August 2016 Central Italy earthquake explained

Map:Shakemap Earthquake 24 Aug 2016 Italy.jpg
Pushpin Map:Italy
Local-Time:03:36 CEST
Anss-Url:us10006g7d
Isc-Event:611462212
Magnitude:6.2 [1]
Depth:4.4km (02.7miles)[2]
Type:Dip-slip (normal)
Intensity:[3]
Casualties:299 deaths[4]
388 injured[5]
4,500 homeless[6]
August 2016 Central Italy earthquake
Map Alt:USGS ShakeMap of the earthquake
Timestamp:2016-08-24 01:36:32
Countries Affected:Central Italy

An earthquake, measuring 6.2 ± 0.016[1] on the moment magnitude scale, hit Central Italy on 24 August 2016 at 03:36:32 CEST (01:36 UTC). Its epicentre was close to Accumoli, with its hypocentre at a depth of 4 ± 1 km,[2] approximately 75km (47miles) southeast of Perugia and 45km (28miles) north of L'Aquila, in an area near the borders of the Umbria, Lazio, Abruzzo and Marche regions., 299 people had been killed.[4]

Background

The central Apennines is one of the most seismically active areas in Italy. The Apennines mountain belt were formed in the Miocene to Pliocene as a result of the ongoing subduction of the Adriatic Plate beneath the Eurasian Plate, forming a fold and thrust belt. During the Quaternary, thrust tectonics gave way to extensional tectonics, with the development of a zone of normal faulting running along the crest of the mountain range. The extension is a result of either subduction rollback or the opening of the Tyrrhenian Sea. In the Central Apennines the zone of extension is about 30 km wide, closely matching the zone of observed extensional strain as shown by GPS measurements. Recent large earthquakes in this area have been caused by movement on SW-dipping normal faults.[7]

This was the largest tremor since 2009,[8] when an earthquake near L'Aquila in the Abruzzo region killed over 300 people and displaced about 65,000.

Earthquake

The earthquake was initially reported by INGV to have occurred at a depth of approximately 5km (03miles), with a magnitude of 6.0  and epicentre in the comune of Accumoli. The USGS first reported an earthquake at a depth of 10km (10miles) with a magnitude of 6.4  and epicentre southeast of Norcia,[9] [10] but subsequently revised the magnitude to 6.2 . The first seismic wave was recorded at 3:36 a.m.[11] The European-Mediterranean Seismological Centre put the magnitude at 6.1.[12] [13] The discrepancies between the different estimates of the magnitude led INGV to explain in a blog post that they use a crustal velocity model specifically calibrated for Italy and give more weight to the seismometric stations situated close to the epicentre. Using global models, INGV further stated that it can reproduce the values reported by foreign agencies.

, the initial earthquake was followed by at least 2,500 aftershocks.[14] The tremor and a number of aftershocks were felt across the whole of central Italy (from Rimini to Naples), including Rome, Florence and Bologna.[15]

The local school was the first place to be repaired and reopened to the public on 15 September 2016.

Number of earthquakes by magnitude[16]
Date≥6.05.0–5.94.0–4.93.0–3.92.0–2.91.0–1.9≤0.9Total
24 Aug11783214460352
25 Aug00282282331472
26 Aug001141901782385
27 Aug00191303306476
28 Aug0019863516453
29 Aug0005712688352
30 Aug00046930822403
31 Aug00095335522439
Date! class="unsortable" rowspan="2"
Local time
(CEST)
Moment
magnitude
Hypocenter
depth
Epicenter
MunicipalityLatitudeLongitude
24 August 201603:36:32[17] 6.210km (10miles)Norcia42.7113.17
24 August 201603:56:02[18] 4.610km (10miles)Amatrice42.6113.28
24 August 201604:33:29[19] 5.510km (10miles)Norcia42.7913.15
24 August 201604:59:35[20] 4.39km (06miles)Norcia42.8013.14
24 August 201605:40:11[21] 4.310.7km (06.6miles)Amatrice42.6213.25
24 August 201606:06:53[22] 4.410km (10miles)Cascia42.7513.03
24 August 201613:50:31[23] 4.910km (10miles)Visso42.8713.11
24 August 201613:50:57[24] 4.18km (05miles)Arquata del Tronto42.8213.15
24 August 201619:46:09[25] 4.610km (10miles)Arquata del Tronto42.7213.19
25 August 201601:22:06[26] 4.17.3km (04.5miles)Maltignano42.6713.14
25 August 201605:17:16[27] 4.710km (10miles)Norcia42.7813.18
25 August 201605:36:074.310km (10miles)Maltignano42.6513.16
26 August 201606:28:27[28] 4.710km (10miles)Amatrice42.6613.25
27 August 201604:50:59[29] 4.212.2km (07.6miles)Norcia42.8313.15
28 August 201615:07:34[30] 4.311.7km (07.3miles)Amatrice42.6613.24
28 August 201617:55:36[31] 4.65.7km (03.5miles)Norcia42.7813.15
28 August 201618:42:024.310km (10miles)Visso42.8613.03

