Snowbirds (aerobatic team) explained

Unit Name:Snowbirds
Country:Canada
Branch:Royal Canadian Air Force
Role:Aerobatic flight demonstration team
Command Structure:15 Wing Moose Jaw
Garrison:CFB Moose Jaw
Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan, Canada
Motto:moh|The Hatiten Ronteriios|warriors of the air
Colors:White and red
Commander1:LCol Denis Bandet[1]
Commander1 Label:Commanding Officer
Aircraft Trainer:11 CT-114 Tutors

The Snowbirds, officially known as 431 Air Demonstration Squadron (French: 431<sup>e</sup> Escadron de démonstration aérienne|links=no), are the military aerobatics flight demonstration team of the Royal Canadian Air Force. The team is based at 15 Wing Moose Jaw near Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan. The Snowbirds' official purpose is to "demonstrate the skill, professionalism, and teamwork of Canadian Forces personnel".[2] The team also provides a public relations and recruiting role, and serves as an aerial ambassador for the Canadian Armed Forces.[3] The Snowbirds are the first Canadian air demonstration team to be designated as a squadron.[4]

The show team flies 11 CT-114 Tutors: nine for aerobatic performances, including two solo aircraft, and two spares, flown by the team coordinators. Additionally, 13 are maintained in storage.[5] [6] [7] Approximately 80 Canadian Forces personnel work with the squadron full-time; 24 personnel are in the show team that travels during the show season. The Snowbirds are the only major military aerobatics team that operates without a support aircraft.[8]

The Snowbirds continue the flying demonstration tradition of previous Canadian air force aerobatic teams, which include the Siskins, the Blue Devils, the Golden Hawks, and the Golden Centennaires.

Squadron history

Second World War

Although 431 Air Demonstration Squadron was formed in 1978, its history truly began during the Second World War when, as part of the Commonwealth contribution to aircrew for the war in Europe, 431 (Iroquois) Squadron Royal Canadian Air Force was created under the control of RAF Bomber Command.[9]

Number 431 Squadron formed on 11 November 1942, at RAF Burn (in North Yorkshire), flying Wellington B.X medium bombers with No. 4 Group RAF Bomber Command. The squadron moved to RAF Tholthorpe in mid-1943 as part of the move to bring all RCAF squadrons into one operational groupNo. 6 Group RCAF – and converted to Halifax B.V four-engined heavy bombers. In December 1943 the squadron moved to RAF Croft where it was re-equipped with Halifax IIIs and later, Lancaster B.X aircraft. The squadron moved to RCAF Station Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, after the war, disbanding there on 5 September 1945.

Battle honours

Postwar

Squadron re-formed

No. 431 (Fighter) Squadron re-formed at RCAF Station Bagotville on 18 January 1954, using the new Canadair Sabre. The squadron was formed on a temporary basis until there were enough new CF-100s available to fulfill RCAF squadron needs. No. 431's duties included aerial combat training and displaying the capabilities of jet operations to the public at air shows, the largest being Operation Prairie Pacific: a 50-minute exhibition with aircraft from several squadrons that travelled to selected locations across western Canada. The team from No. 431 Squadron consisted of four Sabres and a solo aircraft. This was the first Sabre team to be authorized to perform formation aerobatics in Canada.[10] The unit was disbanded on 1 October 1954.

2 Canadian Forces Flying Training School Formation Team

In 1969, Colonel O.B. Philp, base commander of CFB Moose Jaw and former commander of the defunct Golden Centennaires aerobatic team, considered using several of the leftover Golden Centennaire CT-114 Tutor aircraft for another team.[11] These Tutors were still fitted for aerobatic flying and, because of some minor corrosion, had been painted with white anti-corrosive paint. Philp, at this point, did not receive approval to form the new team; however, approval had been given for single Tutors to provide simple flypasts at local football games.

