2022 Istanbul bombing explained

Partof:Terrorism in Turkey
2022 Istanbul bombing
Time:16:20
Timezone:TRT
Location:İstiklal Avenue, Beyoğlu, Istanbul, Turkey
Coordinates:41.035°N 28.9814°W
Perpetrator:Ahlam Albashir
Reported Deaths:6
Reported Injuries:81
Caption:Memorial point after the attack

A terrorist attack occurred on İstiklal Avenue in the Beyoğlu district of Istanbul, Turkey, on,[1] [2] killing 6 people and injuring 81 others.[3]

No group has claimed responsibility, but Turkish authorities announced that Kurdish separatists were behind the attack,[4] implicating the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) and the Syrian Kurdish Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF). Turkey's interior minister, Süleyman Soylu, announced the arrest of the bomber and forty-six others.[5]

The city experienced previous terrorist attacks during the late 20th and early 21st century by Kurdish separatists and Islamist insurgents. An Islamic State suicide bombing in the same district killed four people in 2016.[6]

PKK, and SDF denied involvements in the bombing.[7] On 20 November, Turkey launched Operation Claw-Sword,[8] bombing nearly 500 targets in Syria and Iraq.[9]

Background

During the late 20th and early 21st century, Islamists and Kurdish nationalists carried out many attacks in Istanbul, including a suicide bombing attack in March 2016 in İstiklal Avenue, which killed five people.[10]

Islamic State-Turkey conflict

The last attack by Islamic State in Turkey was a mass shooting in Ortaköy, Beşiktaş, Istanbul, in 2017, in which 39 people were killed.[11] [12]

PKK-Turkey conflict

See also: Kurdish-Turkish conflict. For decades, the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) has led an insurgency in Turkey, demanding Kurdish self-rule in southeastern Turkey.[13] An estimated 45,000 and 15,000 people have been killed in the conflict in Turkey and in its southern neighbor countries, respectively. PKK is considered a terrorist organization by Turkey, the European Union, and the United States. The People's Defense Units (YPG) are a Syrian Kurdish group related to Turkey's PKK while part of the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) which controls northeastern Syria; both YPG and SDF are supported by the US, leading to tensions between Turkey and the US.The 2013–2015 ceasefire supported by Erdogan and PKK gave hope for a long-term peace to the conflict in Turkey. In June 2015, the parliamentary elections delivered AKP's government a major defeat, losing its majority, while pro-Kurdish-rights HDP made notable progresses. Soon after, the Ceylanpınar incident was considered a casus belli to return to full scale confrontation, resulting in much higher monthly death tolls.[14] Erdogan conveyed the November 2015 snap elections, regaining AKP's majority through security concerns. Since the 2016 Turkish coup attempt and the following purges, political discourse, media, public speech as well as academic and judiciary voices are heavily monitored, with nearly no possible opposition to governmental discourse.[15] [16] While the intensity of the PKK-Turkey conflict in Turkey decrease in recent years, since 2015, Turkey lead nearly 12 external military operations resulting in the deaths of an estimated 15,000 neighbouring citizens.[17]

As of 2022, Turkey is heading toward its 2023 Turkish general election which is expected to be a major challenge for the AKP party due to economic slowdown and very high inflation.[18] [19] In the past decade, Erdoğan and the AKP government used anti-PKK, security, martial rhetoric and external operations to raise Turkish nationalist votes before elections.[20] [21] [22] In between, security concerns and anti-terrorism laws have been used to repress and neutralize elected oppositions. Opposition HDP elected officials are systematically probed, arrested, dismissed based on tenuous accusations, to then be replaced by pro-government AKP appointees.[23] [24] [25]

In April 2022, as Turkey continued Operation Claw-Lock and strikes against PKK and YPG targets, senior Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) commander, Duran Kalkan publicly said: "We will attack everywhere in Turkey. Not only military targets and military positions, but large cities. Areas they don't expect will become war zones"[26] [27] unless Turkey halts its operations.[28] Since May 2022, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and his government have called for new external ground operations toward autonomous territories in Syria and ramped up attacks on the area.[29] The PKK, SDF, and the YPG have denied any involvement and the AANES accused Turkey with having used such attacks as a pretext for invasions in the past.[30]

