2022 Wrexham County Borough Council election explained

Election Name:2022 Wrexham County Borough Council election
Country:Wales
Type:Parliamentary
Ongoing:no
Party Colour:yes
Previous Election:2017 Wrexham County Borough Council election
Previous Year:2017
Next Year:2027
Seats For Election:All 56 (4; previously 52) seats to Wrexham County Borough Council
Majority Seats:29
Election Date:5 May 2022
Leader1:Mark Pritchard
Party1:Independent politician
Leaders Seat1:Esclusham
Seats Before1:26
Seats1:23
Seat Change1: 3
Leader2:Dana Davies
Party2:Welsh Labour
Leaders Seat2:Ruabon
Seats Before2:12
Seats2:14
Seat Change2: 2
Leader3:Hugh Jones
Party3:Welsh Conservatives
Leaders Seat3:Rossett
Seats Before3:9
Seats3:9
Seat Change3: 0
Leader4:Marc Jones
Party4:Plaid Cymru
Leaders Seat4:Grosvenor
Seats Before4:3
Seats4:9
Seat Change4: 6
Party5:Welsh Liberal Democrats
Seats Before5:2
Seats5:1
Seat Change5: 1
Council control
Posttitle:Council control after election
Before Election:No overall control
Before Party:IndependentWelsh Conservatives coalition
After Election:No overall control
After Party:Independent GroupWelsh Conservatives coalition
Turnout: 36.47%

The 2022 Wrexham County Borough Council election took place on 5 May 2022 to elect 56 members to Wrexham County Borough Council, the principal council of Wrexham County Borough, Wales. On the same day, elections were held to the other 21 local authorities, and community councils in Wales as part of the 2022 Welsh local elections. The previous Wrexham County Borough all-council election took place in May 2017 and future elections will take place every five years, with the next scheduled for 2027.

On 5 May 2022, the election was held in forty-one of the forty-nine wards for 2022 in Wrexham County Borough. The remaining eight had no opposition nominated by 5 April 2022, and the councillors for these wards were re-elected unopposed, with their wards not holding the election. The councillors unopposed were six independents and two conservative councillors.

Independent politicians (including "non-specified" and the "Wrexham Independents") formed the largest group in the council with twenty-three councillors, down from 2017's twenty-six, and were six short of the twenty-nine needed for a majority. The second largest group were Labour with fourteen councillors elected, up from 2017's twelve councillors. The Conservatives had the same amount councillors as in 2017 with nine. Plaid Cymru increased their number of councillors to match the Conservatives also at nine, up from their three councillors in 2017. The Liberal Democrats had their share of councillors split to one councillor, down from two in 2017.

Following the results, the council was again under no overall control. Talks between independent politicians and Labour occurred over the weekend. On 10 May 2022, the two formerly separately organised groups of independents in the council, the independents and the "Wrexham Independents" group, merged into one "mega" 21-member "Independent Group". The Independent Group was initially in talks with Welsh Labour councillors but talks collapsed over mandatory councillor anti-discrimination training. On 11 May 2022, the Independent Group formed another coalition with the Welsh Conservatives for another five-year term with a total of thirty members, a two-member majority.

Background

Council elections in Wales were originally scheduled for May 2021 but were delayed to avoid a conflict with the 2021 Senedd election. The frequency of the elections was also increased from four years to five years to avoid future clashes,[1] meaning (after 2022) the next council election is expected in 2027. The number of councillors is to be increased from fifty-two to fifty-six at the 2022 election, with several ward changes to ensure better electoral parity. There would be forty-nine wards up for election, up from forty-seven in the 2017 election following a recent local boundary review.

An IndependentWelsh Conservatives coalition group was formed following the 2017 local election and were in control of the council since 2017 up to the election.

