2020 Michigan House of Representatives election explained

Election Name:2020 Michigan House of Representatives election
Country:Michigan
Type:legislative
Ongoing:no
Previous Election:2018 Michigan House of Representatives election
Previous Year:2018
Next Election:2022 Michigan House of Representatives election
Next Year:2022
Seats For Election:All 110 seats in the Michigan House of Representatives
Majority Seats:56
Turnout:66.36% 11.72 pp
Leader1:Lee Chatfield
(term-limited)
Party1:Michigan Republican Party
Leaders Seat1:107th District
Leader Since1:January 9, 2019
Seats Before1:58
Seats1:58
Popular Vote1:2,653,603
Percentage1:49.60%
Swing1: 2.20%
Leader2:Christine Greig
(term-limited)
Party2:Michigan Democratic Party
Leaders Seat2:37th District
Leader Since2:January 9, 2019
Seats Before2:52
Seats2:52
Popular Vote2:2,667,279
Percentage2:49.86%
Swing2: 2.27%
Speaker
Before Election:Lee Chatfield
Before Party:Michigan Republican Party
After Election:Jason Wentworth
After Party:Michigan Republican Party

An election was held on November 3, 2020, to elect all 110 members to Michigan's House of Representatives. The election coincided with elections for other offices, including U.S. President, U.S. Senate, and U.S. House of Representatives.[1] Michigan Republican Party retained control of the chamber.[2] [3] As of 2023, this was the last time Republicans controlled the Michigan House of Representatives.

Background

In the 2018 Michigan House of Representatives election, the Michigan Republican Party narrowly retained their majority on the chamber.

Despite the COVID-19 pandemic, elections proceeded as planned, though with a larger number of mail-in ballots than usual.[4]

In October 2020, The Washington Post identified this state election as one of eight whose outcomes could affect partisan balance during post-census redistricting.[5]

Term-limited members

Under the Michigan Constitution, members of the state Senate can only serve two four-year terms, and members of the House of Representatives are limited to three two-year terms, some of the toughest term-limit laws in the country.[6]

Democrats

Republicans

Marginal districts

The following districts would be considered marginal seats.

Republican-held targets

These Republican-held districts were the most vulnerable to Democratic challengers.

DistrictIncumbentHeld since% to gainResult
NetElected Rep.
79th district201911.36%Republican hold
17th district201711.32%Republican hold
24th district201711.08%Republican hold
94th district201910.98%Republican hold
45th district201510.24%Republican hold
93rd district20197.89%Republican hold
99th district20176.84%Republican hold
98th district20194.06%Republican hold
61st district20152.74%Democratic gain
110th district20191.64%Republican hold[7]
38th district20151.30%Democratic gainKelly Breen
104th district20150.74%Republican hold[8] John Roth

Democratic-held targets

These Democratic districts were the most vulnerable to Republican challengers.

DistrictIncumbentHeld since% to gainResult
NetElected Rep.
50th district201714.35%Democratic hold
40th district201913.10%Democratic hold
96th district201713.02%Republican gain
23rd district201712.52%Democratic hold
67th district20199.79Democratic hold
48th district20199.66%Republican gainDavid Martin
25th district20198.08%Democratic hold
62nd district20193.70%Democratic hold
20th district20192.84%Democratic hold
41st district20192.64%Democratic hold
71st district20191.60%Democratic hold[9]
19th district20190.48%Democratic hold[10]

Close races

Seats where the margin of victory was under 10%:

  1. (gain)
  2. (gain)
  3. (gain)
  4. (gain)

Results by district

District 1

In the 1st district Democratic incumbent Tenisha Yancey won her primary unopposed on August 4. On November 3, Yancey defeated the Republican nominee, Latricia Ann Lanier, in the general election.[12]

District 2

In the 2nd district, Joe Tate won re-election.[13]

District 3

Incumbent Democrat Wendell Byrd stood down in the 3rd district due to term limits.[14]