Bombing

The explosion occurred at 4:13 pm on 13 November 2022, on İstiklal Avenue in Beyoğlu, in the European part of Istanbul.[31] İstiklal Avenue is a popular tourist street and one of the main roads leading to Taksim Square. The bomb went off in front of a shopping store. At the time of the blast, the area was more crowded than normal, as a football club was preparing to play nearby.[32] According to Turkish news portal OdaTV, the explosion was caused by an improvised explosive device containing TNT.[33] The blast caused windows to break and images circulating on social media showed people bleeding. Firefighters and ambulances rushed to the scene.[34] The police set up a perimeter around the scene around the bombing site and banned people from going to İstiklal Avenue and Taksim Square.[34]

Victims

Six people were killed and at least 81 others were injured by the explosion.[35] The dead were all Turkish citizens, a man and his nine-year-old daughter;[36] a woman and her teenage daughter, and a married couple.[37] Of the 81 treated in hospital, 61 were released. By 15 November, twenty were still being treated in hospital.[38]

Investigation

State investigation

Istanbul's Chief Public Prosecutors' Office quickly opened an investigation after the attack, and at least eight prosecutors have been assigned to the case. Justice Minister Bekir Bozdağ said a woman was filmed sitting on a bench for about 40 minutes and that she left shortly before the blast.[39] The arrest of the main suspect in the attack, Ahlam Albashir, a female Syrian national, was reported a day after the bombing. She had been working in the textile industry in Esenler district in Istanbul.[40] Several of her co-workers were also detained and questioned.[41] Two human traffickers who are suspected to have been trying to bring the suspect to Bulgaria were also detained. Since the attack, forty-nine people were detained and interrogated by twenty-nine prosecutors.[42] On 18 November 2022, against seventeen people including the main suspect Ahlam Albashir arrest warrants have been issued.[43] One alleged accomplice of Albashir fled to Azaz, which is a Syrian town controlled by Turkey, where he was captured by the Turkish forces.

The Turkish police said Albashir confirmed her affiliation with PKK and YPG,[44] and that she had been trained by them as a special intelligence officer in Syria, entering Turkey through Afrin District. During her interrogation she admitted having met her contact in Manbij, a city governed by the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria (AANES) and on his orders travelled to Idlib where she met a man with whom she pretended to be married. They crossed the border to Turkey on 27 July 2022, her alleged partner bringing a bomb with him. They travelled to Istanbul the same day.

Kurdish forces denials and investigation

The PKK, SDF, and the YPG have denied any involvement and the AANES accused Turkey with having used such attacks as a pretext for invasions in the past. SDF and YPG, via Mazloum Abdi, denounced the attack.

On 22 November, SDF top military official Mazloum Abdi claimed the bomber, Albashir, to be related to IS jihadists via her brothers and past husbands, some of whom were killed in battles against Kurdish forces. More recently, she was inhabiting Turkey-controlled area within North-Western Syria.[45] Abdi called for peace between Turkey and Syrian Kurds, excluding any operation against Turkey in Turkey, and denying responsibility for the bombing. He vowed however to defend Syrian territories under AANES control. He also deplores Erdogan's electoral strategy, preferring war and tension over a peace agreement with his forces, which would be an equally winning electoral strategy.