To further the cause of an aerobatic team, Philp began informal enhanced formation practice for the instructors at 2 Canadian Forces Flying Training School with the aim of providing multi-aircraft flypasts at special events. In 1970, four-aircraft formations began providing flypasts at fairs and festivals, as well as Armed Forces Day at CFB Moose Jaw. In July 1970, a white Tutor was introduced to the formation for flypasts. Four white Tutors were finally flown together at the Abbotsford Air Show, followed by a flypast in Winnipeg. Known as the "2 Canadian Forces Flying Training School Formation Team", or informally as the "Tutor Whites", the team grew in size to seven aircraft in 1971 using eleven pilots, and gradually gained recognition. Formation flypasts were replaced with more complicated manoeuvres, and more aircraft were added as the team matured.

New name and squadron reactivation

A contest to give the air demonstration team a formal name was held at Bushell Park Elementary School at CFB Moose Jaw, and resulted in the name "Snowbirds".[12] The name reflected the aircraft's distinctive mostly-white paint scheme used at the time, connoted grace and beauty and was clearly linked to its Canadian origins. The name was formally adopted on 25 June 1971. The Snowbirds were officially authorized to be designated the "Canadian Forces Air Demonstration Team" on 15 January 1975, and was formed into its own squadron by reactivating 431 Squadron (renamed 431 Air Demonstration Squadron) on 1 April 1978.[13]

The squadron badge has, since 1942, portrayed "an Iroquois' head adorned".[14] In January 2021, the squadron began an initiative to remove this image from the badge.[15]

Show routine

Formations and manoeuvres are designed each season by the team, and must be approved by the Canadian Forces, Transport Canada and the United States Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to ensure safety guidelines are complied with. FAA approval is necessary since the team performs in the United States.

Three aerobatic shows are designed: a high show flown when weather is ideal, a low show and a flat show. The latter two are flown where some manoeuvres are not permitted because of cloud. A non-aerobatic show, or flypast, is also flown. Manoeuvres are arranged from those selected from the Standard Manoeuvre Manual.[16] Some elements of the show are passed down from one season to the next. These include the Canada burst, heart, downward bomb burst, solo head on crosses, and their signature nine-abreast exit. Training occurs over several months. Once manoeuvres are mastered and the team is comfortable with the routine, the Snowbirds deploy to CFB Comox for specialized training. After approvals are obtained, an "acceptance show" is performed at Moose Jaw to allow representatives from the three approving agencies to see a live performance. The team will go on to perform shows throughout North America from May to October. The last show is performed at Moose Jaw.Pilots typically stay with the Snowbirds for a maximum of three years, and one third of the pilots are replaced each year. Replacing pilots this way allows experienced members to train the new team members, which ensures that the Snowbirds' routines are consistent.[17]

The Snowbirds were the first aerobatic team in the world to use music in their show, and music is often used with live commentary from the performing pilots.[18]

The Snowbirds fly at speeds between 100knots and 320knots, with a separation between aircraft of 1.8m (05.9feet) in many of the formations. When two aircraft perform head-on passes, they aim to be about 10m (30feet) apart.[19]

Due to crashes in October 2019 and May 2020, restrictions were placed on shows beginning in 2021. To give pilots "more time to react", restrictions were placed on altitude and speed, and new rules were introduced concerning the minimum runway length permitted for Snowbird operations. Maintenance and inspections on the Tutors have also been increased.[20]

Transportation of support material such as repair parts, luggage, and other equipment is provided by an 18-wheeler mobile support unit that follows the team across the country.[21]

Awards, honours, and ambassadorships

Notable performances

Notable staff

Incidents and fatalities

Incidents

Since the Snowbirds' first show in July 1971, there have been several incidents involving damage to airplanes, loss of airplanes, and loss of life. The following is a list of notable incidents only. There are other incidents, some involving loss of aircraft, that are not listed below.