Casualties and rescue work

+ Nationalities of victims
NationalityDeadInjured
[32]
[33] [34]
[35]
[36] [37]
[38]
[39]
[40]
[41]
-
-

, the official figures of the Protezione Civile report that the earthquake caused the death of 297 people: 234 in Amatrice, 11 in Accumoli and 49 in Arquata del Tronto.[42] At least 365 injured had to be treated in hospitals, mainly in Rieti and Ascoli Piceno, while people with less serious injuries were treated on the spot.[43]

In addition to those rescued with the help of other inhabitants or escaped by themselves, 238 people were pulled alive from the rubble by the timely intervention of the authorities, 215 by the Vigili del Fuoco and 23 by the Soccorso Alpino.[44] [45]

Approximately 2,100 people found shelter at emergency camps. Approximately 4,400 people were involved in the search and rescue operations, including 70 teams with rescue dogs. Logistics made use of 12 helicopters, with nine more on stand-by.[46]

The earthquake killed 280 Italians, 11 Romanians, and several others. The complete list is seen to the right.

Damage

Early reports indicated severe damage in the town of Amatrice, near the epicentre,[47] and in Accumoli and Pescara del Tronto. Sergio Pirozzi, the mayor of Amatrice, stated that "Amatrice is not here anymore, half of the town is destroyed."[48] [49] Photos of the destruction depicted a massive pile of rubble in the town's centre with only a few structures still standing on the outskirts.[50] It also cost an estimated economic loss between $1 billion to $11 billion.[51]

Cultural heritage

In addition to the loss of human life, widespread destruction of cultural heritage is also reported.[52] [53] [54]

In Amatrice, the facade and rose window of the Church of Sant'Agostino were destroyed, and the museum dedicated to the painter Nicola Filotesio, student and companion of Raphael, collapsed. The earthquake also created cracks in the Baths of Caracalla in Rome. The earthquake was so broad that authorities made structural tests on the Colosseum as well, which was not damaged.[54]

The Basilica of Saint Francis of Assisi – a UNESCO World Heritage site with frescoes by Giotto and Cimabue that were partly destroyed by an earthquake in 1997 – was declared safe after an extensive survey by the head restorer.[55] [56]

Robot-assisted disaster response in Amatrice

3D computer models were used to help damage assessment of the Basilica of Saint Francis of Assisi and the Church of Sant'Agostino. The data for building the models was collected by robots deployed by the European project TRADR. Two ground robots and one drone were used inside the San Francesco Basilica, one drone was used inside the Sant'Agostino church, and two drones were used on the outside of both churches.[57] [58]

Controversies

After the earthquake in Central Italy, the court of Rieti discovered that not all the buildings of those cities were constructed or renovated under the antiseismic law of 1974 in which it explained all the construction techniques of an earthquake resistant building. In fact, a family was killed that night by the rubble of a church that was not renovated under that law.[59] Similarly, the Romolo Capranica elementary school in Amatrice partially collapsed, even if in 2013 the town spent 160,000 euros in a seismic retrofit operation that improved the building's seismic resistance, but wasn't enough to comply with 2012 earthquake standards in Italy.[60] The investigation is ongoing to discover the causes that allowed buildings to become reduced to rubble instead of sustaining damage attributed to buildings following anti-seismic regulations, especially Amatrice.