MHP connection

The Turkish Nationalist Movement Party's (MHP) president Mehmet Emin İlhan of Güçlükonak, Şırnak was interrogated due to a call that was made from the telephone line registered in the name of İlhan to the bombing attacker of Istiklal Avenue Ahlam Albashir.[46] [47] Ilhan was interrogated but not detained.[48] He alleged that the PKK was to blame for it and that someone registered a telephone line in his name with a copy of his ID card.[48]

Other events

Jiyan Tosun, a lawyer and member of the Human Rights Association, was accused by Adem Taskaya, a politician of the far-right Victory Party, of having planted the bomb by order of the PKK.[49] Following this, she was threatened repeatedly and preferred to stay at a courthouse instead of returning home. In January 2023, an investigation for illegally obtaining and releasing personal data was initiated against Taskaya.[50]

Aftermath

See also: Operation Claw-Sword. Around an hour after the explosion took place, a broadcast ban was issued by the Istanbul Criminal Court for all visual and audio news and social networking sites related to the incident.[51] Only interviews with government officials are allowed to be reported about. CNN Türk and TRT then stopped reporting on the incident.[52] Internet speeds throughout Turkey and access to social media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube have been significantly decreased since the attack.

Istanbul's anti-terrorist office decided to suspend the rights of defense of suspects but also of Internet users who have shared "negative information" about the attack on social networks.[53] [54]

On 20 November 2022, Turkish Air Force launched a series of airstrikes against Kurdish separatist positions in Northern Syria and Iraq, dubbed Operation Claw-Sword. Despite dubious links,[55] the Istanbul bombing and alleged link to YPG/PKK was used as justification for massive bombing of the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria and its infrastructures.[56] About 500 targets were hit in Syria and Iraq. Top SDF officials called for resuming peace talks, avoid a deadly conflict, and vowed resistance if attacked.

On 24 February 2023, Turkish authorities reported that intelligence services had conducted an operation in northern Syria, killing the alleged mastermind of the attack, reported to be PKK member Halil Menci.[57] [58]

On 26 April 2024, Alham Albashir was convicted by a Turkish court and sentenced to seven consecutive life sentences for her role in the bombing.[59]

Internal reactions

Government politicians

Health Minister Fahrettin Koca said the victims were being treated in the hospitals nearby. President Erdoğan released a statement, stating, "After the treacherous attack, our members of the police went to the scene, and our wounded were sent to the surrounding hospitals. Efforts to take over Turkey and the Turkish nation through terrorism will reach their goal neither today nor in the future, the same way they failed yesterday."[60] Erdoğan also said: "The perpetrators would be punished."[61]

The Minister of the Interior Süleyman Soylu argued that the attack was carried out by the PKK in retaliation for the Turkish invasion of northeastern Syria and criticized the United States for its support of the Kurdish People's Defense Units (YPG) in north-eastern Syria.[62] [63] He had previously blamed the United States for the attack in Mersin in September and had said that the US had funded the Syrian Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD) up to $2 billion since 2019.[64] [65]

Opposition

Ekrem İmamoğlu, the mayor of Istanbul, inspected the bombing site and called the population not to pay attention to misleading information on the incident. The leader of the Republican People's Party (CHP), Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu, said immediately after the attack, "We must unite against all forms of terrorism. We must raise a common voice against all forms of terrorism and we must condemn terrorism. No matter where the terror comes from, whatever its source, 85 million people living in this country must be saying the same thing. They must curse terrorism, those who commit it and those who support it. When we do this, we will have a unity of heart, it will be better for us to embrace each other."[66]

The chairwoman of the Good Party (İYİ) Meral Akşener condemned the attack, stating: "I strongly condemn this vile attack. We would like those responsible to be caught as soon as possible".[67]

The Kurdish People's Democratic Party (HDP) expressed its "deep sorrow and grief over the explosion that has killed six of our fellow citizens and injured 81 others", adding that "Our grief and sorrow is great. We wish God's mercy to the citizens who lost their lives". The attack was also condemned by the imprisoned former chairman of the HDP Selahattin Demirtaş.

