2022 South Ayrshire Council election explained

Election Name:2022 South Ayrshire Council election
Flag Image:S Ayrs arms.png
Type:parliamentary
Ongoing:no
Previous Election:2017 South Ayrshire Council election
Previous Year:2017
Next Election:2027 South Ayrshire Council election
Next Year:2027
Seats For Election:All 28 seats to South Ayrshire Council
Majority Seats:15
Registered:92,112
Turnout:49.7%
Image1:File:Martin Dowey.jpg
Leader1:Martin Dowey
Party1:Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party
Leaders Seat1:Ayr West
Seats Before1:11
Seats1:10
Seat Change1: 2
Popular Vote1:14,520
Percentage1:33.3%
Swing1: 10.1%
Leader2:Peter Henderson
Party2:Scottish National Party
Leaders Seat2:Girvan and South Carrick
Seats Before2:9
Seats2:9
Popular Vote2:14,838
Percentage2:34.1%
Swing2: 3.9%
Image4:File:Brian McGinley.jpg
Leader4:Brian McGinley
Party4:Scottish Labour Party
Leaders Seat4:Ayr East
Seats Before4:5
Seats4:5
Popular Vote4:7,276
Percentage4:16.7%
Swing4: 1.5%
Image5: Ind
Leader5:N/A
Party5:Independent (politician)
Leaders Seat5:N/A
Seats Before5:3
Seats5:4
Seat Change5: 2
Popular Vote5:5,313
Percentage5:12.2%
Swing5: 1.5%
Leader
Before Election:Peter Henderson
(SNP)
Before Party:No overall control
Posttitle:Leader after election
After Election:Martin Dowey
(Conservative)
After Party:No overall control

Elections to South Ayrshire Council took place on 5 May 2022 on the same day as the 31 other Scottish local government elections. As with other Scottish council elections, it was held using single transferable vote (STV) – a form of proportional representation – in which multiple candidates are elected in each ward and voters rank candidates in order of preference.

Despite shedding almost a quarter of their vote and coming second in the popular vote, the Conservatives retained their position as the largest party returning 10 councillors - two less than in the previous election. Both the Scottish National Party (SNP) – who topped the popular vote – and Labour made no gains or losses to remain as the second and third parties respectively. The number of independents returned increased from two to four.

Following the election the Conservatives formed a minority administration, replacing the previous SNP-Labour-Independent administration which was formed as a result of the previous election in 2017.

Background

Previous election

See main article: 2017 South Ayrshire Council election. At the previous election in 2017, the Conservatives won the most seats returning 12 councillors. The Scottish National Party (SNP) maintained their position as the second-largest party while boundary changes saw Labour lose out as they lost four seats to return five councillors. Two independents were also returned.[1] [2]

2017 South Ayrshire Council election result
PartySeatsVote share
Conservatives1243.4%
SNP930.2%
Labour515.2%
Independent210.7%

Source:[1] [2]

Electoral system

The election used the eight wards created under the Local Governance (Scotland) Act 2004, with 28 councillors elected. Each ward elected either three or four members, using the single transferable vote (STV) electoral system – a form of proportional representation – where candidates are ranked in order of preference.[3]

Composition

There was one change to the composition of the council following the previous election in 2017. Conservative councillor Hugh Hunter was de-selected in the run-up to the 2022 elections and resigned from the party to stand as an independent.[4] [5]

Composition of South Ayrshire Council
Party2017 resultDissolution
Conservative1211
SNP99
Labour55
Independents23

Retiring Councillors

Retiring councillors
Council WardPartyRetiring Councillor
TroonConservativePeter Convery
PrestwickConservativeMargaret Toner
LabourHelen Moonie
Ayr NorthSNPDouglas Campbell
Ayr WestSNPSiobhian Brown
KyleLabourAndy Campbell
Girvan and South CarrickConservativeIan Fitzsimmons

Source:[2] [6]

Candidates

The total number of candidates increased from 45 in 2017 to 61 mainly due to the increased number of parties contesting the election. Unlike the previous vote, the Conservatives fielded the highest number of candidates at 19 – seven more than they had in 2017. Both the SNP and Labour also fielded at least one candidate in every ward but the 13 candidates fielded by the SNP and the eight fielded by Labour was one less than in 2017. The Liberal Democrats named six candidates in this election after fielding none in South Ayrshire in 2017. The number of independent candidates increased from nine in 2017 to 10 but the Greens did not contest the election as they did five years previous. Both the Scottish Family Party and the Alba Party fielded their first ever candidates in a South Ayrshire election.[2] [6] [7]