French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo published a cartoon depicting Italian earthquake victims as pasta dishes, causing "shock and outrage."[61] In response to the reaction of Italians unleashed on social networks, the cartoonist Coco pointed out with another cartoon on the official Facebook page of the magazine: "Italians ... it's not Charlie Hebdo who builds your houses, it's the Mafia!"[62] The French ambassador in Rome, in a statement, pointed out that the French Government's position on the Italian earthquake is not that expressed by Charlie Hebdo.[63]

October 2016 and January 2017 earthquakes

See main article: October 2016 Central Italy earthquakes and January 2017 Central Italy earthquakes. A magnitude 6.1 intraplate earthquake struck Italy 3km (02miles) west of Visso on 26 October at 9:18 p.m. local time. The earthquake, initially considered an aftershock of the magnitude 6.2 earthquake in August, struck about 30km (20miles) to the northwest of the August earthquake.[64] The civil protection, however, estimated the consequences less dramatically than feared. According to official data, a man died because he had suffered a heart attack as a result of the quake.[65] On 30 October, an earthquake larger than the 24 August shock struck Norcia with a USGS moment magnitude of 6.6.[66]

A magnitude 5.3 earthquake struck 25 km northwest of L'Aquila on 18 January at 10:25 local time at a depth of 9 km.[67] A stronger, 5.7 tremor hit the same epicentral area at 11:14 local time.[68] A third earthquake of preliminary magnitude of 5.6 struck 11 minutes later.[69] At 14:33 local time, the fourth tremor of a magnitude 5.2 was registered.[70] These earthquakes were followed by multiple aftershocks.