District 4

Incumbent representative Isaac Robinson died in March 2020 of a suspected COVID-19 infection. Twelve Democrats ran to succeed him, but Abraham Aiyash was elected as the Democratic nominee for the seat. On November 3, Aiyash defeated the Republican nominee Howard Weathington in the general election.[15]

District 5

In the 5th district, Cynthia A. Johnson faced two Democratic challengers in the primary. Jermaine Tobey and Rita Ross, the sister of singer Diana Ross.[16] Johnson won her primary and won against Republican nominee Harold Day in the general election.[17]

District 6

In the 6th district, Democrat Tyrone Carter is running for re-election in the general election unopposed. He won his primary election, beating challengers Ivy Nichole Neal and David Palmer. There was no Republican primary held.[18]

District 7

Incumbent Democrat LaTanya Garrett stood down in the 7th district due to term limits. Helena Scott was the Democratic nominee and Ronald Cole was the Republican nominee.[19] On November 3, Scott defeated Cole in the general election.[20]

District 8

Incumbent Democrat Sherry Gay-Dagnogo did not run in the primary, instead running to be on the Detroit school board.[21] Democrat Stephanie Young was elected as the Democratic nominee in the 8th district. On November 3, Young defeated Republican nominee Miroslawa Teresa Gorak in the general election.[22]

District 9

In the 9th district, Democrat Karen Whitsett won re-election.[23]

District 10

In the 10th district, incumbent Democrat Leslie Love was unable to run for re-election due to term limits.[24]

District 11

In the 11th district, incumbent Democrat Jewell Jones won re-election.[25]

District 12

In the 12th district, incumbent Democrat Alex Garza won re-election.[26]

District 13

In the 13th district, incumbent Democrat Frank Liberati was unable to run for re-election due to term limits.[27]

District 14

In the 14th district, incumbent Democrat Cara Clemente won re-election.[28]

District 19

In the 19th district, Democrat Laurie Pohutsky ran for re-election. Her Republican opponent was Martha Ptashnik. Pohutsky narrowly won re-election

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Laurie
Pohutsky (D)
Martha
Ptashnik (R)
Mitchell Research & Communications/MIRSSeptember 14–18, 2020~ 300 (V)± 5.6%47%45%

District 23

In the 23rd district, Democrat Darrin Camilleri won re-election.[29] [30] He was challenged by Republican nominee John Poe.[31]

District 25

In the 25th district, Democrat Nate Shannon won re-election. His Republican opponent was Paul Smith.[32]

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Nate
Shannon (D)
Paul
Smith (R)
Mitchell Research & Communications/MIRSSeptember 14–18, 2020~ 300 (V)± 5.6%48%41%

District 38

In the 38th district, incumbent Republican Kathy Crawford was prevented from running for re-election due to term limits. Kelly Breen was elected as a Democrat in this Republican district.[33]

District 39

In the 39th district, incumbent Republican Ryan Berman won re-election.[34]

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Ryan
Berman (R)
Julia
Pulver (D)
Anthony
Croff (L)
Mitchell Research & Communications/MIRSSeptember 14–18, 2020~ 300 (V)± 5.6%43%47%2%
Generic Democrat vs Generic Republican

District 45

In the 45th district, incumbent Republican Michael Webber could not run for re-election due to term-limits.[35]

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Mark
Tisdell (R)
Barb
Anness (D)
Mitchell Research & Communications/MIRSSeptember 14–18, 2020~ 300 (V)± 5.6%44%45%

District 51

On August 4, 2020, the primary elections occurred. Incumbent Republican Mike Mueller ran unopposed.[36] Brad May, a mental health clinician, was nominated on the Democratic ticket.[37] In the primary, May defeated Conner Wallace. Wallace later endorsed May's candidacy.[38]

