2014 Australian Senate special election in Western Australia explained

Election Name:2014 Western Australian Senate election
Country:Western Australia
Seats For Election:6 (of 12) Western Australian Senate seats
Type:parliamentary
Ongoing:no
Election Date:5 April 2014
Image1:Senator Eric Abetz crop.jpg
Leader1:Eric Abetz
Party1:Liberal Party of Australia
Leaders Seat1:Tasmania
Seats Before1:6
Seats1:3
Seats After1:6
Popular Vote1:435,220
Percentage1:34.06%
Swing1: 8.93pp
Leader2:Penny Wong
Party2:Australian Labor Party
Leaders Seat2:South Australia
Seats Before2:4
Seats2:1
Seats After2:3
Seat Change2: 1
Popular Vote2:275,094
Percentage2:21.53%
Swing2: 8.17pp
Image4:Christine Milne profile.jpg
Leader4:Christine Milne
Party4:Australian Greens
Leaders Seat4:Tasmania
Seats Before4:2
Seats4:1
Seats After4:2
Popular Vote4:199,538
Percentage4:15.60%
Swing4:1.64pp
Image5:Clive Palmer Aug15 crop.jpg
Leader5:Clive Palmer
Party5:Palmer United Party
Leaders Seat5:MP for Fairfax
Seats Before5:
Seats5:1
Seats After5:1
Seat Change5:New
Popular Vote5:157,740
Percentage5:12.34%
Swing5:New

On 5 April 2014, an Australian Senate special election in Western Australia was held.[1] The special election was held six months after the 2013 Australian federal election. The result of that 2013 election for the Australian Senate in Western Australia was voided on 20 February 2014 by the High Court of Australia, sitting as the Court of Disputed Returns, because 1,375 ballot papers were lost during an official recount in November 2013. The High Court ruled that because the number of lost ballots exceeded the margin for the two remaining Senate seats, the only acceptable remedy was to void the results and hold a special election.[2] [3]

Following the election on 5 April, preferences were distributed on 29 April 2014 according to the group voting ticket voting system used at that time.[4] [5] The outcome was 3 senators from the Liberal Party of Australia, 1 from the Australian Labor Party, 1 from the Australia Greens and 1 from the Palmer United Party. Compared to the November 2013 result, the Australian Sports Party's Wayne Dropulich was replaced by Dio Wang of the Palmer United Party.

The election is unprecedented in Australian federal politics. An election was held in South Australia in 1907 for the election of one senator under a previous electoral system. Half-Senate elections without a corresponding Australian House of Representatives election have occurred several times due to effluxion of time, the last one in 1970.

The date was set by Sir Peter Cosgrove, the Governor-General of Australia, on the advice of Prime Minister Tony Abbott. However, the onus for setting times and processes fell on the Governor of Western Australia, Malcolm McCusker, on the advice of Colin Barnett, Premier of Western Australia, in McCusker's obligations under the operation of the Election of Senators Act 1903 (WA).

Result

Summary

Senate (STV GV) — Turnout 88.50% (CV) — Informal 2.50%[6] [7]
PartyVotes%Seats wonTotal seatsChange
 Liberal Party of Australia435,220 34.06–8.9336
 Australian Labor Party275,094 21.53–8.1713 1
 Australian Greens199,35815.60+1.6412
 Palmer United Party157,74012.34+12.3411 1
 Nationals WA38,8183.04–0.39
 Other171,57413.43
Total1,277,804612
Invalid/blank votesalign = right 32,757align = right 2.50align = right –0.68
Registered voters/turnoutalign=right 1,480,820align = right 88.50
Source: Commonwealth Election 2013

Results in detail

align=right
ElectedSenatorParty
20141David Johnston Liberal
20142Joe Bullock Labor
20143Scott Ludlam  Greens
20144Michaelia Cash Liberal
20145Dio Wang Palmer
20146Linda Reynolds Liberal
2010
20101Mathias Cormann Liberal
20102Chris Evans Labor
20103Chris Back Liberal
20104Glenn Sterle Labor
20105Judith Adams Liberal
20106Rachel Siewert Greens
The sixth and last seat was a close contest between third Liberal candidate Linda Reynolds and second Labor candidate Louise Pratt.[8] Reynolds was ahead in the ABC's detailed count projection, with Antony Green predicting on 10 April "It is clear the Liberals will win the last seat".[9] The result was confirmed by the Electoral Commission on 29 April. The score at the final count was 188,169 to Reynolds versus 176,042 for Pratt, a margin of 12,127. The projected margin on Green's calculator, which treated all votes as above-the-line, was a narrower 8,109.[10]

