Atacama Large Millimeter Array Explained

The Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) is an astronomical interferometer of 66 radio telescopes in the Atacama Desert of northern Chile, which observe electromagnetic radiation at millimeter and submillimeter wavelengths. The array has been constructed on the elevation Chajnantor plateau – near the Llano de Chajnantor Observatory and the Atacama Pathfinder Experiment. This location was chosen for its high elevation and low humidity, factors which are crucial to reduce noise and decrease signal attenuation due to Earth's atmosphere.[1] ALMA provides insight on star birth during the early Stelliferous era and detailed imaging of local star and planet formation.[2] [3]

ALMA is an international partnership amongst Europe, the United States, Canada, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and Chile.[4] Costing about US$1.4 billion, it is the most expensive ground-based telescope in operation.[5] [6] ALMA began scientific observations in the second half of 2011 and the first images were released to the press on 3 October 2011. The array has been fully operational since March 2013.[7] [8]

Overview

The initial ALMA array is composed of 66 high-precision antennae, and operates at wavelengths of 3.6 to 0.32 millimeters (31 to 1000 GHz).[9] The array has much higher sensitivity and higher resolution than earlier submillimeter telescopes such as the single-dish James Clerk Maxwell Telescope or existing interferometer networks such as the Submillimeter Array or the Institut de Radio Astronomie Millimétrique (IRAM) Plateau de Bure facility.

The antennae can be moved across the desert plateau over distances from 150 m to 16 km, which will give ALMA a powerful variable "zoom", similar in its concept to that employed at the centimeter-wavelength Very Large Array (VLA) site in New Mexico, United States.

The high sensitivity is mainly achieved through the large numbers of antenna dishes that make up the array.

The telescopes were provided by the European, North American and East Asian partners of ALMA. The American and European partners each provided twenty-five 12-meter diameter antennae, for a subtotal of fifty antennae, that compose the main array. The participating East Asian countries are contributing 16 antennae (four 12-meter diameter and twelve 7-meter diameter antennae) in the form of the Atacama Compact Array (ACA), which is part of the enhanced ALMA.

By using smaller antennae than the main ALMA array, larger fields of view can be imaged at a given frequency using ACA. Placing the antennae closer together enables the imaging of sources of larger angular extent. The ACA works together with the main array in order to enhance the latter's wide-field imaging capability.

History

ALMA has its conceptual roots in three astronomical projects: the Millimeter Array (MMA) of the United States, the Large Southern Array (LSA) of Europe, and the Large Millimeter Array (LMA) of Japan.

The first step toward the creation of what would become ALMA came in 1997, when the National Radio Astronomy Observatory (NRAO) and the European Southern Observatory (ESO) agreed to pursue a common project that merged the MMA and LSA. The merged array combined the sensitivity of the LSA with the frequency coverage and superior site of the MMA. ESO and NRAO worked together in technical, science, and management groups to define and organise a joint project between the two observatories with participation by Canada and Spain (the latter became a member of ESO later).

A series of resolutions and agreements led to the choice of "Atacama Large Millimeter Array", or ALMA, as the name of the new array in March 1999 and the signing of the ALMA Agreement on 25 February 2003, between the North American and European parties. ("Alma" means "soul" in Spanish and "learned" or "knowledgeable" in Arabic.) Following mutual discussions over several years, the ALMA Project received a proposal from the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan (NAOJ) whereby Japan would provide the ACA (Atacama Compact Array) and three additional receiver bands for the large array, to form Enhanced ALMA. Further discussions between ALMA and NAOJ led to the signing of a high-level agreement on 14 September 2004 that makes Japan an official participant in Enhanced ALMA, to be known as the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array. A groundbreaking ceremony was held on November 6, 2003 and the ALMA logo was unveiled.[10]

During an early stage of the planning of ALMA, it was decided to employ ALMA antennae designed and constructed by known companies in North America, Europe, and Japan, rather than using one single design. This was mainly for political reasons. Although very different approaches have been chosen by the providers, each of the antenna designs appears to be able to meet ALMA's stringent requirements. The components designed and manufactured across Europe were transported by specialist aerospace and astrospace logistics company Route To Space Alliance,[11] 26 in total which were delivered to Antwerp for onward shipment to Chile.

