2024 Saxony state election explained

Election Name:2024 Saxony state election
Country:Saxony
Type:parliamentary
Ongoing:no
Previous Election:2019 Saxony state election
Previous Year:2019
Next Election:2029 Saxony state election
Next Year:2029
Seats For Election:All 120 seats in the Landtag of Saxony
Majority Seats:61
Election Date:1 September 2024
Turnout:2,367,607 (74.4%)
8.2 pp
Leader1:Michael Kretschmer
Party1:Christian Democratic Union of Germany
Last Election1:45 seats, 32.1%
Seats1:41
Seat Change1: 4
Popular Vote1:749,114
Percentage1:31.9%
Swing1: 0.2 pp
Leader2:Jörg Urban
Party2:Alternative for Germany
Last Election2:38 seats, 27.5%
Seats2:40
Seat Change2: 2
Popular Vote2:719,279
Percentage2:30.6%
Swing2: 3.1 pp
Leader3:Sabine Zimmermann
Party3:Bündnis Sahra Wagenknecht
Last Election3:Did not exist
Seats3:15
Seat Change3: 15
Popular Vote3:277,568
Percentage3:11.8%
Swing3:New party
Leader4:Petra Köpping
Party4:Social Democratic Party of Germany
Last Election4:10 seats, 7.7%
Seats4:10
Seat Change4: 0
Popular Vote4:172,021
Percentage4:7.3%
Swing4: 0.4 pp
Leader5:Wolfram Günther &<br>Katja Meier
Party5:Alliance 90/The Greens
Last Election5:12 seats, 8.6%
Seats5:7
Seat Change5: 5
Popular Vote5:119,980
Percentage5:5.1%
Swing5: 3.5 pp
Leader6:Susanne Schaper
Party6:The Left (Germany)
Last Election6:14 seats, 10.4%
Seats6:6
Seat Change6: 8
Popular Vote6:104,891
Percentage6:4.5%
Swing6: 5.9 pp
Image7: FW
Leader7:Matthias Berger
Party7:Free Voters
Last Election7:0 seats, 3.4%
Seats7:1
Seat Change7: 1
Popular Vote7:53,027
Percentage7:2.3%
Swing7: 1.1 pp
Map Size:425px
Government
Before Election:Kretschmer II
Before Party:CDU–Greens–SPD
Posttitle:Government after election

The 2024 Saxony state election was held on 1 September 2024 to elect members to the 8th Landtag of Saxony. It was held on the same day as the 2024 Thuringian state election.[1] Going into the election, the state government was led by Michael Kretschmer of the CDU as Minister-President, in a coalition with the Greens and the SPD.

The CDU remained the largest party with slight losses, followed closely by the Alternative for Germany (AfD) which obtained its best ever result. The SPD remained steady while the Greens fell to just over 5% of the vote; the incumbent coalition lost its majority.[2] [3] [4] The Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance ran for the first time and won 12% and fifteen seats. The Left fell below the 5% electoral threshold but retained its representation in the Landtag after winning two direct constituencies. The Free Voters of Saxony (FW) elected a single member after lead candidate Matthias Berger won the constituency of Leipzig-Land III.[5] [6]

Background

The 2019 election was marked by high gains for the Alternative for Germany (AfD), which gained almost 28 percent of the vote and became the second strongest force. After losses, the CDU ended up with almost 32 percent as the strongest party ahead of the AfD. The Left and the SPD received 10.4 and 7.7 percent of the vote, respectively. The Greens increased and achieved their best result in a state election in Saxony with 8.6 percent, the Free Democratic Party (FDP) again missed entering parliament with 4.5 percent.

Parties and lists

Party2019 result
candidates
List
candidates
Lead candidate
bgcolor=Christian Democratic Union (CDU)32.1%6078Michael Kretschmer
bgcolor=Alternative for Germany (AfD)27.5%6075Jörg Urban
bgcolor=The Left (LINKE)10.4%6047Susanne Schaper
bgcolor=Alliance 90/The Greens (GRÜNE)8.6%6030Katja Meier
bgcolor=Social Democratic Party (SPD)7.7%6054Petra Köpping
bgcolor=Free Democratic Party (FDP)4.5%6048Robert Malorny
bgcolor=Free Voters of Saxony (FW)3.4%5933Matthias Berger
bgcolor=Die PARTEI1.6%39Sabine Kuechler
bgcolor=Pirate Party Germany (PIRATEN)0.3%9Stephanie Henkel
bgcolor=Ecological Democratic Party (ÖDP)0.3%211Jonas Bialon
bgcolor=Civil Rights Movement Solidarity (BüSo)0.1%412Michael Gründler
bgcolor=Bündnis Sahra Wagenknecht (BSW)3930Sabine Zimmermann
Free Saxons (FS)3530Martin Kohlmann
bgcolor=Values Union (WU)57Heiko Petzold
bgcolor=Alliance Germany (BD)316Steffen Grosse
bgcolor=Grassroots Democratic Party (dieBasis)311David Murcek
bgcolor=Alliance C – Christians for Germany (Bündnis C)7Thomas Lamowski
bgcolor=V-Partei³4Simone Schwarzbach
bgcolor=Action Party for Animal Welfare (Tierschutz hier)3Uwe Werner
Other13