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Origin. USGS Technical. USGS. 26 August 2016.
  2. Web site: Relazione di dettaglio: Rieti Mw 6.0 del 2016-08-24 01:36:32 UTC. it. INGV. 24 August 2016. 25 August 2016.
  3. Paolo Galli . Sergio Castenetto . Edoardo Peronace . The Macroseismic Intensity Distribution of the 30 October 2016 Earthquake in Central Italy (Mw 6.6): Seismotectonic Implications . Tectonics . 2017 . 36 . 10 . 2179–2191 . 10.1002/2017TC004583 . 2017Tecto..36.2179G . 134166952 .
  4. News: Terremoto nell'Italia centrale. È morta una donna ricoverata: le vittime sono 299. it. 15 November 2016. 15 November 2016. Rai News24.
  5. News: Italy Earthquake: Death toll reaches 278 while road damage could see town 'isolated' . . 26 August 2016 . 26 November 2016 . Santalucia, Paolo.
  6. http://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/notizie/2016-09-08/terremoto-curcio-4500-tende-ma-presto-via-li-le-casette-7-mesi-115052.shtml?uuid=ADnS26GB Terremoto, Curcio: 4500 nelle tende, ma presto via da lì. Per le casette 7 mesi
  7. [ftp://ftp-server.rm.ingv.it/pub/nicola.dagostino/papers/dagostino_etal_tectonophysics2008.pdf Contemporary crustal extension in the Umbria–Marche Apennines from regional CGPS networks and comparison between geodetic and seismic deformation]. D'Agostino N. . Mantenuto S. . D'Anastasio E. . Avallone A. . Barchi M. . Collettini C. . Radicioni F. . Stoppini A. . Fastellini G. . Tectonophysics. 2009. 476. 1–2. 3–12. 10.1016/j.tecto.2008.09.033. 2009Tectp.476....3D.
  8. Web site: Breslin. Sean. 6.2 Magnitude Earthquake Hits Italy; Residents Trapped, Major Damage Reported. Weather.com. 24 August 2016. 24 August 2016.
  9. Web site: M6.2 – 10 km SE of Norcia, Italy. United States Geological Survey. 24 August 2016. 24 August 2016.
  10. News: Scherer. Steve. Magnitude 6.4 quake hits Italy near Perugia: USGS. Reuters. 24 August 2016. 24 August 2016.
  11. Web site: Fabio . Carosi . Terremoto ad Amatrice, una perla d'Italia cancellata nell'ora del diavolo . it . 24 August 2016 . https://archive.today/20200508185629/https://www.affaritaliani.it/roma/terremoto-ad-amatrice-una-perla-italia-cancellata-nell-ora-del-diavolo-437571.html . 8 May 2020 . live.
  12. News: Park. Madison. Karimi. Faith. Earthquake hits central Italy. CNN . 24 August 2016. 24 August 2016.
  13. Web site: Santalucia. Paola. Winfield. Nicole. 6.2-magnitude earthquake rattles Rome, central Italy. The Boston Globe. 24 August 2016. 24 August 2016.
  14. News: Terremoto: fino a questo momento più di 2500 scosse dopo quella principale. meteoweb.eu. Earthquake, up to now more than 2500 aftershocks after the main one. it . 31 August 2016.
  15. News: Palazzo. Chiara. Graham. Chris. Squires. Nick. Italy quake: 6.4 magnitude tremor rocks heart of the country. The Telegraph. United Kingdom. 24 August 2016 . 24 August 2016.
  16. Web site: Earthquake list . Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia . Data
  17. Web site: M6.2 – 10 km SE of Norcia, Italy.
  18. Web site: M4.6 – 10 km W of Amatrice, Italy.
  19. Web site: M5.5 – 4 km NE of Norcia, Italy.
  20. Web site: M4.1 – 2 km NNE of Norcia, Italy.
  21. Web site: M4.3 – 4 km W of Amatrice, Italy.
  22. Web site: M4.5 – 4 km NNE of Cascia, Italy.
  23. Web site: M4.9 – 5 km SSE of Visso, Italy.
  24. Web site: M4.1 – 1 km ENE of Amatrice, Italy.
  25. Web site: M4.6 – 10 km WSW of Arquata del Tronto, Italy.
  26. Web site: M4.3 – 10 km ESE of Maltignano, Italy.
  27. Web site: M4.7 – 7 km E of Norcia, Italy.
  28. Web site: M4.7 – 5 km NW of Amatrice, Italy.
  29. Web site: M4.2 – 6 km NE of Norcia, Italy.
  30. Web site: M4.3 – 5 km NW of Amatrice, Italy.
  31. Web site: M4.6 – 4 km E of Norcia, Italy.
  32. Web site: 2016-08-26 . L'elenco delle vittime riconosciute pubblicato dalle prefetture di Rieti e Ascoli Piceno . 2023-02-13 . Corriere della Sera . it.
  33. https://www.balcanicaucaso.org/aree/Romania/Terremoto-anche-la-Romania-piange-173893|titolo=Terremoto: anche la Romania piange
  34. Web site: romaniainsider . 2016-08-29 . Eleven Romanians die in Italy earthquake . 2023-02-13 . Romania Insider . en.
  35. News: 2016-08-25 . Italy earthquake: At least three Britons killed, official says . en-GB . BBC News . 2023-02-13.
  36. Web site: Chi sono le vittime del terremoto in Centro Italia - Panorama . 2023-02-13 . www.panorama.it . it.
  37. One of the injured had dual Macedonian–Albanian nationality
  38. https://www.laprensagrafica.com/departamento15/Salvadorena-muere-en-terremoto-en-Italia-su-hijo-fue-rescatado-con-vida-20160825-0064.html Salvadoreña muere en terremoto en Italia; su hijo fue rescatado con vida
  39. https://www.macleans.ca/news/dion-canadian-killed-italy-earthquake/ Canadian among those killed in Italian earthquake
  40. News: Terremoto, Sayed non ce l'ha fatta Individuato cadavere del rifugiato afgano: il fratello attendeva da giorni. 5 September 2016.
