coastal waters.[12] [13] The exclusion circles were defined in the chart attached to the treaty as "Colombia's territorial sea in Serranilla and Bajo Nuevo". The agreement came into force in March 1994.

Nicaragua formerly claimed all the islands on its continental shelf, covering an area of over 50,000 km2 in the Caribbean Sea, including Bajo Nuevo Bank and all islands associated with the San Andrés and Providencia archipelagoes. It had persistently pursued this claim against Colombia in the International Court of Justice (ICJ), filing cases in both 2001 and 2007.[14] The dispute originated in the debated validity and applicability of the Esguerr–Bárcenas treaty, exchanged with Colombia in March 1928. Nicaragua formally accepted the ICJ's 2012 ruling of Colombian sovereignty in a 2014 constitutional amendment.[15]

The United States claim was made on 22 November 1869 by James W. Jennett[16] under the provisions of the Guano Islands Act.[17] Most claims made by the U.S. over the guano islands in this region were officially renounced in a treaty with Colombia, dated September 1972.[18] However, Bajo Nuevo Bank was not mentioned in the treaty, and Article 7 of the treaty states that matters not specifically mentioned in the treaty are not subject to its terms. The United States considers the bank an insular area.[19]

Honduras, prior to its ratification of a maritime boundary treaty with Colombia on 20 December 1999,[20] had previously also laid claim to Bajo Nuevo and nearby Serranilla Bank. Both states agreed upon a maritime demarcation in 1986 that excluded Honduras from any control over the banks or their surrounding waters.[21] [22] [23] This bilateral treaty ensured that Honduras implicitly recognises Colombia's sovereignty over the disputed territories. Honduras's legal right to hand over these areas was disputed by Nicaragua before the ICJ.[24] [25]

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Territorial and maritime dispute (Nicaragua vs Colombia) . 2012 . 2012-11-27 . International Court of Justice . International Court of Justice .
  2. Web site: Anexo 7 . Colombian Government, Ministry of National Defence . August 1997 . 2009-12-22 . es . dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20111009153834/http://www.coralina.gov.co/archivos/archi19.pdf . 9 October 2011 . Legal status of the Banks of Serranilla and Bajo Nuevo, page 8.
  3. Web site: Contract No. 153 . Colombian Government, Ministry of National Defence . February 2008 . 2009-10-23 . es . dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20110707053952/http://www.contratos.gov.co/archivospuc1/2008/C/115001007/08-11-78323/C_PROCESO_08-11-78323_115001007_755461.pdf . 7 July 2011 . Contract detail between Colombian Defence Ministry and private contractor, Tecnosoluciones Ltda, for the replacement of various metal lighthouse structures, including on Bajo Nuevo Bank.
  4. Web site: Grupo de Señalización Marítima del Caribe. Colombian Government, Ministry of National Defence. May 2008. 2009-11-16. es. https://web.archive.org/web/20110707053317/http://www.dimar.mil.co/vbeContent/library/documents/DocNewsNo5625DocumentNo4811.pdf. 7 July 2011. dead. Photographs of Colombian lighthouses, with Bajo Nuevo Bank shown, pages 4–5.
  5. Web site: Historia del Departamento Archipiélago . Government of the San Andrés Department . 2008 . 2009-12-20 . es . dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20110707053739/http://www.sanandres.gov.co/historia.html . 7 July 2011 . Description and general history of the Department of San Andrés, Providencia and Santa Catalina.
  6. Web site: Mapa Oficial Fronteras Terrestriales y Maritima Convenciones . . 2009-10-25 . An official map of Colombian borders, with treaty dates.
  7. Armada de la República de Colombia: Forces and Commands – area is under the jurisdiction of Comando Específico de San Andrés y Providencia.
  8. Web site: Territorial and Maritime Dispute. International Court of Justice. December 2007. 2009-11-17. Nicaragua v. Colombia, Preliminary Objections.
  9. Web site: Fishing Agreement Between Jamaica and the Republic of Colombia. United Nations. November 1982. 2009-11-20. Fishing agreement which permits regulated fishing rights to Jamaican vessels around Bajo Nuevo and Serranilla Banks.
  10. Book: Charney . Jonathan . American Society of International Law . American Society of International Law . International Maritime Boundaries, Vol. 2–3 . . 2004 . Boston, United States . 2616 . p2179-2192 . 978-90-411-0345-1.
  11. https://www.un.org/Depts/los/LEGISLATIONANDTREATIES/PDFFILES/TREATIES/JAM-COL1993MD.PDF Colombia Jamaica Joint Regime Treaty
  12. Web site: Sentencia No. C-045/94 . Government of Colombia, Secretaría del Senado . February 1994 . 2009-11-22 . es . dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20110707053609/http://www.secretariasenado.gov.co/senado/basedoc/cc_sc_nf/1994/c-045_1994.html . 7 July 2011 . Review of the 1993 Maritime Delimitation Treaty between Colombia and Jamaica.
  13. Web site: Continental, Coastal and Marine Ecosystems of Colombia, 1 of 36. José Benito Vives de Andréis Marine and Coastal Research Institute (INVEMAR). 2001. 2009-12-22. Topographic map of the Colombia-Jamaica Joint-Regime Area, with the two exclusion circles shown.
  14. http://www.icj-cij.org/docket/index.php?pr=567&p1=3&p2=1&case=124&p3=6 International Court of Justice: Nicaragua v. Colombia
  15. Web site: Nicaragua 1987 (rev. 2014) Constitution - Constitute . 2023-12-13 . www.constituteproject.org . en.
  16. Book: Moore . John Bassett . United States Government, Department of State . United States Department of State . A Digest of International Law, Vol. 8 . . 1906 . Washington, United States . 788 . p77 . 978-1-4432-8111-9.
  17. Web site: Acquisition Process of Insular Areas . . 2008-01-13 . dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20120414172502/http://www.doi.gov/oia/Islandpages/acquisition_process.htm . 14 April 2012 . Lists Bajo Nuevo Bank as an insular area under U.S. sovereignty.
  18. Treaty of exchange between Colombia and the United States, 1972
  19. Web site: Application of the U.S. Constitution . . November 1997 . 2008-01-13 . https://web.archive.org/web/20080216015423/http://www.gao.gov/archive/1998/og98005.pdf. 16 February 2008 . live. Page 39 states that U.S. sovereignty over Bajo Nuevo is disputed. "Currently, the United States conducts maritime law enforcement operations in and around Serranilla Bank and Bajo Nuevo consistent with U.S. sovereignty claims." This is the only archived document from this source that mentions Bajo Nuevo Bank as an insular area.
  20. Affirmation of Maritime Delimitation Treaty between Honduras and Colombia, 1999
  21. Treaty between Colombia and Honduras, 1986
  22. Republic of Honduras: Political Constitution of 1982 through 2005 reforms
  23. http://www.asil.org/insights071017.cfm The American Society of International Law
  24. http://www.munuc.org/munucxvii/pdfs/ICJ_A.pdf The Republic of Nicaragua v. The Republic of Colombia, CCJ Case File
  25. http://www1.american.edu/ted/ice/nicaragua-honduras.htm Nicaragua-Honduras Territorial Dispute