Results

Source: [8]

Note: Votes are the sum of first preference votes across all council wards. The net gain/loss and percentage changes relate to the result of the previous Scottish local elections on 4 May 2017. This is because STV has an element of proportionality which is not present unless multiple seats are being elected. This may differ from other published sources showing gain/loss relative to seats held at the dissolution of Scotland's councils.[9] [10]

Ward summary

|- class="unsortable" align="centre"!rowspan=2 align="left"|Ward! %!Cllrs! %!Cllrs! %!Cllrs! %!Cllrs! %!Cllrs!rowspan=2|Total
Cllrs|- class="unsortable" align="center"!colspan=2|Con!colspan=2|SNP!colspan=2|Lab!colspan=2|Ind!colspan=2|Others|-|align="left"|Troon|bgcolor="#add8e6"|37.3|bgcolor="#add8e6"|2|35.9|1|19.2|1|2.8|0|4.7|0|4|-|align="left"|Prestwick|25.5|1|bgcolor="#efe146"|34.8|bgcolor="#efe146"|1|15.4|1|23.2|1|1.2|0|4|-|align="left"|Ayr North|20.5|1|bgcolor="#efe146"|45.9|bgcolor="#efe146"|2|24.1|1|6.3|0|3.2|0|4|-|align="left"|Ayr East|30.0|1|bgcolor="#efe146"|39.2|bgcolor="#efe146"|1|16.5|1|12.1|0|2.3|0|3|-|align="left"|Ayr West|bgcolor="#add8e6"|39.6|bgcolor="#add8e6"|2|21.9|1|10.9|0|22.8|1|4.8|0|4|-|align="left"|Kyle|bgcolor="#add8e6"|36.7|bgcolor="#add8e6"|1|33.9|1|23.0|1|colspan="2" |6.4|0|3|-|align="left"|Maybole, North Carrick and Coylton|bgcolor="#add8e6"|35.5|bgcolor="#add8e6"|1|32.0|1|12.4|0|17.7|1|2.5|0|3|-|align="left"|Girvan and South Carrick|28.0|1|24.9|1|8.8|0|bgcolor="#c0c0c0"|37.2|bgcolor="#c0c0c0"|1|1.2|0|3|- class="unsortable" class="sortbottom"!align="left"|Total!32.6!10!33.4!9!16.3!5!15.3!4!2.2!0!28|}

Source: [8]

Seats changing hands

Below is a list of seats which elected a different party or parties from 2017 in order to highlight the change in political composition of the council from the previous election. The list does not include defeated incumbents who resigned or defected from their party and subsequently failed re-election while the party held the seat.

Seats changing hands
Seat20172022
PartyMemberPartyMember
PrestwickConservativeHugh HunterIndependentHugh Hunter
Ayr WestConservativeDerek McCabeIndependentBob Shields
Notes

Ward results

Troon

The Conservatives (2), the SNP (1) and Labour (1) retained the seats they won at the previous election.

Prestwick

The Conservatives held one of the two seats they won at the previous election and lost one to independent candidate Hugh Hunter while the SNP and Labour retained the seats they had won at the previous election. In 2017, Hugh Hunter was elected as a Conservative candidate.

Ayr North

The SNP (2), Labour (1) and the Conservatives (1) retained the seats they had won at the previous election.

Ayr East

The SNP, Labour and the Conservatives retained the seats they won at the previous election.

Ayr West

The Conservatives retained two of the three seats they won at the previous election and lost one to independent candidate Bob Shields while the SNP retained their only seat.

Kyle

The SNP, Labour and the Conservatives retained the seats they won at the previous election.

Maybole, North Carrick and Coylton

The SNP, the Conservatives and independent candidate Brian Connolly retained the seats they won at the previous election.

Girvan and South Carrick

Independent candidate Alec Clark, the SNP and the Conservatives held the seats they won at the previous election.

