1919 Australian referendum (Monopolies) explained

Australian Nationalisation of Industries referendum, 1919
Do you approve of the proposed law for the alteration of the Constitution entitled —

"Constitution Alteration (Nationalisation of Monopolies) 1919" ?
Country:Australia
Yes:813,880
No:859,451
Invalid:357,580
Electorate:2,849,862

The Constitution Alteration (Nationalization of Monopolies) Bill 1919,[1] was an unsuccessful Australian referendum seeking to alter the Australian Constitution to extend the government's power to legislate in respect of monopolies. The question was put to a referendum in 1919, held in conjunction with the 1919 federal election.

Question

The proposal was to alter the text of section 51 of the Constitution as reads as follows:

51a.—(1.) The Parliament shall have power to make laws for carrying on by or under the control of the Commonwealth, the industry or business of producing, manufacturing, or supplying any specified goods, or of supplying any specified services, and for acquiring for that purpose on just terms the assets and goodwill of the industry or business, where each House of the Parliament has in the same Session, by resolution passed by an absolute majority of its members, referred to the High Court, for inquiry and report by a Justice thereof, the question whether the industry or business is the subject of a monopoly, and where, after the report of the Justice has been received, each House of the Parliament has, in one Session, by resolution passed by an absolute majority of its members, declared that the industry or business is the subject of a monopoly.

Results

Do you approve of the proposed law for the alteration of the Constitution entitled 'Constitution Alteration (Nationalization of Monopolies) 1919'?

Result
width:180px" rowspan="2" Statewidth:70px" align=center rowspan="2" Electoral rollwidth:70px" align=center rowspan="2" Ballots issuedwidth:140px" align=center colspan="2" Forwidth:140px" align=center colspan="2" Againstwidth:70px" align=center rowspan="2" Informal
width:70px" align=center Votewidth:70px" align=center %width:70px" align=center Votewidth:70px" align=center %
New South Wales 1,079,439 717,565 227,156 38.31 365,847 124,330
Victoria 837,408 638,098 324,343 188,129 36.71 124,834
Queensland 389,200 330,231 162,062 122,650 43.08 45,209
South Australia 268,235 178,092 38,503 25.54 112,259 27,203
Western Australia 163,544 103,235 45,285 38,584 46.01 19,019
Tasmania 112,036 65,716 16,531 34.08 31,982 16,985
Total for Commonwealth noWrap 2,849,862 noWrap 2,032,937 noWrap 813,880 noWrap align="middle" 48.64 noWrap 859,451 noWrap 357,580
ResultsObtained majority in three states and an overall minority of 45,571 votes. Not carried

Discussion

The 1911 referendum asked a single question that dealt with the acquisition of monopolies, trade, commerce and industrial . The second resolution separated the laws in relation to monopolies and the acquisition of monopolies into different questions. On each of the many occasions a similar question was asked at a referendum the public decided not to vest power in the Commonwealth over these matters.

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Constitution Alteration (Nationalization of Monopolies) Bill 1919 . legislation.gov.au . 22 April 2019.