Civil reactions

The Turkish Football Federation (TFF) announced that the Süper Lig match at Vodafone Park between Beşiktaş J.K. and Antalyaspor was postponed due to the bombing.[68] Several football clubs offered their condolences. A day after the incident the avenue was decorated with 1200 Turkish flags as a way of remembering the victims of the bombing, and most tree benches on the İstiklal were removed.[69]

French writer Patrice Franceschi argues the attack is unlikely to be from Syrian Kurdish forces, who are pragmatically aware of Turkey's superior force and carefully avoid to provoke it and another Turkish operation in Syria. Franceschi argues there are both electoral and ideological motives on the part of AKP government to put the blame on autonomous, socialist, egalitarian AANES, since their social vision and existence is in opposition with autocratic, increasingly Islamist and expansionist nationalism of the AKP government.[70]

International reactions

Representatives of many governments condemned the attack and offered their condolences.[71] [72] [73] Condolences were also offered by international organizations such as the European Council,[74] North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO),[75] and Organization of Turkic States (OTS).[76]

German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier expressed his condolences to Recep Tayyip Erdoğan the president of Turkey. Steinmeier said, "In this moment of shock, we Germans stand by the citizens of Istanbul and the Turkish people." Steinmeier wrote Sunday, in step with an assertion from his office."[77]

German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock also said: "My thoughts are with the people who simply wanted to stroll on the Istiklal shopping street on a Sunday and have now become victims of a serious explosion." Baerbock also said, "Our thoughts are with those who were injured, and our deepest condolences go to those who lost loved ones."

French President Emmanuel Macron expressed his condolences on Twitter. Macron said, "On this meaningful day for our nation, just as we commemorate those who lost their lives on November 13, 2015, the Turkish people were attacked from their heart, from Istanbul," Macron said, referring to November 2015 Paris attacks on the Bataclan theatre and other parts of Paris claimed by the so-called "Islamic State" militant group seven years ago. "We share your pain. Our condolences. We are with you in the fight against terrorism," Macron said.

The condolences offered by the U.S. embassy in Turkey were rejected by the Turkish Interior Minister Süleyman Soylu,[78] [79] who repeated the claim that the attack was carried out by the US-supported YPG.[80]

The Left in the European Parliament – GUE/NGL argued AKP accusations linking the attack to Syrian YPG is an electoral strategy, using war mongering to distract from deepening economic context and to raise nationalist votes.[81]

