This is a list of college baseball players named first team All-Americans for the 2024 NCAA Division I baseball season. With the end of Collegiate Baseball Newspaper, the NCAA now recognizes three different All-America selectors for baseball: the American Baseball Coaches Association (ABCA) (since 1947), Baseball America (since 1981), and the National Collegiate Baseball Writers Association (NCBWA) (since 2001).
| ABCA | American Baseball Coaches Association[1] | |
|---|---|---|
| BA | Baseball America[2] | |
| NCBWA | National Collegiate Baseball Writers Association[3] | |
| Consensus All-American (selected by 2 or more selectors) | ||
| Awarded the Golden Spikes Award or Dick Howser Trophy as national Player of the Year |
| Position | Name | School | ABCA | BA | NCBWA | Notes | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting pitcher | style= | — | ||||||
| Starting pitcher | style= | ACC Pitcher of the Year | ||||||
| Starting pitcher | style= | — | — | Big West Pitcher of the Year | ||||
| Starting pitcher | style= | — | CUSA Pitcher of the Year | |||||
| Starting pitcher | style= | — | — | SoCon Pitcher of the Year | ||||
| Starting pitcher | style= | SEC Pitcher of the Year | ||||||
| Starting pitcher | style= | |||||||
| Relief pitcher | style= | — | ||||||
| Relief pitcher | style= | — | — | |||||
| Relief pitcher | style= | |||||||
| Relief pitcher | style= | — | — | |||||
| Relief pitcher | style= | — | — | |||||
| Relief pitcher | style= | — | — | |||||
| Catcher | style= | — | — | |||||
| Catcher | style= | — | ||||||
| First baseman | style= | |||||||
| Second baseman | style= | Pac-12 Player of the Year | ||||||
| Third baseman | style= | Golden Spikes Award Dick Howser Trophy SEC Player of the Year | ||||||
| Shortstop | style= | — | Sun Belt Player of the Year | |||||
| Shortstop | style= | — | — | Big Ten Player of the Year | ||||
| Outfielder | style= | — | ||||||
| Outfielder | style= | — | — | WCC Player of the Year | ||||
| Outfielder | style= | — | — | |||||
| Outfielder | style= | — | ||||||
| Outfielder | style= | — | — | ASUN Player of the Year | ||||
| Outfielder | style= | — | ||||||
| Outfielder | style= | ACC Player of the Year | ||||||
| style= | — | SoCon Player of the Year | ||||||
| style= | — | — | ||||||
| Utility player | style= |