Babur Explained

Babur
Ghazi[1]
Succession:Mughal Emperor (Padishah)
Predecessor:Ibrahim Lodhi (as sultan of Delhi)
Successor:Humayun
Succession1:Amir of Kabul
Reign1:October 1504[2] –21 April 1526
Predecessor1:Mukin Begh
Successor1:Himself as the Mughal Emperor
Succession2:Amir of Ferghana
Reign2:10 June 1494–1497
Predecessor2:Umar Sheikh Mirza
Birth Date:14 February 1483
Birth Place:Andijan, Timurid Empire
Death Place:Agra, Mughal Empire
Burial Place:Gardens of Babur, Kabul, Afghanistan
Spouse-Type:Consort
Spouses:
    Spouses-Type:Wives
    more...
    Issue:
    Issue-Link:
    1. Issue
    Issue-Pipe:more...
    Full Name:Zahīr ud-Dīn Muhammad Bābur
    Posthumous Name:Firdaws Makani (Dwelling in Paradise)
    House:House of Babur
    Dynasty:Timurid dynasty
    Father:Umar Shaikh Mirza II
    Mother:Qutlugh Nigar Khanum
    Signature:Detail of Babur's dynastic seal, from a Mughal land grant dating from August 1527.jpg
    Signature Type:Seal
    Religion:Sunni Islam[3]

    Babur (in Persian βɑː.βuɾ/; 14 February 148326 December 1530; born Zahīr ud-Dīn Muhammad) was the founder of the Mughal Empire in the Indian subcontinent. He was a descendant of Timur and Genghis Khan through his father and mother respectively.[4] [5] He was also given the posthumous name of Firdaws Makani ('Dwelling in Paradise').[6]

    Born in Andijan in the Fergana Valley (now in Uzbekistan), Babur was the eldest son of Umar Shaikh Mirza II (1456–1494, governor of Fergana from 1469 to 1494) and a great-great-great-grandson of Timur (1336–1405). Babur ascended the throne of Fergana in its capital Akhsikath in 1494 at the age of twelve and faced rebellion. He conquered Samarkand two years later, only to lose Fergana soon after. In his attempt to reconquer Fergana, he lost control of Samarkand. In 1501, his attempt to recapture both the regions failed when the Uzbek prince Muhammad Shaybani defeated him and founded the Khanate of Bukhara.

    In 1504, he conquered Kabul, which was under the putative rule of Abdur Razaq Mirza, the infant heir of Ulugh Beg II. Babur formed a partnership with the Safavid emperor Ismail I and reconquered parts of Turkestan, including Samarkand, only to again lose it and the other newly conquered lands to the Shaybanids.

    After losing Samarkand for the third time, Babur turned his attention to India and employed aid from the neighbouring Safavid and Ottoman empires.[7] He defeated Ibrahim Lodi, the Sultan of Delhi, at the First Battle of Panipat in 1526 and founded the Mughal Empire. Before the defeat of Lodi at Delhi, the Sultanate of Delhi had been a spent force, long in a state of decline.

    The rival adjacent Kingdom of Mewar under the rule of Rana Sanga had become the most powerful native power in North India.[8] [9] [10] [11] Sanga unified several Rajput clans for the first time after Prithviraj Chauhan and advanced on Babur with a grand coalition of 80,000-100,000 Rajputs, engaging Babur in the Battle of Khanwa. Babur arrived at Khanwa with 40,000-50,000 soldiers. Nonetheless, Sanga suffered a major defeat due to Babur's skillful troop positioning and use of gunpowder, specifically matchlocks and small cannons.[12]

    The Battle of Khanwa was one of the most decisive battles in Indian history, more so than the First Battle of Panipat, as the defeat of Rana Sanga was a watershed event in the Mughal conquest of North India.[13] [14]

    Religiously, Babur started his life as a staunch Sunni Muslim, but he underwent significant evolution. Babur became more tolerant as he conquered new territories and grew older, allowing other religions to peacefully coexist in his empire and at his court.[15] He also displayed a certain attraction to theology, poetry, geography, history, and biology—disciplines he promoted at his court—earning him a frequent association with representatives of the Timurid Renaissance.[16] His religious and philosophical stances are characterized as humanistic.[17]

    Babur married several times. Notable among his children are Humayun, Kamran Mirza, Hindal Mirza, Masuma Sultan Begum, and the author Gulbadan Begum.

    Babur died in 1530 in Agra and Humayun succeeded him. Babur was first buried in Agra but, as per his wishes, his remains were moved to Kabul and reburied. He ranks as a national hero in Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan. Many of his poems have become popular folk songs. He wrote the Baburnama in Chaghatai Turkic; it was translated into Persian during the reign (1556–1605) of his grandson, the emperor Akbar.

    Name

    Ẓahīr-ud-Dīn is Arabic for "Defender of the Faith" (of Islam), and Muhammad honours the Islamic prophet. The name was chosen for Babur by the Sufi saint Khwaja Ahrar, who was the spiritual master of his father.[18] The difficulty of pronouncing the name for his Central Asian Turco-Mongol army may have been responsible for the greater popularity of his nickname Babur, also variously spelled Baber, Babar, and Bābor. The name is generally taken in reference to the Persian word babur, meaning "tiger" or "panther".[19] The word repeatedly appears in Ferdowsi's Shahnameh and was borrowed into the Turkic languages of Central Asia.[20]

    Background

    Babur's memoirs form the main source for details of his life. They are known as the Baburnama and were written in Chagatai, his first language,[21] though, according to Dale, "his Turkic prose is highly Persianized in its sentence structure, morphology or word formation and vocabulary."[22] Baburnama was translated into Persian during the rule of Babur's grandson Akbar.

    Babur was born on 14 February 1483 in the city of Andijan, Fergana Valley, contemporary Uzbekistan. He was the eldest son of Umar Shaikh Mirza II,[23] ruler of the Fergana Valley, the son of Abū Saʿīd Mirza (and grandson of Miran Shah, who was himself son of Timur) and his wife Qutlugh Nigar Khanum, daughter of Yunus Khan, the ruler of Moghulistan (a descendant of Genghis Khan).[24]

    Babur hailed from the Barlas tribe, which was of Mongol origin and had embraced the Turco-Persian tradition[25] They had also converted to Islam centuries earlier and resided in Turkestan and Khorasan.