See also

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 31 May 2024 . Taksim İstiklal Caddesi'nde patlama: Ölü ve yaralılar var . Explosion in Taksim Istiklal Street: There are dead and injured . https://web.archive.org/web/20221115044353/https://www.sozcu.com.tr/2022/gundem/son-dakika-istiklal-caddesinde-patlama-7477808/ . 15 November 2022 . 13 November 2022 . live . . tr.
  2. Web site: English . Duvar . 13 November 2022 . Explosion hits Istanbul's Istiklal Avenue . . tr-TR . 13 November 2022.
  3. News: Deadly explosion hits busy pedestrian street in Istanbul . Tidman . Zoe . Daragahi . Borzou . 13 November 2022 . 13 November 2022 . The Independent.
  4. Web site: Sabin . Lamiat . 13 November 2022 . Woman may be involved in Istanbul 'terror attack' that killed at least six – Turkey . 13 November 2022 . The Independent . en.
  5. Web site: Turkish police arrest 46 people over Istanbul blast . 14 November 2022 . Al Jazeera . en.
  6. News: Six dead in Istanbul blast, Erdogan says it 'smells like terrorism' . Reuters . 13 November 2022 . Gauthier-Villars . David . Ceylan . Azra . Toksabay . Ece.
  7. Web site: Opinion We’re America’s most loyal ally in Syria. Don’t forget us. . 3 December 2022 . . https://web.archive.org/web/20230503083203/https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/12/03/mazloum-abdi-kurds-syria-turkey-threat/ . 3 May 2023 . live .
  8. News: Hermann . Rainer . 20 November 2022 . Syrien und Irak: Türkei bombardiert kurdische Stellungen . de . . 2022-11-20 . 0174-4909.
  9. Web site: 23 November 2022 . Turkey vows intent 'stronger than ever' to secure Syrian border . 2022-11-23 . France 24 . en.
  10. Web site: Sunday's explosion was a shocking reminder of the anxiety that pervaded the Turkish population during years when such attacks were common. The country was hit by a string of deadly bombings between 2015 and 2017, some by the Islamic State group, and others by Kurdish militants who seek increased autonomy or independence. . Istanbul bombing: Turkey swift to accuse Kurdish militants . 2022-11-14 . CSMonitor.com .
  11. Web site: UK government travel advice for Turkey . 21 November 2022 . 29 October 2017 . https://web.archive.org/web/20171029173024/https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/turkey/terrorism . live .
  12. News: Spicer . Jonathan . Kucukgocmen . Ali . Toksabay . Ece . Turkey blames deadly bomb on Kurdish militants; PKK denies involvement . .
  13. News: Michaelson . Ruth . Oltermann . Philip . Abdul-Ahad . Ghaith . Istanbul bombing: 46 detained as Turkey minister blames Kurdish separatists . .
  14. Web site: 18 July 2022 . Turkey's PKK Conflict: A Visual Explainer . 2022-11-15 . www.crisisgroup.org . en.
  15. Web site: Erdoğan's alliance leaves Turkey's opposition bloc behind without votes of pro-Kurdish HDP: poll . 2022-11-15 . Turkish Minute . 29 October 2022 . en-US.
  16. Web site: 8 March 2019 . Turkish intelligence vetted journalists working at Kurdish state TV station . 2022-11-15 . Nordic Monitor . en-US.
  17. Tally based on sources cited in Kurdish–Turkish conflict (1978–present)#External operations.
  18. Web site: English . Duvar . 23 October 2022 . 'People's inflation' for basic goods at 177 percent in Turkey . 2022-11-16 . duvaR.english . tr-TR.
  19. Web site: 3 November 2022 . Annual inflation in Turkey reaches record 25-year high of 85.5% . 2022-11-16 . euronews . en.
  20. Web site: Bilginsoy . Zeynep . EXPLAINER: Why Istanbul blast has political implications . 2022-11-15 . ABC News . en.
  21. Web site: 16 April 2019 . Acquittal of nine Ceylanpinar murder suspects upheld . 2022-11-15 . IPA NEWS . en-US.
  22. Web site: Can Erdoğan Survive Without the Kurdish Question? . 2022-11-15 . Middle East Institute . en.
  23. Web site: English . Duvar . 19 January 2021 . Every single HDP deputy in Turkish parliament subject to probes . duvaR.english . tr-TR . 2022-11-16.
  24. Web site: Meghan . Bodette . 28 October 2022 . Democracy Destroyed: Turkey's Crackdown on Local Pro-Kurdish Politics . 2022-11-16 . Kurdish Peace Institute . en-US.
