Armand Dorville Explained

Armand Dorville (1875–1941) was a French art collector and lawyer whose art collection was plundered during the Nazi occupation of France.

Early years

Armand Isaac Dorville was born in 1875 into a family belonging to the old Parisian bourgeoisie.[1]

His great-grandfather, Alexis Francfort adopted the name Dorville in 1808. His father Léon Albert Dorville was a banker and director of the Bienfaisante israélite, a mutual aid society founded by his own father, Armand Théophile Dorville, in 1843. His mother, Léonie Monteaux, came from a family of bankers from Avignon, established in Paris since the beginning of the Restoration.

After graduating from the Condorcet and Janson de Sailly high schools, Armand Dorville studied law and was admitted to the Paris Court of Appeals in 1897, earning his doctorate in law in 1901. He was awarded the thesis prize in 1902 for his thesis, De l'intérêt moral dans les obligations, étude de droit comparée sur le principe de réparation pécuniaire des dommages non-économiques (Paris, A. Rousseau, 1901). He became secretary of the Conference of Lawyers (1903-1904) and began his career as an associate of Jean Cruppi.

Art Collector

Armand Dorville's art collection included 450 works by Bonnard, Vuillard, Renoir, Manet, Signac, Caillebotte, Daumier, Degas, Vallotton,[2] [3] Delacroix, Rodin, Carpeaux and also an artist he particularly liked, Constantin Guys.[4] [5]

Persecution during the Occupation of France

When Nazi Germany invaded France in 1940, and anti-Jewish laws were imposed, Dorville took refuge in Cubjac, in Périgord, where he died in 1941.

His estate which included furniture, paintings,[6] drawings, sculptures, books and manuscripts, was put up for auction. Under the title "a Parisian amateur's cabinet", the main part, from June 24 to 27, 1942 at the Hotel Savoy in Nice, included 450 works by Bonnard, Vuillard,[7] Renoir, Manet, Signac, Caillebotte, Daumier, Degas, Vallotton, Delacroix, Rodin, Carpeaux and Constantin Guys.

The Commissariat-General for Jewish Affairs (Commissariat aux questions juives) sent an administrator, Amédée Croze, who informed the auctioneer that he would seize the proceeds, which exceeded nine million francs.[4] The Dorville family received nothing at the time. Dorville's sister Valentine, his two daughters and his two granddaughters, aged two and four died in deportation to Auschwitz.[8] [9] [10]

The Louvre's René Huyghe, who knew the collection belonged to Dorville, bought twelve lots with French government funds for France's museums.[11]

The paintings were hung in French museums,[12] and the story remained secret for seventy years until the French researcher Emmanuelle Polack was hired in 2020 by the Louvre to investigate the provenance of its artworks and immediately found ten Nazi-looted paintings in its collections.[13] [14] [15]

Claims for restitution

Some artworks from Dorville's collection turned up in the stash of Cornelius Gurlitt, the son of one of Hitler's official art dealers, Hildebrand Gurlitt.[16] [17] [18] On January 22, 2020 in Berlin, in the presence of Monika Grütters, German Minister of Culture, two paintings by the painter Jean-Louis Forain (1852-1931) and one by Constantin Guys (1802-1892) were to be officially returned to Dorville's heirs.[19]

In 2021, two private collectors from Nice returned a small painting attributed to de Nittis to Dorville's heirs [20]

As of March 2021 French museums still held eighteen artworks from the Dorville collection.[21] Other paintings, including Henri Fantin-Latour's Still Life with Roses and Fruit, acquired at the Hotel de Savoy, Nice auction in 1942, are currently in European[22] or American museums[23] or in private collections.