Opinion polls

Party polling

Polling firmFieldwork dateSample
size
CDUAfDLinkeGrüneSPDFDPFWBSWOthersLead
2024 state election31.930.64.55.17.30.92.311.85.61.3
Wahlkreisprognose1,000333135.5613.582
Forsa1,01233313671282
Forschungsgruppe Wahlen1,97333304661293
INSA1,000303245631552
Forschungsgruppe Wahlen1,02833304671193
Infratest dimap1,56631304671481
Wahlkreisprognose1,00034.5304.54.551146.54.5
Forsa1,04133303661393
INSA1,5002932555241533
Forschungsgruppe Wahlen1,00334304661194
Infratest dimap1,15729303771591
INSA1,500303245521572
2024 EP electiondata-sort-value="2024-06-09"9 Jun 202421.831.84.95.96.92.42.412.611.310
Civey3,002313056631091
INSA1,0003034556231144
Wahlkreisprognose1,20031.53136.561.513.570.5
Infratest dimap1,1773035477895
Forsa1,507303468733484
Wahlkreisprognose97033.5328.5762.5101.5
30.528.565.55.5215.56.52
Civey3,00433378731114
Civey3,0023333777238data-sort-value="0"Tie
Wahlkreisprognose1,17328.532.57.55.58.5413.54
27.5314.55.5614.5113.5
INSA1,5002935967596
Wahlkreisprognose1,5583032.5971056.52.5
Wahlkreisprognose98731329.579.5471
Wahlkreisprognose1,02029.53189.510.53.581.5
Wahlkreisprognose1,00034301077394
Wahlkreisprognose1,20435287.59.59387
Wahlkreisprognose1,02333275.59.512496
INSA1,000252899127373
Wahlkreisprognose1,1002926.5691559.52.5
Infratest dimap1,1782724108137383
Wahlkreisprognose1,0022225.57919107.53.5
2021 federal election17.224.69.38.619.311.02.37.75.3
INSA1,000312611711865
Infratest dimap1,17935211071164614
INSA1,00134251378859
INSA1,0002426111361282
Wahlkreisprognose40309.5871.5410
INSA1,008342611107578
Wahlkreisprognose3827.51010.5532410.5
INSA1,0203626111074610
Wahlkreisprognose40268.59.5631614
Wahlkreisprognose36.52997.57.541.557.5
2019 state election32.127.510.48.67.74.53.45.84.6

Minister-President polling

Polling firmFieldwork dateSample
size
None/
Unsure
Lead

CDU

AfD

AfD

Linke

Grüne

SPD

BSW
Forschungsgruppe Wahlen1,97370151555
INSA1,00045183727
Forschungsgruppe Wahlen1,02868131955
Infratest dimap1,56658202238
Forsa1,041501423436
Forschungsgruppe Wahlen1,00364142250
Infratest dimap1,15758172541
Wahlkreisprognose97056232133
56291527
Wahlkreisprognose1,17357261731
Wahlkreisprognose1,55845213424
Wahlkreisprognose1,02039244392115

Aftermath

The first announcement of the seat distribution, which was early in the morning of 2 September, showed 42 seats for CDU, 41 for AfD, 9 for SPD, and 6 for the Greens. Later in the morning, the state electoral committee announced there had been an error in calculating the seat distribution: one seat was deducted from CDU's and AfD's blocs, and one seat was added to SPD's and Greens' blocs.[7] The committee blamed a software bug that resulted in the 117th through 120th seats being allocated incorrectly. External observers initially speculated that the seat distribution was mistakenly calculated with the D'Hondt method, even though the Sainte-Laguë method was to replace it beginning with this election; administrators denied this and stated it was a coincidence that the incorrect seat distribution matched the D'Hondt method's result.[8] [9] Notably, the loss of this one seat denied AfD a Sperrminorität ("blocking minority") that would have given it veto power over certain parliamentary actions requiring a two-thirds majority, such as judicial appointments and constitutional amendments, even if it is not in government.