DateLocationReasonCasualtiesDamage
10 June 1972 CFB Trenton, Ontariowingtip collision[29] 1 fatality plane crashed
14 July 1973 bird strike caused engine stall[30] back injuries plane crashed
16 July 1977 Paine Field, Washingtoncollision during formation change[31] [32] none 2 planes crashed
3 May 1978 horizontal stabilizer failed[33] 1 fatality plane crashed
17 June 1986 midair collision[34] minor injuries plane crashed
3 September 1989 midair collision[35] 1 fatality 2 planes crashed
26 February 1991 Moose Jaw, Saskatchewancrashed during flight[36] no serious injuries plane crashed
14 August 1992 Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan failed engine bearing none plane crashed
22 October 1992midair collision none 2 planes crashed
21 March 1994 Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan engine failure minor injuries plane crashed
24 September 1995 three planes collided with birds[37] none planes damaged
7 June 1997 touched wings none planes damaged
10 December 1998 midair collision[38] 1 fatality plane crashed
27 February 1999 Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan nose gear collapsed on landing[39] none plane damaged
4 September 2000 planes touched[40] none plane damaged
10 April 2001 nose & wing landing gear failed[41] none plane damaged
21 June 2001 midair collision[42] serious injuriesplane crashed
10 December 2004 midair collision[43] 1 fatality 2 planes crashed
24 August 2005 engine failure[44] [45] minor injuries plane crashed
18 May 2007 restraining strap malfunction[46] 1 fatality plane crashed
9 October 2008 near Moose Jaw, Saskatchewanpilot error[47] [48] 2 fatalities plane crashed
1 March 2011 Moose Jaw, Saskatchewanlanded with gear up[49] none plane damaged
26 August 2017Greenwood, Nova Scotianose gear fire[50] none plane damaged
13 October 2019 engine fuel delivery system failure[51] [52] minor injuriesplane crashed
17 May 2020 Kamloops, British Columbiabird strike, compressor stall, aerodynamic stall[53] 1 fatality, 1 injuredplane crashed
2 August 2022Fort St. John, British Columbiaengine failure during takeoff caused by "an improperly assembled oil filter", ran off runway during landing[54] [55] noneplane crashed

Fatalities

Snowbird aircraft have been involved in several accidents, resulting in the deaths of seven pilots and two passengers and the loss of several aircraft. One pilot, Captain Wes Mackay, was killed in an automobile accident after a performance in Latrobe, Pennsylvania, in 1988.[56] The RCAF commented: "... there is risk associated with formation flying. Flying by its very nature has an inherent element of risk. Eight Snowbird pilots have lost their lives in the performance of their duty. We remember them."[57]

Aircraft replacement

Due to the age of the Tutors (developed in the 1950s, first flown in 1960, and accepted by the RCAF in 1963[62] [63]), a 2003 Department of National Defence study recommended that the procurement process to replace the aircraft should begin immediately so the aircraft could be retired by 2010 because of obsolescence issues that would affect the aircraft’s viability. The report mentions that "with each passing year, the technical, safety and financial risk associated with extending the Tutor into its fifth decade and beyond, will escalate".[64] Some concerns include the inevitability of metal fatigue and parts failure, outdated ejection seats and antiquated avionics.[65] [66] [67] There has also been criticism about the aircraft not being representative of a modern air force.

A 2008 review recommended that the Tutors' life could be extended to 2020 because of cost concerns related to purchasing new aircraft,[68] and a 2015 report called "CT-114 Life Extension Beyond 2020", outlined planned upgrades to extend the life of the Tutor beyond 2020. These planned upgrades included replacing the ejection seats and wing components, and updating the brakes.[69]

The Government of Canada had plans to replace the Tutors with new aircraft between 2026 and 2035 via the Snowbird Aircraft Replacement Project whose aim was "to satisfy the operational requirement to provide the mandated Government of Canada aerobatic air demonstration capability to Canadian and North American audiences". The preliminary estimated cost was $500 million to $1.5 billion. Official sources were quoted: "The chosen platform must be configurable to the 431 (AD) Squadron standard, including a smoke system, luggage capability and a unique paint scheme. The platform must also be interchangeable with the training fleet to ensure the hard demands of show performances can be distributed throughout the aircraft fleet."[70] [71] However, the Snowbird Aircraft Replacement Project was discontinued and replaced by the Tutor Life Extension Program implemented by a contractor (L3Harris) that is meant to extend the use of the Tutor fleet to 2030. The Tutors will receive modernized avionics to comply with regulations and permit the team to continue flying in North America. The Tutors’ escape system, which includes parachutes and harness will also be upgraded, and canopy designs will be assessed.[71] [72] [73]