  25. Web site: 2022 . Democracy Destroyed Kurdish Peace Institute Report 2022-01 . Trustee Appointments Have Ended Local Democracy for Supporters of Pro-Kurdish Parties in Turkey . Kurdish Peace Institute.
  26. News: 17 November 2022 . A Terrorist Attack in Turkey and the Hunt for the Perpetrators . European Eye on Radicalization . 18 November 2022.
  27. News: Ateşçi . Ulaş . 14 November 2022 . Terrorist attack in Istanbul leads to stepped-up police-state measures, militarism . World Socialist Website . 18 November 2022.
  28. News: 21 April 2022 . PKK'yı 'Pençe Kilit' korkusu sardı: Elebaşı Murat Karayılan çareyi eylem çağrısı yapmakta buldu . . 18 November 2022.
  29. Web site: PKK denies involvement in deadly Istanbul bombing . 2022-11-15 . www.rudaw.net.
  30. Web site: 15 November 2022 . Kurdish groups deny involvement in Istanbul bombing . 2022-11-20 . The New Arab . en.
  31. Web site: Michaelson . Ruth . 14 November 2022 . Kurdish militants deny Turkish claims they carried out Istanbul attack . 14 November 2022 . The Guardian . en.
  32. Web site: Hubbard . Ben . 14 November 2022 . Deadly Bombing in Istanbul Is Being Investigated as a Terrorist Attack . 14 November 2022 . The New York Times.
  33. Web site: Emniyet, laboratuvar sonuçlarını paylaştı: Patlamada TNT kullanıldı . 14 November 2022 . 14 November 2022 . Halk TV . tr.
  34. Web site: 13 November 2022 . Live updates: At least six killed, 81 injured in explosion on İstanbul's İstiklal Avenue . Bianet.
  35. Web site: Güzel . Mehmet . Turkey detains 1, suspects Kurdish militants behind bombing . 14 November 2022 . ABC News.
  36. Web site: Isil Sariyuce . Sophie Tanno . Holly Yan . 13 November 2022 . Istanbul blast that killed 6 and injured 81 is considered a terrorist attack, Turkish vice president says . 13 November 2022 . CNN . en.
  37. Web site: Deadly Istanbul bombing sparks fear and defiance in Turkey. Al Jazeera. 14 November 2022.
  38. Web site: 17 November 2022. 15 November 2022. İstanbul'daki terör saldırısında yaralananlardan 61'i taburcu edildi, 20'sinin tedavisi sürüyor. Anadolu Ajansı.
  39. News: Anschlag in Istanbul: Fahndung nach Verdächtiger läuft . de . Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung . 0174-4909 . 13 November 2022.
  40. Web site: 18 November 2022 . İstanbul bomber, accomplice 'brought bomb-laden bag from Syria' . Bianet.
  41. Web site: Detentions over İstanbul attack rise to 50 including human smugglers . Bianet.
  42. Web site: Istanbul terror attack was from Manbij: Minister – Türkiye News . 2022-11-18 . Hürriyet Daily News . 18 November 2022 . en.
  43. News: Hermann . Rainer . 18 November 2022 . Türkisches Gericht: 17 Haftbefehle nach Anschlag in Istanbul . de . FAZ.NET . 2022-11-18 . 0174-4909.
  44. News: 14 November 2022 . Istanbul police says Syrian woman main suspect, detains 46 over bombing . . 14 November 2022.
  45. Web site: Zaman . Amberin . Amberin Zaman . 22 November 2022 . Syrian Kurdish commander says Kobani likely target of threatened Turkish ground offensive – Al-Monitor: Independent, trusted coverage of the Middle East . 2022-11-23 . . en.
  46. Web site: Turkish Nationalist Movement Party's member of Şırnak line registered in the name of İlhan to the bombing attacker of Istiklal Avenue Ahlam Albashir . 15 November 2022 . tr . YouTube . Artı TV.
  47. Web site: 16 November 2022 . Istanbul bombing: Arrest of suspect produces more questions than answers . 2022-11-18 . Medya News . en-US.
  48. Web site: 15 November 2022 . Turkish ultranationalist politician interrogated over Istanbul attack . 2022-11-18 . www.rudaw.net.
  49. Web site: 14 November 2022 . Lawyer accused of planting bomb in Taksim spends night at courthouse after harassment . Bianet.
  50. Web site: 6 January 2022 . Far-right politician who falsely blamed deadly bombing on Kurdish lawyer faces jail sentence . Bianet.
  51. Web site: Turkey: Several killed and wounded after explosion hits Istanbul's busy Istiklal street . 13 November 2022 . .
  52. News: 13 November 2022 . Istanbul: Recep Tayyip Erdoğan spricht nach Explosion von"hinterhältigem Anschlag". de . Der Spiegel . 13 November 2022 . 2195-1349 .