Funding

ALMA was initially a 50-50 collaboration between the National Radio Astronomy Observatory and European Southern Observatory (ESO) and later extended with the help of the other Japanese, Taiwanese, and Chilean partners.[12] ALMA is the largest and most expensive ground-based astronomical project, costing between US$1.4 and 1.5 billion.[13] (However, various space astronomy projects including the Hubble Space Telescope, the James Webb Space Telescope, and several major planet probes have cost considerably more).

Partners

Construction

The complex was built primarily by European, U.S., Japanese, and Canadian companies and universities. Three prototype antennae have undergone evaluation at the Very Large Array since 2002.

General Dynamics C4 Systems and its SATCOM Technologies division was contracted by Associated Universities, Inc. to provide twenty-five of the 12 m antennae,[14] while European manufacturer Thales Alenia Space provided the other twenty-five principal antennae[15] (in the largest-ever European industrial contract in ground-based astronomy). Japan's Mitsubishi Electric was contracted to assemble NAOJ's 16 antennae.[16] [17] The antennae were delivered to the site from December 2008 to September 2013.[18]

Transporting the antennae

Transporting the 115 tonne antennae from the Operations Support Facility at 2900 m altitude to the site at 5000 m, or moving antennae around the site to change the array size, presents enormous challenges; as portrayed in the television documentary Monster Moves: Mountain Mission.[19] The solution chosen is to use two custom 28-wheel self-loading heavy haulers. The vehicles were made by [20] in Germany and are 10 m wide, 20 m long and 6 m high, weighing 130 tonnes. They are powered by twin turbocharged 500 kW Diesel engines.

The transporters, which feature a driver's seat designed to accommodate an oxygen tank to aid breathing the thin high-altitude air, place the antennae precisely on the pads. The first vehicle was completed and tested in July 2007.[21] Both transporters were delivered to the ALMA Operations Support Facility (OSF) in Chile on 15 February 2008.

On 7 July 2008, an ALMA transporter moved an antenna for the first time, from inside the antenna assembly building (Site Erection Facility) to a pad outside the building for testing (holographic surface measurements).[22]

During Autumn 2009, the first three antennae were transported one-by-one to the Array Operations Site. At the end of 2009, a team of ALMA astronomers and engineers successfully linked three antennae at the 5000m (16,000feet) elevation observing site thus finishing the first stage of assembly and integration of the fledgling array. Linking three antennae allows corrections of errors that can arise when only two antennae are used, thus paving the way for precise, high-resolution imaging. With this key step, commissioning of the instrument began 22 January 2010.

On 28 July 2011, the first European antenna for ALMA arrived at the Chajnantor plateau, 5,000 meters above sea level, to join 15 antennae already in place from the other international partners. This was the number of antennae specified for ALMA to begin its first science observations, and was therefore an important milestone for the project.[23] In October 2012, 43 of the 66 antennae had been set up.

Scientific results

Images from initial testing

By the summer of 2011, sufficient telescopes were operational during the extensive program of testing prior to the Early Science phase for the first images to be captured.[24] These early images gave a first glimpse of the potential of the new array that will produce much better quality images in the future as the scale of the array continues to increase.

The target of the observation was a pair of colliding galaxies with dramatically distorted shapes, known as the Antennae Galaxies. Although ALMA did not observe the entire galaxy merger, the result is the best submillimeter-wavelength image ever made of the Antennae Galaxies, showing the clouds of dense cold gas from which new stars form, which cannot be seen using visible light.

Comet studies

On 11 August 2014, astronomers released studies, using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) for the first time, that detailed the distribution of HCN, HNC, H2CO, and dust inside the comae of comets C/2012 F6 (Lemmon) and C/2012 S1 (ISON).[25] [26]

Planetary formation

An image of the protoplanetary disc surrounding HL Tauri (a very young T Tauri star[27] in the constellation Taurus) was made public in 2014, showing a series of concentric bright rings separated by gaps, indicating protoplanet formation., most theories did not expect planetary formation in such a young (100,000-1,000,000-year-old) system, so the new data spurred renewed theories of protoplanetary development. One theory suggests that the faster accretion rate might be due to the complex magnetic field of the protoplanetary disc.[28]