    Aside from the Chaghatai language, Babur was equally fluent in Classical Persian, the lingua franca of the Timurid elite.[26]

    Some of Babur's relatives, such as his uncles Mahmud Khan (Moghul Khan) and Ahmad Khan, continued to identify as Mongols, and allowed him to use their Mongol troops to help recover his fortunes in the turbulent years that followed.[27]

    Hence, Babur, though nominally a Mongol (or Moghul in Persian language), drew much of his support from the local Turkic and Iranian people of Central Asia, and his army was diverse in its ethnic makeup. It included Sarts, Tajiks, ethnic Afghans, Arabs, as well as Barlas and Chaghatayid Turko-Mongols from Central Asia.[28]

    Ruler of Central Asia

    As ruler of Fergana

    In 1494, eleven-year-old Babur became the ruler of Fergana, in present-day Uzbekistan, after Umar Sheikh Mirza died "while tending pigeons in an ill-constructed dovecote that toppled into the ravine below the palace".[29] During this time, two of his uncles from the neighbouring kingdoms, who were hostile to his father, and a group of nobles who wanted his younger brother Jahangir to be the ruler, threatened his succession to the throne. His uncles were relentless in their attempts to dislodge him from this position as well as from many of his other territorial possessions to come.[30] Babur was able to secure his throne mainly because of help from his maternal grandmother, Aisan Daulat Begum, although there was also some luck involved.

    Most territories around his kingdom were ruled by his relatives, who were descendants of either Timur or Genghis Khan, and were constantly in conflict. At that time, rival princes were fighting over the city of Samarkand to the west, which was ruled by his paternal cousin. Babur had a great ambition to capture the city. In 1497, he besieged Samarkand for seven months before eventually gaining control over it.[31] He was fifteen years old and for him the campaign was a huge achievement. Babur was able to hold the city despite desertions in his army, but he later fell seriously ill. Meanwhile, a rebellion back home, approximately 350km (220miles) away, amongst nobles who favoured his brother, robbed him of Fergana. As he was marching to recover it, he lost Samarkand to a rival prince, leaving him with neither. He had held Samarkand for 100 days, and he considered this defeat as his biggest loss, obsessing over it even later in his life after his conquests in India.

    For three years, Babur concentrated on building a strong army, recruiting widely amongst the Tajiks of Badakhshan in particular. In 1500–1501, he again laid siege to Samarkand, and indeed he took the city briefly, but he was in turn besieged by his most formidable rival, Muhammad Shaybani, Khan of the Uzbeks.[32] The situation became such that Babar was compelled to give his sister, Khanzada, to Shaybani in marriage as part of the peace settlement. Only after this were Babur and his troops allowed to depart the city in safety. Samarkand, his lifelong obsession, was thus lost again. He then tried to reclaim Fergana, but lost the battle there also and, escaping with a small band of followers, he wandered the mountains of central Asia and took refuge with hill tribes. By 1502, he had resigned all hopes of recovering Fergana; he was left with nothing and was forced to try his luck elsewhere.[33] He finally went to Tashkent, which was ruled by his maternal uncle, but he found himself less than welcome there. Babur wrote, "During my stay in Tashkent, I endured much poverty and humiliation. No country, or hope of one!" Thus, during the ten years since becoming the ruler of Fergana, Babur suffered many short-lived victories and was without shelter and in exile, aided by friends and peasants.

    At Kabul

    Kabul was ruled by Babur's paternal uncle Ulugh Beg II, who died leaving only an infant as heir. The city was then claimed by Mukin Begh, who was considered to be a usurper and was opposed by the local populace. In 1504, Babur was able to cross the snowy Hindu Kush mountains and capture Kabul from the remaining Arghunids, who were forced to retreat to Kandahar. With this move, he gained a new kingdom, re-established his fortunes and would remain its ruler until 1526. In 1505, because of the low revenue generated by his new mountain kingdom, Babur began his first expedition to India; in his memoirs, he wrote, "My desire for Hindustan had been constant. It was in the month of Shaban, the Sun being in Aquarius, that we rode out of Kabul for Hindustan". It was a brief raid across the Khyber Pass.

    In the same year, Babur united with Sultan Husayn Mirza Bayqarah of Herat, a fellow Timurid and distant relative, against their common enemy, the Uzbek Shaybani.[34] However, this venture did not take place because Husayn Mirza died in 1506 and his two sons were reluctant to go to war. Babur instead stayed at Herat after being invited by the two Mirza brothers. It was then the cultural capital of the eastern Muslim world. Though he was disgusted by the vices and luxuries of the city, he marvelled at the intellectual abundance there, which he stated was "filled with learned and matched men".[35] He became acquainted with the work of the Chagatai poet Mir Ali Shir Nava'i, who encouraged the use of Chagatai as a literary language. Nava'i's proficiency with the language, which he is credited with founding,[36] may have influenced Babur in his decision to use it for his memoirs. He spent two months there before being forced to leave because of diminishing resources; it later was overrun by Shaybani and the Mirzas fled.Babur became the only reigning ruler of the Timurid dynasty after the loss of Herat, and many princes sought refuge with him at Kabul because of Shaybani's invasion in the west. He thus assumed the title of Padshah (emperor) among the Timurids—though this title was insignificant since most of his ancestral lands were taken, Kabul itself was in danger and Shaybani continued to be a threat. Babur prevailed during a potential rebellion in Kabul, but two years later a revolt among some of his leading generals drove him out of Kabul. Escaping with very few companions, Babur soon returned to the city, capturing Kabul again and regaining the allegiance of the rebels. Meanwhile, Shaybani was defeated and killed by Ismail I, Shah of Shia Safavid Persia, in 1510.[37]

    Babur and the remaining Timurids used this opportunity to reconquer their ancestral territories. Over the following few years, Babur and Shah Ismail formed a partnership in an attempt to take over parts of Central Asia. In return for Ismail's assistance, Babur permitted the Safavids to act as a suzerain over him and his followers.[38] Thus, in 1513, after leaving his brother Nasir Mirza to rule Kabul, he managed to take Samarkand for the third time; he also took Bokhara but lost both again to the Uzbeks. Shah Ismail reunited Babur with his sister Khānzāda, who had been imprisoned by and forced to marry the recently deceased Shaybani.[39] Babur returned to Kabul after three years in 1514. The following 11 years of his rule mainly involved dealing with relatively insignificant rebellions from Afghan tribes, his nobles and relatives, in addition to conducting raids across the eastern mountains. Babur began to modernise and train his army despite it being, for him, relatively peaceful times.