  41. Web site: 2016-08-25 . La española fallecida en el terremoto de Italia es una joven de Granada . 2023-02-13 . Europa Press.
  42. http://www.protezionecivile.gov.it/jcms/it/view_com.wp?contentId=COM58731 "Terremoto Centro Italia: aggiornamento del numero di vittime, feriti e popolazione assistita"
  43. http://www.protezionecivile.gov.it/jcms/it/view_com.wp?contentId=COM58709 "Terremoto Centro Italia: aggiornamento del numero di vittime e feriti"
  44. Web site: Piccolillo . Beatrice Montini, Virginia . 2016-08-26 . Terremoto, 281 morti e 388 i feriti Amatrice decimata: 221 le sue vittime 2.500 le persone senza una casa . 2023-02-13 . Corriere della Sera . it.
  45. Web site: Terremoto, Alfano: "I Vigili del Fuoco e il sistema della sicurezza hanno garantito un'azione pronta di recupero e di salvataggio di tante persone". . 25 August 2016.
  46. http://www.protezionecivile.gov.it/jcms/it/view_com.wp?facetNode_1=f1_1&prevPage=comunicati_stampa&facetNode_2=terremoto_centro_italia_2016&contentId=COM58694 Terremoto Italia centrale: le forze in campo
  47. News: Povoledo. Elisabetta. Mele. Christopher. Large Earthquake Strikes Central Italy. The New York Times. 23 August 2016. 0362-4331. 28 August 2016.
  48. Web site: Mayor of Amatrice: 'the town isn't here any more' after strong earthquake. 24 August 2016. Chrisafis. Angelique. The Guardian. 24 August 2016.
  49. News: Lorenzi. Rossella. Italy Quake: Famous Village 'Isn't Here Any More'. Seeker.com. 24 August 2016. 28 August 2016.
  50. News: Terremoto ad Amatrice, la distruzione vista dall'alto. it. Earthquake at Amatrice, the destruction seen from above. Corriere della Sera. 28 August 2016.
  51. Web site: Reinsurers face up to $166m Italy quake loss. 1 September 2016.
  52. News: Kennedy. Maev. Art experts fear serious earthquake damage to historic Italian buildings. The Guardian. United Kingdom. 24 August 2016. 0261-3077. 28 August 2016.
  53. News: Dichiarante. Anna. Terremoto nel centro Italia, i danni al patrimonio artistico. it. Earthquake in Central Italy, the damage to heritage. La Repubblica. 24 August 2016. 25 August 2016.
  54. News: Terremoto Centro Italia, chiese e monumenti storici danneggiati. Sopralluogo anche al Colosseo: "Tutto ok". it. Earthquake in Central Italy, churches and historical monuments damaged. Inspection also at the Coliseum: "Everything ok". Il Fatto Quotidiano. 24 August 2016. 28 August 2016.
  55. News: Assisi basilica declared safe after fatal earthquake strikes central Italy. McGivern. Hannah. 24 August 2016. The Art Newspaper. 27 August 2016.
  56. News: After Earthquake in Italy, 'Half the Town No Longer Exists'. Povoledo. Elisabetta. The New York Times. 24 August 2016 . 0362-4331. 28 August 2016.
  57. Book: Deployment of Ground and Aerial Robots in Earthquake-Struck Amatrice in Italy (brief report). In: Proceedings of the 2016 IEEE International Symposium on Safety, Security and Rescue Robotics, EPFL, Lausanne, Switzerland, October 23–27, 2016. Ivana . Kruijff-Korbayová . Luigi . Freda . Mario . Gianni . Valsamis . Ntouskos . Vaclav . Hlavac . Vladimir . Kubelka . Erik . Zimmermann . Hartmut . Surmann . Kresimir . Dulic . Wolfgang . Rottner . Emanuele . Gissi . IEEE. 2016. 978-1-5090-4349-1. Lausanne, Switzerland. 278–279.
  58. Web site: TRADR successfully deployed robot technology for disaster response in Amatrice. 1 September 2016. TRADR Project. 8 November 2016.
  59. News: Sisma, nel mirino della procura di Rieti appalti e collaudi: occhi puntati sul campanile killer. tgcom24. Earthquake, the court of Rieti is concentrating on construction sites and tests, eyes on the bell tower killer. it . 29 August 2016.
  60. News: Il crollo della scuola di Amatrice. Il Post. The collapse of the school in Amatrice. it.
  61. Web site: James. McAuley. Jennifer. Hassan. Charlie Hebdo's latest cartoon depicts Italian earthquake victims as pasta dishes. The Washington Post. 4 September 2016. 2 September 2016.
  62. Web site: The drawing of the day, by coco. www.facebook.com . Charlie Hebdo. 2 March 2019.
  63. Web site: French embassy disowns Charlie Hebdo cartoons. ANSA. 2 September 2016 . 5 September 2016.
  64. Web site: M6.1 - 2km NNW of Visso, Italy. United States Geological Survey. 2016-10-26. 26 October 2016.
  65. News: Ein Toter nach schweren Erdbeben in Mittelitalien. www.t-online.de. 2016-10-27.
  66. Web site: M6.6 - 6km N of Norcia, Italy. United States Geological Survey. 30 October 2016. 30 October 2016.
  67. Web site: Earthquake, Magnitude 5.3 - CENTRAL ITALY - 2017 January 18, 09:25:40 UTC. 18 January 2017.
  68. Web site: Earthquake, Magnitude 5.7 - CENTRAL ITALY - 2017 January 18, 10:14:10 UTC. 18 January 2017.
  69. Web site: Earthquake, Magnitude 5.6 - CENTRAL ITALY - 2017 January 18, 10:25:25 UTC. 18 January 2017.
  70. Web site: Earthquake, Magnitude 5.2 - CENTRAL ITALY - 2017 January 18, 13:33:37 UTC. 18 January 2017.