Local political context

In the 2019 United Kingdom general election, Conservative candidates won the constituencies of Wrexham and Clwyd South for the first time in their existence. The constituencies were generally considered to be Labour heartlands part of its "red wall",[2] and were won by Labour in the June 2017 election.[3] [4] Sarah Atherton was elected for the Conservatives to represent the Wrexham constituency with 15,199 votes, and Simon Baynes for Clwyd South with 16,222 votes.[5] Atherton is the first Female MP to be elected to the Wrexham seat since its creation in 1918, and the first female Conservative MP elected to Westminster representing a Welsh constituency.[6] [7] [8]

On 31 January 2020, the UK left the EU, with the county borough in the 2016 referendum, voting in favour of Leave.

In the 2021 Senedd election, Welsh Labour incumbents for the Senedd constituencies of Wrexham and Clwyd South covering the county borough were re-elected, despite media predictions and polling stating that one or both constituencies should follow the 2019 UK general election results and be won by Welsh Conservative candidates with a tight margin.[9] [10] [11] For the 2021 Police and Crime Commissioner election, Andy Dunbobbin of the Labour and Co-operative party received the most votes (98,034) in the county borough.

Between 2017 and 2021, various community councils had by-elections, leading to three independent, four Welsh Labour, one Plaid Cymru, and five non-aligned candidates elected. An additional independent candidate was elected to Rhosllanerchrugog Community Council's Pant ward in September 2017 but was replaced by a Welsh Labour candidate in a by-election five months later. Eight elections in this period were uncontested.

On 20 September 2018, an independent candidate for community councillor for Gwersyllt North was elected with 98 votes. The councillor was later replaced in another by-election on 27 February 2020 leading to the Plaid Cymru candidate being elected with 189 votes.

On 18 March 2021, a by-election for the council's Maesydre ward occurred, leading to the Plaid Cymru candidate, Rebecca Martin, being elected with 150 votes, over the Welsh Labour (133 votes) and Welsh Conservative (123 votes) candidates.[12]

On 28 October 2021, a by-election in the ward of Gresford East and West was held following the resignation of the incumbent Conservative candidate.[13] The Welsh Conservatives were able to hold onto the ward, with Jeremy Kent being elected for the ward with 351 votes.[14] [15]

On 17 December 2021, in the neighbouring English constituency of North Shropshire, the Liberal Democrat candidate overturned a 23,000 (2019) Conservative majority following the former MP Owen Paterson's scandal.[16] [17]

Council context

In 2021, the council submitted bids for UK City of Culture 2025 on behalf of the county borough, and a separate bid for awarding the then town of Wrexham the status of a city for the 2022 Platinum Jubilee of Queen Elizabeth II civic honours.[18] In October 2021, the council's bid for UK City of Culture 2025 made it onto the competition's shortlist of only 8 shortlisted places in the UK, outbidding 12 other places (20 applied in total) and being the only one of the five bids from Wales making it onto the shortlist. In March 2022, Wrexham County Borough's bid for City of Culture made onto the competition's shortlist of only four places.[19] [20] Wrexham's city status bid was submitted in December 2021 to local controversy.[21] [22] Protests against the city status bid, led by Plaid Cymru, were held outside Wrexham's Guildhall, the council's main building.[23] [24] A public consultation into the city status bid revealed that of those surveyed, 61% did not believe Wrexham should be awarded city status at all.[25] Within the council, political groups threatened to walk out over the debate of city status.[26] The council was criticised for ignoring the survey's results by submitting a bid. Wrexham's city status bid is one of 39 bids across the UK and territories, it is the only bid from Wales, following Merthyr Tydfil's withdrawal of their bid. It is hoped that being the only Welsh bid leads to increased chances of Wrexham winning city status if the Queen awards city status to at least one town in the four countries of the United Kingdom. Wrexham has applied for city status three other times, in 2000, 2002 and 2012, with the 2012 bid lost to St Asaph, Denbighshire. Following the election and unrelated to it, on 20 May 2022, it was announced that Wrexham would be awarded city status through letters patent later in 2022.[27] However, on 31 May 2022, it had lost its bid for UK City of Culture to Bradford, but was formally awarded city status on 1 September 2022.[28]

In January 2022, the council considered raising salaries for councillors to encourage more skilled and more diverse candidates for the 2022 election.[29] [30] [31] [32]