    Foreign relations

    Determined to conquer the Uzbeks and recapture his ancestral homeland, Babur was wary of their allies the Ottomans, and made no attempt to establish formal diplomatic relations with them. He did, however, employ the matchlock commander Mustafa Rumi and several other Ottomans.[40] From them, he adopted the tactic of using matchlocks and cannons in the field (rather than only in sieges), which gave him an important advantage in India.

    Formation of the Mughal Empire

    See main article: Lodi dynasty, Delhi Sultanate and Siege of Kabul (1504).

    Babur still wanted to escape from the Uzbeks, and he chose India as a refuge instead of Badakhshan, which was to the north of Kabul. He wrote, "In the presence of such power and potency, we had to think of some place for ourselves and, at this crisis and in the crack of time there was, put a wider space between us and the strong foeman." After his third loss of Samarkand, Babur gave full attention to the conquest of North India, launching a campaign; he reached the Chenab River, now in Pakistan, in 1519. Until 1524, his aim was to only expand his rule to Punjab, mainly to fulfill the legacy of his ancestor Timur, since it used to be part of his empire. At the time parts of North India were part of the Delhi Sultanate, ruled by Ibrahim Lodi of the Lodi dynasty, but the sultanate was crumbling and there were many defectors. Babur received invitations from Daulat Khan Lodi, Governor of Punjab and Ala-ud-Din, uncle of Ibrahim.[41] He sent an ambassador to Ibrahim, claiming himself the rightful heir to the throne, but the ambassador was detained at Lahore, Punjab, and released months later.

    Babur started for Lahore in 1524 but found that Daulat Khan Lodi had been driven out by forces sent by Ibrahim Lodi.[42] When Babur arrived at Lahore, the Lodi army marched out and his army was routed. In response, Babur burned Lahore for two days, then marched to Dibalpur, placing Alam Khan, another rebel uncle of Lodi, as governor. Alam Khan was quickly overthrown and fled to Kabul. In response, Babur supplied Alam Khan with troops who later joined up with Daulat Khan Lodi, and together with about 30,000 troops, they besieged Ibrahim Lodi at Delhi. The sultan easily defeated and drove off Alam's army, and Babur realised that he would not allow him to occupy the Punjab.

    First battle of Panipat

    See main article: First Battle of Panipat.

    In November 1525 Babur got news at Peshawar that Daulat Khan Lodi had switched sides, and Babur drove out Ala-ud-Din. Babur then marched onto Lahore to confront Daulat Khan Lodi, only to see Daulat's army melt away at their approach. Daulat surrendered and was pardoned. Thus within three weeks of crossing the Indus River Babur had become the master of Punjab.[43]

    Babur marched on to Delhi via Sirhind. He reached Panipat on 20 April 1526 and there met Ibrahim Lodi's numerically superior army of about 100,000 soldiers and 100 elephants. In the battle that began on the following day, Babur used the tactic of Tulugma, encircling Ibrahim Lodi's army and forcing it to face artillery fire directly, as well as frightening its war elephants. Ibrahim Lodi died during the battle, thus ending the Lodi dynasty.

    Babur wrote in his memoirs about his victory:

    After the battle, Babur occupied Delhi and Agra, took the throne of Lodi, and laid the foundation for the eventual rise of Mughal rule in India. However, before he became North India's ruler, he had to fend off challengers, such as Rana Sanga.

    Many of Babur's men allegedly wanted to leave India due to its warm climate, but Babur motivated them to stay and expand his empire.

    Battle of Khanwa

    See main article: Battle of Khanwa.

    The Battle of Khanwa was fought between Babur and the Rajput ruler of Mewar, Rana Sanga on 16 March 1527. Rana Sanga wanted to overthrow Babur, whom he considered to be a foreigner ruling in India, and also to extend the Rajput territories by annexing Delhi and Agra. He was supported by Afghan chiefs who felt Babur had been deceptive by refusing to fulfil promises made to them. Upon receiving news of Rana Sangha's advance towards Agra, Babur took a defensive position at Khanwa (currently in the Indian state of Rajasthan), from where he hoped to launch a counterattack later. According to K.V. Krishna Rao, Babur won the battle because of his "superior generalship" and modern tactics; the battle was one of the first in India that featured cannons and muskets. Rao also notes that Rana Sanga faced "treachery" when the Hindu chief Silhadi joined Babur's army with a garrison of 6,000 soldiers.[44]

    Babur recognised Sanga's skill in leadership, calling him one of the two greatest non-Muslim Indian kings of the time, the other being Krishnadevaraya of Vijayanagara.

    Battle of Chanderi

    The Battle of Chanderi took place the year after the Battle of Khanwa. On receiving news that Rana Sanga had made preparations to renew the conflict with him, Babur decided to isolate the Rana by defeating one of his staunchest allies, Medini Rai, who was the ruler of Malwa.[45] [46]

    Upon reaching Chanderi, on 20 January 1528, Babur offered Shamsabad to Medini Rao in exchange for Chanderi as a peace overture, but the offer was rejected. The outer fortress of Chanderi was taken by Babur's army at night, and the next morning the upper fort was captured. Babur himself expressed surprise that the upper fort had fallen within an hour of the final assault. Seeing no hope of victory, Medini Rai organized a jauhar, during which women and children within the fortress immolated themselves.[45] A small number of soldiers also collected in Medini Rao's house and killed each other in collective suicide. This sacrifice does not seem to have impressed Babur, who did not express a word of admiration for the enemy in his autobiography.