  53. Web site: Taksim'deki terör saldırısıyla ilgili savcılıktan görülmemiş talep . 13 November 2022 . 14 November 2022 . Halk TV . tr.
  54. Web site: 13 November 2022 . Taksim'deki patlamanın ardından mahkemeden dikkat çeken 'şüpheli' kararı . 14 November 2022 . soL . tr.
  55. Web site: Ciddi . Sinan . 17 November 2022 . The Istanbul Terror Attack Is More Than It Seems . 2022-11-23 . The National Interest . en.
  56. News: Turkish jets hit targets in Syria, Iraq after Istanbul bomb blast . 20 November 2022 . Al Jazeera . 20 November 2022.
  57. News: Mostafa . Amr . Istanbul bombing 'mastermind' killed in northern Syria, says Turkey . 24 February 2023 . MENA News . 24 February 2023.
  58. News: Türkiye: mastermind of Istanbul terror attack 'neutralised' in Syria . 24 February 2023 . TRT World . 24 February 2023.
  59. News: A Turkish court sentences a Syrian woman to life in prison for a bombing in Istanbul in 2022 . 26 April 2024 . Associated Press . 26 April 2024.
  60. Web site: Tarihi . Güncelleme . 14 November 2022 . Son dakika... Cumhurbaşkanı Erdoğan'dan İstiklal Caddesi'ndeki patlamaya ilişkin açıklama . . tr .
  61. News: 13 November 2022 . Istanbul: Six dead, dozens wounded in Turkey explosion . en-GB . BBC News . 2022-11-15.
  62. Web site: Soylu . Ragip . 14 November 2022 . Turkey blames deadly Istanbul blast on PKK, arrests 46 people . . en.
  63. News: 12 March 2019 . Pentagon 2020 budget allocates $550 million for Kurdish forces in Syria . Ahval . 14 November 2022 . 29 July 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210729123230/https://ahvalnews.com/turkey-us/pentagon-2020-budget-allocates-550-million-kurdish-forces-syria . dead .
  64. Web site: Turkish Minister Says Deadly Gun Attack Was 'America-Based . 14 November 2022 . VOA . October 2022 . en.
  65. Web site: Sabah . Daily . 19 August 2022 . No PKK terrorists will remain in rural Türkiye by 2023: Minister Soylu . 14 November 2022 . Daily Sabah . en-US.
  66. Web site: 13 November 2022 . Kılıçdaroğlu'ndan patlamaya ilişkin açıklama: Her türlü teröre karşı ortak ses çıkarmak ve terörü lanetlemek zorundayız . . tr .
  67. Web site: Stewart . Daniel . 13 November 2022 . Turkish opposition deplores deaths in Istanbul blast . 360 News . en-ZA.
  68. Web site: Erozden . Can . Turkish Super Lig match postponed after Istanbul explosion . Anadolu Agency.
  69. Web site: Bombalı saldırının ardından İstiklal Caddesi Türk bayraklarıyla donatıldı . 2022-11-15 . www.cumhuriyet.com.tr . 14 November 2022 . tr.
  70. Web site: Boucaud-Victoire . Kévin . 23 November 2022 . Patrice Franceschi : "Erdogan viole toutes les lois internationales en attaquant les Kurdes" . 2022-11-24 . www.marianne.net . fr.
  71. Web site: 14 November 2022 . World leaders send condolences to Türkiye over Istiklal Street blast . .
  72. News: 14 November 2022 . Int'l community sends condolences after Istanbul terrorist attack . .
  73. Web site: 13 November 2022 . Lapid, Herzog send condolences to Turkey over Istanbul bombing . Times of Israel.
  74. charlesmichel . Charles . Michel . Horrific news from #Istanbul tonight. [...] . 1591821697627607040 . 14 November 2022.
  75. jensstoltenberg . Jens . Stoltenberg . Shocking images from #Istanbul. [...] . 1591839222440263680 . 14 November 2022.
  76. Web site: Message of OTS regarding the explosion in Istanbul today . 13 November 2022 . Organization of Turkic States . 14 November 2022.
  77. Web site: Istanbul explosion: Suspect arrested after 'vile attack' – DW – 11/14/2022 . 2022-11-15 . dw.com . en.
  78. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/europe/turkey-rejects-us-condolences-over-istanbul-attack-interior-minister/articleshow/95505670.cms Turkey 'rejects' US condolences over Istanbul attack: Interior Minister
  79. https://guardian.ng/news/turkish-interior-minister-rejects-u-s-condolences-after-terror-attack/ Turkish interior minister rejects U.S. condolences after terror attack
  80. News: Türkiye Rejects US Condolences over Blast. Asharq Al-Awsat.
  81. Web site: EU silent as Erdogan electioneers with bombs . 2022-11-24 . GUE/NGL . 22 November 2022 . en.