Revised national totals

Revised national Senate totals following WA special election (STV GV)
Turnout 93.45% (CV) – Informal 2.93%
PartyVotes%SwingSeats wonContinuing senatorsTotal seatsChange
 / joint ticketalign=right 3,938,204align=right 29.43align=right –0.03align=right 8align=right 8align=right 16align=right 1
 align=right 928,291align=right 6.94align=right –1.65align=right 8align=right 8align=right 16align=right
 align=right 41,920align=right 0.31align=right –0.19align=right 0align=right 0align=right 0align=right
 Country Liberal (NT)align=right 42,781align=right 0.32align=right –0.01align=right 1align=right 1align=right 1align=right
Coalition total4,951,19637.00–1.29171633 1
 Australian Labor Party3,965,28429.63–5.50121325 6
 Australian Greens1,234,5929.23–3.884610 1
 Palmer United Party751,1215.61+5.6133 3
 Liberal Democratic Party502,1803.75+1.9411 1
 Xenophon Group258,3761.93+1.9311
 Family First Party149,9941.12–0.9811 1
 Democratic Labour Party115,2760.86–0.20011
 Australian Motoring Enthusiast Party66,8070.50+0.5011 1
 Other1,385,71910.36+0.49
Total13,380,545align=right 40align=right 3676
Invalid/blank votesalign = right 403,380align = right 2.93align = right –0.82
Registered voters/turnoutalign=right 14,750,392align = right 93.45
Source: Commonwealth Election 2013

Candidates

There were a number of candidate changes from the original election. Notable changes included:

The Socialist Equality Party and Australian Independents contested the 2013 election in Western Australia, but did not contest the special election. The Socialist Alliance, Pirate Party, Voluntary Euthanasia Party, Building Australia Party, Mutual Party, Republican Party and Democratic Labor Party did not contest the 2013 election in WA, but decided to contest the special election.

Sitting members are shown in bold text. Tickets that elected at least one member in 2014 are highlighted in the relevant colour and successful candidates are indicated with an asterisk (*). Candidates marked with ‡ were declared elected after the final count in 2013.

Labor candidatesLiberal candidatesGreens candidatesPalmer candidatesNationals candidatesKatter candidates
 
valign=top
  1. Joe Bullock‡*
  2. Louise Pratt
  3. Shane Hill
  4. Klara Andric
valign=top
  1. David Johnston‡*
  2. Michaelia Cash‡*
  3. Linda Reynolds‡*
  4. Slade Brockman
valign=top
  1. Scott Ludlam‡*
  2. Christine Cunningham
  3. Ian James
  4. Jordon Steele-John
  5. Sarah Nielsen-Harvey
  6. Judith Cullity
valign=top
  1. Dio Wang
  1. Chamonix Terblanche
valign=top
  1. Shane Van Styn
  2. Colin de Grussa
valign=top
  1. Phillip Bouwman
  2. Susan Hoddinott
Shooters & Fishers candidatesChristians candidatesFamily First candidatesAustralian Sex Party candidatesWikileaks candidatesLiberal Democrats candidates
 
valign=top
  1. Murray Bow
  2. John Parkes
valign=top
  1. Ray Moran
  2. Justin Moseley
valign=top
  1. Linda Rose
  2. Henry Heng
valign=top
  1. Fiona Patten
  2. Mark Coleman
valign=top
  1. Tibor Meszaros
  2. Lucy Nicol
valign=top
  1. Jim Fryar
  2. Neil Hamilton
Democrats candidatesSmokers' Rights candidatesHEMP candidatesSocialist Alliance candidatesVoice candidatesFishing & Lifestyle candidates
 
valign=top
  1. Chris Fernandez
  2. William Thiel
valign=top
  1. Max Katz-Barber
  2. Daniel Di Rado
valign=top
  1. James Moylan
  2. Tayla Moylan
valign=top
  1. Alex Bainbridge
  2. Chris Jenkins
valign=top
  1. Brian Parkes
  2. Sean Butler
valign=top
  1. Daniel McCarthy
  2. Suzzanne Wyatt
Secular candidatesPirate candidatesFreedom & Prosperity candidatesSustainable Population candidatesOutdoor Recreation candidatesAnimal Justice candidates
 