Event Horizon Telescope

See main article: Event Horizon Telescope. ALMA participated in the Event Horizon Telescope project, which produced the first direct image of a black hole, published in 2019.[29]

Phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus

ALMA participated in the claimed detection of phosphine, a biomarker, in the air of Venus. As no known non-biological source of phosphine on Venus could produce phosphine in the concentrations detected, this would have indicated the presence of biological organisms in the atmosphere of Venus.[30] [31] Later reanalyses cast doubt on the detection,[32] although later analyses confirmed the results.[33] The detection remains controversial, and is awaiting additional measurements.[34] [35]

Global collaboration

The Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA), an international astronomy facility, is a partnership of Europe, North America and East Asia in cooperation with the Republic of Chile. ALMA is funded in Europe by the European Southern Observatory (ESO), in North America by the U.S. National Science Foundation (NSF) in cooperation with the National Research Council of Canada (NRC) and the National Science Council of Taiwan (NSC) and in East Asia by the National Institutes of Natural Sciences of Japan (NINS) in cooperation with the Academia Sinica (AS) in Taiwan. ALMA construction and operations are led on behalf of Europe by ESO, on behalf of North America by the National Radio Astronomy Observatory (NRAO), which is managed by Associated Universities, Inc (AUI) and on behalf of East Asia by the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan (NAOJ). The Joint ALMA Observatory (JAO) provides the unified leadership and management of the construction, commissioning and operation of ALMA.[36] Its current director since February 2018 is Sean Dougherty.[37]

ALMA regional centre (ARC)

The ALMA regional centre (ARC) has been designed as an interface between user communities of the major contributors of the ALMA project and the JAO. Activates for operating the ARC have also divided into the three main regions involved (Europe, North America and East Asia). The European ARC (led by ESO) has been further subdivided into ARC-nodes[38] located across Europe in Bonn-Bochum-Cologne, Bologna, Ondřejov, Onsala, IRAM (Grenoble), Leiden and JBCA (Manchester).

The core purpose of the ARC is to assist the user community with the preparation of observing proposals, ensure observing programs meet their scientific goals efficiently, run a help-desk for submitting proposals and observing programs, delivering the data to principal investigators, maintenance of the ALMA data archive, assistance with the calibration of data and providing user feedback.[39]

Project detail

Atacama Compact Array

The Atacama Compact Array, ACA, is a subset of 16 closely separated antennae that will greatly improve ALMA's ability to study celestial objects with a large angular size, such as molecular clouds and nearby galaxies. The antennae forming the Atacama Compact Array, four 12-meter antennae and twelve 7-meter antennae, were produced and delivered by Japan. In 2013, the Atacama Compact Array was named the Morita Array after Professor Koh-ichiro Morita, a member of the Japanese ALMA team and designer of the ACA, who died on 7 May 2012 in Santiago.[40]

Work stoppage

In August 2013, workers at the telescope went on strike to demand better pay and working conditions. This is one of the first strikes to affect an astronomical observatory. The work stoppage began after the observatory failed to reach an agreement with the workers' union.[41] [42] [43] [44] After 17 days an agreement was reached providing for reduced schedules and higher pay for work done at high altitude.[45] [46]

In March 2020, ALMA was shut down due to the COVID-19 pandemic. It also delayed the cycle 8 proposal submission deadline and suspended public visits to the site.[47]

On October 29, 2022, ALMA suspended observations due to a cyber attack.[48] Observations were restarted 48 days later, on December 16, 2022.[49]