On September 18, 2020, the Michigan Republican Party pointed to May's criminal record, which included conviction for robbery, possession of cocaine, and retail fraud. The state Republican Party criticized the Michigan Education Association for endorsing him, despite his criminal past.[39] May responded to these allegations. He confirmed that they were true, but also claimed that he had made significant improvements to his life since his convictions, and that through his work as a clinician, has been able to help those who had been in a similar position to himself.[37]

In the general election on November 3, 2020, Mueller was re-elected, defeating May.[40]

District 61

Incumbent Republican Brandt Iden was term limited, which made the 61st district an open seat.[41] The primaries occurred on August 4 and decided that Republican nominee Bronwyn Haltom was to run against incumbent Kalamazoo County Commissioner, Christine Morse, as the Democratic nominee. Morse won the seat.[42] [43]

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Branwyn
Haltom (R)
Christine
Morris (D)
Mitchell Research & Communications/MIRSSeptember 14–18, 2020~ 300 (V)± 5.6%41%45%
Generic Democrat vs Generic Republican

District 62

Incumbent Democrat Jim Haadsma won re-election in the 62nd district against Republican nominee Dave Morgan.[44]

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Jim
Haadsma (D)
Dave
Morgan (R)
Mitchell Research & Communications/MIRSSeptember 14–18, 2020~ 300 (V)± 5.6%52%39%

District 66

In the 66th district, Republican Beth Griffin won reelection.[45]

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Beth
Griffin (R)
Abigail
Wheeler (D)
Practical Political Consulting/Abigail WheelerReleased Jul 10, 202053%47%

District 71

In Michigan's 71st House of Representatives district, Democrat Angela Witwer was re-elected.

District 73

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Brian
Posthumus (R)
Bill
Saxton (D)
Target Insyght/MIRS NewsOct 20–22, 2020300 (V)± 5.7%41%40%

District 79

In the 79th district Pauline Wendzel won re-election.[46]

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Pauline
Wendzel (R)
Chokwe
Pitchford (D)
Chokwe PitchfordReleased Jul 6, 202049%51%

District 96

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
Brian
Elder (D)
Timothy
Beson (R)
Target Insyght/MIRS NewsOct 20–22, 2020300 (V)± 5.7%46%47%

District 104

In the 104th district, incumbent Republican Larry Inman did not run for re-election due to term limits. District 104 was the number 1 target for the Democrats but was retained for the GOP by John Roth.[8]

Poll sourcedata-sort-type="date" Date(s)
administered
data-sort-type="number" Sample
size
Margin
John
Roth (R)
Dan
O'Neil (D)
Mitchell Research & Communications/MIRSSeptember 14–18, 2020~ 300 (V)± 5.6%48%40%

District 110

Gregory Markkanen was re-elected in the 110th district.