Changes since 2017

Party!Candidate!Votes!%
Plaid CymruRebecca Ann Martin15030.7
Welsh LabourThomas Stanford13327.2
Welsh ConservativesCatherine Brown12325.2
Welsh Liberal DemocratsPeter Roger Davies479.6
IndependentClive Graham Ray367.4
Total489
Party!Candidate!Votes!%
Welsh ConservativesJeremy Kent35143
Welsh Liberal DemocratsBeryl Blackmore16520
Plaid CymruAimi Waters16320
Welsh LabourAled Canter13216
Reform UKCharles William Henry Dodman61
Green PartyAlan Butterworth51
Total822

Nominations

The deadline for councillor nominations was 4 April 2022 at 16:00. 146 candidates were nominated, a decline of 9 from 155 in 2017. These nominees include: 48 independents (down 13), 30 Welsh Labour (down 9), 28 Welsh Conservatives (up 8), 24 Plaid Cymru (up 9), 8 Welsh Liberal Democrats (down 5), 4 Wales Green Party (up 2), 3 non-aligned and 1 Reform UK candidate.[33]

Due to a lack of competing candidates for some electoral wards, upon the deadline for councillor nominees, eight councilors were re-elected due to no competition. These uncontested seats represent 14.29% of the total seats in the election, cancelling the election for 14,583 electors.[34] Wards with only the incumbent or one contender standing would not be holding the ward election. The eight wards with no competition, is an increase from the three non-contending wards in the 2017 election.

The eight wards and councillors not facing competition, and are re-elected prior to the election are:

Ward changes

See also: List of electoral wards in Wrexham County Borough. In July 2021, the Welsh Government accepted the various ward change proposals made by the Local Democracy and Boundary Commission for Wales, with only slight modification, for Wrexham County Borough. The number of councillors will increase by four, from 52 to a total of 56, giving an average of 1,801 electors per councillor. These took effect from May 2022 following the election. The changes gave a better parity of representation. The Welsh Government rejected three recommendations on the names of three wards. Twenty-four wards remained unchanged. Seven wards have two councillors, up from four wards having two councillors in 2017.[35]

Of the other wards, and not mentioning minor boundary changes, the major changes are:[36] [37]

No changes performed on the following wards:

Overview of results

The election was held on 5 May 2022, no party gained a majority of seats, making the council under no overall control. Four councillors were added for the 2022 election. Below is a table comparing the seat numbers of the 2022 and 2017 election using notional election results, which uses an estimated version of 2017's results using 2022 boundaries.

Notional results

Below is an election summary table using notional election results. These are based on an estimated 2017 result using 2022's electoral boundaries, which are then compared to 2022's results. Compared to 2017, there is an increase of four councillors on the council, and various ward boundary changes. Data and calculations are provided by BBC News. Turnout was 36.47%,[38] down from the 40% in 2017.

|}

! rowspan="2"
2022 Total2017Change from 2017
or Ward
Registered electors87,291
Ballots issued31,840
Votes cast (incl. two cllr ward ballots)37,304
Candidates elected146155 9
Ward with highest turnout50%Llangollen Rural
Overall turnout36.47%40% 3.53%
Ward with most votes3034Pant and Johnstown (two cllrs)
Ward with least votes373Queensway (one cllr)
Ward with most spoilt ballots25Hermitage
Candidate with most votes1,168Rob Walsh (Llay)
Winning candidate with least votes184Paul Williams (Smithfield)
Candidate with least votes7Stephen James Rooney (Penycae candidate)
Winning candidates total21,800
Losing candidates total15,500