Project timeline

Timeline!style="width:10em;"
DateActivity
1995ESO/NRAO/NAOJ joint site testing with Chile.
May 1998Start of phase 1 (design & development).
June 1999European/U.S. memorandum of understanding for design & development.
February 2003Final European / North American agreement, with 50% of funding from ESO, and 50% of funding shared between USA and Canada.
April 2003Testing of first prototype antenna begins at the ALMA Test Facility (ATF) site in Socorro, New Mexico.
November 2003Groundbreaking ceremony at ALMA site.
September 2004European, North American & Japanese draft agreement, with Japan providing new extensions to ALMA.
October 2004Opening of Joint ALMA office, Santiago, Chile.
September 2005Taiwan joins the ALMA Project through Japan.
July 2006European, North American & Japanese amend agreement on the Enhanced ALMA.
April 2007Arrival of first antenna in Chile.
February 2008Arrival of the two ALMA transporters in Chile.
July 2008First antenna movement with a transporter.
December 2008Acceptance of the first ALMA antenna.
May 2009First interferometry with two antennae at the Operations Support Facility (OSF).
September 2009First move of an ALMA antenna to Chajnantor.
November 2009Phase closure with three antennae at Chajnantor.
2010Call for shared-risk Early Science proposals.
September 2011Start of Early Science Cycle 0. Sixteen 12-m antennae in the 12-m array.
February 2012First paper published with ALMA data[50]
January 2013Start of Early Science Cycle 1. Thirty-two 12-m antennae in the 12-m array.
March 13, 2013ALMA Inauguration.
September 23, 201366th and final antenna arrived and accepted.
June 2014Start of Early Science Cycle 2. Thirty-four 12-m antennae in the 12-m array, nine 7-m antennae in the 7-m array, and two 12-m antennae in the TP array.
June 2018ALMA 1000th published paper[51]
March 2020ALMA shut down due to the COVID-19 crisis