A 2024 decision by the Department of National Defence to consider retiring costly older equipment will affect the Snowbirds. The defence minister is concerned that the Tutor has finally “aged out” and mentioned that the aircraft is “well past its utility.” The minister is also concerned about safety issues. The government intends to keep the Snowbirds, albeit with better aircraft. The defence minister has asked the RCAF to start searching for a potential replacement aircraft and the Department of National Defence is in the process of "examining a number of capabilities".[74] [75]

References

Bibliography

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Snowbirds hold private change of command ceremony. R. Palmer. Moosejaw Today. 3 June 2020 . 3 July 2020.
  2. Dempsey 2002, p. 567.
  3. Dempsey 2002, p. 684.
  4. Dempsey 2002, p. 718.
  5. Web site: CT-114 Tutor. 24 May 2020. Canadian Armed Forces. Canadian Armed Forces. www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca. 29 July 2019. https://archive.today/20200524111504/http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/aircraft-current/ct-114.page. 24 May 2020. live .
  6. Web site: CT1140071 Tutor - From the investigator. 24 May 2020. Canadian Armed Forces. Canadian Armed Forces. rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca. 13 October 2019. https://archive.today/20200524111756/http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/article-template-standard.page?doc=ct1140071-tutor-from-the-investigator/k37g8df1. 24 May 2020 . live .
  7. Web site: One Canadian Military Member Killed One Injured in CF Snowbirds Accident. 24 May 2020. Canadian Armed Forces. Canadian Armed Forces. rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca. 17 May 2020. https://archive.today/20200524112116/http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/article-template-standard.page?doc=one-canadian-military-member-killed-one-injured-in-cf-snowbirds-accident/kadurjf7 . 24 May 2020 . live .
  8. Dempsey 2002, p. 659.
  9. http://www.rafweb.org/Sqn431-443.htm "Air of Authority – A History of RAF Organisation."
  10. Dempsey 2002, pp.91-95.
  11. Web site: Member Profiles. Canada's Aviation Hall of Fame. 3 January 2018. 4 January 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20180104132405/http://www.cahf.ca/CUSTOMPAGES/907/MemberList.cfm?firstLetter=P#230. dead.
  12. http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/snowbirds/page-eng.asp?id=1568 "Snowbirds – Full History."
  13. Web site: 45 facts about the Snowbirds air demonstration team. Government of Canada National Defence. 20 November 2015 . 2023-04-01.
  14. Web site: 2019-04-04. 431 Air Demonstration Squadron. 2021-07-20 . www.canada.ca.
  15. Web site: Snowbirds 'warriors of the air' squadron crest to get makeover - 680 NEWS. 2021-07-20. www.680news.com.
  16. https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2017/05/18/snowbirds-had-flight-safety-incident-during-us-airshow.html "Snowbirds safety incident a factor behind air show cancellations". The Star, 18 May 2017
  17. http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/snowbirds/faq.page#SnowbirdsTeamDuration "FAQ: Snowbirds."
  18. Dempsey 2002, p. 643.
  19. http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/snowbirds/faq.page#SnowbirdsSpeed "FAQ: Snowbirds."
  20. https://globalnews.ca/news/7296010/snowbirds-restrictions-lifted/ Military lifts order grounding Snowbirds team, some restrictions still in place. Global News. 24 August 2020.