Summarised ward results

2017 result! colspan="2"
Notes2022 resultChange
Acrefair Northdid not existLabournew seat
ActonIndependentabolished
Acton and Maesydredid not existPlaid Cymrunew seat
Labour
Bangor Is-y-Coeddid not existConservativenew seat
Borras ParkConservativeConservativehold
BroningtonConservativeabolished
Bronington and Hanmerdid not existConservativenew seat
BrymboConservativeConservative defectedto IndependentIndependenthold
did not existLabournew seat
Bryn CefnConservativeConservativehold
BrynyffynnonIndependentIndependenthold
CartrefleIndependentIndependenthold
CefnIndependentabolished
Labourabolished
Cefn Eastdid not existLabournew seat
Cefn Westdid not existLabournew seat
Chirk NorthLabourLabourhold
Chirk SouthIndependentIndependenthold
CoedpoethLabourLabourhold
IndependentLabourgain
Dyffryn CeiriogIndependentIndependenthold
ErddigConservativeConservativehold
EsclushamIndependentIndependenthold
Garden VillageIndependentIndependenthold
Gresford East and WestConservativeConservative hold (28 October 2021by-election)Conservativehold
GrosvenorPlaid CymruPlaid Cymruhold
GwenfroIndependentIndependenthold
Gwersyllt Eastdid not existIndependentnew seat
Gwersyllt East and SouthIndependentabolished
Independent
Gwersyllt NorthIndependentPlaid Cymrugain
Gwersyllt Southdid not existPlaid Cymrunew seat
Gwersyllt WestPlaid CymruPlaid Cymruhold
HermitageLabourLabourhold
HoltConservativeConservativehold
JohnstownIndependentabolished
Little ActonIndependentIndependenthold
Llangollen RuralIndependentIndependenthold
LlayLiberal DemocratsIncumbent defected from Liberal Democrats to IndependentsIndependenthold
LabourLabourhold
MaesydreLabourPlaid Cymru gain from Labour

(18 March 2021 by-election)

abolished
MarchwielIndependentIndependenthold
Marford and HoseleyConservativeLiberal Democratsgain
MineraIndependentLabourgain
New BroughtonIndependentIndependenthold
OffaLiberal DemocratsPlaid Cymrugain
OvertonIndependentabolished
Overton and Maelor Southdid not existIndependentnew seat
PantIndependentabolished
Pant and Johnstowndid not existIndependentnew seat
Independentnew seat
PenycaeIndependentIndependenthold
Penycae and Ruabon SouthIndependentIndependenthold
Plas MadocLabourabolished
PonciauIndependentIndependenthold
Labourabolished
QueenswayPlaid CymruPlaid Cymruhold
Rhosdid not existIndependentnew seat
RhosnesniIndependentIndependenthold
did not existPlaid Cymrunew seat
RossettConservativeConservativehold
did not existConservativenew seat
RuabonLabourLabourhold
SmithfieldLabourPlaid Cymrugain
StanstyIndependentIndependenthold
WhitegateLabourLabourhold
WynnstayLabourLabourhold

Aftermath

Following the results, the council was under no overall control, with no single party holding a majority of councillors. Independents were initially in talks with Welsh Labour councillors over the 7–8 May weekend.

On 10 May 2022, the two formerly separately organised groups of independents in the council, the Independents, led by Mark Pritchard, and the "Wrexham Independents" group, led by David A Bithell, merged into one "mega" "the Independent Group". The group contains twenty-one of the twenty-three independent politicians elected, with Mike Davies and Ronnie Prince being the only two independents not join the group. It is led by incumbent council leader and deputy leader, Mark Pritchard and David A Bithell respectively.[39] On the start of more talks between Labour and the Independent Group, Labour Cllr Davies, questioned whether the merger was an attempt to stay in power, and questioned the relationship between Cllr Pritchard and Cllr Bithell over a rumoured falling out prior to the election. However, Cllr Davies added if they are "able to reconcile their differences" and have a "new and ambitious agenda", then Welsh Labour would welcome the merger.[40]

On 11 May 2022, the Independent Group formed another coalition with the Welsh Conservatives for the next five-year term following an agreement between the two. The coalition would have 30 members, a two councillor majority on the 56 seat council.[41] Labour Cllr Davies said that the IndependentConservatives deal was based on "pure self-interest" "to protect their own positions". Leader of Plaid Cymru in the council, Marc Jones also accused the deal to be more focused in retaining power than representation. Welsh Labour leader in the council, Dana Davies claimed talks between the two failed due to Labour's requirement that any deal involves all councillors undertaking training on addressing anti-Semitism, homophobia, racism and sexism.[42] [43] Cllr Davies described this deal to have been a "UK-first" and "ground-breaking" if it were to have been agreed. Cllr Davies also said that every member would have to sign up a motion condemning racism and misogyny. Talks with Plaid Cymru were ruled out from the beginning by the independents due to Plaid Cymru's disagreement with Mark Pritchard's leadership.[44] [45]

The Independent Group and the Welsh Conservatives following the announcement describe it to be "an exciting time for Wrexham", and Cllr Pritchard and Conservative group leader Hugh Jones said that they are "please to have reached a workable agreement [...] we will continue to build on our success".