    Religious policy

    Babur defeated and killed Ibrahim Lodi, the last Sultan of the Lodi dynasty, in 1526. Babur ruled for 4 years and was succeeded by his son Humayun whose reign was temporarily usurped by the Suri dynasty. During their 30-year rule, religious violence continued in India. Records of the violence and trauma, from Sikh-Muslim perspective, include those recorded in Sikh literature of the 16th century.[47] The violence of Babur in the 1520s was witnessed by Guru Nanak, who commented upon it in four hymns. Historians suggest the early Mughal period of religious violence contributed to introspection and then the transformation in Sikhism from pacifism to militancy for self-defense.[47] According to Babur's autobiography, Baburnama, his campaign in northwest India targeted Hindus and Sikhs as well as apostates (non-Sunni sects of Islam), and an immense number were killed, with Muslim camps building "towers of skulls of the infidels" on hillocks.[48]

    Personal life and relationships

    There are no descriptions about Babur's physical appearance, except from the paintings in the translation of the Baburnama prepared during the reign of Akbar. In his autobiography, Babur claimed to be strong and physically fit, and that he had swum across every major river he encountered, including twice across the Ganges River in North India.[49]

    Babur did not initially know Old Hindi; however, his Turkic poetry indicates that he picked up some of its vocabulary later in life.[50]

    Unlike his father, he had ascetic tendencies and did not have any great interest in women. In his first marriage, he was "bashful" towards Aisha Sultan Begum, later losing his affection for her.[51] Babur showed similar shyness in his interactions with Baburi, a boy in his camp with whom he had an infatuation around this time, recounting that: However, Babur acquired several more wives and concubines over the years, and as required for a prince, he was able to ensure the continuity of his line.

    Babur's first wife, Aisha Sultan Begum, was his paternal cousin, the daughter of Sultan Ahmad Mirza, his father's brother. She was an infant when betrothed to Babur, who was himself five years old. They married eleven years later, . The couple had one daughter, Fakhr-un-Nissa, who died within a year in 1500. Three years later, after Babur's first defeat at Fergana, Aisha left him and returned to her father's household.[52] In 1504, Babur married Zaynab Sultan Begum, who died childless within two years. In the period 1506–08, Babur married four women, Maham Begum (in 1506), Masuma Sultan Begum, Gulrukh Begum and Dildar Begum. Babur had four children by Maham Begum, of whom only one survived infancy. This was his eldest son and heir, Humayun. Masuma Sultan Begum died during childbirth; the year of her death is disputed (either 1508 or 1519). Gulrukh bore Babur two sons, Kamran and Askari, and Dildar Begum was the mother of Babur's youngest son, Hindal. Babur later married Mubaraka Yusufzai, a Pashtun woman of the Yusufzai tribe. Gulnar Aghacha and Nargul Aghacha were two Circassian slaves given to Babur as gifts by Tahmasp Shah Safavi, the Shah of Persia. They became "recognized ladies of the royal household."

    During his rule in Kabul, when there was a time of relative peace, Babur pursued his interests in literature, art, music and gardening. Previously, he never drank alcohol and avoided it when he was in Herat. In Kabul, he first tasted it at the age of thirty. He then began to drink regularly, host wine parties and consume preparations made from opium. Though religion had a central place in his life, Babur also approvingly quoted a line of poetry by one of his contemporaries: "I am drunk, officer. Punish me when I am sober". He quit drinking for health reasons before the Battle of Khanwa, just two years before his death, and demanded that his court do the same. But he did not stop chewing narcotic preparations, and did not lose his sense of irony. He wrote, "Everyone regrets drinking and swears an oath (of abstinence); I swore the oath and regret that."[53]

    Babur was opposed to the blind obedience towards the Chinggisid laws and customs that were influential in Turco-Mongol society:

    "Previously our ancestors had shown unusual respect for the Chingizid code (Mongolian: törah). They did not violate this code sitting and rising at councils and court, at feasts and dinners. [However] Chingez Khan's code is not a nass qati (categorical text) that a person must follow. Whenever one leaves a good custom, it should be followed. If ancestors leave a bad custom, however it is necessary to substitute a good one."
    Making clear that to him, the categorical text (i.e. the Quran) had displaced Genghis Khan's Yassa in moral and legal matters.[54]

    Poetry

    Babur was an acclaimed writer, who had a profound love for literature. His library was one of his most beloved possessions that he always carried around with him, and books were one of the treasures he searched for in new conquered lands. In his memoirs, when he listed sovereigns and nobles of a conquered land, he also mentioned poets, musicians and other educated people.[55]

    During his 47-year life, Babur left a rich literary and scientific heritage. He authored his famous memoir the Bāburnāma, as well as beautiful lyrical works or ghazals, treatises on Muslim jurisprudence (Mubayyin), poetics (Aruz risolasi), music, and a special calligraphy, known as khatt-i Baburi.[56] [57] [58] [59]

    Babur's Bāburnāma is a collection of memoirs, written in the Chagatai language and later translated into Persian, the usual literary language of the Mughal court, during the rule of emperor Akbar.[60] However, Babur's Turkic prose in Bāburnāma is already highly Persianized in its sentence structure, vocabulary, and morphology,[61] and also consists of several phrases and minor poems in Persian.

    Babur wrote most of his poems in Chagatai Turkic, known to him as Türki, but he also composed in Persian. However, he was mostly praised for his literary works written in Turkic, which drew comparison with the poetry of Ali-Shir Nava'i.[55]

    The following ruba'i is an example of Babur's poetry written in Turkic, composed in the aftermath of his famous victory in North India to celebrate his ghazi status.[62] Chagatai: Islam ichin avara-i yazi buldim, Kuffar u hind harbsazi buldim Jazm aylab idim uzni shahid olmaqqa, Amminna' lillahi ki gazi buldimI am become a desert wanderer for Islam,Having joined battle with infidels and HindusI readied myself to become a martyr,God be thanked I am become a ghazi.

    Family

    Consorts

    The identity of the mother of one of Babur's daughters, Gulrukh Begum is disputed. Gulrukh's mother may have been the daughter of Sultan Mahmud Mirza by his wife Pasha Begum who is referred to as Saliha Sultan Begum in certain secondary sources, however this name is not mentioned in the Baburnama or the works of Gulbadan Begum, which casts doubt on her existence. This woman may never have existed at all or she may even be the same woman as Dildar Begum.

    Issue

    The sons of Babur were:

    The daughters of Babur were:

    Death and legacy

    Babur died in Agra at the age of 47 on and was succeeded by his eldest son, Humayun. He was first buried in Chauburji, Agra.[63] [64] Later as per his wishes, his mortal remains were moved to Kabul and reburied in Bagh-e Babur in Kabul sometime between 1539 and 1544.

