2024 Harehills riot explained

2024 Harehills riot
Place:Harehills, Leeds, Yorkshire
Causes:Anti-police sentiment
Methods:Rioting, arson, assault
Side1:Local residents of Harehills
Side2:West Yorkshire Police

In July 2024, a riot took place in the Harehills area of Leeds, Yorkshire, England. The incident was triggered on 18 July by a dispute over four children of a Romani family being taken into care by social services and police. The situation escalated as residents, angry and filming the police, gathered, forcing the police to retreat. The unrest involved violent confrontations between local residents and police officers, resulting in the overturning of a police car, the torching of a double-decker bus, a bonfire of debris blocking a main road and widespread disorder in the streets.[1]

Background

Harehills is a diverse working class suburb of Leeds, with significant populations of Romani and Pakistanis.[2] [3] In 2020, it was described as the second most socio-economically deprived area in Leeds.[4]

Earlier in 2024, Leeds Children’s Services had presented claims to family court that a baby had been injured, and that the family might attempt to take the children out of the country. The judge ruled that the children should be taken into care to prevent this, and placed with extended family in order to keep the children together. The removal and placement was criticised by the barrister for the Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service, claiming that inadequate time was allowed for them to visit and assess safety issues.[5]

Harehills has seen civil unrest before with a riot in the same area in 2001 after police were accused of being "heavy handed" in their arrest of a British Asian man over a driving offence.[6] The community is considered to be diverse, and where Leeds' Roma community is mostly based, described by a resident as: "Romanian, Gypsy, Pakistani, Asian – this is what it means to be from Harehills".[7] [8]

Incident

At 5 pm on 18 July 2024, West Yorkshire police responded to a residential street disturbance in the Gipton and Harehills ward sparked by a dispute over four children from a residential family, being taken into care by social services.[9] [10] [11] [12] The spark has been described as a "family incident" and a "child protection matter" handled by social workers.[13] [14] According to The Guardian, as police attempted to manage the situation, more people began to gather at the scene, with some residents becoming angry and filming the police, leading to increased tension and the eventual outbreak of violence.[15] A crowd of people began attacking a police car after witnessing an altercation between social services, the police and a local family. Footage shared on social media showed individuals using scooters, pushchairs, bikes, and bats to assault the vehicle. The police car's windows were broken, the car was overturned, and additional officers were dispatched to the area to attempt to control the situation. Videos and images of the riot quickly spread on platforms like X and TikTok, drawing widespread attention to the incident.[16] Cars in the area were reported to be set alight, and two First Leeds buses were attacked, one of which was set on fire. Videos posted on social media from the riot show people speaking Romanian while overturning a police car.[17] [18] iNews reported that police were 'outnumbered' and 'ran away' from riot disorder. A number of locals perceived a lack of emergency personnel at the scene for most of the night.[19]

Throughout the evening, Gipton and Harehills Councillor Mothin Ali was present at the scene of the riot attempting to calm the violent situation.[20] Videos were posted during the night, on TikTok and X, of him stopping those present from throwing wooden pallets and wheelie bins onto the fire.[21] [22]

Reactions

Salma Arif, Councillor from Gipton and Harehills, posted on X platform on Thursday standing along with a police inspector, urging people to stay at home, with the BBC noting Arif's comment on the "an ongoing situation currently in Harehills... We are asking everybody in the area please stay at home at this moment in time."

Tracy Brabin, the mayor of West Yorkshire, mentioned she had been "reassured no one has been seriously injured but suggest those who are using this to inflame community tensions to think again." During a press conference on 19 July, Ms. Brabin discussed meeting with "key partners," during which they developed a plan to ensure the safety of Harehills, with "imams and the faith leaders [...] getting the message out there that we need to stay calm and ensure we don't have what we saw, which was frightening, horrible and unacceptable."[23]

Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, a Member of Parliament from Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley of West Yorkshire, expressed her dismay stating that she was "appalled at the shocking scenes", and that "disorder of this nature has no place in our society".

Richard Burgon, the Member of Parliament for Leeds East, posted on X: "I am on my way back to Leeds from Parliament and am in touch with the police and concerned residents about the on-going incident in Harehills." The MP continued, "The police say no injuries have been reported but are advising people to avoid the area at the moment if possible."

The far-right and social media users blamed the riots on the local Muslim community. British Muslim Green councillor Mothin Ali, who was at the scene trying to calm the situation and urging the police to speak in Urdu, faced online smears and received death threats after the news coverage.[24] [25] The Independent described how Ali was a "hero", who formed a "human shield" to stop people adding further combustible material to fires.[26]

Aftermath

In response to the riot, the city's council has commenced an "urgent review" concerning its management of child care cases. This decision comes after discussions with members of the Gypsy Roma community, who have accused the authorities of "systemic racism and discrimination" in managing the case involving a family from their community.[27] On Friday 19 July, some members of the community held a vigil and chanted "please bring the kids back". The children's parents also declared a hunger strike until their four children were returned. On 23 July, children were returned to the family.[28]

Nine Romanian citizens were detained following the street riot on 18 July, according to Romania's Ministry of Foreign Affairs on 21 July. Of these, eight were later released.[29] Police have charged one Romanian man aged 37 with violent disorder and arson that endangered life.[30] The Romanian Consulate in Manchester said they are maintaining communication with the family affected by child custody measures, as well as with British authorities.