Opposition in the council will be Welsh Labour, Plaid Cymru, the two non-aligned independents, and the Liberal Democrats councillor.[46]

Full ward results

Incumbent councillors are marked with a *. Councillors who served for different (including abolished) wards are marked with **.

Gwersyllt East (one seat)

David Griffiths and Tina Mannering were the two incumbent councillors for the former Gwersyllt East and South ward, and elected in 2012 for such ward.

Ponciau (one seat)

Ponciau was reduced from a two-seat ward to a one-seat ward for the 2022 election. Both incumbents stood for re-election.

Rossett (two seats)

Rossett gained an additional councillor seat for 2022.

Wynnstay (one seat)

See also

Notes and References

  1. News: Mosalski. Ruth. 24 September 2019. The date of the next council elections in Wales has moved. Wales Online. 30 November 2021.
  2. News: 2019-12-05. The Tories are well ahead in Wrexham, part of Labour's "Red Wall". The Economist. 2022-01-18. 0013-0613.
  3. Web site: Election results Wrexham County Borough Council. 2022-01-17. www.wrexham.gov.uk.
  4. Web site: 2019-12-06. 'People are fed up, tired and scared': the battle for Wrexham. 2022-01-18. The Guardian. en.
  5. News: Wrexham parliamentary constituency - Election 2019 - BBC News. en-GB. 2022-01-18.
  6. News: Randall. Liam. Sarah Atherton: Wrexham elects Conservative MP for first time in history. Leader Live. live. https://web.archive.org/web/20191213132532/https://www.leaderlive.co.uk/news/18099441.sarah-atherton-wrexham-elects-conservative-mp-first-time-history/. 13 December 2019. 13 December 2019.
  7. Web site: 2021-06-08. In Wrexham, voters are abandoning Labour over Brexit. 2022-01-18. New Statesman. en-US.
  8. Web site: General Election 2019 - Wrexham turns blue for the first time. 2022-01-18. www.shropshirestar.com. en.
  9. Web site: Randall. Liam. 2021-05-07. Senedd Election 2021: Wrexham constituency result in full. 2022-01-18. North Wales Live. en.
  10. Web site: Mosalski. Ruth. Burkitt. Sian. 2021-05-07. Senedd election 2021 result in Wrexham: Labour hold seat. 2022-01-18. WalesOnline. en.
  11. Web site: 2021-05-07. Seat projection: Conservatives on course to gain seats from Labour. 2022-01-19. ITV News. en.
  12. Web site: 2021-03-19. Plaid Cymru gain council seat from Labour in Wrexham as by-elections resume after pandemic pause. 2022-01-18. Nation.Cymru. en-GB.
  13. Web site: Voters set to go to the polls at Gresford by-election in October. 2022-01-18. The Leader. en.
  14. Web site: Candidates confirmed in race to replace Wrexham councillor who relocated to Panama. 2022-01-18. The Leader. en.
  15. Web site: Jeremy Kent wins Gresford election – Welsh Conservatives Hold. 2022-01-18. Wrexham.com. en.
  16. Web site: North Shropshire by-election 'drubbing' will send shockwaves through the Tory party. 2022-01-18. Sky News. en.
  17. Web site: 2021-12-17. 'Party is over': UK's ruling Tories lose safe seat they've always held. 2022-01-18. euronews. en.
  18. News: 2021-07-07. Wrexham mulls launching fourth bid for city status. en-GB. BBC News. 2022-01-18.
  19. Web site: 2022-03-18 . UK city of culture 2025: Southampton and Bradford among those on shortlist . 2022-03-18 . The Guardian . en.
  20. News: 2022-03-18 . UK City of Culture 2025: Derby misses out on shortlist . en-GB . BBC News . 2022-03-18.
  21. News: 2021-12-07. Wrexham to make fourth city status bid despite opposition. en-GB. BBC News. 2022-01-18.