The Louvre restituted to the Dorville family the twelve paintings purchased directly by Huyghes at the 1942 Hotel de Savoy Nice auction.[24] However, according to The Art Newspaper, the official position of the French state is that the Dorville auction was not linked to Nazi persecution of Jews and that there is no reason for restitution:

"Once again, French museums are heading to court over their refusal to restitute works of art claimed by Jewish families persecuted by the Nazis. On Friday, attorney Corinne Hershkovitch summoned the Musée du Louvre and Musée d'Orsay, as well as France's culture ministry and four provincial museums, demanding the restitution of 21 works from the collection of Armand Isaac Dorville. The state claims that the objects were not looted but sold in an estate sale after Dorville's death.[25]

In October 2021 Berlin’s Alte Nationalgalerie restituted the Camille Pissarro painting, "A Square in La Roche-Guyon" (1867) to the Dorville heirs, and then purchased it back from them as it was a "core holding".[26]

Paintings from the Dorville collection ended up in several American museums, including in the Minneaopolis Institute of Art, The Yale University Art Gallery and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York.[27] [28] [29]

In 2024 UNC-Chapel Hill’s Ackland Art Museum restituted the painting The Studio of Thomas Couture, (L'atelier du Maître / The Master's workshop).[30] [31]

See also

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Armand Dorville, avocat, collectionneur. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20211016163038/https://www.cairn.info/revue-archives-juives1-2017-1-page-140.htm . 2021-10-16 .
  2. Web site: Jeune femme cousant / Young woman sewing Lost Art Database . 2024-02-16 . www.lostart.de.
  3. Web site: Enchères VALLOTTON Félix (1865-192... - Lot 43 - « Paysage maritime à Varengeville... Gazette Drouot . 2024-02-16 . www.gazette-drouot.com . fr.
  4. Web site: Ventes Dorville : l'État récuse la spoliation. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20210614161109/https://www.gazette-drouot.com/article/ventes-dorville-%3A--l-etat-recuse-la-spoliation/25059. 2021-06-14. 2021-10-16. gazette-drouot.com. 10 June 2021 . fr.
  5. Book: Polack, Emmanuelle. Le marché de l'art sous l'Occupation, 1940-1944. 2021. 979-10-210-4984-0. 1272852427.
  6. Web site: Les promeneurs du parc / Walkers in the park Lost Art Database . 2024-02-16 . www.lostart.de.
  7. Web site: Edouard Vuillard (1868-1940) Lucy Hessel au ruban de velours noir . Christies . PROVENANCE Armand Dorville, Paris; his sale, Hall du Savoy, Nice, 24-27 June 1942, lot 397 (illustrated). Anonymous sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, 24 April 1947, lot 71 (illustrated). The Leicester Galleries, London. Captain Richard A. Peto, Isle of Wight, by 1960. Arthur Tooth & Sons Ltd., London (no. 8570). Acquired from the above by Maurice and Vivienne Wohl on 12 October 1968..
  8. News: 2021-03-25. Nouvelle restitution aux héritiers spoliés d'Armand Dorville. fr-FR. La Croix. 2021-10-16. https://web.archive.org/web/20211016161700/https://www.la-croix.com/Culture/Nouvelle-restitution-heritiers-spolies-dArmand-Dorville-2021-03-25-1201147579. 2021-10-16. 0242-6056.
  9. Web site: Ventes Dorville : l'État récuse la spoliation. 2021-10-17. gazette-drouot.com. 10 June 2021 . fr.
  10. Web site: McAuley. James. Love and Theft. live. 2021-10-17. www.lootedart.com. Even Magazine. After the German invasion of France, Dorville fled Paris to his château in the Dordogne, where he died of natural causes in July 1941. The Vichy government confiscated his property, and his vast art collection was auctioned in Nice on four consecutive days in late June 1942. Neither his will nor his earlier bequest to the Musée des Arts Décoratifs suggested that Dorville had intended such an auction, and no effort was made to transfer his possessions to the family members who still stood to inherit the collection. In the end, almost all of his family would be deported and murdered in April 1944.. https://web.archive.org/web/20180501195645/https://www.lootedart.com/news.php?r=SVQJGV315551 . 2018-05-01 .