    It is generally agreed that, as a Timurid, Babur was not only significantly influenced by the Persian culture, but also that his empire gave rise to the expansion of the Persianate ethos in the Indian subcontinent. He emerged in his own telling as a Timurid Renaissance inheritor, leaving signs of Islamic, artistic literary, and social aspects in India.[65]

    For example, F. Lehmann states in the Encyclopædia Iranica:Although all applications of modern Central Asian ethnicities to people of Babur's time are anachronistic, Soviet and Uzbek sources regard Babur as an ethnic Uzbek.[66] [67] [68] At the same time, during the Soviet Union Uzbek scholars were censored for idealising and praising Babur and other historical figures such as Ali-Shir Nava'i.[69]

    Babur is considered a national hero in Uzbekistan.[70] On 14 February 2008, stamps in his name were issued in the country to commemorate his 525th birth anniversary.[71] Many of Babur's poems have become popular Uzbek folk songs, especially by Sherali Joʻrayev.[72] Some sources claim that Babur is a national hero in Kyrgyzstan too.[73] In October 2005, Pakistan developed the Babur Cruise Missile, named in his honour.

    Shahenshah Babar, an Indian film about the emperor directed by Wajahat Mirza was released in 1944. The 1960 Indian biographical film Babar by Hemen Gupta covered the emperor's life with Gajanan Jagirdar in the lead role.[74]

    One of the enduring features of Babur's life was that he left behind the lively and well-written autobiography known as Baburnama.[75] Quoting Henry Beveridge, Stanley Lane-Poole writes:

    In his own words, "The cream of my testimony is this, do nothing against your brothers even though they may deserve it." Also, "The new year, the spring, the wine and the beloved are joyful. Babur make merry, for the world will not be there for you a second time."[76]

    Babri Masjid

    The Babri Masjid ("Babur's Mosque") in Ayodhya is said to have been constructed on the orders of Mir Baqi, one of the commanders of his army. In 2003 the Allahabad High Court ordered the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to conduct a more in-depth study and an excavation to ascertain the type of structure beneath the mosque.[77] The excavation was conducted from 12 March 2003 to 7 August 2003, resulting in 1360 discoveries.[78]

    The summary of the ASI report indicated the presence of a 10th-century temple under the mosque.[79] [80] The ASI team said that, human activity at the site dates back to the 13th century BCE. The next few layers date back to the Shunga period (second-first century BCE) and the Kushan period. During the early medieval period (11–12th century CE), a huge but short-lived structure of nearly 50 metres north–south orientation was constructed. On the remains of this structure, another massive structure was constructed: this structure had at least three structural phases and three successive floors attached with it. The report concluded that it was over the top of this construction that the disputed structure was constructed during the early 16th century.[81] Archaeologist KK Muhammed, the only Muslim member in the team of people surveying the excavation, also confirmed individually that there existed a temple like structure before the Babri Masjid was constructed over it.[82] The Supreme Court judgement of 2019 granted the entire disputed land to the Hindus for construction of a temple, stating that Hindus continues to worship at the site and continued to hold the land outside the yard. It also held that there is nothing to prove that the structure, which was present before the construction of the mosque, was demolished for the purpose of building mosque or was already in ruins.[83] [84]