valign=top
  1. Simon Cuthbert
  2. Andrew Thompson
valign=top
  1. Fletcher Boyd
  2. Michelle Allen
valign=top
  1. Bill Koutalianos
  2. Leon Ashby
valign=top
  1. Peter Strachan
  2. William Bourke
valign=top
  1. David Fishlock
  2. Joaquim De Lima
valign=top
  1. Katrina Love
  2. Alicia Sutton
Motoring Enthusiast candidatesSports candidatesRise Up Australia candidatesVoluntary Euthanasia candidatesBuilding Australia candidatesMutual candidates
 
valign=top
  1. Richie Howlett
  2. Rob Zandvliet
valign=top
  1. Wayne Dropulich
  2. Al Lackovic
valign=top
  1. Jane Foreman
  2. Joanne Bennett
valign=top
  1. Philip Nitschke
  2. Jim Duffield
valign=top
  1. Ken Bezant
  2. Daniel Smee
valign=top
  1. Anthony Fels
  2. Felly Chandra
Republican candidatesDLP candidatesGroup C candidatesUngrouped candidates
 
valign=top
  1. Marcus Anderson
  2. Rohan Hollick
valign=top
  1. Adrian Good
  2. Cathy Kiernan
valign=top
  1. Russell Woolf
  2. Verity James
valign=top Teresa van Lieshout (Ind)
Kim Mubarak (Ind)
valign=top valign=top

Electoral events timeline

2013 Senate result background

The Senate after the 2013 election, once the new senators' terms started on 1 July 2014, was originally going to consist of the Coalition government on 33 seats with the Labor opposition on 25 seats and a record crossbench of 18 – the Greens on ten seats, Palmer United on two seats, with other minor parties and independents on six seats – the LDP's David Leyonhjelm, Family First's Bob Day, Motoring's Ricky Muir, Sports Party's Wayne Dropulich and incumbents Nick Xenophon and the DLP's John Madigan. The Coalition government would originally have required the support of at least six non-coalition Senators to pass legislation.

Most Senate votes cast in Western Australia were subject to a formal recount.[20] During the recount it was determined that WA Senate ballot papers could not be located.[21] [22] After the final recount the result was duly declared which changed the last two predicted WA Senate spots from Palmer and Labor back to Sports Party and Greens. Mick Keelty, a former AFP Commissioner, was requested by the AEC to investigate the issue of the misplaced ballot papers.[23] [24] On 15 November, the AEC petitioned the High Court, acting as the Court of Disputed Returns, to seek an order from the court that the WA Senate election of all six senators (3 Liberal, 1 Labor, 1 Green, 1 Sports Party) be declared void.[25] [26] [27]

A record number of candidates stood at the election.[28] Group voting tickets came under scrutiny because multiple candidates were provisionally elected with the vast majority of their 14.3 percent quotas coming from the preferences of other parties across the political spectrum. "Preference whisperer" Glenn Druery organised tight cross-preferencing between many minor parties.[29] [30] [31] The Sports Party's Wayne Dropulich won a Senate seat on a record-low primary vote of 0.2 percent in Western Australia, his party placing coming 21st out of 28 groups on primary votes.[32] [33] [34] The result caused discussion across a range of organisations and parties about whether there should be changes to the GVT system.[35] [36] [37]