  11. News: Sciolino. Elaine. 2021-07-16. The Louvre's Art Sleuth Is on the Hunt for Looted Paintings. en-US. The New York Times. 2021-10-17. 0362-4331.
  12. News: 2021-07-16. Works From the Dorville Sale in the Louvre Collection. en-US. The New York Times. 2021-10-17. 0362-4331.
  13. Web site: 2020-01-13 . Nazi loot expert joins Louvre to investigate its wartime acquisitions . 2023-11-15 . The Art Newspaper - International art news and events.
  14. Web site: Machemer. Theresa. Art Historian Identifies Ten Nazi-Looted Paintings in the Louvre's Collections. 2021-10-17. Smithsonian Magazine. en.
  15. News: 2020-01-22. Dix œuvres du Louvre sont issues de la collection d'Armand Dorville, spolié sous Vichy. fr. Le Monde.fr. 2021-10-17.
  16. Web site: Packard. Cassie. 2020-01-16. Sotheby's Auctions Impressionist Paintings Recovered From Nazi Looting; Watercolors by JFK Also Go to Auction. 2021-10-16. Hyperallergic. en-US.
  17. Web site: Provenienzbericht zu Forain, Portrait de femme / Porträt einer Frau mit Hut im Profil, Lost Art-ID: 478437 Proveana. 2021-10-17. www.proveana.de.
  18. Web site: 2020-01-23. Three Nazi-looted works bought by Gurlitt return to Jewish collector's heirs. 2021-10-17. The Art Newspaper - International art news and events.
  19. Web site: Pillées sous l'Occupation, trois œuvres officiellement restituées aux héritiers d'Armand Dorville Emmanuelle Polack Site officiel. 2021-10-16. fr-FR.
  20. News: 2021-03-25. Nouvelle restitution aux héritiers spoliés d'Armand Dorville. fr-FR. La Croix. 2021-10-16. 0242-6056.
  21. News: 2021-03-25. Nouvelle restitution aux héritiers spoliés d'Armand Dorville. fr-FR. La Croix. 2021-10-17. 0242-6056. Les musées français détiennent toujours 18 œuvres réclamées par ces mêmes héritiers..
  22. Web site: Koninklijke Bibliotheek bezit nazi-roofkunst - The Royal Library has Nazi-looted Art . 2023-06-30 . www.lootedart.com . A study by this newspaper shows that the Royal Library in Brussels also has a work from the Dorville collection in its depot. It is 'La buveuse d'absinthe', a watercolour by Félicien Rops dating to 1876. The Library acquire the painting from a French art dealer in 1968. The documentation makes it clear that it is the same watercolour as the one that was auctioned off in Nice during the Second World War..
  23. Web site: Still Life with Roses and Fruit 1863 Henri Fantin-Latour. live. 2021-10-17. www.metmuseum.org. https://web.archive.org/web/20160305071701/http://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/436292 . 2016-03-05 .
  24. Web site: L'Etat va rendre aux ayants droit d'Armand Dorville douze œuvres des collections nationales achetées en juin 1942. 2021-10-17. www.culture.gouv.fr. fr.
  25. Web site: 2021-07-15. French museums face fresh legal action over refusal to restitute works to Jewish families. 2021-10-17. The Art Newspaper - International art news and events.
  26. Web site: 2021-10-18. Berlin museum restitutes—and then buys back—Nazi-looted Pissarro painting. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20211018162611/https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2021/10/18/berlin-museum-restitutesand-then-buys-backnazi-looted-pissarro-painting. 2021-10-18. 2021-11-06. The Art Newspaper - International art news and events.
  27. News: Sciolino . Elaine . 2021-07-16 . The Louvre’s Art Sleuth Is on the Hunt for Looted Paintings . 2024-02-16 . The New York Times . en-US . 0362-4331.
  28. Web site: Henri Fantin-Latour Still Life with Roses and Fruit . 2024-02-16 . The Metropolitan Museum of Art . en.
  29. Web site: Cristal, roses blanches, raisin et poire / Crystal, white roses, grapes and pears Lost Art Database . 2024-02-16 . www.lostart.de.
  30. Web site: 2024-01-17 . More than 80 years after it was taken from a Jewish family, a painting at a NC museum returns home . 2024-02-16 . WUNC . en.
  31. Web site: L'atelier du Maître / The Master's workshop Lost Art Database . 2024-02-16 . www.lostart.de.

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Armand Dorville".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.