    Citations

    References

    Books

    Notes and References

    1. Book: Dale, Stephen F. . Babur . 2018 . 154.
    2. Web site: Avali . Raghu . The Conquest of Kabul (1504) . Indian History for Everyone . 2023-12-17 . 2024-07-12.
    3. Book: Christine, Isom-Verhaaren . Allies with the Infidel . 2013 . I.B. Tauris . 58.
    4. Book: Baumer, Christoph . Christoph Baumer . The History of Central Asia: The Age of Islam and the Mongols . 2018 . Bloomsbury Publishing . 47.
    5. Book: Canfield, Robert L. . Turko-Persia in historical perspective . 1991 . Cambridge University Press . 20 . The Mughals-Persianized Turks who invaded from Central Asia and claimed descent from both Timur and Genghis – strengthened the Persianate culture of Muslim India..
    6. Book: Jahangir, Emperor Of Hindustan . The Jahangirnama : memoirs of Jahangir, Emperor of India . Washington, D.C. : Freer Gallery of Art, Arthur M. Sackler Gallery, Smithsonian Institution ; New York : Oxford University Press . 1999 . 9780195127188 . 6 . Thackston . W. M..
    7. Quote: "Babur then adroitly gave the Ottomans his promise not to attack them in return for their military aid, which he received in the form of the newest of battlefield inventions, the matchlock gun and cast cannons, as well as instructors to train his men to use them."
    8. Book: Bhatnagar, V. S. . Life and Times of Sawai Jai Singh, 1688–1743 . 1974 . Impex India . en . 6 . From 1326, Mewar's grand recovery commenced under Lakha, and later under Kumbha and most notably under Sanga, till it became one of the greatest powers in northern India during the first quarter of sixteenth century..
    9. Book: Sarda, Har Bilas . Maharana Sanga; the Hindupat, the last great leader of the Rajput race . Ajmer, Scottish Mission Industries . University of California Libraries . 01–03 . Babur, the founder of the Turk power in India, says in his Memoirs that Rana Sanga was the most powerful sovereign in Hindustan when he invaded it, and that he attained his present high eminence by his own valour and sword. Eighty thousand horse, 7 Rajas of the highest rank, 9 Raos and 104 chieftains bearing the titles of Rawal and Rawat, with 500 war elephants, followed him into the field. The princes of Marwar and Amber (Jodhpur and Jaipur) did him homage, and the Raos of Gwalior, Ajmer, Sikri, Raisen, Kalpi, Chanderi, Boondi, Gagroon, Rampura and Abu served him as tributaries or held of him in chief..
    10. Book: Sharma, G. N. . Mewar and the mughal emperors . 1954 . 8–45 . Before describing his early power, it is worthwhile to say a word or two concerning the personality and the previous history of the man (Rana Sanga) who was destined to be the acknowledged leader of Hindu India of the first half of the 16th century..
    11. Book: Chandra, Satish . Medieval India: From Sultanat to the Mughals Part - II . 2005 . Har-Anand Publications . 978-81-241-1066-9 . 25–40 . en.
    12. Book: Dale . Stephen F. . Babur . 3 May 2018 . Cambridge University Press . 978-1-108-47007-0 . en.
    13. Book: Majumdar . R.C. . Raychaudhuri . H.C. . Datta . Kalikinkar . An Advanced History of India . 1950 . 2nd . Macmillan & Company . 419 . "The battle of khanua was one of the most decisive battles in Indian history certainly more than that of Panipat as Lodhi empire was already crumbling and Mewar had emerged as major power in northern India. Thus, Its at Khanua the fate of India was sealed for next two centuries" . en.
    14. Book: Chaurasia, Radheyshyam . History of Medieval India: From 1000 A.D. to 1707 A.D. . 2002 . Atlantic Publishers & Dist . 978-81-269-0123-4 . 161 . "The battle of Kanwaha was more important in its result even than the first battle of panipat. While the former made Babur ruler of Delhi alone the later made him King of hindustan. As a result of his success, the Mughal empire was established firmly in India. The sovereignty of India now passed from Rajputs to Mughals" . en.
    15. Hamès . Constant . 1987 . Babur Le Livre de Babur . . 63 . 2 . 222–223 . 9 August 2023 . 10 August 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230810230349/https://www.persee.fr/doc/assr_0335-5985_1987_num_63_2_2432_t1_0222_0000_2 . live.
    16. Book: Babur . Le livre de Babur: le Babur-nama de Zahiruddin Muhammad Babur . Bacqué-Grammont . Jean-Louis . Taha Hussein-Okada . Amina . 2022 . les Belles lettres . 978-2-251-45370-5 . Série indienne . Paris.
    17. Dale . Stephen Frederic . 1990 . Steppe Humanism: The Autobiographical Writings of Zahir al-Din Muhammad Babur, 1483–1530 . International Journal of Middle East Studies . en . 22 . 1 . 37–58 . 10.1017/S0020743800033171 . 161867251 . 0020-7438.
    18. Book: Noshahi, Arif . خواجہ احرار . پورب اکیڈمی . 2005 . Lahore, Pakistan.
    19. Book: Babur . Le livre de Babur: le Babur-nama de Zahiruddin Muhammad Babur . Bacqué-Grammont . Jean-Louis . Taha Hussein-Okada . Amina . 2022 . les Belles lettres . 978-2-251-45370-5 . Série indienne . Paris . 3.
    20. Thumb, Albert, Handbuch des Sanskrit, mit Texten und Glossar, German original, ed. C. Winter, 1953, Snippet, p. 318
    21. Book: Hiro, Dilip . Babur Nama: Journal of Emperor Babur . 2006 . Penguin Books India . Mumbai . 978-0-14-400149-1 . xviii .
    22. Book: Dale, Stephen Frederic . The garden of the eight paradises: Bābur and the culture of Empire in Central Asia, Afghanistan and India (1483–1530) . Brill . 2004 . 15, 150 . 90-04-13707-6.
    23. Web site: On the occasion of the birth of Babar Padishah (the son of Omar Shaikh) . Mirza Muhammad Haidar . Silk Road Seattle . . 7 November 2006 . 16 April 2015 . https://web.archive.org/web/20150416044122/http://depts.washington.edu/silkroad/texts/rash1.html . live .
    24. Book: Babur. Babur Nama. Penguin Books. 978-0-14-400149-1. vii. 2006.
    25. Web site: Bābur (Mughal emperor) . Encyclopædia Britannica . 29 August 2016 . 5 March 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230305124145/https://www.britannica.com/biography/Babur . live .
    26. Web site: Iran: The Timurids and Turkmen . Encyclopædia Britannica . 29 August 2016 . 18 June 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230618001818/https://www.britannica.com/place/Iran/The-Timurids-and-Turkmen . live .
    27. Book: Dale, Stephen F. . Babur:Timurid Prince and Mughal Emperor, 1483-1530 . 35 . 2018 . Cambridge University Press . 9781316996379.
    28. Book: Manz, Beatrice Forbes . Central Asia in Historical Perspective . The Symbiosis of Turk and Tajik . Boulder, Colorado & Oxford . 1994 . 58 . 0-8133-3638-4.
    29. Babur, the first Moghul emperor: Wine and tulips in Kabul . The Economist . 16 December 2010 . 80–82 . 12 June 2015 . 15 January 2017 . https://web.archive.org/web/20170115140216/http://www.economist.com/node/17723207 . live .
