This list comprises all players who have participated in at least one league match for Long Island Rough Riders in the USL since the league began keeping detailed records in 2003. Players who were on the roster but never played a first team game are not listed; players who appeared for the team in other competitions (US Open Cup, etc.) but never actually made an USL appearance are noted at the bottom of the page where appropriate.
A "*" indicates a player known to have appeared for the team prior to 2003.