  21. News: Snowbirds ready for weekend performances. TBNewswatch. 2023-06-01 . 2023-06-18.
  22. Dempsey 2002, p. 540.
  23. Dempsey 2002, p. 538
  24. Dempsey 2002, p. 545.
  25. Dempsey 2002, p. 552.
  26. Dempsey 2002, p. 597.
  27. Dempsey 2002, pp. 605, 606.
  28. Dempsey 2002, p. 615.
  29. Dempsey 2002, p. 546.
  30. Dempsey 2002, p. 550.
  31. Dempsey 2002, p. 563.
  32. http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1314&dat=19770717&id=9YkwAAAAIBAJ&sjid=0u0DAAAAIBAJ&pg=6824,1001202 "Two pilots rescued after jets collide."
  33. Dempsey 2002, p. 569.
  34. https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=QBJtjoHflPwC&dat=19860618&printsec=frontpage&hl=en "Snowbirds collide n mid-air; pilots escape serious injury."
  35. Dempsey 2002, p. 602.
  36. http://www.canada.com/story.html?id=0ea7b420-2269-4f41-9bbd-b2b9c588fbd9 "A History of Snowbird Crashes."
  37. Dempsey 2002, p. 622.
  38. http://www.forces.gc.ca/site/news-nouvelles/news-nouvelles-eng.asp?cat=02&id=819 "Snowbird crash, December 10, 1998 – investigation update."
  39. http://www.airforce.forces.gc.ca/dfs-dsv/nr-sp/index-eng.asp?id=10077 "Canadian Forces Flight Safety Report:CT114019 Tutor."
  40. http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/flight-safety/article-template-flight-safety.page?doc=ct114172-tutor-and-ct114006-tutor-epilogue/hlhp4ao1 "Canadian Forces Flight Safety Report:CT114172 Tutor and CT114006 Tutor."
  41. http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/flight-safety/article-template-flight-safety.page?doc=ct114142-tutor-epilogue/hlhp4ant "Canadian Forces Flight Safety Report:CT114142 Tutor."
  42. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/snowbirds-collide-one-crashes-in-lake-erie-1.281689 "Snowbirds collide, one crashes in Lake Erie"
  43. Web site: Canadian Forces Flight Safety Report: CT114173 / CT114064 Tutor . airforce.forces.gc.ca . https://web.archive.org/web/20180810031530/http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/flight-safety/article-template-flight-safety.page?doc=ct114173-ct114064-tutor-epilogue-flight-safety-investigation-report/hlhp4ao0 . 2017-01-07 . 2004-12-10 . 2018-08-10 . dmy-all.
  44. http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/flight-safety/article-template-flight-safety.page?doc=ct114120-tutor-epilogue/hlhp4am1 "Canadian Forces Flight Safety Report: CT114120 Tutor."
  45. Bridges, Holly. "Snowbird safely ejects, Flight Safety investigation continues, p. 12." Maple Leaf, Vol 8., No. 31. 8 September 2005 via airforce.forces.gc.ca. Retrieved: 16 June 2010.
  46. http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/flight-safety/article-template-flight-safety.page?doc=ct114159-tutor-epilogue/hlhp4anw "Canadian Forces Flight Safety Report: CT114159 Tutor."
  47. News: Report findings on 2008 Snowbird Crash . Wings Magazine. 2010-07-09 . 2023-04-02.
  48. News: Two dead in Snowbird jet crash in Saskatchewan. CTV News. 2008-10-09 . 2023-04-02.
  49. News: Snowbirds jet makes crash landing in Moose Jaw . CTV Regina . 2011-03-01 . 2020-11-07.
  50. News: Snowbird catches fire on runway after Nova Scotia airshow. CBC. 2017-08-26 . 2022-05-12.
  51. https://theaviationist.com/2020/07/02/official-accident-report-in-canadian-forces-snowbird-october-2019-crash-released/ Official Accident Report in Canadian Forces Snowbird October 2019 Crash Released
  52. https://globalnews.ca/news/6261532/snowbirds-return-after-crash/ "Global News Story."
  53. News: Bird strike blamed in fatal crash of Canadian military Snowbird jet . CBC News . 2021-03-29 . 2021-03-29.