See also

Further reading

External links

Notes and References

  1. 10.1086/679330 . Parque Astronómico de Atacama: An Ideal Site for Millimeter, Submillimeter, and Mid-Infrared Astronomy . 2014 . Bustos . R. . Rubio . M. . Otárola . A. . Nagar . N. . Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific . 126 . 946 . 1126 . 1410.2451 . 2014PASP..126.1126B . 118539242 . 3 .
  2. Bae . Jaehan . Teague . Richard . Andrews . Sean M. . Benisty . Myriam . Facchini . Stefano . Galloway-Sprietsma . Maria . Loomis . Ryan A. . Aikawa . Yuri . Alarcón . Felipe . Bergin . Edwin . Bergner . Jennifer B. . Booth . Alice S. . Cataldi . Gianni . Cleeves . L. Ilsedore . Czekala . Ian . Guzmán . Viviana V. . Huang . Jane . Ilee . John D. . Kurtovic . Nicolas T. . Law . Charles J. . Gal . Romane Le . Liu . Yao . Long . Feng . Ménard . François . Öberg . Karin I. . Pérez . Laura M. . Qi . Chunhua . Schwarz . Kamber R. . Sierra . Anibal . Walsh . Catherine . Wilner . David J. . Zhang . Ke . Molecules with ALMA at Planet-forming Scales (MAPS): A Circumplanetary Disk Candidate in Molecular-line Emission in the AS 209 Disk . The Astrophysical Journal Letters . 1 August 2022 . 934 . 2 . L20 . 10.3847/2041-8213/ac7fa3. 2207.05923 . 2022ApJ...934L..20B . 250492936 . free .
  3. Web site: Plait . Phil . A still-forming exoplanet predicted to exist is found in exactly the right spot . SYFY Official Site . 8 September 2022.
  4. News: Alma telescope peers into space from Chile's mountains . Gideon . Long . BBC News . 29 May 2016 . 29 May 2016.
  5. Web site: ALMA Inauguration Heralds New Era of Discovery . ESO - European Southern Observatory . 13 March 2013 . 29 April 2014.
  6. Web site: Romero . Simon . At the End of the Earth, Seeking Clues to the Universe . The New York Times . 7 April 2012 . 8 April 2012.
  7. News: Alma telescope: Ribbon cut on astronomical giant. BBC. 13 March 2013. BBC News. 2013-03-13. Hernandez. Vladimir.
  8. 10.1117/2.3201407.14. Pierre Cox plenary: ALMA Update. SPIE Newsroom. 2014. Spie.
  9. Web site: ALMA - Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array. www.eso.org.
  10. Web site: Ground breaking ceremony for the Atacama Large Millimeter Array (ALMA). Alejandro Peredo. 15 November 2014. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20141111161008/http://www.almaobservatory.org/en/press-room/press-releases/121-ground-breaking-ceremony-for-the-atacama-large-millimeter-array-alma. 11 November 2014.
  11. Web site: Route To Space Alliance. Grieves. Shell. www.route-to-space.eu. en-gb. 2017-02-15. 2022-01-17. https://web.archive.org/web/20220117012844/https://route-to-space.eu/index.php/en/projects/atacama-large-millimeter-array. dead.
  12. Web site: National Radio Astronomy Observatory - Legacy Content - ALMA (CV). nrao.edu.
  13. http://bigstory.ap.org/article/chiles-alma-probes-origins-universe Chile's ALMA probes for origins of universe
  14. Web site: General Dynamics Receives $169 Million to Build 12-Meter Antennae for Advanced Radio Telescope. gdsatcom.com.
  15. Web site: ESO - 2005. https://web.archive.org/web/20060207152851/http://www.eso.org/outreach/press-rel/pr-2005/pr-31-05.html. dead. February 7, 2006.
  16. Web site: ALMA. National Astronomical Observatory of Japan. 8 March 2021.
  17. Web site: Result of the initial testing of the Japanese ACA 12-m antenna to be delivered to ALMA . March 18, 2008 . ALMA . https://web.archive.org/web/20200225154548/https://www.almaobservatory.org/en/announcement/result-of-the-initial-testing-of-the-japanese-aca-12-m-antenna-to-be-delivered-to-alma-2/ . February 25, 2020 . dead.
  18. ALMA observatory equipped with its first antenna . December 19, 2008 . ALMA . https://web.archive.org/web/20191220214024/https://www.almaobservatory.org/en/press-release/alma-observatory-equipped-with-its-first-antenna/ . December 20, 2019 . dead.
  19. Web site: Monster Moves, Season 5, Episode 6: Mountain Mission . 17 March 2012.
  20. http://www.scheuerle.de/en/products/new-vehicles/special-transporters/antenna-transporter.html Scheuerle Fahrzeugfabrik
  21. News: Giant truck set for sky-high task . BBC News . 30 July 2007 . 31 July 2007.
  22. July 2008 NRAO ALMA newsletter article by Dr. Al Wootten
  23. News: European ALMA antenna brings total on Chajnantor to 16. 29 July 2011. ESO Organisation Release. 28 July 2011.
  24. News: ALMA Opens its Eyes. 4 October 2011. ALMA Press Release. 3 October 2011. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20111005042527/http://www.almaobservatory.org/en/press-room/press-releases/297-alma-opens-its-eyes. 5 October 2011.
  25. Web site: Zubritsky . Elizabeth . Neal-Jones . Nancy . RELEASE 14-038 - NASA's 3-D Study of Comets Reveals Chemical Factory at Work . 11 August 2014 . . 12 August 2014 .
  26. Cordiner, M.A. . Mapping the Release of Volatiles in the Inner Comae of Comets C/2012 F6 (Lemmon) and C/2012 S1 (ISON) Using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array . 11 August 2014 . . 792 . 1 . 10.1088/2041-8205/792/1/L2 . etal. 1408.2458 . 2014ApJ...792L...2C . L2. 26277035 .
