Starting in the 1945 season, on its third year of operation, the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League honored with the Player of the Year Award the top performer in the circuit. The AAGPBL folded at the end of the 1954 season. This is the list of winners.
| Year | Player! | Team | Position | Highlights | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Connie Wisniewski | Grand Rapids Chicks | 32–11, 0.81 earned run average | |||
| .286 batting average, 117 runs, 201 stolen bases | |||||
| Pitcher / Outfield | 11–4, 0.98 ERA / .280 BA | ||||
| Outfield | .312 BA, 56 runs batted in, 70 runs, 53 SB, .469 slugging average | ||||
| Pitcher / Outfield | 15–10, 1.58 ERA / .279 BA, 35 R, 35 RBI, 29 SB | ||||
| Pitcher | 19–7, 1.38 ERA | ||||
| Pitcher | 15–7, 1.33 ERA, 135 strikeouts, one perfect game | ||||
| .331 BA, .505 SLG, 74 RBI, 81 runs, 56 SB | |||||
| Pitcher | 17–11, 1.51 ERA, 143 SO, one perfect game | ||||
| Outfield | .429 BA, 29 home runs, 87 RBI, 109 runs, .763 SLG |