Arrival theorem explained

In queueing theory, a discipline within the mathematical theory of probability, the arrival theorem^[1] (also referred to as the random observer property, ROP or job observer property^[2]) states that "upon arrival at a station, a job observes the system as if in steady state at an arbitrary instant for the system without that job."^[3]

The arrival theorem always holds in open product-form networks with unbounded queues at each node, but it also holds in more general networks. A necessary and sufficient condition for the arrival theorem to be satisfied in product-form networks is given in terms of Palm probabilities in Boucherie & Dijk, 1997. A similar result also holds in some closed networks. Examples of product-form networks where the arrival theorem does not hold include reversible Kingman networks^{[4] [5]} and networks with a delay protocol.

Mitrani offers the intuition that "The state of node i as seen by an incoming job has a different distribution from the state seen by a random observer. For instance, an incoming job can never see all k jobs present at node i, because it itself cannot be among the jobs already present."^[6]

Theorem for arrivals governed by a Poisson process

For Poisson processes the property is often referred to as the PASTA property (Poisson Arrivals See Time Averages) and states that the probability of the state as seen by an outside random observer is the same as the probability of the state seen by an arriving customer.^[7] The property also holds for the case of a doubly stochastic Poisson process where the rate parameter is allowed to vary depending on the state.^[8]

Theorem for Jackson networks

In an open Jackson network with m queues, write $\backslash mathbf\; =\; (n\_1,\; n\_2,\; \backslash ldots,\; n\_m)$ for the state of the network. Suppose $\backslash pi(\backslash mathbf)$ is the equilibrium probability that the network is in state $\backslash mathbf$. Then the probability that the network is in state $\backslash mathbf$ immediately before an arrival to any node is also $\backslash pi(\backslash mathbf)$.

Note that this theorem does not follow from Jackson's theorem, where the steady state in continuous time is considered. Here we are concerned with particular points in time, namely arrival times.^[9] This theorem first published by Sevcik and Mitrani in 1981.

Theorem for Gordon–Newell networks

In a closed Gordon–Newell network with m queues, write

{ n = (n _{1,} n _{2,} \ldots, n _{m)}} for the state of the network. For a customer in transit to state i , let {\alpha _{i(n-e} _{i)}} denote the probability that immediately before arrival the customer 'sees' the state of the system to ben - e _{i} = (n _{1,n} _{2,\ldots,n} _{i} - 1 ,\ldots,n _{m).}

This probability,

{\alpha _{i(n-e} _{i)}} , is the same as the steady state probability for state { n - e _{i}} for a network of the same type with one customer less.^[10] It was published independently by Sevcik and Mitrani,^[11] and Reiser and Lavenberg,^[12] where the result was used to develop mean value analysis.

Notes and References

1. Book: Søren . Asmussen. 10.1007/0-387-21525-5_4 . Queueing Networks and Insensitivity . Applied Probability and Queues . Stochastic Modelling and Applied Probability . 51 . 114–136 . 2003 . 978-0-387-00211-8 .
2. Book: El-Taha, Muhammad. Sample-path Analysis of Queueing Systems. limited. Springer. 1999. 0-7923-8210-2. 94.
3. Van Dijk . N. M. . On the arrival theorem for communication networks . 10.1016/0169-7552(93)90073-D . Computer Networks and ISDN Systems . 25 . 10 . 1135–2013 . 1993 .
4. Boucherie . R. J. . Van Dijk . N. M. . 10.1016/S0166-5316(96)00045-4 . On the arrivai theorem for product form queueing networks with blocking . Performance Evaluation . 29 . 3 . 155 . 1997 .
5. Kingman . J. F. C. . John Kingman . 1969 . Markov Population Processes . Journal of Applied Probability . 6 . 1 . 1–18 . Applied Probability Trust . 3212273. 10.2307/3212273 .
6. Book: Mitrani, Isi . 114 . Modelling of Computer and Communication Systems . CUP . 1987 . 0521314224 .
7. Wolff . R. W. . Poisson Arrivals See Time Averages . 10.1287/opre.30.2.223 . Operations Research . 30 . 2 . 223–231 . 1982 .
8. Van Doorn . E. A. . Regterschot . G. J. K. . 10.1016/0167-6377(88)90036-3 . Conditional PASTA . Operations Research Letters . 7 . 5 . 229 . 1988 .
9. Book: Harrison, Peter G.. Peter G. Harrison. Naresh M.. Patel. Performance Modelling of Communication Networks and Computer Architectures. Addison-Wesley. 1992. 228. 0-201-54419-9. registration.
10. Book: L. . Breuer. Dave . Baum. 10.1007/1-4020-3631-0_5 . Markovian Queueing Networks . An Introduction to Queueing Theory and Matrix-Analytic Methods . limited . 63–61 . 2005 . 1-4020-3630-2 .
11. Sevcik . K. C. . Mitrani . I. . 10.1145/322248.322257 . The Distribution of Queuing Network States at Input and Output Instants . Journal of the ACM . 28 . 2 . 358 . 1981 . free .
12. Reiser . M.. Lavenberg . S. S. . 10.1145/322186.322195 . Mean-Value Analysis of Closed Multichain Queuing Networks . Journal of the ACM. 27 . 2 . 313 . 1980 . free .