Saxony has a version of the Grundmandatsklausel ("basic mandate clause") that is present in federal elections, which grants full proportional seating to parties that win two constituency seats even if they do not reach the electoral threshold of 5% of party-list votes. This enabled Die Linke, which received only 4.5% of party-list votes, to win list seats and receive representation in parliament proportionate to its vote share.[10]

Electoral fraud investigations

The State Criminal Police Office is prosecuting a case of suspected electoral fraud, in which 111 mail ballots in Dresden, 14 in Radeberg, and one in Dohna had their actual votes pasted over and replaced with votes for the right-wing extremist Free Saxony.[11] [12] Initial suspicions were raised after the postal voting district Langebrück-2/Schönborn in Dresden returned an unusually high result of 10.2% of votes for the party, which polled around 2% or less nearly everywhere else in the state. The Dresden and Bautzen electoral committees invalidated all of the modified ballots in their final canvasses of the results on 5 September.[13] The state electoral committee decided this was sufficient and took no further action in its final canvass on 13 September.[14]

Experts from TU Dresden later noticed the neighboring postal voting district Langebrück-1 had returned a similarly unusual figure of 13.4% in June 2024 local elections. Police confirmed that 154 manipulated postal ballots from that election were discovered. Michael Schleinitz, a 44-year-old Free Saxony member from Langebrück who was elected to its district council because of the modified ballots, was suspected of both cases.[15] [16] Schleinitz was arrested for electoral fraud and unrelated charges of attempted arson on 28 October.[17]

Government formation

After the elections in both Thuringia and Saxony, Sahra Wagenknecht, leader of the BSW, stated her preferences to go into a coalition with either the CDU and/or the SPD in an interview with ARD.

Though a right-wing CDU-AfD coalition would have a majority, the national CDU has prohibited any state faction from working with that party. Because of this, the only possible majority coalition is between the CDU, BSW and SPD,[18] also known as the “blackberry coalition”.[19] [20] This coalition would involve 66 members of the Landtag.

Kretschmer met with Wagenknecht on 9 September "to explore possibilities for constructive political cooperation", with an eye toward beginning negotiations with BSW on the state level. Federal CDU leader Friedrich Merz appealed to nervous party members to trust Kretschmer and Mario Voigt in their respective negotiations, but reiterated that the party would refuse any cooperation or even discussions with AfD.[21] Kretschmer admitted successful government formation would be a "major challenge" but has repeatedly ruled out a minority government.[22] [23]

In a speech on 20 September, Merz described a potential coalition including BSW in either Saxony or Thuringia as "very, very, very unlikely", though with a stated goal of keeping AfD out of the Minister-President's office, he did not rule out other forms of cooperation with the party.[24] Exploratory talks between CDU, BSW and SPD began on 23 September.[25] [26]

On 17 October, the three parties produced a report on the exploratory talks concluding that "constructive and solution-oriented cooperation for Saxony is possible". The parties' state executive committees will meet to vote on approving further negotiations in the following days.[27] On 25 October, SPD suspended its participation in protest of several BSW MdLs voting with AfD to establish a parliamentary inquiry committee into the state government's handling of the COVID-19 pandemic; they were resumed the following week after discussions among the parties' leadership.[28]

On 5 November, BSW left the talks permanently and declared they had failed, citing that the parties had irreconcilable differences on the topics of state finances, migration and the War in Ukraine. The only possible remaining government was a CDU-led minority government or coalition, though Kretschmer repeatedly ruled it out. If a Minister-President is not elected in four months after the first sitting of the Landtag (a deadline of 1 February 2025), the state constitution requires a dissolution of the Landtag and new elections.[29]