See also

Notes

Partisan clients

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: SOS - Elections. 2020-06-26. www.michigan.gov.
  2. Web site: Egan. Paul. Republicans retain control of Michigan state House after both parties flip seats. 2020-11-05. Detroit Free Press. en-US.
  3. Web site: 2020-10-25. Can Democrats win back the Michigan House after a decade? ⋆ Michigan Advance. 2020-11-11. Michigan Advance. en-US.
  4. Web site: Gibbons . Lauren . 2020-11-11 . One big winner in Michigan’s 2020 election cycle: No-reason absentee voting . 2023-11-10 . mlive . en.
  5. News: The state legislative battles to watch in 2020 . Amber . Phillips . The Washington Post . October 2, 2020 . October 2, 2020.
  6. Web site: 2016-10-11. Michigan's Term Limits Are Toughest in Nation. 2020-09-27. The Ballenger Report. en-US.
  7. Web site: Incumbent Markkanen takes 110th District seat. 2020-11-11. miningjournal.net. en-US.
  8. Web site: 2020-11-04. Republican John Roth earns state House seat in Grand Traverse County. 2020-11-11. mlive. en.
  9. Web site: 2020-11-04. ELECTION: Rep. Angela Witwer returns for another term in 71st District. 2020-11-11. WLNS 6 News. en-US.
  10. Web site: 2020-11-05. Livonia Democrat narrowly holds onto to Michigan House seat. 2020-11-11. mlive. en.
  11. Web site: October Overview: Handicapping the 2020 State Legislature Races. The Cook Political Report. November 1, 2020.
  12. Web site: Zaniewski. Ann and Kathleen Gray . Some State House elections still undeclared for Districts 1-50. 2021-04-06. Detroit Free Press. en.
  13. Web site: Joseph Tate. . April 6, 2021.
  14. Web site: Egan. Paul. Big spending Thanedar, sister of Diana Ross are among Detroit House primary candidates. 2020-09-09. Detroit Free Press. en-US.
  15. Web site: Abraham Aiyash. . April 6, 2021.
  16. Web site: The Detroit News. 2020-09-09. www.detroitnews.com.
  17. Web site: Cynthia A. Johnson. . April 6, 2021.
  18. Web site: 2020-06-15. Primary Election Overview: 6th House District. 2020-09-09. Michigan Legislative Consultants. en. 2020-08-22. https://web.archive.org/web/20200822102619/https://mlcmi.com/primary-election-overview-6th-house-district-2/. dead.
  19. Web site: 2020 Michigan Official Primary Election Results - 08/04/2020. 2020-09-15. mielections.us.
  20. News: Helena Scott. . April 6, 2021.
  21. Web site: Two incumbents and a Michigan legislator win tight Detroit school board race. 5 November 2020. . April 6, 2021.
  22. Web site: Stephanie Young. . April 6, 2021.
  23. News: Karen Whitsett. . April 6, 2021.
  24. Web site: Leslie Love. . April 6, 2021.
  25. Web site: Jewell Jones. . April 6, 2021.
  26. Web site: Alex Garza. . April 6, 2021.
  27. Web site: Frank Liberati. . April 6, 2021.
  28. Web site: Cara Clemente. . April 6, 2021.
  29. Web site: Kasuba. Jim. State Rep. Darrin Camilleri announces re-election campaign for state representative seat. 2020-09-15. News-Herald. 28 January 2020. en.
  30. Web site: Darrin Camilleri. 2021-04-15. Ballotpedia. en.
  31. Web site: Bolthouse. Scott. 2020-09-14. Meet the candidates: John Poe running for state representative for the 23rd District. 2020-09-15. The Huron Hub - Huron Township News - New Boston News. en.
  32. News: Nate Shannon. . April 15, 2021.
  33. Web site: Hall. Christine Ferretti and Kalea. Republicans take two key House races in Oakland County, Democrats win one. 2020-11-11. The Detroit News. en-US.
  34. Web site: Ryan Berman. . April 15, 2021.
  35. Web site: Michael Webber. . April 15, 2021.
  36. Web site: Mike Mueller. . March 14, 2021.
  37. Web site: Candidate for Michigan House acknowledges convictions for robbery, drug possession and retail fraud. 18 September 2020 . . March 14, 2021.
  38. Web site: Wallace . Conner . I want to endorse Brad May as a fellow progressive who I can trust to push forth policy changes that will help all working people not the billionaires. . @conner_for . September 10, 2020 . en . August 11, 2020.
  39. Web site: MEA Endorses Democrat With A Severe Criminal Background. Michigan Republican Party. March 14, 2021. April 17, 2021. https://web.archive.org/web/20210417015119/https://www.migop.org/mea_endorses_democrat_with_a_severe_criminal_background. dead.
  40. Web site: Brad May. . March 14, 2021.
  41. Web site: Republicans face off for Michigan's 61st House District nomination. 10 July 2020 . . September 10, 2020.
  42. Web site: Haltom declared victor in GOP primary race for 61st District state House seat. 5 August 2020. . September 10, 2020.
  43. Web site: Christine Morse. . September 10, 2020.
  44. Web site: Jim Haadsma. . September 10, 2020.
  45. Web site: Beth Griffin. . April 16, 2021.
  46. Web site: Pauline Wendzel. . April 19, 2021.