    30. Book: Lal, Ruby . Domesticity and Power in the Early Mughal World . 0-521-85022-3 . 2005 . 69 . Cambridge University Press . It was over these possessions, provinces controlled by uncles, or cousins of varying degrees, that Babur fought with close and distant relatives for much of his life..
    31. Book: Ewans, Martin . 2002 . Afghanistan: A Short History of Its People and Politics . registration . HarperCollins . 26–27 . 0-06-050508-7 . Babur, while still in his teens, conceived the ambition of conquering Samarkand. In 1497, after a seven months' siege, he took the city, but his supporters gradually deserted him and Ferghana was taken from him in his absence. Within a few months he was compelled to retire from Samarkand ... Eventually he retook Samarkand, but was again forced out, this time by an Usbek leader, Shaibani Khan ... Babur decided in 1504 to trek over the Hindu Kush to Kabul, where the current ruler promptly retreated to Kandahar and left him in undisputed control of the city..
    32. Web site: The Memoirs of Babur . After being driven out of Samarkand in 1501 by the Uzbek Shaibanids ... . 8 November 2006 . Silk Road Seattle . . 21 October 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20191021154433/https://depts.washington.edu/silkroad/texts/babur/babur1.html . live .
    33. Book: Mahajan, V.D.. History of medieval India. 2007. S Chand. New Delhi. 978-81-219-0364-6. 10th. 428–29.
    34. Book: Brend, Barbara . Perspectives on Persian Painting: Illustrations to Amir Khusrau's Khamsah . 2002 . 0-7007-1467-7 . Routledge (UK) . 188 .
    35. Book: Lamb, Christina . The Sewing Circles of Herat: A Personal Voyage Through Afghanistan . 153 . 0-06-050527-3 . HarperCollins . 2004 .
    36. Book: Hickmann, William C. . Mehmed the Conqueror and His Time . 1992 . 0-691-01078-1 . 473 . Princeton University Press . Eastern Turk Mir Ali Shir Neva'i (1441–1501), founder of the Chagatai literary language.
    37. Book: Doniger, Wendy . Merriam-Webster's Encyclopedia of World Religions . 0-87779-044-2 . 1999 . 539 . Merriam-Webster .
    38. Book: Sicker, Martin . The Islamic World in Ascendancy: From the Arab Conquests to the Siege in Vienna . 0-275-96892-8 . 2000 . 189 . Bloomsbury Academic . Ismail was quite prepared to lend his support to the displaced Timurid prince, Zahir ad-Din Babur, who offered to accept Safavid suzerainty in return for help in regaining control of Transoxiana..
    39. Erdogan . Eralp . July 2014 . Babür İmparatorluğu'nun Kuruluş Safhasında Şah İsmail ile Babür İttifakı . https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20221009/http://www.historystudies.net/dergi/tar20151234f99.pdf . 2022-10-09 . live . Journal of History Studies . 6 . 4 . 31–39 . 10.9737/historyS1150 . tr.
    40. Book: Farooqi, Naimur Rahman . 2008 . Mughal-Ottoman relations: a study of political & diplomatic relations between Mughal India and the Ottoman Empire, 1556–1748 . 13–14 . 20894584.
    41. Book: Chaurasia, Radhey Shyam . History of medieval India : from 1000 A.D. to 1707 A.D. . 2002 . Atlantic Publ. . New Delhi . 81-269-0123-3 . 89–90 .
    42. Book: Chandra, Satish . 2009 . Medieval India:From Sultanat to the Mughals . 2 . New Delhi . Har-Anand . 27 . 978-81-241-1268-7.
    43. Web site: Bābur, Mughal emperor . 2023-11-19 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230220132730/https://www.britannica.com/biography/Babur . 2023-02-20 . live.
    44. Book: Rao, K. V. Krishna . Prepare Or Perish: A Study of National Security . 978-81-7212-001-6 . Lancer Publishers . 453 . 1991 . 7 October 2020 . 5 February 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240205161458/https://books.google.com/books?id=G7xPaJomYsEC&pg=PA453#v=onepage&q&f=false . live.
    45. Book: Lane-Poole, Stanley . Stanley Lane-Poole . 1899 . Babar . 182–83 . The Clarendon Press.
    46. Book: Chandra, Satish . Satish Chandra (historian) . 1999 . Medieval India: From Sultanat to the Mughals . 2 . 1st . New Delhi . Har-Anand Publications . 36 . 36806798.
    47. Book: Hinnells . John . King . Richard . Religion and Violence in South Asia: Theory and Practice . 2006 . Routledge . 978-0-415-37291-6 . 101–114.
    48. Book: Elliot . H. M. . Henry Miers Elliot . Dowson . John . John Dowson . Leyden . John . John Leyden . Erskine . William . William Erskine (historian) . 1872 . Tuzak-i Babari . The Autobiography of Babur . https://archive.org/details/cu31924073036745/page/n285/mode/1up . The History of India, as Told by Its Own Historians . The History of India, as Told by Its Own Historians . IV . London . Trübner and Co. . 272, 275.
    49. Book: Elliot, Henry Miers . John Dowson . The History of India, as Told by Its Own Historians . The Muhammadan Period . http://persian.packhum.org/persian//pf?file=80201014&ct=56 . 2 April 2008 . 1867–1877 . Trubner . London . ... and on the same journey, he swam twice across the Ganges, as he said he had done with every other river he had met with. . 22 June 2008 . https://web.archive.org/web/20080622122152/http://persian.packhum.org/persian/pf?file=80201014&ct=56 . dead .
    50. Book: Rahman, Tariq . From Hindi to Urdu : a social and political history . 2011 . Karachi . Oxford University Press . 73–74 . 978-0-19-906313-0. 731974235 .
    51. Book: Memoirs of Zehīr-ed-Dīn Muhammed Bābur Emperor of Hindustan, Written by himself, in the Chaghatāi Tūrki . Translated by John Leyden and William Erskine, Annotated and Revised by Lucas King . Oxford University Press . 1921 . The Memoirs of Babur, Volume 1, chpt. 71 . http://persian.packhum.org/persian/main?url=pf%3Ffile%3D03501051%26ct%3D70%26rqs%3D187%26rqs%3D196 . Āisha Sultan Begum, the daughter of Sultan Ahmed Mirza, to whom I had been betrothed in the lifetime of my father and uncle, having arrived in Khujand, I now married her, in the month of Shābān. In the first period of my being a married man, though I had no small affection for her, yet, from modesty and bashfulness, I went to her only once in ten, fifteen, or twenty days. My affection afterwards declined, and my shyness increased; in so much, that my mother the Khanum, used to fall upon me and scold me with great fury, sending me off like a criminal to visit her once in a month or forty days. . 2 April 2008 . https://web.archive.org/web/20081205161213/http://persian.packhum.org/persian/main?url=pf%3Ffile%3D03501050%26ct%3D0 . 5 December 2008 . dead.
    52. Book: Babur Nama:Journal of Emperor Babur . Penguin . 362 . 978-0-14-400149-1 . Babur . 2006 . Hiro . Dilip . Babur's wives and children . 2006.
    53. Pope, Hugh (2005). Sons of the Conquerors, Overlook Duckworth, pp. 234–35.
    54. Book: F. Dale, Stephen . THE GARDEN OF THE EIGHT PARADISES: Babur and the Culture of Empire in Central Asia, Afghanistan and India (1483-1530) . Brill . 2004 . 171.