  22. Web site: Randall. Liam. 2021-12-07. Wrexham pushes ahead with fourth city status bid despite backlash over plans. 2022-01-18. North Wales Live. en.
  23. News: 2021-12-04. Wrexham's city status bid plan opposed by protesters. en-GB. BBC News. 2022-01-18.
  24. Web site: 'Say No To City Status' - protesters demonstrate outside Wrexham Guildhall. 2022-01-18. The Leader. en.
  25. Web site: Majority say Wrexham does not deserve city status – council say "people lack confidence in their town". 2022-01-18. Wrexham.com. en.
  26. Web site: Council issue statement 70 days after mess of Full Council meeting on City Status bid. 2022-01-18. Wrexham.com. en.
  27. Web site: The City of Wrexham: History made as city status is granted . 2022-05-21 . The Leader . en.
  28. Web site: Official – Wrexham is now a city . 2022-09-01 . Wrexham.com . en.
  29. Web site: Councillors set to back action plan aiming to increase diversity in 2022's local government elections. 2022-01-18. Wrexham.com. en.
  30. Web site: Councillor pay could rise by 16.9% in 'significant reset' to encourage more candidates for May 2022 elections. 2022-01-18. Wrexham.com. en.
  31. Web site: "You said we did" – Public again suggest cutting Mayoral role, trimming councillor pay and numbers. 2022-01-18. Wrexham.com. en.
  32. Web site: Wrexham politicians to discuss £2,400 a year councillor pay rise proposals. 2022-01-19. Border Counties Advertizer. en.
  33. Web site: Wrexham council election: 138 candidates fighting election with eight others already elected with no competition . 2022-04-19 . Wrexham.com . en.
  34. Web site: Dozens of council seats in Wales already decided as 70 councillors unopposed in upcoming elections . 2022-04-19 . Wrexham.com . en.
  35. Web site: Wrexham Council Boundary Reforms Confirmed LDBC. 2022-01-16. ldbc.gov.wales.
  36. Web site: November 2020. Review of the Electoral Arrangements of the County Borough of Wrexham – Final Recommendations Report. live. 19 January 2022. ldbc.gov.wales. Local Democracy and Boundary Commission for Wales. 12. https://web.archive.org/web/20220119010836/https://ldbc.gov.wales/sites/ldbc/files/review/Wrexham%20Final%20Report_e_1.pdf . 19 January 2022 .
  37. Web site: Shake up of Wrexham council wards would see more councillors and boundary changes. 2022-01-19. Wrexham.com. en.
  38. Web site: Turnout up across Wrexham in council election – however nine wards saw less than 30% of voters take part . 2022-05-17 . Wrexham.com . en.
  39. Web site: Questions over whether Wrexham independent group merger is 'marriage of convenience' . 2022-05-11 . The Leader . en.
  40. Web site: "Change takes courage" as Welsh Labour in talks with new Independent Group . 2022-05-11 . Wrexham.com . en.
  41. Web site: New mega Independent Group join forces with Conservatives to run Wrexham Council . 2022-05-11 . Wrexham.com . en.
  42. Web site: Coalition deal 'faltered on anti-Semitism, anti-homophobia, anti-racism and anti-sexism' training condition, says labour group leader . 2022-05-11 . Wrexham.com . en.
  43. Web site: Independents and Conservatives agree deal to run Wrexham Council for next five years . 2022-05-11 . The Leader . en.
  44. Web site: Wrexham Independents merge with Independents to form new mega Independents Group . 2022-05-11 . Wrexham.com . en.
  45. Web site: "Independent candidates have taken the public for a ride" say Plaid Cymru . 2022-05-11 . Wrexham.com . en.
  46. Web site: Randall . Liam . 2022-05-11 . Wrexham council to be led by Independents and Conservatives . 2022-05-11 . North Wales Live . en.