Despite Kretschmer's previous statements, CDU and SPD leaders announced on 15 November they had begun negotiations toward forming a minority coalition, which are expected to finish within a month. Kretschmer stated there would be a "consultation process" with the other parties before any legislation is introduced to ensure it has enough support to pass. BSW placed a commitment to halting cuts in social-welfare spending and a harder policy toward illegal migration as conditions of supporting the government.[30] On 4 December, CDU and SPD announced they had completed a coalition agreement. The path to re-electing Kretschmer as Minister-President is unclear; The Left also spoke out against social-spending cuts, while the Greens ruled it out after he sharply attacked them during the campaign. AfD stated they would only support a minority government if it were CDU alone.[31] The state constitution requires an absolute majority for any Minister-President candidate on the first ballot, after which only more yes than no votes (abstentions therefore effectively counting as "yes" votes) is sufficient.[32]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 2024-08-30 . German elections: Far-right AfD on brink of political earthquake . 2024-09-01 . BBC News . en-GB . 2 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240902144719/https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c05jvve89g3o . live .
  2. Web site: 1 September 2024 . Far-right AfD wins eastern state in Germany's regional election . 2 September 2024 . Al Jazeera . en . 1 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240901165329/https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/9/1/germanys-far-right-party-likely-to-make-gains-in-eastern-region-elections . live .
  3. Web site: 1 September 2024 . Success of far-right AfD shows east and west Germany are drifting further apart . 2 September 2024 . The Guardian . en . 1 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240901185234/https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/sep/01/success-far-right-afd-shows-east-west-germany-drifting-further-apart . live .
  4. Web site: 1 September 2024 . German far right hails 'historic' election victory in east . 2 September 2024 . BBC News . en . 2 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240902144402/https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cn02w01xr2jo . live .
  5. News: Achterberg . Beatrice . 2024-09-02 . Landtagswahlen 2024: Koalitionsmöglichkeiten in Sachsen und Thüringen . 2024-09-02 . Neue Zürcher Zeitung . de-CH . 0376-6829 . 2 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240902144720/https://www.nzz.ch/international/landtagswahlen-koalitionsmoeglichkeiten-in-sachsen-und-thueringen-ld.1846398 . live .
  6. Web site: Germany: Thuringia and Saxony elections propel far-right AfD. 1 September 2024. Deutsche Welle. 2 September 2024. 2 September 2024. https://web.archive.org/web/20240902144719/https://www.dw.com/en/germany-thuringia-and-saxony-elections-propel-far-right-afd/a-70106147. live.
  7. News: Tschirner . Ulrike . Sadeghi . Julian . Sperrminorität der AfD: Sitzverteilung in Sachsen könnte falsch berechnet worden sein . AfD blocking minority: Seat distribution in Saxony may have been incorrectly calculated . Die Zeit . 2 September 2024 . de . 2 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240902064718/https://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2024-09/sperrminoritaet-sachsen-landtagswahl-afd-wahlleiter-ergebnis . live.
  8. News: Thust . Sarah . Softwarefehler bei der Landtagswahl in Sachsen: Was hinter der Korrektur der Sitzverteilung steckt . Software errors in the state election in Saxony: What is behind the correction of the seat distribution . correctiv.org . 6 September 2024 . de . 6 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240906124952/https://correctiv.org/faktencheck/2024/09/06/softwarefehler-bei-der-landtagswahl-in-sachsen-was-hinter-der-korrektur-der-sitzverteilung-steckt/ . live.
  9. Web site: Landtagswahl in Sachsen am 1. September 2024 . Wahlrecht.de . de . 5 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240905112828/https://www.wahlrecht.de/news/2024/landtagswahl-sachsen-2024.html . live.
  10. Web site: Wahlsystem Landtagswahl Sachsen 2024 . Wahlrecht.de . de . 6 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240906012407/https://www.wahlrecht.de/landtage/sachsen.htm . live.
  11. News: Ermittlungen gegen 44-Jährigen wegen Wahlfälschung in Dresden . www.mdr.de . 13 September 2024 . de . 13 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240913173238/https://www.mdr.de/nachrichten/sachsen/politik/landtagswahl/ermittlungen-wahlfaelschung-briefwahl-durchsuchung-100.html . live.
  12. News: Kreuze für Rechtextreme: Dresden untersucht mögliche Wahlfälschung auf Stimmzetteln . Crosses for right-wing extremists: Dresden investigates possible election fraud on ballot papers . Der Spiegel . 3 September 2024 . de . 3 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240903080045/https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/sachsen-dresden-untersucht-moegliche-wahlfaelschung-auf-stimmzetteln-a-7de9f2c2-8a70-4ac1-b116-e34c353ea98c . live.
