Alarodian languages explained

Alarodian
Acceptance:controversial
Familycolor:Caucasian
Family:Proposed language family
Glotto:none

The Alarodian languages are a proposed language family that encompasses the Northeast Caucasian (Nakh–Dagestanian) languages and the extinct Hurro-Urartian languages.

History

The term Alarodian is derived from Greek Ἀλαρόδιοι (Alarodioi), the name of an ethnic group mentioned by Herodotus which has often been equated with the people of the kingdom of Urartu, although this equation is considered doubtful by modern scholars. A leading Urartologist, Paul Zimansky, rejects a connection between the Urartians and the Alarodians.[1] Nearly nothing is known about the Alarodians except that they "were armed like the Colchians and Saspeires," according to Herodotus.[2] The Colchians and Saspeires are generally associated with the Kartvelians and/or Scythians, neither of whom spoke a Hurro-Urartian or Northeast Caucasian language

Historically, the term "Alarodian languages" was employed for several language family proposals of various size. Sayce (1880) employed the name for a small group that comprised Urartian (then called "Vannic") and the Kartvelian languages (Georgian, Laz, Mingrelian, and Svan).[3] In 1884, the German orientalist Fritz Hommel further included all languages of the Caucasus and the ancient Near East which did not belong to the Indo-European, Semitic, and the now obsolete Ural–Altaic language families, e.g. Elamite, Kassite.[4] Later, he extended the Alarodian family to include the pre-Indo-European languages of Europe, e.g. Lemnian, Etruscan, Ligurian. Karel Oštir's (1921) version of Alarodian included all aforementioned languages, further Basque, Sumerian, Egyptian, the Cushitic and Berber languages.[5] [6] The historical Alarodian proposal – especially Oštir's maximal extension – was however not well-received by the majority of scholars ("Ce petit livre donne le vertige"—"This little book makes one dizzy", A. Meillet),[7] and eventually abandoned.

The term "Alarodian languages" was revived by I. M. Diakonoff for the proposed language family that unites the Hurro-Urartian and Northeast Caucasian languages.[8] Work by I. M. Diakonoff and Starostin (1986) asserted the connection between "Nakh-Dagestanian" (NE Caucasian) and Hurro-Urartian on the basis of comparison of their reconstruction to Proto-Nakh-Dagestanian, later published in 1994 with Nikolayev.[9]

Proposed relation to Tyrsenian

The inclusion of Etruscan and the related Tyrsenian languages has also been proposed, first by Orel and Starostin in 1990, on the basis of sound correspondences.[10] Facchetti has argued that there is a "curious" set of isoglosses between Etruscan and Hurrian,[11] while Pliev proposed instead that Etruscan had a Nakh substrate.[12] In 2006, Robertson further developed the hypothesis for including Tyrsenian based on proposed Etruscan/Nakh sound correspondences and reconstructions for the numerals.[13]

Reception

The validity of the Alarodian hypothesis remains fairly controversial.[14] Many scholars doubt that the Hurro-Urartian and Northeastern Caucasian languages are related,[15] [16] [17] or believe that, while a connection is possible, the evidence is far from conclusive.[18] [19] [20] The Indo-Europeanist Allan R. Bomhard argues instead for a genetic relationship between Hurro-Urartian and Indo-European[21] [22] (most experts exclude a close genetic relationship between Northeast Caucasian and Indo-European, making the two hypotheses probably exclusive). The Caucasian language specialist Johanna Nichols grounds her scepticism in the Alarodian theory in that "neither Diakonoff and Starostin, nor Nikolayev and Starostin, take on the burden of proof and discuss whether the incidence of resemblances exceeds chance expectation, nor do they present examples of the kind of shared morphological paradigmaticity that would strongly support genetic relatedness".[23]

Nevertheless, Petri Kallio, a Uralicist and Indo-Europeanist, argues that from the perspective of what relationships are most likely for Northeast Caucasian, the Alarodian theory is considered the most promising, more so than the attempts to link Northeast and Northwest Caucasian,[24] let alone attempts to link Northeast Caucasian to Indo-European, Kartvelian, Etruscan, Burushaski, or "Dene-Caucasian". A major obstacle to progress on the question (and any other questions about relationships with or within Northeast Caucasian) is the lack of consensus about the reconstruction of Proto-Northeast-Caucasian itself.[24]