Aftermath

It had initially been expected that the ruling SNP-Labour-Independent administration would continue to run the council, but discussions broke down between the parties amid Labour's claims of a "political stitch-up". As a result, the SNP planned to run the council as a minority administration on a "collaboration and consensus basis".[11] However, the Conservative group formed a minority administration and took control of the council[12] after the first full-council meeting thanks to Labour abstentions. The party also had the support of two of the local authority's four independents.[13]

In June 2023, both the SNP and Labour groups made changes to their leadership. Cllr Peter Henderson, leader of the SNP group, retired as a councillor due to "personal ill-health" which triggered a by-election in Girvan and South Carrick. He was replaced by Cllr William Grant as the SNP group leader. Labour group leader Cllr Brian McGinley was replaced in the role by Cllr Duncan Townson.[14] [15]

Ayr East councillor Chris Cullen defected from the SNP to the Alba Party in October 2023 saying the party had "failed to deliver on independence".[16]

At some point in late 2023 or early 2024, Ayr North councillor Mark Dixon left the SNP to sit as an independent. He has stated on social media that he is now a member of the Greens but the party do not allow members who have defected from other parties to formally sit under their banner so he remains an independent on the council.[8] [17]

In July 2024, Cllr Stephen Ferry resigned from the Conservatives to sit as an independent councillor and from his position as education portfolio holder. A deal was subsequently struck between the Conservative administration and Cllr Grant – who resigned from his position as SNP group leader and from the party to sit as an independent – which would see him return as education portfolio holder, a position he held while the SNP were in administration before the 2022 election.[18]

Girvan and South Carrick by-election

Cllr Henderson stood down on 30 June 2023 and a by-election took place on 21 September 2023.[19] This resulted in a Conservative gain from the SNP and Alan Lamont was elected on the fourth count.[20]

Notes and References

  1. News: South Ayrshire Council . BBC News . 5 May 2017 . 9 May 2022.
  2. Web site: Local Elections Archive Project - 2017 - South Ayrshire . Andrew . Teale . 17 March 2023.
  3. Web site: Notice of Election . South Ayrshire Council . 17 March 2023.
  4. News: Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party to drop Prestwick councillor Hugh Hunter from 2022 local election team . Daily Record . Stuart . Wilson . 9 November 2021 . 8 April 2022.
  5. News: Former South Ayrshire Conservative councillor Hugh Hunter confirms Independent bid for May election . Daily Record . Stuart . Wilson . 13 February 2022 . 8 April 2022.
  6. News: Scottish council elections 2022: South Ayrshire candidates revealed for May 5 vote . Daily Record . Stuart . Wilson . 30 March 2022 . 12 May 2022.
  7. Web site: Notice of Election Agents . South Ayrshire Council . 30 March 2022 . 19 May 2023.
  8. Web site: South Ayrshire Council 2022 . Allan . Faulds . Ballot Box Scotland . 4 April 2024.
  9. Web site: The Local STV Voting System Explained . Allan . Faulds . 25 September 2021 . Ballot Box Scotland . 24 October 2022.
  10. Web site: Single Transferable Vote . Electoral Reform Society . 24 October 2022.
  11. News: SNP to run South Ayrshire as minority administration as Labour claim 'political stitch-up' . Daily Record . Kevin . Dyson . 10 May 2022 . 12 May 2022.
  12. News: BREAKING: Tories take control of South Ayrshire Council . Daily Record . Stuart . Wilson . 19 May 2022 . 19 May 2022.
  13. News: Every Scottish council with a Tory-Labour deal - see the full list . Richards . Xander . Robertson . Adam . 26 May 2022 . The National . 12 December 2022 . subscription.
  14. News: South Ayrshire SNP leader Peter Henderson to retire this month . Ayr Advertiser . Adam . Lyon . 9 June 2023 . 28 August 2023.
  15. News: South Ayrshire Council: All change for SNP and Labour leadership . Ayr Advertiser . Kevin . Dyson . 9 June 2023 . 28 August 2023.
  16. News: SNP councillor Chris Cullen defects to Alba in Ash Regan's wake . BBC News . 30 October 2023 . 4 April 2024.
  17. Web site: Councillor Mark Dison . South Ayrshire Council . 4 April 2024.
  18. News: SNP stunned as leader quits and is set to prop up Conservative administration in South Ayrshire . Daily Record . 15 July 2024 . 15 July 2024.
  19. News: Gibson . Darren . 16 August 2023 . Girvan and South Carrick: By-election taking place in Ward 8 . Ayr Advertiser . 28 August 2023.
  20. Web site: Dyson . Kevin . 2023-09-22 . Conservatives snatch precious seat from SNP in South Ayrshire by-election . 2023-09-23 . Daily Record . en.