  13. News: Manipulierte Wahlzettel: Wahlauschüsse tagen in Dresden und Radeberg . Manipulated ballot papers: Election committees meet in Dresden and Radeberg . MDR Aktuell . de . 6 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240906023332/https://www.mdr.de/nachrichten/sachsen/dresden/dresden-radebeul/landtagswahl-briefwahl-wahlfaelschung-wahlzettel-freie-sachsen-100.html . live.
  14. Web site: Landtagswahl 2024: Endgültiges amtliches Wahlergebnis . 13 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240913201729/https://wahlen.sachsen.de/download/Presse%20Landtagswahl%202024/LWL-MI-28-2024.pdf . live.
  15. News: LKA Sachsen übernimmt Ermittlungen zu manipulierten Stimmzetteln . LKA Saxony takes over investigations into manipulated ballot papers . tagesschau.de . de . 3 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240903092149/https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/regional/sachsen/dresden-landtagswahl-sachsen-wahlbetrug-100.html . live.
  16. News: Wegen Wahlbetrug in Dresden werden Neuwahlen gefordert . www.saechsische.de . de . 16 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240916160454/https://www.saechsische.de/politik/wahlen/kommunalwahl/wegen-wahlbetrug-in-dresden-werden-jetzt-neuwahlen-gefordert-6045219-plus.html . live.
  17. News: Festnahme: Verdächtigter Wahlfälscher in Dresden soll auch Brandstifter sein . mdr.de . 28 October 2024 . de.
  18. News: Landeswahlleiter in Sachsen will Ergebnis überprüfen: Landtagswahlen in Thüringen und Sachsen im Liveticker . FAZ . 2024-09-02 . 2024-09-02 . DE . 2 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240902072004/https://www.faz.net/aktuell/politik/inland/landeswahlleiter-in-sachsen-will-ergebnis-ueberpruefen-landtagswahlen-in-thueringen-und-sachsen-im-liveticker-faz-19906947.html . live.
  19. News: "Brombeer"-Koalition: Was der Begriff bedeutet und wer ihn erfunden hat . 2024-09-03 . Sächsische Zeitung . DE . 3 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240903131223/https://www.saechsische.de/sachsen/politik-sachsen/brombeer-koalition-was-der-begriff-bedeutet-und-wer-ihn-erfunden-hat-6040594.html . live.
  20. News: Bekommt Thüringen eine links tolerierte Brombeer-Koalition? . 2024-09-05 . MDR Aktuell . DE . 5 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240905035316/https://www.mdr.de/nachrichten/thueringen/landtagswahl/koalition-regierung-mehrheit-afd-bsw-linke-cdu-100.html . live.
  21. News: Nach Landtagswahlen in Sachsen: Kretschmer trifft sich zum Gespräch mit Wagenknecht . Der Spiegel . 9 September 2024 . de . 9 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240909202421/https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/cdu-und-bsw-in-sachsen-michael-kretschmer-traf-sahra-wagenknecht-a-5da7b355-76fd-44df-849b-3a52fc276b88 . live.
  22. News: CDU und BSW in Sachsen: Kretschmer stimmt versöhnliche Töne an . www.diesachsen.de . de . 20 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240920203706/https://www.diesachsen.de/politik/cdu-und-bsw-in-sachsen-kretschmer-stimmt-versoehnliche-toene-an-2956318 . live.
  23. News: Sachsen: Kretschmers Annäherung an Wagenknecht . de . 2024-09-10 . 10 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240910055419/https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/regional/sachsen/kretschmer-wagenknecht-100.html. live.
  24. News: Merz hält Koalition mit BSW in Ländern für unwahrscheinlich . tagesschau.de . de . 20 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240920055352/https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/innenpolitik/thueringen-sachsen-bsw-cdu-100.html. live.
  25. News: Mögliche Koalition in Sachsen? CDU, BSW und SPD vereinbaren weitere Gespräche . MDR . 24 September 2024 . de . 24 September 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20240924062452/https://www.mdr.de/nachrichten/sachsen/politik/landtagswahl/treffen-cdu-spd-bsw-landtagswahl-koalition-sondierung-100.html. live.
  26. News: Landtags-Vize: BSW- und SPD-Kandidaten fallen zunächst durch . www.diesachsen.de . 1 October 2024 . de . 1 October 2024 . https://web.archive.org/web/20241001132149/https://www.diesachsen.de/politik/saechsischer-landtag-verabschiedet-neue-geschaeftsordnung-mit-umstrittenem-vierten-2958446 . live.
  27. News: Gemeinsames Papier: CDU, BSW und SPD einigen sich auf Verhandlungsgrundlage . MDR . 17 October 2024 . de.
  28. News: Sachsen: SPD unterbricht Sondierungsgespräche - weil BSW für AfD-Antrag stimmte . Der Spiegel . 25 October 2024 . de.
  29. News: BSW, SPD, CDU: Regierungsbildung in Sachsen gescheitert . Der Spiegel . 6 November 2024 . de.
  30. News: Konsultationsverfahren soll Sachsen regierungsfähig machen . mdr.de . 15 November 2024 . de.
  31. News: Durchbruch bei Koalitionsgesprächen von CDU und SPD in Sachsen . tagesschau.de . 4 December 2024 . de.
  32. News: Minderheitsregierung: Wie schafft Kretschmer die Mehrheit bei seiner Wiederwahl? . www.mdr.de . 16 November 2024 . de.