See also

References

  1. Zimansky, Paul "Urartian and Urartians." The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia (2011): 556. https://www.academia.edu/10023756/Urartian_and_the_Urartians
  2. https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Herodotus/7b*.html Herodotus. Book VII: chapters 57‑137
  3. Book: Sayce, A. H. . 1880 . Introduction to the Science of Language, vol. 2 . London . C. Kegan Paul & Co. .
  4. Hommel . Fritz . 1884 . Die sumero-akkadische Sprache und ihre Verwandtschaftsverhältnisse . Zeitschrift für Keilschriftforschung . 1 . 161–178, 195–221, 323–342 . de .
  5. Oštir, Karel. (1921). Beiträge zur Alarodischen Sprachwissenschaft (a monograph), I, (in German)
  6. Čop . Bojan . 1973 . Oštirs sprachwissenschaftliche Ideenwelt . Linguistica . 13 . 1 . 13–96 . Ljubljana University Press . 10.4312/linguistica.13.1.13-96 . free .
  7. Antoine Meillet . Meillet . Antoine . 1922 . Comptes rendus . Bulletin de la Société de linguistique . 22 . 128–130 .
  8. Diakonoff . Igor M. . 1995 . Long-Range Linguistic Relations: Cultural Transmission or Consanguinity? . Mother Tongue . 24 . 34–40 .
  9. Nikolayev, S. L. and Starostin, S. A. A North Caucasian etymological dictionary. Moscow: Asterisk, 1994
  10. Orël, Vladimir and Starostin, Sergei. Etruscan as an East Caucasian language. In Vitaly Shevoroshkin (ed.), Protolanguages and proto-cultures, Bochum: Brockmeyer, 1990.
  11. Facchetti, Giulio M. Appunti di morfologia etrusca. Firenze: Leo S. Olschki, 2002
  12. Pliev, R. S. Nakhskoetrusskie leksikheskie vstrekhi. Nalchik: Kabardino-Balkarskij Gosudarstvennyj Universitet, 2000.
  13. Ed . Robertson . Etruscan's genealogical linguistic relationship with Nakh–Daghestanian: a preliminary evaluation . 2006 . 2009-07-13 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20110810021157/http://www.nostratic.ru/books/(329)EGRWND.pdf . 10 August 2011 .
  14. Tuite, Kevin. 143379084. The Rise and Fall and Revival of the Ibero‑Caucasian Hypothesis.. Historiographia Linguistica. 35. 1. 2008. 23–82. 10.1075/hl.35.1-2.05tui.
  15. Smeets, Rieks "On Hurro-Urartian as an Eastern Caucasian language." Bibliotheca Orientalis XLVI (1989): 260-280. https://glottolog.org/resource/reference/id/315299
  16. Book: Nichols, Johanna . 2003 . The Nakh-Daghestanian Consonant Correspondences . Howard Isaac Aronson . Dee Ann Holisky . Kevin Tuite . Current Trends in Caucasian, East European and Inner Asian Linguistics: Papers in honor of Howard I. Aronson . Amsterdam . John Benjamins . 207–264 . 9789027247582 .
  17. Fournet, Arnaud "About the Vocalic System of Armenian Words of Substratic Origins" Archiv Orientální (2013): 1 https://www.academia.edu/5551322/Arch%C3%ADv_Orientalni._2013._About_the_vocalic_system_of_Armenian_words_of_substratic_origin._81.2_207_22_
  18. Zimansky, Paul "Urartian and Urartians." The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia (2011): 556.http://www.academia.edu/10023756/Urartian_and_the_Urartians
  19. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Caucasian-languages Gamkrelidze, Thomas V.; Gudava, T.E. (1998). "Caucasian Languages"
  20. Kallio, Petri. "XXI. Beyond Indo-European". In Klein, Jared; Joseph, Brian; Fritz, Matthew (eds.). Handbook of Comparative and Historical Indo-European Linguistics. De Gruyter Mouton. pp. 2285–2286.
  21. Book: Fournet . Arnaud . Bomhard . Allan R. . 2010 . The Indo-European Elements in Hurrian . La Garenne Colombes, Charleston . Self-published online study .
  22. https://www.academia.edu/40055347/PIE_roots_in_Hurrian Fournet, Arnaud "PIE Roots in Hurrian" (2019): 1
  23. Book: The Nakh Dagestanian consonant correspondences. Johanna Nichols. https://books.google.com/books?id=KDaUezvjKfsC&pg=PA208. Current Trends in Caucasian, East European, and Inner Asian Linguistics: Papers in Honor of Howard I. Aronson. January 2003. John Benjamins Publishing. Dee Ann Holisky . Kevin Tuite. 208. 9027247587.
  24. Book: Kallio . Petri . Klein . Jared . Joseph . Brian . Fritz . Matthew . Handbook of Comparative and Historical Indo-European Linguistics . De Gruyter Mouton . 2285–2286 . XXI. Beyond Indo-European.

Literature

External links

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Alarodian languages".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.