    55. Book: Eraly, Abraham . Emperors of the Peacock Throne: The Saga of the Great Moghuls . 1997 . 29 . Penguin Books Limited.
    56. Book: Eraly, Abraham . Emperors of the Peacock Throne: The Saga of the Great Moghuls . 1997 . 30 . Penguin Books Limited.
    57. Hasanov, S. (1981). Bobirning "Aruz risolasi" asari (in Uzbek). pp. 1-4. Uzbekistan: Fan.
    58. Schimmel, A. (2004). The Empire of the Great Mughals: History, Art and Culture. p. 26. India: Reaktion Books.
    59. Eraly, A. (2000). Last Spring: The Lives and Times of Great Mughals. pp. 30-41. India: Penguin Books Limited.
    60. Web site: Biography of Abdur Rahim Khankhana. 2006-10-28. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20060117163845/http://www.poemhunter.com/abdur-rahim-khankhana/biography/poet-33381/ . 2006-01-17.
    61. Book: Dale, Stephen Frederic . The garden of the eight paradises: Bābur and the culture of Empire in Central Asia, Afghanistan and India (1483–1530) . Brill . 2004 . 15,150 . 90-04-13707-6 .
    62. Book: Balabanlilar . Lisa . Imperial Identity in the Mughal Empire. Memory and Dynastic Politics in Early Modern South and Central Asia . 2015 . Bloomsbury Publishing . 978-0-857-72081-8 . 42–43.
    63. News: Datta . Rangan . Agra beyond the Taj: Exploring tombs and gardens on the left bank of Yamuna . 18 July 2024 . My Kolkata . The Telegraph . 5 July 2024.
    64. News: Goel . Shrishti . Did you know Mughal emperor Babur's body was kept at this place for 6 months before being buried in Kabul? . 18 July 2024 . Dainik Jagaran . 20 November 2020.
    65. Book: Dale, Stephen Frederic . The garden of the eight paradises: Bābur and the culture of Empire in Central Asia, Afghanistan and India (1483–1530) . Brill . 2004 . 216. 90-04-13707-6 .
    66. Encyclopedia: A. M. . Prokhorov . Great Soviet Encyclopedia . Babur . 16 September 2013 . ru . 1969–1978 . Soviet Encyclopedia . Moscow . dead . https://archive.today/20130916175254/http://bse-soviet-encyclopedia.info/%D0%91%D0%BE%D0%BB%D1%8C%D1%88%D0%B0%D1%8F_%D0%A1%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B5%D1%82%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%8F_%D1%8D%D0%BD%D1%86%D0%B8%D0%BA%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%BF%D0%B5%D0%B4%D0%B8%D1%8F/54583/%D0%91%D0%B0%D0%B1%D1%83%D1%80 . 16 September 2013.
    67. Encyclopedia: Ibrohim . Muminov . Uzbek Soviet Encyclopedia . Bobur . uz . 1972 . 2 . Tashkent . 287–95.
    68. Book: Bobur, Zahiriddin Muhammad . Boburnoma . 1989 . Yulduzcha . Tashkent . 3 . A'zam Oʻktam . uz . About This Edition.
    69. Book: Fierman . William . Soviet Central Asia . 1991 . Westview Press . Boulder, Colorado . 978-0-8133-7907-4 . 147 .
    70. Web site: Grandeur and Eternity: Zahiriddin Muhammad Bobur in Minds of People Forever . Embassy of Uzbekistan in Korea. . 22 February 2011 . 14 February 2012 . https://web.archive.org/web/20130522171617/http://www.uzbekistan.or.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=news&wr_id=878 . 22 May 2013 . dead.
    71. Web site: The country's history on postage miniatures . Uzbekistan Today . 12 June 2015 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20150614180708/https://old.ut.uz/eng/kaleidoscope/the_countrys_history_on_postage_miniatures.mgr . 14 June 2015.
    72. News: Sherali Joʻrayev: We Haven't Stopped. We Still Exist . 13 April 2007 . BBC's Uzbek Service . uz . 8 October 2013 . 5 February 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240205161345/https://www.bbc.com/uzbek/news/story/2007/04/070412_sherali_juraev_60 . live.
    73. Book: Wang, Zhihong . Dust in the Wind: Retracing Dharma Master Xuanzang's Western Pilgrimage . 121.
    74. Book: Rangoonwalla . Firoze . Das . Vishwanath . Indian Filmography: Silent & Hindi Films, 1897–1969 . 1970 . J. Udeshi . 370 . 8 February 2021 . 5 February 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240205161451/https://books.google.com/books?id=26dZAAAAMAAJ . live.
    75. Book: The Baburnama: Memoirs of Babur, Prince and Emperor . Modern Library . 0-375-76137-3 . 2002 . Babur, Emperor of Hindustan . translated, edited and annotated by W. M. Thackston .
    76. Book: Sen, Sailendra Nath . 2013 . A Textbook of Medieval Indian History . Primus Books . 151 . 978-93-80607-34-4.
    77. Ratnagar . Shereen . April 2004 . Archaeology at the Heart of a Political Confrontation: The Case of Ayodhya . https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20221009/https://www.asia-europe.uni-heidelberg.de/fileadmin/Documents/Professorships/Visual_and_Media_Anthropology/ForUS/381044.pdf . 2022-10-09 . live . Current Anthropology . 45 . 2 . 239–59 . 10.1086/381044 . 149773944.
    78. News: ASI submits report on Ayodhya excavation . Rediff.com . Press Trust of India . 22 August 2003 . 20 June 2012 . 26 October 2012 . https://web.archive.org/web/20121026011030/http://www.rediff.com/news/2003/aug/22ayo.htm . live.
    79. News: ASI findings may not resolve title dispute . Suryamurthy . R . The Tribune . 26 August 2003 . 27 October 2016 . 11 April 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090411193402/http://www.tribuneindia.com/2003/20030826/main6.htm . live.
    80. https://web.archive.org/web/20050323101829/http://www.the-week.com/23sep07/events1.htm Prasannan, R. (7 September 2003) "Ayodhya: Layers of truth"
    81. News: Proof of temple found at Ayodhya: ASI report . Rediff.com . Press Trust of India . 25 August 2003 . 20 June 2012 . 25 December 2018 . https://web.archive.org/web/20181225023956/http://www.rediff.com/news/2003/aug/25ayo1.htm%20 . live.
    82. News: Ram temple existed before Babri mosque in Ayodhya: Archaeologist KK Muhammed . Shekhar . Kumar Shakti . The Times of India . 7 November 2019 . 18 January 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20230118221506/https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/ram-temple-existed-before-babri-mosque-in-ayodhya-archaeologist-kk-muhammed/articleshow/71391712.cms . live.
    83. News: Ayodhya verdict Ruins don't always indicate demolition, observes Supreme Court . Rajagopal . Krishnadas . 10 November 2019 . The Hindu . 24 November 2019 . 0971-751X . 12 November 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20191112003600/https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/ayodhya-verdict-ruins-dont-always-indicate-demolition-observes-sc/article29938243.ece . live.
    84. News: Highlights of the Ayodhya verdict . 9 November 2019 . The Hindu . 24 November 2019 . 0971-751X . 20 December 2019 . https://web.archive.org/web/20191220005358/https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/highlights-of-the-ayodhya-verdict/article29929685.ece . live.