On 3 August, BBC reported that Police have arrested 27 people in connection with the riot in Harehills. Assistant Chief Constable Pat Twiggs expressed gratitude to those who provided information and indicated more arrests are expected.[31]

Journalist Emilia Stankeviciute wrote that "Local contextual factors, such as economic deprivation, can quickly turn minor incidents like this into significant unrest".[32] Right-leaning, libertarian online magazine Spiked argued that due to the reported diversity of the rioters, integration and cultural tensions may have played a role in the unrest.[33]

See also

Notes and References

  1. News: Bird . Steve . 19 July 2024 . Police face a backlash over Leeds riots . 26 July 2024 . The Telegraph . 0307-1235.
  2. Web site: Leeds: Harehills residents condemn 'out of control' disorder . 2024-08-06 . www.bbc.com . en-GB.
  3. News: Elgot . Jessica . reporter . Jessica Elgot Political . 2017-04-27 . Theresa May lays bare ambition to capture Labour heartlands . 2024-08-06 . The Guardian . en-GB . 0261-3077.
  4. Health profile overview for Gipton and Harehills ward . Gipton and Harehills Ward 2020.
  5. Web site: Social Work News . 2024-07-30 . www.mysocialworknews.com.
  6. News: Vinter . Robyn . 2024-07-28 . 'We got failed by the police': how veterans of Leeds riots stepped in to defuse disorder . 2024-07-30 . The Observer . en-GB . 0029-7712.
  7. Web site: Gent . Craig . 19 July 2024 . 'We're All Getting Attacked': How Disorder Broke Out in East Leeds . Novara Media.
  8. Bailey . Liz . June 2019 . Health Needs Assessment of Gypsies, Travellers and Roma Groups in Leeds 2019 . Adults and Health Directorate . Leeds City Council.
  9. Web site: Mackley . Elizabeth . 19 July 2024 . Police issue more details on what sparked night of violence . 19 July 2024 . Yorkshire Live.
  10. News: Vinter . Robyn . 19 July 2024 . 'We're in it together': how unrest in Leeds escalated – and was defused . 19 July 2024 . The Guardian . 0261-3077.
  11. News: Penna . Dominic . 19 July 2024 . Farage under fire after calling Leeds riot 'politics of the subcontinent' . 19 July 2024 . The Telegraph . 0307-1235.
  12. News: Cobham . Tara . 19 July 2024 . Leeds riots – latest: Arrests made over Harehills disorder as council urgently reviews 'family matter' case . 22 July 2024 . The Independent .
  13. News: Watling . Tom . 19 July 2024 . Leeds riots – latest: Harehills violence triggered by 'family incident' as hero councillor calmed disorder . 19 July 2024 . The Independent.
  14. News: Moss . Alex . Ingall . Tom . 18 July 2024 . Bus destroyed and police car flipped in Leeds disorder . 19 July 2024 . BBC News.
  15. News: Vinter . Robyn . Badshah . Nadeem . 19 July 2024 . Police car turned over and vehicles set alight in disorder in Leeds . 19 July 2024 . The Guardian . London.
  16. Web site: Kershaw . Tom . 18 July 2024 . Harehills latest as police car overturned and attacked — Updates . 18 July 2024 . Leeds Live .
  17. News: RFE/RL . Romanians Appear To Be Involved In Mass Riot In Leeds . 22 July 2024 . RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty .
  18. Web site: 22 July 2024 . Nine Romanians detained after disturbances in British city of Leeds, one charged . 22 July 2024 . Romania Insider .
  19. Web site: Robson . Steve . 19 July 2024 . Leeds police 'outnumbered' and 'ran away' from riot disorder, locals claim . 20 July 2024 . inews.co.uk.
  20. News: Vinter . Robyn . 23 July 2024 . 'This is what a councillor is supposed to do': Mothin Ali on false accusations of rioting . 24 July 2024 . The Guardian . 0261-3077.
  21. Web site: 19 July 2024 . 'Hero' councillor formed 'human shield' to stop violence escalating in Leeds riots . 19 July 2024 . The Independent .
  22. Web site: Gent . Craig . 19 July 2024 . 'We're All Getting Attacked': How Disorder Broke Out in East Leeds . Novara Media.
  23. News: 19 July 2024 . Leeds: Arrests made after 'night of chaos' in Harehills . 20 July 2024 . BBC News .
  24. Web site: UK: Far-right blames Muslims and 'third world' migrants for Leeds unrest . 19 July 2024 . Middle East Eye .
  25. Web site: Gipton & Harehills – areainsights.co.uk . https://web.archive.org/web/20240722125959/https://www.areainsights.co.uk/borough/leeds/gipton-harehills/#ethnic_group . 22 July 2024. 19 July 2024 .
  26. Web site: 20 July 2024 . Hero councillor formed a human shield to stop violence escalating in Leeds riots . 20 July 2024 . The Independent .
  27. News: Bird . Steve . 20 July 2024 . Romanians chant 'please bring the kids back' as Leeds council launches 'urgent review' . 20 July 2024 . The Telegraph . 0307-1235.
  28. Web site: 23 July 2024 . Children returned to extended family after Leeds disorder . 24 July 2024 . BBC News .
  29. Web site: 22 July 2024 . Nine Romanians detained after disturbances in British city of Leeds, one charged . https://web.archive.org/web/20240722173205/http://web.archive.org/screenshot/https://www.romania-insider.com/nine-romanians-detained-disturbances-leeds-july-2024 . 22 July 2024 . 22 July 2024 . Romania Insider.
  30. Web site: 20 July 2024 . Harehills Disorder: Man Charged with Arson and Violent Disorder . 22 July 2024 . West Yorkshire Police.
  31. Web site: Harehills: Twenty seven people arrested over Leeds disorder . 2024-08-03 . www.bbc.com . en-GB.
  32. Web site: Stankeviciute . Emilia . Social tensions spark Islamophobic rhetoric: What we know so far about the riots in the Harehills area of Leeds, U.K. . 23 July 2024 . Logically Facts.
  33. Web site: We need to talk about the Harehills riot . 23 July 2024 . www.spiked-online.com .