  54. Web site: Dickson . Courtney. 2 August 2022 . Canadian Snowbird aircraft "incident" reported at northern B.C. airport . CBC News British Columbia.
  55. News: Fedy-Macdonald. Dayna. 21 September 2022 . Operational pause on Snowbirds lifted after cause of accident determined, but remaining 2022 performances cancelled. Skies Magazine. 2022-09-23.
  56. Web site: Car Crash Kills Canadian Pilot, Injures Two Others . deviated . https://web.archive.org/web/20200602213307/https://apnews.com/14c003a43f0adcaa323307abe4ed86b4 . 2 June 2020 . . 24 September 1988 . 11 May 2024.
  57. http://www.rcaf-arc.forces.gc.ca/en/snowbirds/tributes.page "Snowbirds – Tributes."
  58. News: Snowbirds plane crashes near Kamloops, B.C. . . Alanna. Kelly . 17 May 2020 . 17 May 2020.
  59. Canadian Forces Snowbirds launch cross-Canada tour . . 29 April 2020 . 17 May 2020.
  60. https://www.canada.ca/en/air-force/corporate/reports-publications/flight-safety-investigation-reports/ct114161-tutor-epilogue.html Flight Safety Investigation Report for Kamloops Snowbirds accident.
  61. News: Canadian Forces Snowbirds jet crashes in Kamloops, B.C., killing 1, injuring another. 18 May 2020. Ross . Andrea . CBC News. 16 May 2020. https://archive.today/20200518121857/https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/plane-crash-kamloops-1.5573930. 18 May 2020 .
  62. https://www.warplane.com/aircraft/collection/details.aspx?aircraftId=8 Canadair CT-114 Tutor
  63. Milberry 1984, p. 346.
  64. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/replace-snowbird-jets-immediately-dnd-told-in-2003/article1087881/ Replace Snowbird Jets ‘Immediately,’ DND Told in 2003. The Globe and Mail. 25 April 2018.
  65. https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/crash-shows-it-s-time-to-ground-the-snowbirds-aging-tutor-jets-experts-say-1.4944146 Crash shows it's time to ground the Snowbirds' aging Tutor jets, experts say. CTV News. 18 May 2020.
  66. https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2020/05/29/snowbirds-were-waiting-for-new-ejection-seats-before-deadly-crash-now-dnd-wont-say-if-gear-was-replaced.html Snowbirds were waiting for new ejection seats before deadly crash. Now DND won’t say if gear was replaced. The Star. 29 May 2020.
  67. Dempsey 2002, p. 694
  68. https://thestarphoenix.com/news/aircraft-used-by-snowbirds-aerobatic-team-on-the-go-since-1963-will-be-kept-flying-until-2030/wcm/f1c5dc09-8092-4285-a0c8-2f95c0430578 Aircraft used by Snowbirds aerobatic team, on the go since 1963, will be kept flying until 2030. Saskatoon StarPhoenix. 13 May 2018.
  69. https://www.forces.gc.ca/en/business-defence-acquisition-guide-2015/aerospace-systems-990.page CT-114 Life Extension Beyond 2020 (archived). National Defence and the Canadian Armed Forces
  70. http://www.forces.gc.ca/en/business-defence-acquisition-guide-2015/aerospace-systems-347.page "Snowbird Aircraft Replacement Project."
  71. News: Canadian military can't even seem to keep the Snowbirds from crashing. National Post. 2022-08-12 . 2022-08-25.
  72. Web site: Inside the RCAF's $600m fleet avionics upgrade. Joetey Attariwala. Key.Aero. 2022-04-03. 2022-09-23.
  73. News: David Pugliese. Government spending $30 million to keep Snowbirds aircraft flying until 2030. Ottawa Citizen. 2021-03-30 . 2022-09-23.
  74. News: Ottawa looking at retiring some older military equipment — including the Snowbird jets. CBC. 2024-07-17 . 2024-08-08.
  75. News: Ottawa exploring options to replace aging Snowbirds jets. CBC. 2024-07-22 . 2024-08-13.