2023 Uxbridge and South Ruislip by-election explained

Election Name:2023 Uxbridge and South Ruislip by-election
Type:parliamentary
Turnout:46.2% (17.3 pp)
Seats For Election: constituency
Ongoing:no
Previous Election:2019 United Kingdom general election
Previous Year:2019
Next Election:2024 United Kingdom general election
Next Year:2024
Election Date:20 July 2023
MP
Image1:Official portrait of Steve Tuckwell MP (cropped).jpg
Candidate1:Steve Tuckwell
Party1:Conservative Party (UK)
Popular Vote1:13,965
Percentage1:45.2%
Swing1:7.4 pp
Candidate2:Danny Beales
Party2:Labour Party (UK)
Popular Vote2:13,470
Percentage2:43.6%
Swing2:6.0 pp
Before Election:Boris Johnson
Before Party:Conservative
After Election:Steve Tuckwell
After Party:Conservative
Country:United Kingdom

A by-election for the United Kingdom parliamentary constituency of was held on 20 July 2023, following the resignation of former Prime Minister Boris Johnson as its member of Parliament (MP) on 12 June.

The Conservative Party's candidate, Steve Tuckwell, held the seat with a reduced majority of 495 votes. The result was considered an upset, as Labour had targeted the seat heavily; a large backlash against Johnson was expected in the constituency in the wake of the Partygate affair. Tuckwell attributed his victory to the unpopularity of London's Ultra Low Emission Zone scheme and its proposed expansion into the Borough of Hillingdon.[1]

Background

Uxbridge and South Ruislip is a constituency in West London, part of the suburban sprawl of Greater London.[2] Suburbs in the constituency include Uxbridge, South Ruislip, Eastcote, Hillingdon and Yiewsley.

Johnson was first elected as an MP in 2001 for the seat of . After leaving Parliament to focus on being Mayor of London, an office to which he was elected in 2008, he was elected as the MP for Uxbridge and South Ruislip in 2015. In July 2019, he became leader of the Conservative Party and Prime Minister when he won the leadership election touched off by the resignation of Theresa May. He defended his office in December 2019 with a landslide victory at the general election, the largest Conservative victory since 1987. However, he stood down as Prime Minister and party leader in July 2022 following a series of scandals and by-election defeats which culminated in the mass resignation of much of his cabinet. In the subsequent leadership election, Liz Truss succeeded Johnson as Prime Minister, only to resign herself and be succeeded in October by Rishi Sunak.

Johnson announced his pending resignation from Parliament in response to an investigation by the Commons Privileges Committee that was launched into whether he had knowingly misled Parliament in comments about Partygate. He was highly critical of the report, which recommended a suspension from Parliament that would have been long enough to trigger a recall petition that, if successful, would have forced a by-election.[3]

His resignation took effect on 12 June. The writs for the by-election were moved, in Parliament, by Chief Whip Simon Hart on 14 June. A by-election must take place between 21 and 27 working days from the issuing of the writs; thus the by-election for Uxbridge would have had to occur between 13 and 21 July.[4] Hillingdon Council later confirmed that the by-election would take place on 20 July.[5]

On the same day, the Selby and Ainsty and Somerton and Frome by-elections were held.

Campaign

Labour began campaigning the day after Johnson's resignation was announced, with candidate Danny Beales joined by Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary Jonathan Ashworth and Labour's campaign co-ordinator Shabana Mahmood[6] speaking to press with assembled supporters before canvassing.[7] On 10 June, Sir Ed Davey, the leader of the Liberal Democrats, ruled out a Lib–Lab pact,[8] as did Mahmood on 13 June.[9]

At a hustings on 4 July, Beales said that it was "not the right time" to expand London's Ultra Low Emission Zone (ULEZ) into Hillingdon.[10] Beales had previously supported the policy earlier in the campaign.[11]

Weeks before the by-election, London Mayor Sadiq Khan reversed his decision to close Uxbridge police station, in a move described by political opponents as a "cynical" attempt to influence voters. The closure of the station was long opposed by the Conservative-run council and the previous MP.[12] The London Conservatives referred the mayor to the watchdog, Greater London Assembly's monitoring officer.[13] Both the Conservatives and the Labour candidate claimed credit for the reversal of the closure.[14]

Polling

One poll of the constituency was conducted in the days shortly before Boris Johnson's resignation by Lord Ashcroft Polls. The poll was criticised by a journalist in The New Statesman for sampling issues, and allegedly under-representing the young.[15] National polls suggested Labour could win the seat, but that it would be a close race against the Conservatives.[7] A poll by JL Partners after Johnson's resignation showed Labour in the lead, but within its margin of error.[16]

Dates
conducted
PollsterClientSample
size
ConLabLib DemsGreenReformReclaimOthersLead
data-sort-type="number" style="background:;"data-sort-type="number" style="background:;"data-sort-type="number" style="background:;"data-sort-type="number" style="background:;"data-sort-type="number" style="background:;"data-sort-type="number" style="background:;"
2023 by-election45.2%43.6%1.7%2.9%2.3%4.4%1.6
JL Partners38 Degrees50033%41%6%4%5%10%8
Boris Johnson resigns as an MP triggering a by-election
Lord Ashcroft PollsN/A93650%33%6%5%3%4%17
2019 general election52.6%37.6%6.3%2.2%1.3%15.0

Results

Seventeen candidates were standing in this by-election. The full list was announced on 23 June 2023.