  27. In Search of HL Tauri . The Astrophysical Journal Letters . David A. . Weintraub . Joel H. . Kastner . Barbara A. . Whitney . 452 . 2 . L141–L145 . October 1995 . 1995ApJ...452L.141W . 10.1086/309720.
  28. Spatially resolved magnetic field structure in the disc of a T Tauri star . . Ian W. . Stephens . Leslie W. . Looney . Woojin . Kwon . Manuel . Fernández-López . A. Meredith . Hughes . Lee G. . Mundy . Richard M. . Crutcher . Zhi-Yun . Li . Ramprasad . Rao . 5 . 514 . 7524 . 597–599 . October 2014 . 1409.2878 . 2014Natur.514..597S . 10.1038/nature13850 . 25337883. 4396150 .
  29. Web site: Event Horizon Telescope Captures First Image of Black Hole Astronomy Sci-News.com. Breaking Science News Sci-News.com. en-US. 2019-04-10.
  30. Greaves . Jane S. . Richards . A.M.S. . Bains . W . Phosphine gas in the cloud decks of Venus . Nature Astronomy . 14 September 2020 . 5 . 7 . 655–664 . 10.1038/s41550-020-1174-4 . 2009.06593 . 2021NatAs...5..655G . 221655755 . 16 September 2020.
  31. News: Sample . Ian . Scientists find gas linked to life in atmosphere of Venus . 16 September 2020 . The Guardian . 14 September 2020.
  32. Villanueva. Geronimo. Cordiner. Martin. Irwin. Patrick. de Pater. Imke. Butler. Bryan. Gurwell. Mark. Milam. Stefanie. Nixon. Conor. Luszcz-Cook. Statia. Wilson. Colin. Kofman. Vincent. 2021. No phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus. Nature Astronomy. 5. 631–635. 10.1038/s41550-021-01422-z. 2010.14305. 236090264.
  33. Clements . David L. . 12 January 2023 . Venus, Phosphine and the Possibility of Life . astro-ph.EP . 2301.05160 .
  34. News: Sansom . Clare . The hellish chemistry of Venus' atmosphere . Chemistry World . en.
  35. Cleland . Carol E. . Rimmer . Paul B. . Ammonia and Phosphine in the Clouds of Venus as Potentially Biological Anomalies . Aerospace . 26 November 2022 . 9 . 12 . 752 . 10.3390/aerospace9120752. 2211.07786 . 2022Aeros...9..752C . free .
  36. Web site: First Light for Band 5 at ALMA - New receivers improve ALMA's ability to search for water in the Universe . European Southern Observatory . 9 June 2018 . 21 December 2016. Material was copied from this source, which is available under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
  37. https://www.almaobservatory.org/en/announcement/alma-selects-new-director/ ALMA Observatory: ALMA Selects New Director
  38. Web site: ARC-nodes. webteam@eso.org. 15 November 2014.
  39. Web site: ALMA regional centre. webteam@eso.org. 15 November 2014.
  40. News: ALMA Compact Array Completed and Named After Japanese Astronomer. 8 May 2013. ESO Announcement.
  41. Web site: ALMA Observatory Statement. Alejandro Peredo. 15 November 2014. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20141129014233/http://almaobservatory.org/en/component/content/article/634. 29 November 2014.
  42. News: Workers at Earth's largest radio telescope in Chile strike over pay, working conditions. https://web.archive.org/web/20130823191323/http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/workers-at-earths-largest-radio-telescope-in-chile-strike-over-pay-working-conditions/2013/08/22/05eb11d6-0b6e-11e3-89fe-abb4a5067014_story.html. dead. 23 August 2013. 22 August 2013. The Washington Post.
  43. News: Alma telescope crew go on strike. BBC News. 15 November 2014.
  44. Web site: Workers strike at world's largest radio telescope. Huffington Post. 15 November 2014. https://archive.today/20130825013249/http://www.huffingtonpost.com/huff-wires/20130822/lt-chile-alma-observatory-strike/. 25 August 2013. live.
  45. Web site: ALMA resumes operations after end of workers' strike . almaobservatory.org . 11 May 2015 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20150518095236/http://www.almaobservatory.org/en/press-room/announcements-events/639-alma-resumes-operations-after-end-of-workers-strike . 18 May 2015 .
  46. News: 17-Day ALMA Strike Ends in Resolution. Sky & Telescope. 11 May 2015. 2013-09-06.
  47. Web site: COVID-19 (coronavirus) Measures at ALMA. 2020-03-19. ALMA. 2020-03-23.
  48. Web site: ALMA Update on the Recovery from Cyberattack. 2022-11-18. ALMA. 2023-01-15.
  49. Web site: ALMA successfully restarts observations after cyberattack. 2022-12-20. phys.org. 2023-01-16.
  50. Pre-ALMA observations of GRBs in the mm/submm range . February 2012 . de Ugarte Postigo . A. . Lundgren . A. . Martín . S. . García-Appadoo . D. . Astronomy and Astrophysics . 538 . 44 . 1108.1797 . 2012A&A...538A..44D . 10.1051/0004-6361/201117848 . 59140684 . 3 .
  51. Spatial variations in Titan's atmospheric temperature: ALMA and Cassini comparisons from 2012 to 2015 . June 2018 . Thelen . A.E. . Nixon . C.A. . Chanover . N.J. . Molter . E.M. . Icarus . 307 . 380–390 . 2018Icar..307..380T . 10.1016/j.icarus.2017.10.042 . 3 . 1809.10891 . 54641701 .