References

|}

Notes and References

  1. News: WA Senate election to be held on April 5 . Yahoo! News . 28 February 2014 .
  2. News: Fresh WA poll throws Canberra into spin . Australian Associated Press . SBS Online . 20 February 2014 . 22 February 2014.
  3. Australian Electoral Commission v Johnston. HCA . 5 . 2014 . 18 February 2014 . H.C..
  4. Web site: Liberals secure three seats in WA Senate re-run: SMH 29 April 2014 . The Sydney Morning Herald . 2014-04-29 . 2018-07-02.
  5. Web site: 2014 WA Senate election final distribution of preferences: AEC . 29 April 2014 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140429183539/http://vtr.aec.gov.au/External/SenateStateDop-17875-WA.pdf . 29 April 2014 . dead.
  6. Web site: 2014 WA Senate results: Antony Green ABC . Australian Broadcasting Corporation . 2018-07-02.
  7. Web site: Detailed 2014 WA Senate result: Antony Green ABC . Australian Broadcasting Corporation . 2018-07-02.
  8. Web site: WA Senate election: Government hopeful of favourable Upper House as Palmer United Party picks up seat: ABC 6 April 2014 . 6 April 2014 . Australian Broadcasting Corporation . 2018-07-02.
  9. Web site: Green . Antony . Tracking the WA Senate Re-election Count: Antony Green ABC . Australian Broadcasting Corporation . 2013-06-19 . 2018-07-02.
  10. Web site: William . Bowe . WA Senate election finalised: Poll Bludger . Blogs.crikey.com.au . 2014-04-29 . 2018-07-02.
  11. News: Hopkin. Michael. WA Senate recount gets under way. 28 October 2013. The Sydney Morning Herald. 17 October 2013.
  12. News: Packham. Ben. Probe launched into lost WA Senate ballot papers. "serious administrative issue came to light" during the recount. 31 October 2013. The Australian. 31 October 2013.
  13. News: Griffiths. Emma. AEC confirms WA Senate election result, apologises over 1,375 lost ballots. 5 November 2013. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 4 November 2013.
  14. News: Ireland. Judith. Missing votes: AEC asks High Court to void WA Senate election. 18 November 2013. The Sydney Morning Herald. 15 November 2013.
  15. Web site: Court hears submissions to void WA Senate election after votes lost. 29 January 2014. 30 January 2014. Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
  16. Web site: High Court judge reserves judgment on botched West Australian Senate election. 30 January 2014. 30 January 2014. Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
  17. Web site: Court of Disputed Returns voids 2013 WA Senate election result. Australian Electoral Commission. 24 February 2014.
  18. Web site: Bourke . Latika . Latika Bourke . 2014 . Ed Killesteyn resigns as Australian Electoral Commissioner . Australian Broadcasting Corporation . 2014-02-23 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140916071102/http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-02-21/aec-resignation/5275828 . 16 September 2014.
  19. Web site: Campaigning begins in WA after Senate re-election date announced . ABC News . 2014-02-28 . 2018-07-02.
  20. Web site: Most recently updated divisions, Senate: 2013 election, AEC . 18 February 2014 . https://web.archive.org/web/20131031203209/http://vtr.aec.gov.au/SenateUpdatedByDivision-17496-NAT.htm . 31 October 2013 . dead.
  21. News: WA Senate recount in turmoil as 1375 votes go missing . . 31 October 2013 . Harrison, Dan . Hurst, Daniel . Ireland, Judith . 13 November 2013 .
  22. Australian Electoral Commission statement: WA Senate recount . AEC . 31 October 2013 . 13 November 2013 .
  23. News: What's Going on with the WA Senate Count . Antony Green . Green, Antony . . 3 November 2013 . 13 November 2013 .
  24. News: WA Senate Contest Comes Down to Just 1 Vote – and it's one of the Missing . Antony Green . Green, Antony . . 8 November 2013 . 13 November 2013 .
  25. News: Senate recount: electoral commission asks high court to nullify six WA seats . . Australia . Murphy, Katherine . 15 November 2013 . 15 November 2013 .
  26. News: Missing votes: AEC asks High Court to void WA Senate election . . Ireland, Judith . 15 November 2013 . 15 November 2013 .
  27. News: Electoral Commission challenges WA Senate result to bring about fresh election . . 15 November 2013 . 15 November 2013 .
  28. News: Record Number of Candidates to Contest 2013 Election . Antony Green . Green, Antony . . 16 August 2013 . 13 November 2013 .
  29. News: Bitter dispute erupts over Senate preferences in Queensland . . 5 September 2013 .
  30. News: The 'preference whisperer' . Glenn . Druery . . 21 August 2013 . 18 February 2014 . https://web.archive.org/web/20131002051453/http://blogs.abc.net.au/queensland/2013/08/glen-dreuery-the-preference-whisperer.html . 2 October 2013 . dead.
  31. News: 'Preference whisperer' defends role in minor parties' Senate success . Bridie . Jabour . . Australia . 13 September 2013.
  32. News: Western Australia 2013 Senate results and preference flows . .
  33. News: The Preference Deals behind the Strange Election of Ricky Muir and Wayne Dropulich . Antony Green . Green, Antony . . 13 September 2013 . 13 November 2013 .
  34. News: Australian Sports Party 'pleasantly surprised' by potential Senate seat . . 9 September 2013 .
  35. News: Coalition shy of Senate majority . Business Spectator . 9 September 2013 .
  36. News: Tony Abbott fires a warning shot at micro parties in the Senate . WA Today . 9 September 2013 .
  37. News: Xenophon wants voting reform . NineMSN . 9 September 2013 . 18 February 2014 . 17 January 2014 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140117062411/http://news.ninemsn.com.au/national/2013/09/09/08/50/xenophon-wants-voting-reform . dead .