Aftermath

Against expectations, Labour failed to take the seat, despite winning the Selby and Ainsty by-election on the same day with a much larger swing. Many interpreted the result as being about opposition to the ULEZ expansion.[17] [18] [19] Much of Steve Tuckwell's campaign literature did not mention Boris Johnson at all, while barely mentioning either the Conservative Party or Rishi Sunak.[20] Both Labour's leader, Keir Starmer, and deputy leader, Angela Rayner, blamed opposition to ULEZ, with Starmer suggesting the Labour London Mayor Sadiq Khan should rethink the policy.[21] [22] Khan defended the policy[23] and Starmer soon sought to heal the rift.[24] The defeated Labour candidate, Beales, also criticised the ULEZ policy.[25] openDemocracy noted that despite strong negative feeling towards high-ranking politicians like Sunak, Starmer, and Khan, Tuckwell won more than half as many votes as Johnson had won in 2019.[20]

The elected chair of Uxbridge and South Ruislip Constituency Labour Party resigned his position and left the party on the day after the election, praising former leader Jeremy Corbyn.[26]

Tuckwell would later go on to lose the seat to Beales at the 2024 Election by an equally narrow margin of only 587 votes, serving just under a year as the constituency's MP.

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 2023 by-elections: Conservatives hold Boris Johnson's old seat of Uxbridge and South Ruislip . 2023-07-21 . Sky News . en.
  2. Web site: BBC NEWS - VOTE 2001 - RESULTS & CONSTITUENCIES - Uxbridge . 10 June 2023 . news.bbc.co.uk.
  3. News: 9 June 2023 . Boris Johnson resigns: Ex-PM quits Parliament over Partygate report . BBC News . 9 June 2023.
  4. Web site: Rufo . Yasmin . 14 June 2023 . Boris Johnson: By-election confirmed for former constituency . 14 June 2023 . BBC News.
  5. Web site: Salisbury . Josh . 15 June 2023 . By-election date confirmed for Boris Johnson's London constituency . 15 June 2023 . Evening Standard . en.
  6. Web site: Patrick . Holly . Labour candidate begins campaign for Boris Johnson's seat after ex-PM resigns as MP . The Independent . 14 June 2023 . 10 June 2023.
  7. Web site: Topping . Alexandra . Labour's candidate in Uxbridge 'not taking anything for granted' . The Guardian . 14 June 2023 . 12 June 2023.
  8. Web site: Adu . Aletha . Lib Dems rule out tactical voting pact with Labour in byelections . 10 June 2023 . 15 June 2023. The Guardian . en.
  9. Web site: Gye . Chloe Chaplain, Hugo . 13 June 2023 . Labour rules out Lib Dem pact and aims to win three by-elections - including Dorries's old seat . 15 June 2023 . The Independent . en.
  10. Web site: Rogers. Alexandra. Labour split as Uxbridge by-election candidate speaks out against London mayor's ULEZ expansion. 4 July 2023. 5 July 2023. Sky News.
  11. 13 July 2023. "A parting gift for Danny Beales? Tory motion demands call on ULEZ". Camden New Journal.
  12. Cafe, Rebecca (3 July 2023). "Uxbridge: Sadiq Khan saves police station weeks before by-election". BBC.
  13. Penna, Dominic and Gibbons, Amy (3 July 2023). "Tories refer Sadiq Khan to watchdog over decision to save police station amid by-election battle". The Telegraph.
  14. 3 July 2023. "Uxbridge by-election: rivals claim credit for saving police station". Hillingdon Times.
  15. Web site: Walker . Ben . 8 June 2023 . Will Boris Johnson really win in Uxbridge? . 14 June 2023 . State of the Nation . en-US.
  16. Web site: Cecil . Nicholas . 2023-07-07 . Labour ahead in Uxbridge and Selby, polls find in by-elections double blow for Sunak . 2023-07-07 . Evening Standard . en.
  17. News: Big defeats for Tories but party holds on to Uxbridge. BBC News . 21 July 2023.
  18. News: Relying on wedge issues like Ulez won't save Tories from wipeout. Georgina. Quach. Stephen. Bush. Financial Times . 21 July 2023.
  19. News: Residents of Uxbridge react to narrow Tory by-election victory. BBC News . 21 July 2023.
  20. News: The Tories' lesson from Uxbridge: pretend not to be the Tories . Adam . Ramsay . Seth . Thévoz . . 21 July 2023.
  21. Web site: Labour's Uxbridge defeat sparks blame game: 'We've got a lot to think about'. Sky News.
  22. News: Starmer says Labour doing something 'very wrong' after Ulez-linked Uxbridge loss. Donna. Ferguson. Tobi. Thomas. 22 July 2023. The Guardian.
  23. Web site: Labour Civil War Erupts As Sadiq Khan Doubles Down On ULEZ Despite Uxbridge Defeat. 21 July 2023. Yahoo Finance.
  24. Web site: Starmer moves to heal rift with Khan after Uxbridge by-election loss. Chloe Chaplain, Jane Merrick, Paul. Waugh. 21 July 2023. inews.co.uk.
  25. Web site: Exclusive: Defeated Labour Candidate Launches Bitter Attack On Sadiq Khan's ULEZ Expansion. 22 July 2023. HuffPost UK.
  26. Web site: Uxbridge and South Ruislip CLP chair quits party after defeat, praising Corbyn. Tom. Belger. 21 July 2023. LabourList | Latest UK Labour Party news, analysis and comment.